Reliability Of Testimonies Of The Holocaust Survivors: Elie Wiesel's Night And Binjamin Wilkomirski's 'fragments'

3334 words - 13 pages

This essay will explore the relationship between fact and fiction in the representation of the holocaust. I will explore Elie Wiesel's Night and Benjimin Wilkomirski's Fragments and analyse the contribution made by these books to the debate about the authenticity of survivor testimony. The two texts I will look at challenge the notions of truth and reality. They both claim to be factual accounts of an actual moment in time, yet there is strong evidence to suggest that both are fabricated. Some parts of Night have been challenged by critics as fictional whilst the events in Fragments have been challenged to such a degree that it is now generally believed that the holocaust testimony is a figment of Wilkomirski's imagination. It is important to note that Wilkomirski still insists that Fragments is a true account of his past .Louis Montrose states that 'we can have no access to a full and authentic past, a lived material existence.' Our only access to history is through texts. In this way texts not only represent our history but become the only history we know. Hayden White states that because historians shape historical evidence into literary forms, using language for dramatic effect, the writing of history will always be a fictive act. He views history as aesthetic, stating that 'historians do not find stories in the past but form the past into stories.' Since our only access to the Holocaust is through texts, the work of Wilkomirski and Wiesel offers us a looking-glass into the realities of a moment in time. The difference between the looking-glass and the actual reality is the key to understanding why the texts are both 'tokens of reality' and 'questionable as to their authenticity'.Using White's theory, both Wilkomirski and Wiesel are unable to offer us the actuality of the Holocaust, since language can never equate to reality. Primo Levi, in his memoir The Drowned and the Saved, discusses the problems posed by attempting to put the history of the Holocaust into narrative form. He believed that in representing the events of the Holocaust using 'language' the primary concern is to make people 'understand.' Levi draws a parallel between the words 'understand' and 'simplify,' stating that our very understanding of a situation is a simplification of it. Levi concedes that language is the most valuable 'tool' for representing such effects, but asserts that the distinction must be drawn between representation and reality. He states that language 'is useful so long as [it is] not mistaken for reality.'Theodore Adorno stated that 'after Auschwitz, to write a poem is barbaric.' Marianne Hirsch examines Adorno's statement, noting that 'one of its consequences has been to distinguish between the documentary and the aesthetic.' The documentary accounts, such as survivor testimonies, are perceived as more valid as they can be seen as proof of what actually happened. In contrast, an aesthetic account is a form of interpretation and has distance from the...

Find Another Essay On Reliability of Testimonies of the Holocaust Survivors: Elie Wiesel's Night and Binjamin Wilkomirski's 'Fragments'

Elie Wiesel's Night Essay

1281 words - 5 pages function.” (315) Dr. Josef Mengele, known as the “Angel of Death”, was a doctor who performed atrocious operations and experiments in people, especially children, in concentration camps during the holocaust (Kirsch 1). Elie describes him in Night: “Dr. Mengele. The notorious Dr. Mengele. He looked like the typical SS officer: a cruel, though not unintelligent, face, complete with monocle.” (31) His deeds included freezing people to death and

Elie Wiesel's "Night" Essay

2385 words - 10 pages is also Chairman of the Holocaust Memorial Council. This organization is a nonpolitical organization that was formed to educate people of the crimes put forth on the Jewish people during the Holocaust (Chaimberlin 14).Works CitedChamberlin, Brewster, and Marcia Feldman eds. The Liberation of the NaziConcentration Camps 1945. Government Printing Office: Washington, D.C, 1987.Wiesel, Elie. Night . Bantam Books: New York, 1989 .

Elie Wiesel's "Night" and Mark Mathabane's "The Road to Alexandra" exemplify the similarities in the holocaust and apartheid.

913 words - 4 pages "history repeats itself" has never seemed so true. The similarities of these periods are evident in Elie Wiesel's Night, and Mark Mathabane's The Road to Alexandra.Elie Wiesel's Night is a tale of murder and man's inhumanity to mankind. The novel shows the journey that the Wiesel family makes to the concentration camps. Elie Wiesel endured the hardships of three of the worst concentration camps in Germany, and he saw his family, friends, and fellow

Hell on Earth: an exploration of the flame motif in Elie Wiesel's "Night"

1368 words - 5 pages optimism found all throughout the story. However, we then came across the book Night, by Elie Wiesel, where the motif of flames also appeared but this time in a whole new way. In this autobiography where Wiesel writes about his imprisonment in Auschwitz, one of the numerous concentration camps created by Hitler, he connected flames with something completely the opposite of Hawthorne, something negative to the point where he suggests the flames

