Reformulating The Hazards Mitigation Paradigm Essay

2211 words - 9 pages

Scholarly assessments of our nation’s capability to effectively respond to hazards suggest a paradigm shift is needed regarding the future direction of research, policy and tactics for preparing and responding to natural and human-made hazards. This paper will provide a historical overview of our nation’s emergency preparedness and response posture, examine the need to reformulate the existing hazards paradigm into a broader resiliency framework, and suggest roles and responsibilities characteristic of government and community stakeholders in the context of this broadened approach. Mechanisms needed to achieve a successful implementation of this improved strategy will also be examined.


Reformulating the Hazards Mitigation Paradigm
The federal government's role in preparing for, preventing, mitigating, responding to and recovering from natural and man-made disasters can be traced back to the Congressional Act of 1803. The Act was enacted to provide relief from the aftermath of a devastating New Hampshire fire (Federal Emergency Management Agency, 2010). Later disasters that occurred throughout our nation’s history “reached catastrophic proportions in terms of deaths, injuries and property loss which focused government and public attention on the need to develop formal systems to respond to such events” (Waugh & Tierney, 2007, p. 27). Accordingly, federal involvement in emergency planning and response increased to the degree where, by the 1970’s, more than 100 agencies were responsible for some element of emergency preparedness and response. Similarly, numerous programs were instituted at state and local levels, compounding the complexity of response efforts. This broad-based, uncoordinated approach yielded a fragmented response posture, with roles and missions unclear across government, community and private sector lines. An effort to centralize federal emergency functions was instituted in 1979 where many separate disaster-related responsibilities were merged into the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). FEMA developed an integrated emergency management system, realigning its mission from civil defense into disaster relief, recovery and mitigation programs using an all-hazards approach. Following the terrorist attacks of 2001, FEMA coordinated its activities with the newly formed Office of Homeland Security by joining 22 other federal agencies, programs and offices which became the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) in 2003 (Federal Emergency Management Agency, 2010).
Despite efforts to better organize federal response programs, “expectations regarding improved federal response to natural disasters were shattered by FEMA’s poor performance in dealing with hurricanes (Waugh & Tierney, 2007, p.33). While integrating FEMA into DHS was intended to the federal response capability, DHS was found to be plagued by high employee turnover and low morale to the degree Homeland Security had the lowest job-satisfaction rating out of 36...

Find Another Essay On Reformulating the Hazards Mitigation Paradigm

Mitigating The Impact of Disasters Essay

981 words - 4 pages Both disasters and catastrophes are the result of a hazard or hazards coming into contact with humans in a vulnerable position. (Mileti, 1999) A beachfront row of condominiums along the US Gulf coast is an example of a disaster waiting to happen. If the condominiums aren’t there and the beach is in a natural state when a hurricane blows in there will be no disaster or catastrophe because humans wouldn’t be impacted. Although the characteristics

We Must Stop Climate Change Essay

1425 words - 6 pages adaptation could be; effective communication and accessibility of information about the hazards and conditions leading to it, risk covering financing system, economic diversification and livelihood options, awareness raising education, flexible and resilient infrastructure system, voice raising and knowledge sharing and preparing preventive, mitigation, response, recovery and preparedness strategies and plan. The ability to reduce vulnerability

Wichita, Kansas and Tornados

689 words - 3 pages %, respectively (US Census Bureau, 2011). Those vulnerable populations will require additional assistance from local emergency management in the event of a direct hit on the city from a tornado. The people of Wichita, as well as their public officials, should regard mitigation of and preparedness for tornado and storm hazards as a high probability with high consequences. Their efforts should be opposite of what is known as “low probability high

Ice Storms and Severe Winter Storms

2949 words - 12 pages process. In particular relation to ice and winter storms, it does not seem to be that North America focuses much on the mitigation phase. Hwacha (2005) confirms the following:Approximately eighty percent of Canadian disasters are due to weather and weather-related hazards such as tornadoes, hurricanes, hail storms, blizzards, storm surges, ice storms and floods…Canada's current emergency management system remains overtly response focused

Environment Managment Paradigms in New Zealand

1916 words - 8 pages of the brundtland report in 1987 with its definition of sustainable development. The last definition is seeing the environment as a risk, related to mitigation and adaption and is based around discourse on climate change. This definition has been the basis of natural hazard and climate change legislation and policies around the world. While these definitions may be true to the practice of planning in England, many of the definitions in Davoudi’s

Droughts: The End of the American West

661 words - 3 pages Droughts are one of the most expensive natural hazards and have the potential to last for months or even years (U.S. Drought Portal). Along with famine and flooding, droughts are considered one of the top three threats to the population (Oblack). A drought is defined as an unusually long period of time with persistent lack of precipitation that causes serious problems. Several factors that affect the severity of a drought are the degree of

Risk Assessment and Planning in IT Projects.

