This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Relation Between Confucianism And Democracy Essay

2354 words - 9 pages

Introduction
Over years of debate, Confucianism has long been seen as a conflicting force of democracy, particularly among political scientists who are pro-liberal democracy. This thought has been backed up by the trend of communism or competitive authoritarianism in Asia that liberal democracy seems not to be flourishing in this region due to the strong influence of Confucianism. However, this conventional perception starts to get more challenges from Asian scholars, particularly those emphasizing Confucian perfectionism, that Confucianism instead strengthen democracy, rather than acting as a stumbling stock. In the following, the definition of democracy and the conventional critics against Confucianism in the notion of democracy will be covered, followed by the further elaboration of the complementary relationship between Confucianism and democracy.

Confucianism: Complement to democracy
From the above discussion, first and foremost, definition of democracy matters. Due to the injection of liberal values into the democracy, it limits the scope and possibility of these two seemingly contrasting ideals being compatible with each other. Dworkin (2002) believed Confucianism blocked the nurture of universal human nature in which people are treated with equal concern and respect. However, it is advised to take a pause and look back to what kind of democracy Dworkin is referring to. As argued, Dworkin held on the substantive concept of democracy which is intrinsically valuable in promotion of individual liberties and equality. Yet, Chan (2013) rebutted that if democracy is limited by the liberal values, Confucianism would not be on any ground compatible with democracy since it is not embedded with any liberal accounts like individualism and freedom. That shows how analysis and conclusion varies based on different definitions.

When analysing the compatibility of Confucianism and democracy, it is plausible to suggest applying the procedural definition of democracy. Concurred with Schumpeter (1965), democracy can also be regarded as the competition of votes among politicians that is only instrumentally valuable by bringing more desirable results than other systems. In fact, Confucianism has a lot of similarity with the leadership democracy. According to Schumpeter (ibid), he depicted the reality of politics as a small circle competition among elites who are rational and knowledgeable in identify common interests of people. Being a minimalist, he never came close to the democratic ideals drawn by Dworkin, nor did he believe in endorsing greater extent of political participation among the public help improved the governance at the cost of common good. Similar to Confucians, they believe in achieving common goods by endorsing greater power to the gentlemen who are proved to be both virtuous and knowledgeable, at the expense of absolute equality. In applying the definition of procedural concepts of democracy into the discussion of the compatibility of...

Find Another Essay On Relation Between Confucianism and Democracy

The Relation Between Learning and Wisdom

806 words - 3 pages The Relation Between Learning and Wisdom   "But aren't love of learning and love of wisdom the same?" Socrates asks Glaucon in Book II of Plato's Republic. "Yes, the same," Glaucon answers. And the dialogue passes on to the next point. Today, outside utopia one might question whether these two are the same, since we so often see the one pursued in the absence of the other. In an essay of no more than 750 words, take up the problem of

The Relation between Comedy and Tragedy

631 words - 3 pages The Relation between Comedy and Tragedy   On the surface, comedy and tragedy seem to be complete polar opposites of each other. In terms of the actual narrative, examining the consequences of the character's actions reveals the biggest contrast. In Oedipus Rex, Oedipus' 'sin' of not listening to the Gods and trying to avoid his fate assisted in his downfall. Not only does his internal blindness result in him marrying his mother

Understanding the Relation Between Judaism and Christianity

935 words - 4 pages fact, he was the “Messiah/ the anointed one” for years to the Jewish and the Christians, makes the ties between the two religion close to each other. Jesus was proclaimed to be the Savior of the Jews. The Jews and the early Christians called him the Son of God. The preaching of Jesus was not limited to strictly to Christians. Historically, Seduces were the only group who were against the Jesus and him being the anointed one. Another aspect that

The Relation Between Birds and Dinosaurs

993 words - 4 pages The Relation Between Birds and Dinosaurs One question that has stumped many paleontologists for centuries is, “Are birds dinosaurs?” Paleontologists have argued back and forth trying to prove or disprove each side of the theory. So far, advocates have supported their side through the facts of similar bone structures, bone organization, and the idea that dinosaurs had feathers. A common reaction that some people might have about the question

Relation Between Advertising and Our Consumer Culture

2860 words - 11 pages was famous in recent years. She argues that every purchasing behavior could be seemed as a reflection of customer’s aesthetic attitude, consumption taste and buying habit (I Shop, therefore I Am, 2000). In this article, a topic of the reflection and interaction between advertising and modern consumer culture would be analyzed, including the necessity, representation and semiotic meaning. This essay has three main parts, through a basic review about

