Relevance Of Stakeholder Analysis To Society

3843 words - 15 pages

"Stakeholder" is a term bandied about by professors, intellectuals, and others who subscribe to the notions that equality of outcome, not equality of opportunity, is the goal; that property rights can be disregarded when the cause is sufficiently noble and the intentions abundantly good; and that a voice in corporate governance need not be accompanied by risk. The popularity of this concept over the past 35 years has created a void in analytical thought. The term "stakeholder" springs up in everything from community meetings and websites to employee meetings and annual reports. It is surprising to see how many CEOs extol the importance of stakeholders, since by subscribing to stakeholder theory as a means of corporate governance, they send the following message to shareholders: "I realize you have an investment in this corporation, but these other folks came along, and, well, they talk a good game, so I am going to be accountable to them."There are several inherent flaws in the stakeholder theory. I will present those flaws, along with a brief history of the theory's origins and development. The flaws in stakeholder theory are its imprecision in definition and execution, its disregard for property rights, its disincentives in a capitalist economy, and its encouragement of class warfare.The Origins of Stakeholder TheoryStakeholder theory had its origins in law. It subsequently moved to strategic management, then back to law. Today it is prevalent in the field of business ethics.The true origin of the term "stakeholders" is in law, but this history is largely ignored and rarely credited. During the 1930's, Professors Adolf Berle and Merrick Dodd argued with each other in the law reviews about the social responsibility of business. Berle and Dodd debated one of the great legal questions of their time as well as our own: should those who provide the capital for a business and assume its risk be required to accommodate those who have made no investment but who nevertheless seem to sincerely desire constraints on corporate activity? Berle took the position that it is appropriate to consider non-shareholder (i.e., stakeholder) interests only if the shareholders consent to doing so. Dodd contended that stakeholders are "absentee owners whose interests can be subjugated to those of other corporate constituencies and those of society at large." The key words in this statement are "absentee owners." Professor Dodd distinguished two categories of owners: 1) those who have invested capital in the enterprise; and 2) those who have invested not capital but their own cares and concerns in the enterprise. Dodd doesn't clearly explain why this latter class of owners has such concern, or in which areas that concern lies. Professors Berle and Dodd (as well as Gardiner Means, who subsequently joined the fray on Berle's side) were never able to settle their disputes about the focus of corporate governance. Their notions and theories about stakeholders lay dormant for...

Find Another Essay On relevance of stakeholder analysis to society

The Relevance of Ancient Texts in Today’s Society

1810 words - 7 pages word of their god. In today’s American society, the higher power is understood to be the government. People are required to obey the laws set by the government, and lawbreakers must suffer the penalties also established by their government. Laws and rules are created to keep order and separation between the people and the higher power. Without defined rules or leadership, people could do anything they wanted to whether it’s right or wrong

The Relevance of the New Testament in the Modern Society

1287 words - 5 pages There are many different religions exist in the world, they are existing with their own faith and reason, also they are looking for the development to become suitable for the modern society. Christianity, especial the Bible of the New Testament, they also looking for the ways to fit the modern society. People have to update themselves in their lives, otherwise they will eliminate of the society developing. Christianity as one of the most

The Battle of New Orleans' Relevance to Today's Army

1078 words - 5 pages This paper will provide information on The Battle of New Orleans and its relevance to today’s Army. Research was derived from several reliable internet sources such as and an article from The National Geographic online database. Many think that the Battle of New Orleans between the United States and Britain was uncalled for. The Treaty of Ghent, signed in late 1814, ended the War of 1812. Even though the treaty was

The Relevance of Gender In Society: A research paper on Virginia Woolf's views on gender roles using three of her books, "To the Lighthouse", "Mrs. Dalloway", and "A Room of One's Own".

1976 words - 8 pages life, but she embraces her role as a woman and finds affirmation in it. Woolf beautifully conveyed the achievement that both married and unmarried women could attain.Woolf wrote "A Room Of One's Own" to further her analysis on gender. In this lecture, she once more explores gender in society. "A woman must have money and a room of her own if she is to write fiction." (Woolf, A Room Of One's Own, 4). This means that men are not going to assist in

Relevance of Quality Assurance (QA) systems to civil and environmental engineering. Need, Benefits, Common standards.

2052 words - 8 pages both in and outside the company. Detailing these requirements, training people to accomplish them, and measuring results are what quality engineering is all about.Thus we shall take an interest in the relevance of Quality Assurance (QA) systems especially to civil and environmental engineering.First we shall define the need and what quality assurance can achieve, then analyse its benefits and look at how widely with which common standards it is

Critically Discuss The Relevance Of The Holistic Model To Diversity Within Mental Health Services.

