Rehabilitation Or Retribution? Essay

967 words - 4 pages

[Type text] [Type text] [Type text]
Rehabilitation or Retribution?The expectations of society for the criminal justice system are to punish and rehabilitate individuals who have committed crime. Punishment and rehabilitation are two acknowledged objectives of the criminal justice system, Retribution, which is based on "an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth" philosophy, simply means punishment and vengeance for what evils have done. While rehabilitation, as Nicholas Tan (1999) noted that "is the idea of 'curing' an offender of his or her criminal tendencies, of changing their habits, their outlook and possibly even personality, so as to make them less inclined to commit crimes in the future", the main aim of rehabilitation is to help prisoners to get some skills in prison, so that when they re-enter into society, they can adapt quickly to the new environment. Debates over these two notions have lasted for a long time, many would argue that the main purpose of prison systems is to punish people who have committed criminals. While this should be the secondary function of prisons, the most important function should be rehabilitating criminals back to the society, not just retribution. As a recent survey showed that over 60 percent respondents agreed that prison should reform prisoners, rather than punish them (Human Rights and Justice Studies, 2000). In this essay, it will argue that rehabilitation is a more efficient way to help prisoners rather than retribution by illustrating advantages of rehabilitation.Some theorists throughout history have argued that the primary purpose of prisons is to punish criminals for what they have done, criminals should get punished when they break the law. When they are sent into prisons, as punishment, they certainly do not have rights to watch TV, access to internet and so on. However, some people may disagree with this, because going into prison is already a punishment, criminals have already lost their freedom, they should not suffer extra punishment by being denied other human rights while in prison. After all, punishment is not the ultimate goal of prisons, redemption from sin is the basic aim of prisons. The root of all crime is due to the lack of education and training, if prisons prevent offenders from receiving education or learning information from outside, then after released, they may feel alienated from society and not be accepted by society, and employers will not employ those who do not have knowledge or job skills which will deteriorate the situation of recidivism. Therefore, rehabilitation should be the main purpose of prisons, for it promotes the humanizing belief in the notion that offenders can be saved and not simply punished (Nicholas. T.,1999).However, some people are afraid that if allow prisoners to receive education or access to internet may provide an environment to make better criminals. Whereas Dr Paul Fauteck (2006) argued that the prison education programs are not "coddling...

Find Another Essay On Rehabilitation or Retribution?

Deviance and Social Control Essay

1230 words - 5 pages monetary payment or even the death penalty. The retribution should fit the crime of deviant behavior. Deterrence works on persons not wishing to be in any form of trouble by showing them what will happen if they are caught. Rehabilitation work for persons that have been caught performing a deviant behavior. Once a person is in jail or some other form of incarcerations, the officials would then decide what type of rehabilitation would be needed

Theories of Punishment Essay

809 words - 4 pages society by generating an opinion of how each type of punishment deters crime the best and if punishment provides any benefit to the offenders and to society. Retribution is something done or given to somebody as punishment or vengeance for something he or she has done. Those who side with retribution usually do not consider trying to improve a criminal in any way and attempting to make him or her an asset to society. Usually, their motto would


1104 words - 4 pages in retribution for an offence or transgression; (also) that which is inflicted as a penalty; a sanction imposed to ensure the application and enforcement of a law." ("Punishment," 2009). The types of punishment continues to fuel debates throughout our country. When a crime is committed regardless of how severe almost everyone in today's society believes that the criminal should be punished. The consequences of the crime should be calculated

Punishment Research Paper

1218 words - 5 pages calculated based on the gravity of the wrong done. In today's society there are four forms of punishment that are used to deter criminal behavior: retribution, deterrence, rehabilitation, and societal protection. In this paper we will look at the effects of these four types of punishment on American society.RetributionBy far the oldest form of punishment would be retribution. The attitude of revenge was probably the first form of retribution, and is also


659 words - 3 pages What is Punishment? Punishment is an authority's infliction of a penalty on a person convicted of committing a crime. This penalty can range from imprisonment for serious offences and fines for minor offences.What are the objectives of Punishment? Punishment has several objectives, including deterrence, retribution, incapacitation and rehabilitation & reform.Deterrence This is the main objective of punishment and is aimed at deterring

