Reflecting On The Dead Essay

1425 words - 6 pages

Reflecting on the Dead
In Katherine Mansfield’s “The Garden Party” and in D.H. Lawrence’s “Odour of Chrysanthemums,” two women were in a situation where death was literally at their feet. In “The Garden Party,” Laura finds herself contemplating the dead body of Mr. Scott, a man of lower class who lived at the bottom of the hill from her house. In “Odour of Chrysanthemums,” Elizabeth finds herself contemplating the dead body of her husband, Walter. Although the relationships these women shared with the dead men were completely opposite, they both had striking similarities in the ways that they handled the situation. Both women ignored the feelings of the families of the deceased, failed to refer to the deceased by name, felt shame in the presence of the deceased and both had a life and death epiphany. Although Laura and Elizabeth were in two similar yet very different situations, they both had contemplated the dead men, acted in similar ways, felt similar emotions and both ended up having an epiphany regarding life and death at the end of the story.

No real concern was shown in either story for family members of the dead. In fact the only concern shown by Laura and Elizabeth was only concern for themselves. In “The Garden Party,” Laura did not once show any consideration for Mr. Scott’s family. Even in the presence of the widow and her sister, Laura never mentioned anything about feeling sorry for them about their loss. The most concern shown for Mr. Scott’s family was before a party that her family was throwing when she questioned, “what the band would sound like to that poor woman” (Mansfield 2429). Laura also never showed concern for Mr. Scott’s children. Her reference to Mr. Scott’s wife and children as the “poor woman and those little children” (Mansfield 2430), was the only sympathy the widow and her family received from her. Laura seemed only concerned with how “terribly nervous” she was and that she was being watched with “staring eyes” (Mansfield 2432). She didn’t even acknowledge that Mr. Scott had a family that was suffering. Elizabeth, in “Odour of Chrysanthemums,” lacked the same condolence. Unlike Laura, this was her own family she lacked sympathy for. She never expressed any responsibilty about how her children were going to handle the loss of their father. At the end of the story is the only time Elizabeth expressed concern for her children by closing the parlour door where the father was laying “lest the children should see what was lying there” (Lawrence 2330). Obviously this was not a concern with the overall well-being of her children. It was merely a way to prevent the shock of seeing their dead father before they have been told of his passing. Furthermore, the mother-in-law was also denied any sympathy from Elizabeth. Although Elizabeth acknowledged the mother-in-law “moaning” (Mansfield 2327) in her grief, she never expressed concern for the mother-in-law’s well-being. She was so caught up in her own feelings that she...

Find Another Essay On Reflecting on the Dead

Hycn: Encounter On The Dead Planet

1859 words - 8 pages A smile flickered across her face as she realized why she agreed to come along with him. She’d agreed because it was an excuse to fly her anti-gravity fighter craft. She didn’t give a damn about exploring dead worlds and wandering planets. She wasn’t the touring kind; there was nothing interesting in exploring dead worlds. Not for her anyway. There definitely wasn’t anything worth writing home about out here on the dead planet, only ruins left

Hycn: Encounter On The Dead Planet

941 words - 4 pages find him in time he would surely die. There wasn’t much time left. He had lost a lot of blood already. Everything was slowly becoming blurry and distant in his eyes. He was slowly drifting away into darkness. Where are they? He tried to keep awake and avoid passing out by repeating the question over and over in his mind. His plan wasn’t working. Darkness kept on creeping in on him. Cede knew he was on the verge of death. Not the kind of death

Hycn: Encounter On The Dead Planet

3249 words - 13 pages be as simple as ABC. Even I could do it in my sleep. All they have to say is ‘Hi fellow alien friends, how do you do? We are humans from the solar system, and as you can see, our planet is dead and we would be very happy if you gave us space to live on.” Merida finished. “Like the aliens would understand that. Have you forgotten about the language barrier?” Cooke said with an edge to his voice. Angry at Merida for disturbing his relaxation. He

Hycn: Encounter On The Dead Planet - 3794 words

3794 words - 16 pages the alien ruins. It was seven days since they landed on the planet but they only managed to find four gold statues and two gold masks. It wasn’t enough. Cede needed time. Unfortunately for him, the Ekcyrien army had just arrived on the dead planet several hours past, which meant he now had to tread carefully even if his younger brother and commander aboard the Ekcyrien military carrier assured him he shouldn’t have to worry he would look out for

