Reliability Of Usher's Perspective On Madeline

1313 words - 6 pages

Throughout The Fall of the House of Usher, Poe chooses to reveal Lady Madeline’s illness through the perspective of her brother, Roderick, rather than giving readers an unbiased perspective of her illness. Considering that the only description of Madeline’s madness comes from Roderick, who himself had a compromised mental state, one must question the reliability of Roderick’s description of Madeline’s illness. One must closely examine the nature of Roderick’s mental illness in order to fully understand his inability to comprehend the reality of Madeline’s illness. After carefully analyzing Roderick’s hypochondria and Madeline’s escape, one will conclude that the Roderick Usher’s mental state renders his testimony throughout the story an unreliable depiction of reality. Therefore, his discernment of Lady Madeline’s illness cannot be relied upon; putting all of Roderick’s claims throughout the story into question.
Reader’s will not get a first hand observation of Lady Madeline’s mental state because they only witnesses examples of her illness through Roderick Usher’s perspective. One is first made aware of Madeline’s mental disorder when Usher explains that his own affliction is an effect of his sister’s illness. “He admitted...that much of the peculiar gloom which thus afflicted him could be the severe and long continued illness of his beloved sister...A settled apathy, a gradual wasting away of the person …”” (p.7). After Usher reveals his perception of his sister’s suffering, she enters and leaves the room without speaking, and “dies” soon after. The narrator implies that Madeline’s silence may have been a part of the cataleptic character associated with her illness. The reader is never given a chance to see Madeline in a state of illness. Although Madeline’s silence may be interpreted as a symptom of her disorder, the reader never witnesses a psychotic episode. Madeline’s quiet can be attributed to factors other than psychosis; she may have been shy, or perhaps she did not want to interrupt her brother as he was visiting with an old friend. Although other explanations of Madeline’s shyness are purely speculative, attributing her silence to madness would have been just as theoretical had Usher not previously mentioned that his sister suffered from an illness. Once Usher plants the notion of his sister illness in ones mind, the natural course of reasoning is to perceive every misstep of Madeline’s as madness. But, in reality the only direct evidence that Madeline may have been ill, comes from Usher.
Usher’s analysis of his sister’s mental state leads him to believe that his sister is ill, but the reliability of his diagnosis must be questioned when one realizes that Usher himself suffers from a compromised mental state. When Madeline leaves the room in silence without exhibiting any real symptom of mental disorder, Poe curiously describes Usher’s ill deposition, rather than detailing symptoms that would lead one...

Find Another Essay On Reliability of Usher's Perspective on Madeline

The Marxist Crime Perspective on Juvenile Delinquency of African Americans

3121 words - 12 pages Introduction Countless studies from respected sociologists, criminologists, and psychologists have suggested several theories as to why juvenile delinquency exists. The theory this paper uses to explain juvenile delinquency is the Marxist perspective of the Conflict Theory. What this paper seeks to achieve is to show how this theory is conceptualized, how it causes juvenile delinquency particularly for African Americans, statistics on African

The Perspective of a Heterosexual Teenager on Same Sex Marriage

1462 words - 6 pages -25)Suddenly, I realized that Father Murray was about to discuss one of the most controversial debates that the Canadian society has ever faced during his homily. I pondered about the church's decision on this arguable issue, and to what extent will the church's decision is moral? Pastor Murray effectively introduced the topic of same-sex marriage to parishioners by reading the Bishops' Catholic definition of marriage, which suggested that holy

A Philosophical Perspective on the Regulation of Business

3022 words - 12 pages A Philosophical Perspective on the Regulation of Business ABSTRACT: The paper compares the Anglo-American and continental legal systems in parallel with a comparison of the philosophical foundations for each. The defining philosophical distinction between the two legal traditions (viz., the Anglo-American system is predicated on idealism and the continental system on materialism) is shown to influence the way in which criminal justice is

A Rhetorical Perspective on the Issue of WikiLeaks

1715 words - 7 pages Menace or Assurance? : A Rhetorical Perspective on the Issue of WikiLeaks Founded in 2006 by Australian journalist Julian Assange, the website WikiLeaks had quickly risen in infamy over the past few years (Majerol 19). The controversial website had posted hundreds of thousands of classified documents about the Iraq and Afghanistan war, revealing government cover-ups, a secret assassination unit and the killing of civilians among many things

Review of Perspective on Risk Management in Supply Chains

2820 words - 11 pages Introduction The following is the authors’ review of three articles from journals relating to the Operations Management 2 Course. Each of the articles will be reviewed and analysed as to their relevance to a particular or number of subjects of the course. Article 1 Perspective on Risk Management in supply chains; Journal of Operations Management 27 2009 (114-118) @ 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved The article focuses on managing risk

Impact of Banking Sector on Agricultural Development of India with particular reference to Maharashtra – Theoretical perspective

