Reflection Questions About The Novel "My Brother Sam Is Dead"

1734 words - 7 pages

My Brother Sam is DeadChapter 1Explain Mr. Meeker's statement, "You may know principle, Sam, but I know war."Mr. Meeker is saying that Sam doesn't really know what a war is. He has been in a war but Sam hasn't. He has seen a lot of things like 'a dear friend lying in the grass with the top of his skull off and his brains sliding out of them like wet oats' (p21) which Sam hasn't. He is telling his son how terrible a war is and trying to make him not join the army. He is also telling him that he shouldn't risk his life on anything like his principle because his life is the most important thing and it isn't worth it.Chapter 2a. Explain the statements that Mr. Meeker makes, "But you never get rid of injustices by fighting."What Mr. Meeker means is that getting rid of injustices by fighting is another injustice. He means that fighting is not good and should find another way to get rid of injustices. So he doesn't think the Rebel army is right and thinks that they should stop the war now. He also doesn't want other people to agree with the Rebel army and help them.b. How is Mr. Meeker's comment an argument against war?Mr. Meeker's comment is an argument against war because as I say above, he thinks getting rid of injustices by fighting is another injustice.c. Explain the statements that Sam makes. "Either we're going to be free or we're not."Sam is saying that to be free the people of the colonies have to fight. He thinks fighting is the only way to be free. It also means that Sam thinks the King who is so far away from the colonies shouldn't be the governor of the colonies and they should not let him govern their country. "He (the King) thinks he's going to teach us a lesson. But we're going to teach him one" (p35)He's telling Tim to join in his side and make him help the Rebel army.d. How is Sam's comment an argument for war?Sam's comment is an argument for war because he thinks fighting is the only way to be free and thinks that they should attack the British troops before they attack the Rebel army.Chapter 3a. How would you explain Tim's statement, "It made me wonder how the war was going to make us freer if you couldn't read any paper you wanted anymore."I would explain Tim's statement as an argument against the war. He is saying that if people can't read any paper you want that's not freedom. It means that he doesn't like the war and think about what would happen to him and his family after the war.b. What does this tell you about war and revolution in general?It tells me that normally people were against the war and they didn't want to be restrained. I can also know that the war made people can't do certain things like buying a Tory newspaper.Chapter 4Tim said,"...anybody who joined the army to fight couldn't be a coward." Do you agree or disagree, and why?I agree because although they would have known that they might get injured or even die in the battle but they still joined the army and that's a real brave thing. I think people who risk their...

Find Another Essay On Reflection Questions about the novel "My Brother Sam is Dead"

My Brother the Drunk Essay

1342 words - 5 pages ;  We had our fights, though. My brother was never wrong. Anything we disagreed about was my fault. I guess as a child, it really didn't bother me. Whenever we played games he was a sore loser and a poor winner. I was the baby of the family so he got mad when I got more attention. He picked on me when we played with my cousins, and then I would tell on him and he would get in trouble. But we would always forget about our fights, and soon

What is Race: My Reflection Essay

1158 words - 5 pages I took the time today to read the article titled “What is Race” by Victor M. Fernandez, RN, BSN and found myself agreeably intrigued and in admiration of his thoughts regarding race. Victor touched on an extremely insightful and significant topic; one that most people have sturdy opinions about. Race – what is it? What does this mean to you? What does it mean to our upcoming careers in the nursing field? I trust that how we characterize and

The essay is about Transcendental themes in the movie "Dead Poets Society."

1123 words - 4 pages The movie "The Dead Poets Society" is about a group of private school boys in the North East. They encounter a teacher, Mr. Keating, whom is a little different than most teachers. He wanted to instill the motivation to look past what society was telling them to do rather than teach the normal curriculum. He used Thoreau's ideas on transcendentalism by showing them to transcend or go beyond the rules that society poses and create their own

A Reflection on the Movie "Dead Poet's Society"

1745 words - 7 pages to be.The definition of History as a "natural tension between tradition and innovation" is best represented in the movie Dead Poet's Society. Set in 1959, the movie is the story of students at the respected "Welton Academy", an all-boys preparatory school in Vermont. Such schools were (and often still are) very conservative institutions that serve as high schools for parents who insist on sending their children to the best universities.The story

In what ways is Dead Poets Society about the conflict between realism and idealism?

