Reflective Piece On Usefulness Of Porter's Five Forces Model.

893 words - 4 pages

In the first seminar of the term, I was observing how Porter's 5 Forces model (5F) can be used to analyse the strategic business dynamics of the European Forestry/Paper sector in the post 2004 European Union.5F is an analytical framework, which allows competitive dynamics to be systematically appraised in assessing existing and future profitability of markets/industries by analyzing the influence of particular characteristics of each of the five forces(2). Diagram below illustrates the forces and the effects of after-presentation discussion coupled with my additional insights.Porter's 5 Forces applied to the European Forestry/Paper sector (post 2004 EU)[Model about here. Extracted and adapted from http://www.quickmba.com/strategy/porter.shtml]Given that firm's profitability is influenced by the profitability of an industry it is crucial to analyse it. I assume that such an audit would follow PESTLE (it provides macro-environmental analysis, which 5F lacks) and SWOT analyses, and would be done by a company in order to establish whether or not to enter/stay in an industry. Such tools are useful providing we recognise their limitations.*The Forces are difficult to quantify and even if I applied a numerical scale to my analysis above, the overall industry score would be subjective and most likely differ from those of other students in the group, even though we sat in the same seminar.*Government's influence although not represented in the model (it assumes a perfect market) may play an important role in some of the more regulated economies, especially in the acceding countries.*5F mainly base on the economic situation in the 80's characterised by strong competition and relatively stable market structures, and is not able to take into account new business models (e.g. strategic alliances) and the dynamics of markets, therefore providing only snapshots of situation in today's dynamic industries.*It focuses on industry as a determinant of company's profitability underestimating firm's core competencies as a source of competitive advantage. A company won't be profitable just because it's based in an attractive industry(3).Overall though, 5F is a powerful analysis tool, which offers good explanation for the profitability of an industry, allows to identify the source of competition and compare the impact of competitive forces on the firm and on its rivals. It is of great importance when setting out firm's strategic options.Most importantly, in my opinion, it enabled me to analyze the current situation of the industry in a structured and easy-to-understand way.After reflection and further research I think that the belief in a model's ability to provide a solution is too great. No model can be complicated enough to simulate and/or predict reality, and although 5F's simplicity sometimes works against it in the modern world, generally simplicity of a model aids to its usefulness(4). Although 5F offers good analysis of external environment, strategy shouldn't...

Find Another Essay On Reflective piece on usefulness of Porter's Five Forces model.

Five Forces Model Essay

1485 words - 6 pages Professor Michael Porter of the Harvard Business School developed a framework that aids in the development of an organizations competitive advantage. Porter identified five basic forces that act on the organization; I. The bargaining power of suppliers; II. The bargaining power of buyers; III. The threat of potential new entrants; IV. The threat of substitutes; V. The extent of competitive rivalry. The bargaining power

Lowes’ Porter's Five Forces Competitive Analysis

1272 words - 5 pages by discounting, differentiating and adding extra value on the product or services. High level, intense rivalry may result with profit lost for the company. In most cases, new entrant barriers are high due to the intensity of rivalry (Porter, 2008). Lowes’ Porter's Five Forces Competitive Analysis As relevant to these competitive forces, the common and mutual goal of companies can be explained as better profitability with a greater market share

Airline industry and Porter's five forces.

567 words - 2 pages 1.Use Porter's five forces of competition' framework to show how the structure of the airline industry has caused low profitability during the past twenty years.Below are Porter's five forces of competition. In them you will understand what has caused low profitability.The bargaining power of suppliers: Labor is the airline industry's largest single expense. Most airline workers belong to one of a dozen unions, which give the airline workers

Use Michael Porter's five forces model to analyse the business environment in which your organization operates: Victor Chids

1691 words - 7 pages IntroductionAll organizations have got a set of forces and conditions outside their own boundaries that have the potential to affect the way the organization works. MoreMoney Banking Corporation Limited is no exception to this as it has got forces that it has to operate within. Michael Porter came up with the Five Forces Model commonly known as Porters' Five Forces Model which is used for analyzing an industry by looking at five forces believed

Publix Super Markets: The Five Forces Model of Competition

1358 words - 5 pages competitors is the Five Forces Model of Competition. The five aspects that will be discussed are the threat of new entrants into the market, the bargaining power of suppliers and buyers, threat of substitute products and rivalry among competing firms. Striving for the optimal position in each of these categories has given Publix Super Markets the reputation it has pride towards earning. It is important to every company to keep a balance between these five

Porter's Five Forces, online marketing advantages, and marketing ethics.