2190 words - 9 pages Impact of Banking Sector on Agricultural Development of India with particular reference to Maharashtra - Theoretical perspective.Vivek V. Patil*1) Introduction :-Agriculture probably is the oldest profession for livelihood for major portion of the population in our country. Nature and type of farming , however, underwent conspicuous changes during the course of socio-economic transformation which has now attended technologically advanced

The Perspective of Plato and Aristotle on the Value of Art

1389 words - 6 pages The Perspective of Plato and Aristotle on the Value of Art   As literary critics, Plato and Aristotle disagree profoundly about the value of art in human society. Plato attempts to strip artists of the power and prominence they enjoy in his society, while Aristotle tries to develop a method of inquiry to determine the merits of an individual work of art. It is interesting to note that these two disparate notions of art are based upon the

Effects of Affiliation on Female Body Image through a Sorority Perspective

2292 words - 10 pages basis of their physical appearance” (Rolnik et al, 2010, p. 7). Spanning over a week’s time, parties are held where each women is introduced to chapters offered institutionally; and thus rated on their parallel association to the sisterhood (Rolnik et al, 2010). The entire process concludes with the offering of a bid or invitation to join a national organization (Rolnik et al, 2010). From the interpretation of theoretical perspective

Empty Canvas: An Outward Perspective on The Picture of Dorian Gray

2591 words - 11 pages The classic novel by Oscar Wilde, The Picture of Dorian Gray inspires beauty, and romance. The main focus of the novel is aesthetics, a philosophical view detailing the nature of creation and appreciation of art and beauty. The tragedy of the young Dorian Gray after becoming misled by his companion, Lord Henry Wotton, is one that causes many to reform ideas on life and purpose. Lord Henry believes in hedonism, a thought stating that pleasure is

The Cycle of Creativity: A Psychoanalytic Perspective on Samuel T. Coleridge’s Kubla Khan

2357 words - 9 pages place where refinement and logic of the surrounding environment does not hold sway, and thus is untamed and dangerous (Lawall 813-815). Outside of the chasm there is “a woman wailing for her demon lover”, and if one views this from a Jungian perspective it provides insight into the meaning of this otherwise perplexing symbol. Jung posited archetypes within every mind that act as somewhat independent semi-unconscious components of the unified

Narrative Perspective in a Dance Scene of Pride and Prejudice. Comment on the dance scene using a rhetorical analysis. What does the narrator with her moving perspective bring you to understand about...

593 words - 2 pages In-class Essay March 3, 2010 Comment on the dance scene using a rhetorical analysis. What does the narrator with her moving perspective bring you to understand about society, Lizzy, about pride and prejudice? How? One of the most unique techniques used by Jane Austen, in Pride and Prejudice, is her moving narrative perspective. In several parts of the novel, the narrator changes its "position", so that the reader finds her closer to the

Similar Essays

This Is A Science Lesson Plan On Eukaryotic Cells For All Of You Soon To Be Teachers. It Is Using The Madeline Hunter Model For Lesson Planning

514 words - 2 pages The Madeline Hunter ModelCells: The Basic Units of LifeObjectives1.Describe each part of a eukaryotic cell.2.Explain the function of each part of a eukaryotic cell.3.Describe the difference between animal cells and plant cells.Standards CoveredGeorgia Performance Standards (GPS)S7L2. Students will describe the structure and function of cells, tissues, organs, and organ systems.National StandardsLS1a.Living systems at all levels of organization

The United States Contract Bidding Process And Its Effect On The Readiness And Reliability Of Our Nation’s Military Communications Systems

917 words - 4 pages Title of my paper: The United States Contract Bidding Process and Its Effect on the Readiness and Reliability of our Nation’s Military Communications Systems Introduction The United States Government has fostered a lowest bidder mentality among corporations and firms vying to provide government services. The resulting outcome of this system has allowed firms to sacrifice the quality in the materials, manpower and resources to construct and

Describe And Evaluate Contemporary Use Of Personality Measurement And Testing, Focusing On Issues Of Reliability And Validity, Using Empirical Evidence To Support Your Arguments

2278 words - 9 pages Describe and evaluate contemporary use of personality measurement and testing, focusing on issues of reliability and validity, using empirical evidence to support your arguments.Personality tests are widely used these days in both professional and informal settings. One may take a personality test online, for example; in order to determine how much like a film character they are, or they may take one in an employment process or clinical setting

“A Multidimensional Perspective Of Causality On Community Violence”

663 words - 3 pages , negative media influences, parents and communities falling down on the job, teen pregnancy, and a loss of moral values—continue to plague communities and make life an uphill struggle for many children. Several additional problems that are macro in nature emerge from this research as very serious challenges affecting Black communities and children. Some are structural problems, such as economic isolation and an unfair criminal justice system