This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Relationship Of Self Esteem To Objective Success: Is It A Cause Or Consequence?

1936 words - 8 pages

It has been stipulated that self-esteem is one of the most studied concepts in social psychology. In the now classic study Pygmalion in the Classroom by Rosenthal and Jacobsen, it highlights how teachers' unfounded beliefs about their students became objective realities of the students performance (Baumeister, Campbell, Krueger, & Vohs, 2003, p. 2). Early studies like this one has ignited the pursuit to find ways to increase self-esteem and encourage instillment, or creation, of self-esteem to guarantee future success. Because it is so popularly studied, results of studies investigating variables associated with self-esteem often significantly vary. In our individualistic culture, having high-self esteem is a coveted state. Through multiple studies exploring this topic, perhaps a conclusion can be made about the relationship between self-esteem and success. Is self-esteem a predictor of success or a result of achieving the success?
A previous study called "Predictors of situational disengagement in the academic setting," the authors Stephan, Caudroit, Boiché, and Sarrazin (2011) examined the predictors of discounting or devaluing negative feedback in a physical education class in France. By comparing the grades received in class (of which the participants were informed) and the reports of the students type of motivation, as well as their perceived competence in the subject (p.446). The researchers measured the level of disengagement and perceived competence following receiving the individual grades. They identified three different kinds of motivation is from the self-determination theory: intrinsic motivation, extrinsic motivation, and amotivation, or absence of motivation (p.444). If an unsatisfactory grade was received, the student could possibly devalue that failure or discount the grade received as invalid. These reactions acted as means to defend self-esteem, as well as decrease of perceived competence. The measure of motivation was meant to act as the predictor of how the individual reacted to their feedback (p.445). The results shows a student's self-esteem and interpretation of feedback "is a crucial determinant of their persistence in, versus drop-out from, the school context" (p.452).
Self-esteem also has a possible effect on how one recalls memories and the type of memories recalled in relation to success or failure. A study called "Self-esteem memories and school success in early adolescence" by Ivcevic, Pilllemer, and Brackett (2010), the researchers investigated the content of self-esteem memories in relation to whether they were especially good or especially bad (p. 1267). Under the assumption that "autobiographical memories is closely relation to concepts of the self," it was found that the content of memory was influenced by whether it was good or bad (p. 1265). Much of the negative memories were associated with social themes, 63.1%, and most positive memories involved achievement themes, 35.5%, social themes...

Find Another Essay On Relationship of Self-Esteem to Objective Success: Is it a Cause or Consequence?

Rebelling for the Hell of it In order for a rebellion to take place, is there a need for a cause? Or can a rebellion take place without a cause?

1116 words - 4 pages is no promise that you won't get hurt or need to make some sacrifices. If there is no cause for the rebellion and you are doing it just because you felt like it, then you won't be very attached to the idea of a rebellion. It is likely you will give up and go home, where it is safe. But the blood, or pain, that does come out of a rebellion shows a "man's real manhood and immortality." (1572) A rebellion without a cause has no potential to

A Child's Self Esteem Essay

1115 words - 4 pages A Child's Self Esteem Many factors contribute to the mental state that forms as a child grows to become a young adult. His/her self-esteem, or lack of, is a key factor. Unfortunately, low self-esteem is more common than high self-esteem. Most cases of low self-esteem begin during the pre-teen and teenage years of a child’s life. These are the years containing the overwhelming pressures of high school. Teenagers are forced to cope

Migration as a Cause and Consequence of Conflict

1200 words - 5 pages term causes of the conflict. The Democratic Republic of the Congo, short DR Congo or DRC, is a country situated in Central Africa with a long history of civil unrest. The official language is French, it is supposed to be an ethnically neutral language, due to the many ethnic groups found in the DRCongo. During the Belgian colonization French and Dutch were both official languages but French was more widely spoken. Today about 30% of the

Time to Raise Self Esteem!

829 words - 4 pages teen have a positive self esteem. Then, how other see or treat us and how we see ourselves is a key contribution. Just like in the image of text 1, the cat sees himself as a mighty p, brave lion, so it can be said the animal had a high self esteem of himself. The way kids are seen by peers affects self esteem because if the friends don't bully them or talk bad to them, it allows teens to feel good about themselves and therefore have a positive

Is it self or not self, and does it matter?