3600 words - 14 pages institutions, this further proves that risk management techniques are usually tailored for specific sectors or organisations.HAZOPHAZOP (Hazard and Operability Study) is a risk assessment method built on critical examination techniques. It was developed in the sixties for the chemical industries. HAZOP's aim is to improve systems and try to prevent hazards before life-threatening incidents occur, for example nuclear meltdown. The risk assessment is

Changes In The Earths Environment

1961 words - 8 pages exploitation of geographic information systems in hazard mitigation has greatly reduced the extent to which natural hazards are seen as a threat to people in the 90's (Chapman et al, 1994). Loss of life and property from natural disasters continue to rise though as the population of the world rises and puts more demands on the environment for land resources. White (1974) argues that environmental risk may be considered to be primarily a function

Evaluation: Twenty years ago natural hazards were a major topic of study as people were seen to be at risk from the environment. Today the situation appears to be reversed, and there is concern that t

2122 words - 8 pages systems in hazard mitigation has greatly reduced the extent to which natural hazards are seen as a threat to people in the 90's (Chapman et al, 1994). Loss of life and property from natural disasters continue to rise though as the population of the world rises and puts more demands on the environment for land resources. White (1974) argues that environmental risk may be considered to be primarily a function of the value systems of a society. How

Deep Blue Lake or Crater Lake

2181 words - 9 pages , bridges and other structures. Monitoring, Mitigation and Hazard Planning: When you have potential hazards in an area with civilization and populations, plans need to be set in place. Crater Lake is separated into zones for potential threat such as the Proximal Hazard Zone is the crater itself and its rim. The height of ejections is one of the main determinations for the boundaries of the Proximal Zone. Because Ballistic blocks and a possible

Floods in Winnipeg, Canada

2075 words - 8 pages Introduction: Canada is a great place to live. Winnipeg… is good enough. Winnipeg is known for its diverse population, festive multiculturalism, beautiful architecture, vast prairie land and The Jets. One thing Winnipeg is definitely not known for, being a geological hazards hot spot. These hazards are geological events that take place, which have an impact on civilization. Canada is impacted by a wide scope of events ranging from

Similar Essays

Hazard Mitigation Essay

1895 words - 8 pages such as flood protection, infrastructure hardening, tax-free incentives for improving emergency preparedness, and land-use strategies that protect natural habitats and minimize the adverse impacts of development are necessary components for reformulating the hazard mitigation paradigm. Evaluating and hardening facility physical design and layout to protect against disasters will help mitigate risk and damage. Technology also has an important

A Critical Appraisal On The Article By John A. Cross Titled, Megacites And Small Towns: Different Perspectives On Hazard Vulnerability.

1154 words - 5 pages MEGACITIES AND SMALL TOWNS: DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES ON HAZARD VULNERABILITY"In a world of uncertainty, the only constant is change and rapid change produces amultitude of diverse facts." Risk is an integral part of life and it is based on a combination ofhazard and vulnerability. Over the past couple of decades, considerable attention has been placedupon the studies of hazards and their mitigation processes. While no country in the world

Attention Material Essay

954 words - 4 pages INTRODUCTION I. Attention Material A. Issue at hand. 1. Disasters can occur at any moment, anywhere; financial and human consequences are very difficult to predict. 2. Disasters, over the last century have been increasing at a rapid rate as only 50% of events require Federal assistance. (FEMA) 3. Federal mitigation plans and programs reduce the impact of a given disaster also with our dependence on taxes, Treasury for relief. B. What is

Black Swan Events: Global Emergency Management

1155 words - 5 pages system similar to a Tsunami early warning system. According to Mileti there several things that can be done to facilitate this paradigm shift in thinking in leadership in emergency management. He is of the view that there needs to be an adaptation of a global systems perspective in addressing emergency management issues. He stated that human beings need to realize that while we cannot change the course of natural hazards like hurricane