This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Reform Models In Collegiate Sports Essay

1343 words - 5 pages

Over the past 100 years, college sports have attracted controversy pertaining to how they should be treated, that is, as business opportunities or academic vocation. Different reforms have been initiated, with academicians and researchers coming up with different models explaining how college sports and sports people should be treated. These models seek to understand and give directions on the need for balancing education with commercialized sports. Three key conceptual models have been initiated to reform college sports by scholars such as Craughron, Benford, Smith and Gerdy (Sack, 2009). In addition, Roy, Graeff & Harman (2008) underscore that these models include the intellect elitism, the athletes’ rights and academic capitalists. These three models represent varying views pertaining to the role of commercialized college sports in today’s learning education or higher education. This understanding portends that the major focus, despite their contrasting views, is on revenue generating sports, emphasizing the increasing stakeholder’s roles, including college athletes and institutions of higher learning. However, they vary on their interpretation of the relationship that exist academic values and sports commercialization, athletic scholarships legal status and educational impact and finally on higher education’s mission.
Intellectual elitism reformers are of the view that highly commercialization of college athletics negatively affects the higher education in America, as sale of athletic programs by universities to corporate sponsors or television networks leads to the trumping of academic values by television ratings (Sack, 2009). As a result, they argue that commercialization of college athletics make universities to admit students with very low academic qualifications or credentials. Such prioritization attracts students, who care more about sports as compared to education values, which is inconsistent with the goals of higher education.
Notably, Roy, Graeff & Harman (2008) assert that academic capitalism scholars on the other hand argue that the awarding of athletic scholarships enables college athletes to improve on their academic, and that they have a democratizing effect as far as higher education is concerned. Academic capitalism notes that such scholarships help college athletes, especially women and those from minority groups to acquire an education. Sobocinski (2000) notes that close monitoring of athletes and offering them academic support can ensure college athletes to be at par academically with other students. Under this model, college athletes are viewed as amateurs who engage in sports as part of their vocation, being prepared for future careers, with sports offering real life experiences and leadership lessons pertaining to self discipline, self sacrifice and hard work among other leadership elements.
Athlete’s rights reformists argue that commercialization of college sports is part of American life, and that it should not be...

Find Another Essay On Reform Models in Collegiate Sports

Collegiate Athletes Receive Enough Payment Essay

741 words - 3 pages The most recent uproar among college sports is the discussion of whether or not collegiate athletes should receive pay. Leo Gerald of The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette writes about how collegiate athlete do deserve to be paid. Gerald says collegiate athletes deserve payment because of scholarship reduction, the risk of life changing injuries, and schools do not provide medical insurance to the athletes. Some agree with what Gerald wrote in The

The current system of collegiate athletics and the NCAA

2615 words - 11 pages The current system of collegiate athletics and the NCAA Meggyesy, David. "Athletes In Big-time College Sport." society 37.3 (2000): 24-28. Print. The NCAA has become a revenue generator as college athletics have become a multi-billion dollar sports entertainment enterprise. The most prominent contradiction with the NCAA is that amateur rules are applied to the athletes, while the rules of the market apply to the university’s athletic

Title IX’s Lasting Effects on Gender Equality in Federally Funded Sports Activities

1732 words - 7 pages changes required by Title IX has had many financial impacts on high schools and colleges. Colleges in particular have seen large impacts from Title IX, especially in enrollment and the addition of new sports programs. The financial effects of Title IX may seem minimal when compared to the cultural impacts of this legislation due to the fact that finances are ever changing. When examining the financial impacts of Title IX, high school and collegiate

Persuasive essay on college

637 words - 3 pages hard work and effort that they may have spent a tremendous amount of time on. Moreover, there are a lifetime of health care bills for some collegiate athletes in sports that involve contact. How can a scholarship compensate the debilitating injuries caused by their involvement in sports. Above all, how can we truly enjoy a game knowing that a career ending injury can leave him with a lifetime of pain, and not a way to pay for the treatment of such

Sport Safety: Should headgear be made mandatory for all contact sports?

1246 words - 5 pages Australia. 2014. Does football cause brain damage? | Medical Journal of Australia. [ONLINE] Available at: [Accessed 20 March 2014]. Catastrophic Head Injuries in High School and Collegiate Sports. 2014.Catastrophic Head Injuries in High School and Collegiate Sports. [ONLINE] Available at: [Accessed 20 March 2014]. ASTM Sports

Title IX and Equality: Flawed Logic?