1447 words - 6 pages of New York City. If one were to fly to New York City on Southwest, they would have to factor into their travel plans the additional travel cost and time to get from Long Island to the city.Looking at the other factors in Porter's Five Forces Model, the barriers to entry into the industry are difficult to overcome. A company would need to have a fleet of aircraft, proper licensing, and enough qualified staff to safely operate, all of which can be

Comparing the resource based view, Porter's five forces

8332 words - 33 pages exploratory study is an attempt to present the present status of Internet banking in India and the extent of Internet banking services offered by Internet banks. In addition, it seeks to examine the factors affecting the extent of Internet banking services. Design/methodology/approach - The data for this study are based on a survey of bank websites explored during July 2008. The sample consists of 82 banks operating in India at 31 March 2007. Multiple

Ryan Air: Analysis using SWOT & Porter's Five Forces

2073 words - 8 pages operating a fleet of six aircraft, employing 350 people, carrying 700 passengers on just five routes , and it had recorded its first ever profit.Over the next couple of years, schedules on the key Dublin-London route wrew increased average air fares were lowered and new routes were launched from Dublin to Birmingham, Glasgow, Manchester, and Gatwick. The number of customers continued to grow, thanks largely to Ryanair's low fares. By 1994,Ryanair

Five Forces Model for Industry Analysis

1623 words - 6 pages Five Forces Model for Industry AnalysisNew EntrantsThe online bookstore industry that Amazon.com has pioneered in was, at first, very hard to penetrate. There were different barriers such as distributing capabilities and the variety of the selection offered that are supposed to be hurdled. Amazon successfully solved the tricky parameters as being the first one to get into the whole idea of online retail. With being the first, they had the luxury

Choose the airlines as an industry to apply the Michael Porter's 'five forces' model and discuss how one established airline like SIA should respond to the competitive environment.

2109 words - 8 pages effect on a company's strategic competitiveness and above-average returns. While companies, in this case, our very own SIA, cannot directly control the elements of the general environment, it can influence and will be influenced by factors in the airline industry and competitor environments. The intensity of competition in the airline industry and its profit potential are a function of Michael Porter's 'five forces' model of competition: the treats

Describe the porter's diamond model and show how each of the five factors influence the attractiveness of an Industry.

3644 words - 15 pages Porter's Five ForcesA MODEL FOR INDUSTRY ANALYSISThe model of pure competition implies that risk-adjusted rates of return should be constant across firms and industries. However, numerous economic studies have affirmed that different industries can sustain different levels of profitability; part of this difference is explained by industry structure.Michael Porter provided a framework that models an industry as being influenced by five forces

Similar Essays

Porter's Five Forces. Essay

2326 words - 9 pages Introduction.'Competitive strategy is the bases on which a business unit might achieve competitive advantage in its market '.There are two factors for a firm to be profitable: the fetching appearance of the industry in which it operates and its position in this industry.The best known and most used set of competitive strategies are Michael Porter's Generic Strategies; he calls these generic strategies because they can be applied to a firm in any

Porter's Five Forces Essay

2255 words - 9 pages on dotcom boom of around year 1996 and the typical representatives are eTrade, Charles Schwab and Scottrade. They provide speed securities tradings and low commission to the public. 2. Review of the Literature The classical papers of Michael Porter will be largely used in this essay. “Understanding the forces that shape industry competition is the starting point for developing strategy” (Porter, 2008). The Porter (2008) Five Forces Model are

Porter's Five Forces Model And The Movie Rental Business

916 words - 4 pages or partners better by supplying quality products and virtual service to promote brand lifting, customer feedback, great customer experience, and offering the right product to the targeted market. Porter's Five Forces Model is one of the frameworks that help businesses develop their market strategy and analysis. This paper will focus on the Porter Model to evaluate a prospective market entrance for a potential movie rental business. Therefore, the

Five Porter's Model Essay

536 words - 2 pages Five Porter's ModelThe five forces model was developed by Michael Porter in order to analyse the task environment. According to the model there are five competitive forces that affect a firm: the threat of entry by potential competitors, the power of buyers, the power of suppliers, the threat of substitute products, and the intensity of rivalry between already existing firms. Barriers of entry are factors that prevent the competitors to enter an