Relative Moral Superiority And Proselytizing Vegetarianism

947 words - 4 pages

The benefits to maintaining a vegetarian diet are myriad and increasingly well-defined by modern science; these benefits include decreased risk of heart disease and certain cancers. Many vegetarians claim to feel better and more perceptive, and two of the top three sprinters in the world are vegan. Vegetarians often claim moral superiority over non-vegetarians through varieties of a “hurt no living thing” credo. Nevertheless, only 2.8% of American adults are vegetarian. The advantages to vegetarianism are well-known, and the disadvantages seem negligible, yet in most countries only a tiny portion of the populace are vegetarian or vegan; Why would anyone ignore the option to live longer and feel superior, both physically and ethically?
Primarily, the opponents of vegetarianism disagree with it's strictures on scientific grounds. “But of course,” answer the vegetarians “their own muse, science, silences those claims without effort.” No, in fact; studies indicate vegetarians are much more at risk for deficiencies in calcium, iron, zinc, and B-vitamins. Although many devoted vegetarians take supplements to counteract these deficiencies, the eventual lethality of an iron deficiency-related anemia, for example, completely debunks many vegetarian's claims that no meat is somehow “more natural”—if normal humans can't survive unaided after eliminating part of their diet, it can only be concluded that part of their diet was essential.
An even more serious symptom of vegetarian diet is calcium deficiency: calcium deficiency inhibits bone growth, even causing proactive weakening of bone structures, and eventually osteoporosis and death. Again, many vegetarians take supplements or get their calcium from dairy products, which are produced by the very animals they seek to prevent the mistreatment of. Incorporated dairy cows are just as medicated and maltreated as those grown for their meat; not only does this shortsighted approach cause many vegetarians to intake similar amounts of hormones and antibiotics as non-vegetarians, it also again invalidates their moral argument.
Ever met anyone with anorexia? Chances are, in order to disguise their life-threatening eating disorder, they claimed to be vegetarian. This practice is so common among eating-disorder patients that vegetarian diet is considered a medical warning-sign that a patient is at risk for anorexia nervosa, bulimia, stimulant or laxative abuse, or binge eating. That is by no means saying that all vegetarians have eating disorders, but, according to “The Dark Side of Vegetarianism,” teenage and adult vegetarians are 400% more likely to indulge in risky eating behaviors, especially binging. These data suggest that vegetarianism can be, rather than a solution for the bad eating habits of Americans, a simple disguise for an equally unhealthy routine. According to epidemiology professor Dianne Neumark-Sztainer , a co-author of the study, “[Vegetarianism] can be a very, very healthy way to eat, as...

Find Another Essay On Relative Moral Superiority and Proselytizing Vegetarianism

Ethics and Morality in Vegetarianism Essay

2414 words - 10 pages merely a matter of personal health. As believed, vegetarianism was originally founded in ancient India and was generally formed on ethical and moral issues. There were two religions that first accepted vegetarianism: Hinduism made the cow a sacred animal, something to be respected and admired, and over time, these ideals evolved from mere ideas to commonplace social practices. Ahimsa is the principle that teaches one to not to injure a living

The Health and Economic Benefits of Vegetarianism

1646 words - 7 pages For thousands of years, many around the globe have considered vegetarianism as a dietary choice. Some consider it a moral choice to avoid what they may consider to be inhumane treatment of animals. For others the choice was made for them due to the unavailability of meat. Still others practice vegetarianism as part of their religion. While many today still choose a vegetarian diet to take a stand against cruelty to animals, it is becoming more

Think, Exist, and Evolve Vegetarian

1701 words - 7 pages most common include: moral, religious, or health related reasons. Morally, one may feel obligated to exercise vegetarianism due to the inhumane treatment of animals throughout the food production process. The United States has a large population to cater to and the issue is that countless numbers of animals are raised for food consumption alone. Animals such as cows, chickens, pigs, and turkeys are subjected to entrapment and confinement, less

Why Vegeterianism is Increasing Among Americans

2097 words - 9 pages document “Vegetarianism”, the writer explains that the Vegetarianism life style, originated from ancient India and ancient Greece before 2500 years ago. At that time, meat was not available, so some ancient people compelled to depend on a vegetarian diet. However, ancient India and Greece avoided to eat meat as a moral stand against violence animal. In India vegetarianism still remains as a moral issue and it is related to Hindu religion, but it

Vegetarianism and Animal Rights

2485 words - 10 pages kindness, charity and gratitude, and at the same time ignore the fate of helpless animals that people consume as food. Hindus almost always avoided beef because they believe that the cow is a sacred animal. Some people that support vegetarianism say that “the greatness on nation and its moral progress can be measured by the way in which its animals are treated.” Hindus have a principle of nonviolence — Ahimsa — that is also applied to animals. In