762 words - 4 pages fall within the Buddhist rubric of the ego? If ESP exists, and is shown to be evident does it prove the self exists, or is it simply a matter of going in the direction one was destined. Einstein said one can affect the outcome by thinking it, physicists note that light particles know where they are traveling and adjust their behavior accordingly. The Buddhist interpretation, I believe would say that O’Keefe premonitions were a metaphysical

Building a Positve Self Esteem

1116 words - 5 pages the self esteem issues, however, according to the charts in the text 4, a common self esteem issues in girls is that they let themselves down while the boys do whatever they can to increase fix their issues, such as taking steroids. One thing is true, both genders tend to feel depressed as a result of their issues. Not all is dark about self esteem. Obtaining a high self esteem truly benefits a kid's success in life. As it was reported in

Relationship Marketing is a separate branch of marketing thought and it is indispensable to a successful performance of a firm

2452 words - 10 pages Relationship Marketing is a separate branch of marketing thought and it is indispensable to the successful performance of a firm.Marketing and business development professionals are confronting a rapidly different and changing business landscape, and the traditional business model that was once the norm is now being transformed due to technology drivers that make advanced marketing and sales capabilities possible. The new objective for marketers

Low-Self-esteem: A Way of Life Taught over Centuries

970 words - 4 pages lower status to men has caused the low self-esteem that appears to be prevalent within the female population. How much damage has been done by women be objectified as fertile child-bearers? Will women ever be able to overcome the implied societal role of being fertile child-bearers? While there is nothing wrong with women being entertainers it is past time that women have been allowed a pivotal role in society beyond whether or not they bore the

The Struggles Of Self Esteem

714 words - 3 pages interrupted by others, stomach pains, or sleep. Bulimia is exclusively one hazard of having negative body image. Depression has become increasingly common and is thought to be linked closely with low self esteem and eating disorders. Although eating disorders are diagnosed less frequently, they show depressive behavior and connections to negative self esteem. Stanford University states that women with self-critical or depressive features will be

My essay is called A Separate peace It is about Evolution and it answers different question such as: What is Evolution? or What is the cause of Evolution? and so on. I hope it will help you!!!

1840 words - 7 pages and reckless, whether it is intentional or not. Now that Gene has subconsciously fulfilled his own mental necessity to dispose his friend, which he seems to view in some way as an opposing force, he has inadvertently begun Finny's own stage of evolution. Finny sadly realized as a result of his fall that he would never be able to play sports as he previously did and there remained a chance he may not retain the ability to run ever again. All this

Do You Have a Low Self-esteem?

1171 words - 5 pages yourself and everything you do. First of all, having low self-esteem is a terrible thing to have. Some signs of it are depression, unhappiness, giving up on things, being introvert and not feeling good about themselves ("Do you have low self-esteem?"). People with low self-esteem are less likely to succeed in their attempts of doing things. If a basketball player has low self-esteem, chances are they are probably not going to be very good. Depression

Similar Essays

The Relationship Between Self Reinforcement And Self Esteem (B.F. Skinner)

727 words - 3 pages must be considered that this is a correlational study and that positive self-reinforcement does not cause higher self-esteem. It could be said that high self-esteem causes self-reinforcement or vice-versa; it is not clearly defined either way. In addition, there is a sample bias (convenience sample), participants were depended upon to be objective and honest about their opinions, however one's opinion of themselves could be different than

Like Water For Chocolate And The Hundred Foot Journey Describes Self Esteem And Relationship Issues

689 words - 3 pages Body image issues manifest in Like Water for Chocolate and The hundred Foot journey. Describe the self-esteem issues different characters encounter in each text. How do these issues shape their self-identity or relationships with others? Relationship betwwen self esteem and family customs with respect to food Food is fundamental a piece of our life. Each one society has exceptional cooking character. Each society is one of a kind in their

Biceps And Body Image: The Relationship Between Muscularity And Self Esteem, Depression, And Eating Disorder Symptoms

576 words - 2 pages Health of Immigrants 4The article investigates an issue that is not only current but also very divisive. It would be very difficult and probably ineffective for a therapist to treat an immigrant client without having a suitable knowledge of the cultural and socioeconomic background of the specific population. The authors address many different and important issues concerning both the immigrant population of the United States and the role of the

Critically Discuss And Evaluate The Following Statement: "It Is Quite Clear That An Individual State Cannot Create International Law. Nor Are The Acts Or Statements Of A Single State Of Any...

517 words - 2 pages International Law (Ordinary) and IR, 2013 / 2014Practice Essay QuestionTo be submitted to your tutor at tutorial #4 (week beginning Monday 28 October)Critically discuss and evaluate the following statement:"It is quite clear that an individual State cannot create international law. Nor are the acts or statements of a single State of any consequence to international law."Word limit: 1,500 wordsAgree and disagreeComplexity theory - smaller