This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Refuting Objections To Direct Realism Essay

1305 words - 6 pages

Refuting Objections to Direct Realism

Introduction
Realism is the form of perception in which it is believed that there is an external world outside of our own minds. It is the belief that regardless of what we may belief is true of false, the external world is independent of these beliefs. There are two forms of realism which are direct and indirect. In this essay I will argue that direct realism is a more plausible theory of perception than indirect realism by refuting the main arguments against direct realism. I will begin by briefly describing direct and indirect realism and follow with countering two of the main arguments indirect realists use against direct realists.
Direct Realism vs. Indirect Realism
Direct Realism is the belief that perception is an immediate and direct understanding of objects that are existent in the external world, independent of the mind. The objects in this external world have qualities such as shape, size, texture, colour taste and smell which exist and continue to obtain their properties regardless of whether they are being perceived or not. Direct realists hold that through our senses we have the ability to obtain knowledge about the object itself and what is being perceived is the exact object that exists in this external, mind-independent world. Indirect realist do not believe in the direct perception of objects in the external, mind-independent world, but rather in the indirect perception through, what is called, sense-data. Sense-data is the supposed mind-dependent objects through which we are able to perceive the external world. When perceiving an object, indirect realists claim that what we see is not the object itself but a representation of the object and this representation that is seen in our minds is sense-data.

Partial Character of Perception Argument

One of the main arguments against direct realism is the partial character of perception argument. The argument is as follows;
P1: Direct realists claim that we directly and immediately perceive material objects.
P2: But in order to perceive a material object, all parts must be observed at once.
P3: It is not possible to perceive all of an object at once, only a section of its exterior surface.
C: We do not directly perceive material objects and therefore direct realism is false.
The issue with this argument lies within the second premise which claims that in order to perceive an object, all parts must be observed at once. This claim is invalid as perceiving an object does not require all parts to be observed as once just as reading a book does not require all pages to be read at once or visiting friends does not require all friends to be visited at once. In the direct perception of an object we do not see the whole object, however only a section. It is correct that we may not recognise or identify the object we are perceiving, however it is not true that in doing this we are not in fact directly perceiving the section of the object exposed for...

Find Another Essay On Refuting Objections to Direct Realism

The Importance of Rhetoric and Discussion of Freedom of Speech

1710 words - 7 pages this attempt to persuade he uses the fallacy known as “appeal to pity” when commenting, “Racial epithets and harassment often cause deep emotional scarring and feelings of anxiety and fear that pervade every aspect of a victim’s life” (Lawrence 623.) By using this fallacy to create a refuting point, the argument becomes invalid and unreliable. Rauch’s management of rhetorical terms such as, hypophora, metaphor, and allusions all create a more

Do We Perceive the World via Sense Data?

1255 words - 5 pages external world through a veil of perception, representing the real world. The theory of Representative Realism is similar to Direct Realism, in that there is an objective mind independent physical world; however, we only ever perceive it vie a subjective mind-dependent intermediary (called sense data). The idea of Sense Data is designed to circumvent many of the problems in Common Sense Realism. Sense Data successfully explains what illusions are

Analysis of Ways of War and Peace

1258 words - 6 pages Michael W. Doyle’s book Ways of War and Peace systematically analyzes classic theories like realism and liberalism that try to explain why nations wage war. However, not all theories discussed within the text are equal. In this paper I will try to argue that within the book written by Michael Doyle he paints a picture that the theory of realism is more applicable today then liberalism, even if that was not his original intention. Through careful

Realism and the Concepts of Collective Security and Defense

2323 words - 9 pages This is of direct correlation to the ideals of realism. If realism was not applicable then and now then it would be easy to say that the lesser nations (whilst fulfilling their oaths and roles in their respective collectives) would then be able to aid the superior nations and in doing so affect the re-stabilization of the alliance, league, or coalition what have you. However, it is seen time and time again that collectives crumbled because of a

female genital mutilation controversies

1574 words - 6 pages more painful- a life of solitude, humiliation, and deprivation". Therefore, by refuting one of the most common objections to FGM, Tamir argues that although FGM is a deplorable practice, there are deeper roots to the Westerner's opposition towards it.On the other hand, in her respond to Tamir in her article "Double Moral Standards?", Martha Nussbaum takes a clear stance against FGM by arguing that the Westerners' help is needed for the abolishment

Why Shouldnt Societ Y Treat Substance Abusers?

