Comparative Essay: The Church And The Caliphate

2491 words - 10 pages

Every day, all over the world, billions of people strive to embody the legacies of two of histories most influential men; Jesus Christ and the Prophet Muhammad. The death of these prominent religious leaders was devastating to their respective groups of followers, leaving them in the dark and in dire need of leadership, resulting in the formation of two very similar yet profoundly different institutions known as the Church and the Caliphate, respectively. Without divine leadership, and as each grew almost exponentially in size, both religions suffered from division and widespread disunity among the ever-increasing numbers of sects, each applying different interpretations on various aspects of faith. In Christianity, the Roman Catholic Church is the longest standing and most visible symbol of the Christian faith, while in Islam; the Sunni majority and the major (or most accepted as legitimate) dynasties of the Caliphate will be explored. Essentially parallel in purpose, not only have both of these institutions attempted to embody and eternalize the legacies of their founders, but have also played monumental roles in the development of human history; each of which has in its time, controlled vast empires wielding both military and economic dominance. While in their earlier stages with smaller populations, it may have been appropriate for the community to have one 'multi-purpose' leader, it has become necessary to separate the fields of politics and faith as religious communities rapidly expanded and grew in power. This separation of church (in this context referring to any religious institution) and state has, over time resulted in gradual diminishing of the authority of both the Roman Catholic Church and the Sunni Caliphate. Stemming from corruption of authority, historical developments, and gradual deviation from founding principals, the decline of both of these institutions is seen in today's contexts as 'modernization', but whether or not this phenomenon is moving society in a positive direction has yet to be seen.Be it religious, political, or even rebellious, individuals and/or institutions in positions of leadership have a task that is, put simply, to lead. Leaders of divine guidance, such as Muhammad and Jesus, have been said to characterize the 'perfect leaders' of their people, with their deaths testifying that they too are in fact, only human. The succession of these apparently perfect men opens seemingly unfillable holes in their communities, and weakness of future leadership routinely comes as result of greed or corruption that often accompanies power.In the case of Islam, Muhammad, according to the Encyclopedia of Religion, was the "governor of the Ummah, an arbitrator of disputes within it, commander of military its forces, and its principal strategist." His death in 632 CE left the Ummah in a situation it had never envisioned, and the loss of their chief seemed to present the insurmountable problem in the near future as well as...

Find Another Essay On Comparative Essay: The Church and The Caliphate

Improvement. Comparative essay on Leaving by M.G.Vassanji and The Cage

890 words - 4 pages Improvement.Comparative essay on Leaving by M.G.Vassanji and The Cage by Neil Bissoondath By Michael Rosario 821-685-773 Displacement is a theme that deals with leaving home. being able to better yourself through change. "The Cage" by Neil Bissoondath and "Leaving" by M.G.Vassanji both play on this theme. In these two stories characterization is used to convey the topic. Characterization is a process by which we are given an in-depth look at the

Comparative Theory Essay: Ethnohistory and The Postcolonial Perspective

1421 words - 6 pages beginnings of the different studies of mankind are introduced, when the book then jumps to a postcolonial perspective the views of the future are pointed to the mistakes of the past. Each theory has a purpose to explaining the views and studies of different historians around the world. This essay will compare my views on ethnohistory combined with anthropology versus the views of postcolonial history. To start with anthropology, and outlining the

Comparative essay - John and The Director, Brave New world

740 words - 3 pages Sometimes society may make people feel pressured to act a certain way and most follow it. They are the "normal" ones, while the ones who decide to go against society's norms are the "weird" people. In Aldous Huxley's Brave New World, we see a world in which everything is controlled by the World State: a government type group that decides who goes where and how they feel about it. It seems as though everyone has fallen into this, especially the

The Church And The Holocaust

865 words - 3 pages Krakow, over 12,000 Jews were killed. It has also been revealed that the IBM Corporation was involved with the Nazis by supplying them with machines to identify and select holocaust victims.Throughout the Holocaust and the war, Pope Pius spoke publicly and directed people to help all who were suffering and in need regardless of their nationality and race. Unfortunately the Pope and the church have been accused of not doing enough to help the suffering

Homosexuality and the Anglican Church

2189 words - 9 pages discussed as communion wide issue at the 1998 Lambeth conference(gays and the future of Ang), and it was concluded that homosexual practice was " incompatible with scripture." Whether locally or globally debates typically arise around the issue of whether homosexuality should be allowed within the Church. These disagreements have torn Anglicans and created differing beliefs regarding the ordination of gay clergy and same sex marriages. The