Mohandas Gandhi

1129 words - 5 pages while before deciding to continue his studies in England. His mother did not want him to go to England, but after promising her that he would abstain from alcohol, meat, and women, she gave her permission. In England Gandhi found his time more occupied by “personal and moral issues” than those of law. He was teased for his religion and dress fashions and for his vegetarianism. At last he found a vegetarian restaurant and made friends with other

The Misusage of the Vegetarianism in Teenage Females with Eating Disorders

1180 words - 5 pages why these women choose to be a vegan. It can be to protect the environment or to fight for rights of animal. However, it also can be used for own health. Many of them choose to be a vegetarian lifestyle in order to lose weight or maintain the weight. The vegetarian diet can be used socially acceptable way to legitimize food avoidance and avoid certain eating situation (Bardone-Cone et al., 2012). Vegetarianism can be used as another formation of

Should Committed Environmentalists Choose to Adopt a Vegan/Vegetarian Diet?

2213 words - 9 pages human need” without much further clarification (Waller 1997). This stance has been criticised by Waller (1997, p. 191) who states, “To have no stand on vegetarianism is to have no practical stand on land use, availability of food, quality of human life, and the ethics of human-nonhuman interaction—an interaction which, for all of deep ecology's evasions, occurs always between the particular constituents of nature.” Forms of Plant-based Diets The

Animal Rights is a Cause for Vegetarianism

743 words - 3 pages (Edinburgh University Press, 1970 Cavalieri, Paola and Peter Singer (editors). THE GREAT APE PROJECT: EQUALITY BEYOND HUMANITY (New York: St. Martins Press, 1993. ISBN: 0-312-10473-1) Clark, Stephen R. L. THE MORAL STATUS OF ANIMALS (The Clarendon Press 1977 Cohen, Carl. "The Case for the Use of Animals in Biomedical Research." THE NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE 315 (October 2, 1986). Crisp, Roger. "Utilitarianism and Vegetarianism," INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHILOSOPHY 4 (1988) Francis, Leslie Pickering and Richard Norman. "Some Animals Are More Equal Than Others," PHILOSOPHY 53 (October 1978), pp. 507-27.


1841 words - 7 pages The positive effect of vegetarianism(Persuasive Research essay)Jenny LiMrs. JoenENG3U1April 21, 2014As Americans grow more health conscious, vegetarianism has become a popular diet among individuals within the 21st century. However, vegetarianism is not a new idea; in fact, it has been practiced since the early evolution of human beings. 24 million years ago, the human ancestor, hominids has evolved, and since then for one-and-a-half million


1841 words - 7 pages The positive effect of vegetarianism(Persuasive Research essay)Jenny LiMrs. JoenENG3U1April 21, 2014As Americans grow more health conscious, vegetarianism has become a popular diet among individuals within the 21st century. However, vegetarianism is not a new idea; in fact, it has been practiced since the early evolution of human beings. 24 million years ago, the human ancestor, hominids has evolved, and since then for one-and-a-half million

Similar Essays

The Consequences Of Individual Consumption By Ben Almassi

1628 words - 7 pages individual’s choice and the resulting moral progress. In the case of vegetarianism, the threshold argument against act-consequentialism is that if an individual chooses to adhere to vegetarianism, this does not guarantee that there will be a decrease in unnecessary suffering, thus rendering choices that promote vegetarianism useless. In argument form this states that: 1. If a threshold of x cannot be realized, then consequentialist theories of

Vegetarianism Essay

644 words - 3 pages , such as poor nutrition and eating disorders (Dedyna, 2004). These negative effects are alarming. It is important to pay attention to what reasons can lead to vegetarianism and how these can result in a chain of negative consequences.The cause of vegetarianism is very complicated. There are several reasons for vegetarianism, including health reasons, religious reasons and moral reasons. Many people are worrying about their health because some

Morality And Ethics In Vegetarianism Essay

838 words - 4 pages “The assumption that animals are without rights and the illusion that our treatment of them has no moral significance is a positively outrageous example of Western crudity and barbarity. Universal compassion is the only guarantee of morality."( Schopenhauer). Vegetarianism and animal rights movement have been crossing each other since 70’s. The meeting point between two is veganism which means strict vegetarianism. Vegetarianism was firstly

Vegetarianism Philosophy Essay

986 words - 4 pages Vegetarianism is a custom practiced in six out of the seven continents and has become more popular over the years. Vegetarianism can be defined as the exclusion of animal products such as meat and fish from one’s diet. Dairy products and eggs are often times excluded as well. Although there are many reasons one may decide to become a Vegetarian or follow such a code of ethics, the most common include: moral, religious or health reasons