Elie Wiesel's "Night"- Journal Entry

767 words - 3 pages Luck is on Wiesel's Side"I am too old, my son," he answered. "Too old to start a new life. Too old to start from scratch in some distant land…" (9)This scene where Elie's father rejects his son's request to liquidate everything and flee from the place where the extermination of Jews may occur, reminds me of a vivid conversation I once engaged in, with my two former North Korean grandparents.The Korean War (1950-53) and the Holocaust (1938

Forgiveness and Forgetting in Schindler's List and Elie Wiesel's Night

1079 words - 4 pages Universe, the All-Powered and Terrible, was silent. What had I to thank him for?" (Night 31) The biggest part of Elie Wiesel's life began to deteriorate. Wiesel began to question his faith in God whom he formerly believed to be the epitome of good. Wiesel lost the motivation to fulfill His expectations. Elie Wiesel does not understand why God could allow six crematories to work day and night to burn to death thousands of fathers, sisters and

Book Report on Elie Wiesel's Night

4218 words - 17 pages Book Report on Elie Wiesel's Night      Elie tells of his hometown, Sighet, and of Moshe the Beadle. He tells of his family and his three sisters, Hilda, Béa, and the baby of the family, Tzipora. Elie is taught the cabala by Moshe the Beadle. Moshe is taken away and sees an entire train of people murdered by the Gestapo. He returns to Sighet and tries to warn them, but no one believes his story. The Nazis come and take over Sighet. Elie is

Hitler Blindfolded Germany: Elie Wiesel's "Night"

868 words - 3 pages Promises of honor and prosperity, blind folded Germany and granted Hitler the power to implement his Final Solution. The Holocaust ravaged Europe, hopelessly Jews were slaughtered and fed to the flames. In attempt to cheat death, Jews could hide among loyal neighbors or confront the horrors in a Concentration Camp and pray for liberation, either path was a perilous journey. Elie Wiesel endured years of starvation and oppression in

The Holocaust in Night by Elie Wiesel

650 words - 3 pages Author: Elie Wiesel Do you see that chimney over there? See it? Do you see those flames? Over there- that's where you're going to be taken. That's your grave, over there. Haven't you realize it yet? You dumb bastards, don't you understand anything? You're going to be burned. Frizzed away. Turned into ashes. The Holocaust lasted from 1939-1942. During these tough and traumatic years Hitler killed over 6,000,000

Early Warning Signs in Elie Wiesel's Night

1096 words - 4 pages mother, the Jews have signs and warnings to escape the invasion and Elie Wiesel does a superb job of incorporating that in his book, Night. These overlooked chances, or motifs, are Moshe not getting the respect for his word, uncomprehending the news that is given to the Jews, and the misjudgment of how evil a man Hitler is. If one is saved from a massacre of his or her own people, it is indispensable that he or she return back to his or her

Why is the Holocaust Still Relevant Today in Wiesel's Night

867 words - 3 pages The Holocaust is over and has been for about sixty years, so why are we still talking about it? Why is it still relevant in our world today? The world should have learned from its mistakes, but the sad part is that we did not. No, Hitler is no longer killing millions of innocent men, women, and children, but we are still just still just as cruel only in different ways. Night is Elie Wiesel’s factual account of his experiences in the holocaust

Similar Essays

Loss Of Faith In Elie Wiesel's Night

792 words - 3 pages Loss of Faith in Elie Wiesel's "Night" Night is a dramatic book that tells the horror and evil of the concentration camps that many were imprisoned in during World War II. Throughout the book the author Elie Wiesel, as well as many prisoners, lost their faith in God. There are many examples in the beginning of Night where people are trying to keep and strengthen their faith but there are many more examples of people rebelling against God

Elie Wiesel's Night Essay

534 words - 2 pages Elie Wiesel's Night Elie Wiesel’s Night is about what the Holocaust did, not just to the Jews, but, by extension, to humanity. The disturbing disregard for human beings, or the human body itself, still to this day, exacerbates fear in the hearts of men and women. The animalistic acts by the Nazis has scarred mankind eternally with abhorrence and discrimination. It seems impossible that the examination of one’s health, by a doctor, can

Elie Wiesel's Book "Night". Essay

935 words - 4 pages of death for the European Jews. Elie Wiesel focuses a great deal on people in his tale of Night, be they Minor characters or his own family, and the profound impact they had on him and others alike.Wiesel tells us of his world in Night in a way that incorporates all the Jews impacted by the Holocaust. He dose this by integrating side stories of other characters which gives us a broad sense of what other the Jews had experienced durring their

Elie Wiesel's "Night" Essay

773 words - 3 pages In the memoir, Night, author Elie Wiesel portrays the dehumanization of individuals and its lasting result in a loss of faith in God. Throughout the Holocaust, Jews were doggedly treated with disrespect and inhumanity. As more cruelty was bestowed upon them, the lower their flame of hope and faith became as they began turning on each other and focused on self preservation over family and friends. The flame within them never completely died, but