1200 words - 5 pages Augustine and the Early Church Augustine of Hippo by Peter Brown Live Oak Public Library, STACKS 270.2 BROW Q5. In Augustine’s unfailing attempt to fight the heresies that plagued the early church, he realized that much of his colleagues and congregation lived by unquestioned faith in the Catholic Church. He also realized that this left them without a strong foundation for which they believed. (Brown, 354) His contributions to the

Homosexuality and the Anglican Church

1818 words - 7 pages was discussed predominately as a communion wide issue at the 1998 Lambeth conference, and it was concluded that homosexual practice was “incompatible with scripture” (“Lambeth Conferences”). Whether locally or globally, debates typically arise around the issue of homosexuality, and if should be allowed within the Church. These disagreements have torn Anglicans and created differing beliefs regarding the ordination of gay clergy and same-sex

AIDS - and the Catholic Church

1231 words - 5 pages proposals are impractical and inhumane to deny a dying person his or her right to peace and time with family in their last moments. People living with HIV/AIDS face discrimination which is dehumanizing and suffering which strips the person's sense of worth and dignity. Tackling the problematic AIDS isn't easy, and ethics, morals and strong influence from the Catholic Church are all contributors to this issue.AIDS has seen the country of Africa

Psychology, Art and the Church

846 words - 4 pages Psychology suggests that in order for an individual to lead a mostly healthy life is by assisting him/her to make healthy choices which can create a whole and integrated person. The church provides a belief system for an individual by instilling faith and a good deal of moral guidelines which are respected and honored by him/her by more or less surrendering themselves to that Faith. Art consists of conveying the intimate joys and demons in ways

Explain the changing concept of caliphate during the periods of the Rightly-Guided Caliphs, the Umayyads and the Abbasids (Includes bibliography)

1550 words - 6 pages also be viewed as a religiously-rooted concept, that is, it is inherently connected to the traditions and doctrine of Islam. This essay is an attempt to explain why the concept of Islamic caliphate underwent certain changes in terms of its background, its religious literal interpretation and evolving usage, its basis in religious legitimacy and its political character, throughout the rule of the Rightly-Guided Caliphs, the Umayyads and the

The Church

1793 words - 7 pages Edward P. Clowney book titled The Church deals with the doctrines of the church. He takes a deep look at the issues the modern church has neglected. He believed that the demands of the market and the growth of the church threaten to quench theological reflections on its nature and mission (Back cover). He believes that the means to revive the church will be done through theological works. His methodology is based off of his experience in

Similar Essays

The Byzantine Empire And The Islamic Caliphate

1467 words - 6 pages have some form of an absolute monarch. These monarchs can be seen in Justinian I of the Byzantine Empire and Harun-al Rashid of the Abbasid Caliphate. Under both of these rulers, their respective empires began to decline. Because of the rule of Harun-al Rashid, major uprisings began due to his attempts at controlling the local rulers, and civil war broke out. This divided and weakened the Abbasid caliphate. The decisions that led to these massive

The Church And Facebook Essay

1758 words - 7 pages Facebook replacing the imperative physical relationships we need to fellowship with each other. It is a sad truth that we are so busy we cannot find time to carve out an hour in the week to go to church. Out of convenience, more people turn to Facebook as a place to spill their frustrations and praises to the status update question: “What’s on your mind?” If people are confessing and fellowshipping on Facebook, what is the job of the Church in the

The Church And Euthanasia Essay

542 words - 2 pages case, a terminally ill person is asking the physician to assist them in ending their life. Oregon is the only state in the United States who allows this kind of euthanasia. This idea is contradictory to the principles of health care because physicians vow to heal, along with helping the patient feel comfortable and caring for the patient to their best ability.The Church considers these types of euthanasia to be wrong because they involve the

Comparative Essay Between "The Storyteller" And "Oryx And Crake"

949 words - 4 pages The Search of MysteryIn the novel "The Storyteller" by Mario Vargas Llosa, he writes about a man who changes his identity to become accepted in a tribe in the Amazon forests. The setting used in Margaret Atwood's "Oryx and Crake" is much different for it is set in a futuristic community with advanced technology. Although these two novels seem to be very different because of the setting and character personalities, the social message is similar