Hycn: Encounter On The Dead Planet - 1430 words

1430 words - 6 pages ejector seat and the craft spat him out. He watched from above as his craft continued spinning downwards, but quickly lost track of it as Xerla’s blinding spotlights fell on him. In about four minutes Cooke hit the hard ground. He rolled over, released the chute, and pulled himself up. The unidentified craft was circling overhead. Its bright lights on him - blinding him. He tried to run but laser fire hit the ground around him. He stopped dead in

Adolph Hitler, Joseph Stalin and a Turkish Dictator reflecting the fascist and communist worldviews on key political issues

3358 words - 13 pages This paper will present a platonic dialogue between Adolph Hitler, Joseph Stalin and a Turkish Dictator reflecting the fascist and communist worldviews on key political issues. To be more consistent, I wrote an imaginary story in order to create a context that these three people would come and talk to each other. According to the story the new Turkish Dictator did not have a certain political stand. He was about to take control of the country

Reflecting on the Civil War

1112 words - 4 pages to succeed but the main reason had to do with the North's view on slavery. All of this was basically a different interpretation of the United States Constitution on both sides. In the end all of these disagreements on both sides led to the Civil War, in which the North won.There were a few reasons other then the slavery issue, that the South disagreed on and that persuaded them to succeed from the Union. Basically the North favored a loose

A Reflection on the Movie "Dead Poet's Society"

1745 words - 7 pages to be.The definition of History as a "natural tension between tradition and innovation" is best represented in the movie Dead Poet's Society. Set in 1959, the movie is the story of students at the respected "Welton Academy", an all-boys preparatory school in Vermont. Such schools were (and often still are) very conservative institutions that serve as high schools for parents who insist on sending their children to the best universities.The story

Social Promotion: A Dead End on the Road to Success

2220 words - 9 pages SOCIAL PROMOTION: A Dead End on the Road to Success SOCIAL PROMOTION: A Dead End on the Road to Success Our education system faces a myriad of questions. One of which is, what is the main objective of our education system: to graduate students at a high academic standard, to graduate students who can interact socially, or to prepare students wholly in order to become contributing members of society? Parents

This paper is on "The Judge's Wife" it is about two close knit families, are broken because a conflict reflecting personal value breaks these ties

841 words - 3 pages Close Knit FamilyIn Isabel Allende's short story, "The Judge's Wife" the idea of family togetherness seems to be a main theme throughout the story. Familial ties are recognized as binding the two families depicted in this story, even though in the case of one of them, the family members are not close. The idea that blood is thicker than water leads to an action taken by the main character in the story that will not only place stress on the

Reflecting on our failure: The Rwandan Genocide

1099 words - 5 pages s today marks the 20th anniversary of the Rwanda Genocide, the United States reflects on its failure to react to the tragic conflict. Over the course of 100 days in 1994, hundreds of thousands of Tutsi people suffered and were killed by machetes, grenades, clubs and rape; all brought on by the Hutus. Fueled by the tensions growing between the two ethnic groups over dominance and suffering economy, the Hutu people began to blame the Tutsis for

Similar Essays

Reflecting On The Journey Essay

975 words - 4 pages As I near the conclusion of my first semester at Spelman College, I truly cannot help but to sit and reflect back on everything that I have experienced. With a combination of the stressors of college, the people I have met and the experiences that I have been given the pleasure of enduring, I can whole-heartedly state that Spelman has allowed me to take the reigns of an incredible world. A world filled with multiple opportunities, potential

Reflecting On The Reaction In Agatha Christie's Murder Mysteries

1857 words - 7 pages After reading Agatha Christies And Then There Were None and Murder on the Orient Express and a rigorous analysis of critical reviews, biographies, and informational sites critics have come to the conclusion that many people react and reflect on things that happen in their lives. The act of reflecting or the state of being reflected is expressed in many of Agatha Christie’s novels. Agatha Christie a well known author experienced many issues in

Report On The Grateful Dead

1236 words - 5 pages Report on the Grateful Dead I have chosen to do my report on the Grateful Dead. They were a rock and roll band from the sixties that stayed popular and still influenced rock and roll until 1995 when the lead singer, Jerry Garcia, died and the band dissolved. The Dead remained popular for so long because of the style of their live concerts that made people keep coming back. In 1959 when Jerry Garcia was thrown out of the army, he

Maggie: Dead On The Streets Essay

2372 words - 9 pages on textual, historical, and critical evidence. In a textual context Pizer claims that the debate over the cause of death only began after the release of the second, edited version of the story. The key factor leading to the debate is the omission of a section of the original text that includes a “huge fat man” (Dowling 37) who is depicted menacingly in the scene just prior to the revelation of Maggie’s death. Pizer contends that the reason many