1696 words - 7 pages Critically discuss the relevance of the holistic model to diversity within mental health services.The essence of holism within a mental health context takes into account the whole person, and every factor that could effect an individual, it aims to look at the whole picture rather than concentrating on separate parts, for example it would take into account Physical, Psychological, Social (such as culture), Emotional and Spiritual (personal

The Relevance of Edith Wharton’s Roman Fever to the Modern World

1460 words - 6 pages The Relevance of Edith Wharton’s Roman Fever to the Modern World According to the World Health Organization, “of the 75 million children under five in Africa a million and a half die each year of pneumonia.” As distressing and sad as this statistic is, it points out the great danger pneumococcus still is to young people in the developing world. It’s in the developed world, but at a time before antibiotics, at a time when acute respiratory

"The Jungle Book" by Rudyard Kipling. Shows the relevance of the children's stories to adults

2718 words - 11 pages ).Clearly, this shows the comparison of the wolves society to ours. There is one leader who has led the Pack for several years and he has a group of nobles who help in his tasks. There are many members of the pack who are just like normal civilians in our society. They are ranked only by the type of animal they can kill: '... below him sat forty or more wolves of every size and color, from badger-colored veterans who could handle a buckByrne 8alone, to

Analysis of whether or not Transcendentalism is relevant to modern-day society.

604 words - 2 pages Some aspects of Transcendentalism can be applied in today's society, while others have lost their relevance due to the changes of social and economic conditions since the time of Thoreau. The Transcendentalists' goal was to create a Utopia in America. They believed in a society without rules in which you would be free to do whatever you wanted as long as it did not infringe on the freedom or well-being of others. The concept of what is a Utopia

Contributions of Teachers to Society

1353 words - 5 pages Teachers hold a very sensitive role in the modern civilized society. Regarded as social engineers, teachers possess immense knowledge on various issues that affect our daily lives as a community of human beings. Though in many countries including the developed ones, teachers are poorly remunerated they make invaluable contributions to their communities, to society and to the world at large, engaging in yeoman services with selfless love and

The relevance to modern life of the themes brought up in Arthur Miller's "Death of a Salesman"

2820 words - 11 pages styles were already apparent, particularly in the USA where this play is set. In my following paragraphs I am going to cover the topics which I think are very important to the break down of Willy and the relevance it has today. I am going to include, family life, as it is almost exactly the same as today. Then I am going to study the American dream, and finally The pressures of his job and his financial worries.'The American Dream consists of a

Similar Essays

Society In Relation To Stakeholder Theory

1170 words - 5 pages theory. It does not adopt a normative stance. This neutral feature results in conflicting interests among stakeholders. To remedy this problem we propose a crucial modification of the stakeholder theory. This modified 'society-stakeholder theory' (SST) places society as the ultimate stakeholder. Initially, the framework of society in which businesses operate must be examined to ensure the practicality of SST.Framework of Society:SST describes

Stakeholder Analysis (A Case Study Of Pamol Nigeria Ltd)

1857 words - 7 pages out a successful stakeholder analysis and would have responded appropriately to changes in the balance of power between the stakeholders in the company.REFERENCESCAPON, C. (2000) Understanding Organisational Context Essex: Prentice-Hall.DUNN, W.N. (1994) Public Policy Analysis (2nd edition) New Jersey: Prentice-Hall.FREDERICK, W.C., POST, J.E., & DAVIS, K. (1992) Business and Society (7thEdition) Singapore: McGraw-Hill, Inc.JOHNSON, G &amp

Explain The Relevance Of Poverty To Nursing

2895 words - 12 pages To understand the relevance of poverty to nursing we first need to determine what poverty actually is, many sociologists have come up there own definitions of poverty. Townsend's (1979, 125-6) study of poverty in the Britain states that individuals"can be said to be living in poverty when they lack the resources to obtain the type of diet, participate in the activities and have living conditions and amenities which are customary , or at least

History Of Unions And Their Relevance In Todays Society

1423 words - 6 pages in Parliament.Unions mobilize the full industrial strength of workers and as history has shown conditions of workers have greatly improved due to unionism. Unions have earned workers minimal wages forty hour working week, an eight hour day, annual leave, long service leave, accident and illness benefits, and workers compensation.Voting rights have assisted better legislation to protect workers which decrease the relevance of unions in today's