797 words - 3 pages comes to completeness, Leshners essay is lacking in the opposing arguments. He fails to support the opposing side, in most cases. However, even though he provides adequate support and findings to back his thesis, he does anticipate objections and questions that the reader might raise about the effectiveness of different treatments for drug addiction. In paragraph 4, he responds to them by refuting the objections, and simply goes on to state that

The Shift from Realism to Impressionism

1105 words - 4 pages Both Realism and Impressionism began in France with both art periods lending to the world unique techniques, aesthetic approaches and subjects in painting. While Impressionism stemmed from Realism, it can be argued Impressionism ultimately lead to continued individual expression in art through out the historical art periods to follow. The art period of Realism from 1845 to 1900, has roots which trail back to mid 1800s France and developed as

Realism and The Prince

2096 words - 9 pages are typical methods applied in empirical studies for realism. In this way, Machiavelli points out that princes and kings should rule by learning lessons from past experiences. Machiavelli claims to be focusing on what really happens rather than mere theories or speculations (Machiavelli, Book XV). He bases his discussion on historical and contemporary evidence which provides an empirical base for his work. Besides, in refuting ethical and

Why do realists believe international politics to be 'recurrent and repetitive'?

2901 words - 12 pages ): "Realism and International Relations"; Cambridge University Press, pp. 1, 13-154) Elman, Colin & Miriam Fendius Elman (1997): "Lakatos and Neorealism: A reply to Vasquez"; American Political Science Review 91; December; pp. 923-9265) Garnet, John C (1984): "Commonsense and the Theory of International Politics"; Macmillan, London6) Gilpin, Robert (1975): "U.S. Power and Multinational Corporation : The political economy of direct foreign

Is indirect realism a plausable theory of perception?looking at the pros and cons of lockes indirect theory of perception

2374 words - 9 pages following pages I shall examine the arguments for and against such a theory of perception.The direct realist's theory of perception says that to perceive an object is to perceive it directly, through no medium. Direct realism seems to suggest that the following statements hold true;there exists a world of material objectswe can learn of the nature and properties of these objects through sense-experiencewe perceive the object directly, we are

Critically Evaluate Cupitt's Cultural-linguistic Approach to Religious Language

1708 words - 7 pages , consisted of human freedom to make ethical choices (2003). It is this freedom or in Cupitt's words, autonomy, this essay argues, that the Western secular world including Cupitt has been trying to seek to achieve since the Enlightenment. Humans, Cupitt argues, "need a spirituality to direct their freedom and to make it fruitful so that human lives can gain something of the nothing-wasted integrity and completeness of a work of art", a spirituality

Similar Essays

The Utilitarian And Kantian Perspective: Prompt #2

1068 words - 5 pages objections and deaths of the soldiers who were assigned to transport private Ryan. Based on Utilitarianism, since General Marshall is an agent within an agent, a general in the US army, he is a private utility where “the happiness of some few persons is all he has to attend to” (Wetzell PP/ Mills 249). To be deemed as a private utility one has to be operating under/within a greater agent. Mills proclaims in the Greatest Happiness Principle

Humans' Senses And Perceptions Essay

1438 words - 6 pages is going on. This philosophy is called direct realism, and was created by Scottish philosopher Thomas Ried. According to Ried, “Direct realism is the view that the immediate (direct) objects of perception are external objects, qualities, and events.” Although direct realism is still considered a valid philosophical doctrine, the amount of pragmatic evidence refuting it is astounding. Take the Gettier problem: Imagine that you are standing

What Is It Like For Mary To Be A Bat?

1005 words - 5 pages knowledge, because although Mary knew all there was to know about the color red, she still gained knowledge from actually experiencing it-Thus refuting physicalism. Connection to Qualia These two objections are very similar, in the sense that qualia play an important role in consciousness and how organisms perceive the world around them. However; Nagel’s slight difference between comparing bats and humans rather than comparing humans and humans

How Did Aquinas Resolve The Conflict Between Aristotelian Philosophy And The Christian Doctrine Of The Beginning Of The World?

1809 words - 7 pages result of these two articles together is the feeling that Aquinas is entertaining the notion of an eternal yet created universe. But as Wippel points out "Once more he is directly concerned with refuting argumentation in favour of the non-eternity of the world rather than with positively asserting that an eternal world is possible". Aquinas' direct assertion of the possibility of an eternal created entity is left to the De Aeternite mundi where he