Regulatory Takings Due To Historic Designations

1507 words - 6 pages

Historical buildings are undeniably important to the United States and its people. The law of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, or NHPA, was enacted specifically to protect such buildings. Many citizens appreciate the value of these buildings and take strong stances for their preservation. Such citizens include those of California, which will be the state on that this paper will be focusing on. The issue at hand is who takes the side of the private owners of such buildings when their private property is at the mercy of special interest groups and judicial proceedings? Specifically, owners are at risk of holding an economically defunct asset due to the ambiguous rulings on the matter of designating buildings as historically significant. This paper proposes to rid of that ambiguity and recommends that the Constitution of California be amended to ensure that loss of economic use of real property due to historic designation constitutes a taking and requires just compensation.
The Current State of the Law
The section of the California Constitution being proposed for amendment is Article I, Section 19, which states: “Private property may be taken or damaged for public use only when just compensation, ascertained by jury unless waived, has first been paid to, or into the court for, the owner." This clause usually covers condemnation of real property, also known as eminent domain. Eminent domain is generally understood to provide for compensation if the claim is for public use. To take this one step further is the relevant topic of a regulatory taking. This results when the police power of the governing body is applies regulations that deprive all reasonable use of the private owner’s use of the land. To reiterate, this paper is advocating for the clear definition and application as a regulatory taking when a property is burdened with historical designation.

The Need for the Amendment
The law needs to be transparent because it has the potential to unreasonably burden the private owner of a historical building. There have been multiple cases in various states for which the results are unfavorable to the property owner. The most notorious case is Penn Central v. New York City. The U.S. Supreme Court ruling on this case is that if a property owner is left with somewhat of a means of return on investment, the designation as a historical landmark and the prevention of demolition does not qualify as a regulatory taking. The Court also depended on the notion that the preserving such historical landmarks constituted a public benefit. Based on this precedent, owners must bear the task of maintaining historical structures as the current use for the public benefit, while only “gaining” the reputation of historical designation.

To further exemplify this argument, another case that shows detriment towards the private historical property owner is United Artists Theatre Circuit v. City of Philadelphia. In the case, the Boyd Theater was declared a...

Find Another Essay On Regulatory Takings Due to Historic Designations

H2N2 Essay

2243 words - 9 pages . Even if we are willing to accept the controversial proposition position that the court may overturn a statute that offends common decency on Due Process grounds, vaccination, a relatively non-invasive procedure that millions of Americans receive voluntarily every year, cannot possibly rise to this level. A vaccination is not “conduct that shocks the conscience” akin to punitive sterilization or forced stomach pumping to extract evidence of drug

Where Is Disney Most Vulnerable from a Communication Viewpoint?

663 words - 3 pages parties are “due to the nature of their legal or economic relation to the undertaking or affected properties, or their concern with the undertaking’s effects on historic properties” (NHPA, p.15). Their participation is subject to approval by the responsible federal agency. Proper communication and consideration planning would assist Disney to properly located land that was non-historical and public accept site to start Eisner proposal of American

The Major Risks of Financial Intermediaries

2350 words - 9 pages probable outcome is that they can go into severe financial distress or this could lead to bankruptcy. The risks come when the financial intermediaries do not correctly regulate their own techniques and staff. There are many examples where financial intermediaries such as Baring’s bank and BCCI (Bank of Credit & Commerce International) were forced to declare bankruptcy due the inappropriate actions as they themselves played as


1647 words - 7 pages You have been hired by a cell tower company to evaluate a plan that will erect cell towers through a local community. Your job is to locate any historic buildings or sites that might be impacted (placed next to, or on, or be damaged in some way) by the cell towers. You discover there are 10 buildings along the route the cell towers will take. How will you go about deciding if these buildings are historic? What criteria will you use? Why? The

Accounting Regulatory Bodies Paper

945 words - 4 pages Week 1 Assignment Running Head: Accounting Regulatory Bodies Paper Accounting Regulatory Bodies Paper Charles Medley University of Phoenix ACC 300 Minh Truong May 14, 2009 Accounting Regulatory Bodies Paper There are many different accounting regulatory bodies and each one is very important when it comes to accounting and the effects the accounting process has on the organization or

Is it Really Necessary to have a Certificate in Order to be a Paralegal?