The Relation Between Religion and Prosocial Behavior

2935 words - 12 pages ; Rand et al., 2014). Thus, generosity and altruism are more common in religious societies which have big Gods, namely; İslam, Christianity and Judaism (Norenzayan, 2013). These religions have big Gods who are also concerned about morality of humans which is also thought to lead to prosocial behavior. There is a body of research on the relation between religion and prosocial behavior coming from generally priming literature. For instances

Coleridge and the Relation in-between Poet and Critic

4946 words - 20 pages other. That is, without the medium there would be only distinction and separation and no unity. On one level the mediation is between allegory and symbol, then the symbol itself is bifurcated and its binaries are placed in relation through the means of another medium, and then the mind itself is split between faculties of reason, understanding and imagination, and then the imagination is split, first between primary and secondary powers, and

The Relation Between Media Content and Political Power

1226 words - 5 pages It is interesting to comprehend the relation between media content and political power. What biases do the media experience in producing news in relation to government interests? Media, according to Herman and Chomsky, has a tendency toward elites’ political interests; media tend to follow official’s agendas. Herman and Chomsky proved this generalization through the use of terminologies and the way they place such kind of news (a foreign

The Relation Between Gender Equality and Economic Growth

3772 words - 15 pages employment rate matters for GDP and GDP-growth. If the answer is yes two other questions have to follow: 1. What strategies and actions have to be taken in order to “exploit” the economic potential there is in rising female employment and 2. How to fulfil these actions. The aim of my essay is to discuss the relation between gender equality and economic growth, formulated in three questions, and to illustrate this relation on the example of the

Water Crystallization: The Relation Between Water and Crispness

806 words - 4 pages A. Physical Quality in nutrisari, there are 3 main parameters to maintain physical stability: 1. Water and Crispness The relation between water and crispness is that the more aw in the food products, then the less crispness in it. In this case, as we talk about nutrisari (dehydrated juice) the water and crispness parameter has no interaction for the product as it is not one of the parameter for nutrisari. 2. Water and Stickiness, Caking and

The Relation Between Sex, Gender, and Moral Behavior

1526 words - 6 pages The Relation Between Sex, Gender, and Moral Behavior Our history is an account of changes, struggles and progress. It mostly contains writings and deeds of great 'men'. However, in this century, many nations' talent pools have been doubled by the introduction of Women's Suffrage. With that event women in many societies have been able to elevate themselves to a point where they can work towards gaining recognition in domains in which they

Similar Essays

Appropriate Relation Between Confucianism And Democracy

780 words - 4 pages Definition of democracy Before discussing the relationship between Confucianism and democracy, it is important to clarify what definition of democracy will be adopted as it sets the agenda and the framework of the analysis. As argued by many scholars, democracy is an essentially contested that there is no unitary definition can fit universally without regard to context (Whitehead, 1997). Basically, it can be classified into a procedural and

Similarities Between American Puritanism And Chinese Confucianism

1146 words - 5 pages American-Puritanism and Chinese -Confucianism have both played a tremendously important role in the foundation and growth of American and Chinese society respectively. But these two parallels seem to have no point of intersection. Making comparison between them is a hard and daring job. However, it is still worthwhile to study them since their irreplaceable powers have influenced two most wonderful countries in the world. And this article mainly

Intrinsic Human Dignity And Equality In Relation To Liberal Democracy

1762 words - 7 pages Liberal democracy is prevalent in the West. This political arrangement guarantees the rights of a people in relation to their government. Many Westerners, unfortunately, cannot give a philosophical explanation and/or justification for it. Ultimately, an examination of liberal democracy will demonstrate that it rests on notions of human dignity, equality and happiness, which are not recent developments in philosophy, but have their origins in

Coexistence Of Capitalism And Democracy, Tension Between Capitalism And Democracy

1761 words - 7 pages economic and political system that were practiced during the European conquest in Africa; Capitalism and Democracy and how the combination of economy and politic played a significant role during the European conquest in Africa. The finally, analyze the tensions between capitalism and democracy and how the tensions were relevant during the period of conquest.Before making any statements, basic principles of capitalism and democracy must be drawn