623 words - 2 pages Society as we know, has been shaped by numerous conflicts in the past, some between nations, some between races, and some between the interests and issues of certain people. Dead Poets Society in particular, is about the conflict between realism and idealism. For example Welton Academy is a school that is deep-rooted in realism, the teachers are all realists and in turn did not allow the students to think for themselves, but taught them what

The Dead Sea is dying

654 words - 3 pages consensus on what to do about the Dead Sea.Pollution is the reason why Palestine was invited to an international environmental conference pertaining to the Dead Sea. Israel's Foreign Minister ordered a boycott of the conference on the Dead Sea, due to the inclusion of Palestinian Authority Officials(see http://www.metimes.com/issue98-36/reg/dead_sea_is.htm). Turmoil between these two countries and neighboring countries is a good reason why

Comparing the Film and Novel Versions of Sam Hanna Bell’s December Bride

2818 words - 11 pages , but it is bittersweet as Frank moves them into Sarah’s childhood home. Sarah wins and looses. At the end of the movie, Frank has no objection to the marriage between his brother and Sarah. He has become resigned to the affection between them. But in the novel, Frank is dead. He died helping Joe Skillen, young Martha’s (daughter of the three) betrothed, to re-construct the old cottage into a shop for the soon-to-be married young couple

Dead Poets' Society Notes (a passage from the movie and study questions)

609 words - 2 pages about their cause and goal.D. Western society admires individuality, originality and inspiration; but at the same time it is characterized by conformity, obedience to the general rule and the general taste. There are infinite examples for that phenomenon: teenages wearing the same fashionable clothes, grown-ups choosing their careers according to their prestigious position, people spending their leisure hours doing the same spoting and

Franz Kafka's Metamorphosis is a Reflection about Himself

1741 words - 7 pages similarities between Kafka and his family to that of Gregor and his family, readers will come to comprehend the reasons behind why Kafka place Gregor with his type of family members. Furthermore, in order to better understand the method of comparison that I will be applying, one needs to know what biographical criticism is. Biographical criticism is a literary approach that examines a piece of literature as a reflection of its authors’ life

Is the Justice System Dead Wrong?

2439 words - 10 pages logger in Yreka. A weekend of partying led to an ill-fated shootout between police and a group including Croy. By the end, Officer Hittson was dead. Croy was convicted of attempted robbery and Officer Hittson's murder. The jury did not convict Croy of intentionally killing the offer, but, rather, convicted him based on the theory of felony murder -- that is, that he intentionally committed a robbery that resulted in the officer's death. Croy was

This is a reveiw on the novel "The Wave". It discusses the goods, the bads, and my thoughts on the novel.

862 words - 3 pages AuthorMorton RhuePublisherHeinemann New WindmillsTitleThe title of the book is the Wave. The book is called the Wave because the book is all about the Wave. The Wave is an experiment of Ben Ross, he is a history teacher. He wants to give them a taste of what life in Nazi Germany might have been like.SettingThe story takes place in the Palo Alto, California in 1969. It is based on a true story.Main charactersLaurie Saunders: editor-in-chief of

Similar Essays

My Brother Sam Is Dead Essay

1796 words - 7 pages My Brother Sam is Dead Author: by James Lincoln Collier and Christopher Collier Category: Historical Fiction Summary: It starts out in the 1770's during the Revolution War and Samuel Meeker or Sam for short just interred the room of the tavern and he chimes in to everybody who is waiting to eat, he comes in saying where beating the Lobster Backs. His father, Eliphalet Meeker but called Life for short, starts arguing with son. After a

My Brother Sam Is Dead Essay

774 words - 4 pages and start an insurrection. Tim tried to avoid the war but his brother was in it so he couldn't just overlook about it, this shows that he loves his brother. Tim said to Sam "give father the Brown Bess back" (17) Tim needs to give the gun to father from Sam because he doesn't want them to fight. This shows that Tim doesn't want his father to get enraged and at the same time he doesn't want his brother to go to war. This is the beginning of the

My Brother Sam Is Dead Essay

570 words - 2 pages My Brother Sam Is Dead By James & Chris Collier         The five things I liked about Timmy Meeker were his support of his country, distrust of the Militia, love for his family, dedication to his family business, and a positive work attitude. Tim supported the British just as his town and family did. Tim followed the way the people of the town were siding with the war. He felt the Colonists should stop rebelling against the British

Comparing The Watsons Go To Birmingham 1963 And My Brother Sam Is Dead

726 words - 3 pages Comparing The Watsons Go to Birmingham-1963 and My Brother Sam Is Dead In the novels The Watsons Go to Birmingham-1963 by Christopher Paul Curtis and My Brother Sam Is Dead by James Lincoln Collier and Christopher Collier, two young boys are faced with the challenge of learning the moral and ethical codes that will shape their futures. Kenny Watson and Tim Meeker live in very different times, but they face events that complicate their