652 words - 3 pages Paralegal Association. "There are people out there that say to the public that they have those professional designations they don't have, and they dupe the public. We feel if we have the legislation in place, we'll have a means to avoid that and assist in defining who can and can't be a paralegal." Efforts at regulating the paralegal profession are becoming increasingly high. Frederick T. Golder, Professor at the Massachusetts School of

Regression Analysis And Forecasting For Urban Water Supply

1154 words - 5 pages Bay Water Tampa Bay's optimization plan utilizes an integrated hydrologic simulation model and optimization model to manage their 11 wellfields as an integrated water supply system. The hydrologic model simulates changes in water levels due to changes in stress. The optimization model schedules production from the wellfields in order to meet demands from their member counties. The output of the simulation/optimization modeling is a bi-weekly

New Holland Tractors.

1465 words - 6 pages the team heads gave feedback to functional heads and also the organization's main focus was team work, hence priority had to be given to team work over individual work. 2. Dissatisfaction among employees over promotion and recognition - Since NHI was a flat organization so designations were few. An employee working there for many years and a t a senior position would have the same designation as a newly joined employee for similar task. Hence

Judicial Minimalism and Mazimalist in Court Rulings

2351 words - 10 pages decided to only rule on the present case. Rather, the majority opinion left certain aspects open for future debate and discussion regarding the Taking Clause and public purpose. This is seen in the closing statements of the decision as Justice Steven states “We emphasize that nothing in our opinion precludes any State from placing further restrictions on its exercise of the takings power.” In this sense, the court determined that it was not its duty

Women’s Quality of Life and Work

1145 words - 5 pages life in this endeavor and have earned not only my brokers license, but several professional designations to assist others in their success in becoming owners and developers of real property. (Designations explained below) Our goal would be to reach a 90% female contractor base. Also, given the current glut of foreclosures, I would approach lenders to donate foreclosed homes to a not for profit, tax-exempt corporation. Banks would get the tax

Historic Fabrics Design Case Study

1321 words - 5 pages The first step in regenerating the historic fabric, must be recognizing the existence values and desire to protect them. Restoration process begins with cognition of opportunities and advantages of each neighborhood, and understanding of different aspect of neighborhood distressed. These days one of the problems face to regenerating historic fabrics is juxtaposition of valuable buildings with abandoned and deteriorated buildings and areas that

Similar Essays

Case Study: Issue: Takings Clause, Campaign Finance Laws, Commerce Clause

1155 words - 5 pages with foreign nations, and among the several states, and with the Indian tribes; (Article 1)5th and 14 ammendment Takings Clause - Two questions: if the 5th amendment was sufficient to decide what was a taking in terms of state action (as shown in Lucas), why was it necessary for the courts to extend the takings clause to the 14th amendment? Also, why was the Court ever able in the first place to apply the 5th amendment takings clause to states? The

Lochner Essay

1581 words - 7 pages Washington possesses police powers, they may constitutionally remedy social evils they deem necessary. Another area the Constitution allowed businesses to escape economic regulations by the states in the 19th and 20th Centuries is the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment. Businesses claimed the depreciating value of land due to regulations constituted a taking. When the government passes a law regulating the use of property, the ability of the

Constitutional Law: Final Case Scenario Essay

1194 words - 5 pages related to substantive due process. The determination of a “legitimate interest” of the city can be questioned. The city argued that the inclusion of man-made dunes would prevent damage but expert testimony showed that artificial dunes actually increased erosion. If the implementation and construction of the dunes does not prevent the erosion the city is trying to address, then the interest of the city is not legitimate because the law enacted does

The Case Of Procedural And Substantive Law

2226 words - 9 pages 1. Define the terms takings as it relates to the environmental law and provide one example of a legally resolved taking case. Answer: Taking is a general term of an act of taking something. In an environmental point of view, the taking is ta process that involves taking something of an environmental assets, such as land, from an individual or organization. However, most cases, it involves government taking private property from owners when that