Death Penalty for Youth Offenders

1159 words - 5 pages ." According to our cristian values we must forgive those who do harm against us not do harm onto them. The legal system can't focus on retribution and punishment, but rehabilitation and reform. If the death penatly is not revoked atleast for youth offenders we are not abiding by our religious values in which our nation was constructed. We must be civil and peaceful as a society or else we are no different then animals that roam their habitats

Correctional Facilities in The United States

2417 words - 10 pages rehabilitation, deterrence, incapacitation, and retribution. These four methods work individually as well as collectively to produce felons who can be productive citizens of society. Firstly, one main, effective method used by correctional facilities today is rehabilitation. Prisons aim of rehabilitation is to create productive law-abiding citizens through social and moral improvement. (Holt v. Sarver) An examination conducted by California Youth Authority

The Purpose of Punishment in a Modern Society

2454 words - 10 pages rights and are not to be held totally responsible for their deviant actions, instead they can be reformed and rehabilitated through the prison system and that crimes committed habitually should be considered a disease (Garland, 1990). It is through this that philosophers, government and prison officials have arrived at the five traditional goals of punishment which replicates elements of criminal punishment. They are retribution, rehabilitation

The Sentence

769 words - 3 pages "How would you incorporate the sentencing goals of retribution, incapacitation, deterrence, rehabilitation, and restitution in your sentence of this individual for this particular crime?"Need to know InformationBefore imposing a sentence in this case, a judge needs to know specific information. The first piece of information a judge would need before making a decision about sentencing would be how many identities the offender has stolen. The judge

Criminal Sentencing

1378 words - 6 pages . Constitution was added. This amendment also prohibited cruel and unusual punishment from being inflicted to those accused of a crime.Within our legal system there are four main theories of punishment; retribution, deterrence, incapacitation and rehabilitation. Those theories are the basis for criminal sentencing in the United States today.Retribution is defined as "something given or exacted in recompense" (Levinson, 2002). This is basically the act of

Julie Foushi

2256 words - 10 pages rehabilitation. The sentencing board has three punishment goals that consist of deterrence, incapacitation, and retribution. Deterrence sentencing just simple is a tool that hopeful the punishment will deter the offender from such crime again. Incapacitate just removes them from the general public. Retribution simple makes them pay for the crime they have committed whether it be jail or prison time or monetary fees back to the court or victim

Similar Essays

Corrections: Rehabilitation Is More Effective Than Retribution Vs

1550 words - 6 pages , wearing a tether that automatically sends a signal when leaving the confinement area. The offender may be allowed to leave the confinement area for work or school or they may be under the restriction of a curfew. This is in my opinion the lightest of confinement sentences one can receive. Offender’s sentenced to a period of probation are considered likely candidates for rehabilitation; they may be required by the terms of their probation to

Criminal Punishment Essay

1198 words - 5 pages rehabilitation then it might be different. For these types of offenses the best deterrent would be societal protection for the reason most people who commit these crimes cannot be rehabilitated. The people who commit murder need to spend their lives in jail because if they get rehabilitation or small retribution then they might do it again. For most people the fear of having to spend their lives in jail or go to rehabilitation for a long period is

Punishment Essay

873 words - 3 pages ). Retribution demands that the punishment fit the crime, but rehabilitation tailors treatment to each offender (Macionis, 2006, p. 183).The last of the four punishments I will be discussing is societal protection. This punishment is known for rendering an offender incapable of further offenses temporarily through imprisonment or permanently by execution (Macionis, 2006, p. 183). Due to this punishment there are 2 million people imprisoned in the

Assignment: Punishment Research Paper Statistics Show That There Is A High Rate Of Criminal Recidivism In The United States. This Raises The Question, "Does Punishment Deter Crime?"

993 words - 4 pages meetings rather than jail time. Once the citizen has completed rehab, through the proper reformatory chosen for them, they can choose to stay on the same path of freedom contributing to society or go back to their old ways. Rehabilitation is the most forgiving and positive punishment of the four justifications discussed because it promises the offender a second chance at life. Unlike retribution, which demands that the punishment fit the crime