1696 words - 7 pages level of play for women’s sports would increase fan interest and provide more viable female role models. Another added benefit of better competition would be increased media coverage. Essentially the problem which Title IX seeks to address can only be effectively addresses at a younger age and lower level, attempting a quick and immediate fix at the collegiate level only provides a temporary patch rather than a lasting solution. Also it creates

The Name of the Game

2284 words - 10 pages NCAA, regulates all aspects of collegiate sports, including payment of athletes, or rather, lack thereof. Although many people believe that attending America’s top universities on scholarships is payment enough, the NCAA should change its rules on player payment because it would encourage players to stay in school, help players who live below the poverty line, and distribute the money to the players who rightfully earn it. Interestingly, the

Homosexuality in the Locker Room

643 words - 3 pages Sports, from high school to the professional level, value concepts of masculinity (Zipp, 2010) that create both real and perceived environments of fear for gay male (1) athletes (Anderson, 2011), (2) employees of professional and collegiate athletic programs (Cavalier, 2011), as well as (3) sport journalists (Kian, 2013). According to Hernandez (2011, p. 4), since the World Health Organization (WHO) established a written definition of health in

The Time has Come for Women's Wrestling

1012 words - 4 pages athletics offered by a recipient, and no recipient shall provide any such athletics separately on such basis." This sentence alone gives the impression that women are or should be allowed to participate in all collegiate sports. Title IX further states that, "A recipient may operate or sponsor separate teams for members of each sex where selection for such teams is based upon competitive skill or the activity involved is a contact sport. However

Sports and Recruitment for Colleges

1364 words - 5 pages sports. Since 1971, the number of girl athletes has risen more than two million females. These young girls go out get exercise, have a good time, meet new people all while possibly earning a free college education. The great increase in numbers has not just been with younger females, but also with post-collegiate female athletes. Within the past five years, U.S. females have made great accomplishments in Olympic soccer, softball, basketball

Women Athletes of the 1920s

1720 words - 7 pages become athletes in the early twentieth century. These women, such as Gertrude Ederle, Glenna Collett Care, and Helen Wills Moody, became female role models in the male-oriented world of sports. Gertrude Ederle was the first woman swimmer to join the crowd of poor and humble Americans who became national heroes. Ederle never graduated from high school, yet her accomplishments “had definite feminist implications” (Wukovits, 2000, p. 179). On

Similar Essays

Is Drug Abuse A Common Theme In Collegiate And Professional Levels In Sports

1447 words - 6 pages Robert Harlin III Professor Paul Hankamp Biology 130 16 May 2014 Is drug abuse a common theme in collegiate and professional levels in sports? Drug abuse is a common dilemma throughout America. According to the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration’s (SAMHSA) National Survey on Drug Use and Health, it was found that 23.5 million persons aged 12 or older needed treatment for an illicit drug or alcohol abuse problem in 2009

America's Obsession With Sports Essay

2263 words - 9 pages the use of technological innovations. As we continue to get more advanced, the closer we can get to true feelings of our role models. These feelings remind us that even though one may be a hero in our eyes, they are still just a simple human being like ourselves. Sports over the years have changed both in positive and in negative ways, not only in the broader base of the players, but in the attention of society. With America’s passion for sports

America's Love Of Sports Essay

2224 words - 9 pages through the use of technological innovations. As we continue to get more advanced, the closer we can get to true feelings of our role models. These feelings remind us that even though one may be a hero in our eyes, they are still just a simple human being like ourselves. Sports over the years have changed both in positive and in negative ways, not only in the broader base of the players, but in the attention of society. With America’s passion for

Womens Bodies In Sports Ads Essay

607 words - 2 pages level. The models shown are just an image that fuels the sale of these exercise magazines.Generally, the women who buy these magazines are ones like myself. I am interested in women?s sports and fitness, since I am a varsity athlete. These magazines do not just target female collegiate athletes; they attract most women concerned with body image and a healthy lifestyle. Although, many buyers of these magazine do not see how women in sports advertising are women first and athletes second they still attract female buyers.