This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Religion In James Hogg’s The Private Memoirs And Confessions Of A Justified Sinner And J.G. Lockhart’s Adam Blair

2709 words - 11 pages

Religion in James Hogg’s The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner and J.G. Lockhart’s Adam Blair

“There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus. For the law of the Spirit of life has set you free in Christ Jesus from the law of sin and death” (Romans 8:1-2). Given the highly charged religious environment of eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Scotland, the above passage must have been discussed many times in Christian circles then. Some of the Reformed faithful, perhaps, took the first part too seriously, to the expense of any normal sense of morality, while others might have forgotten their freedom from condemnation and fallen into despair. Either way, both views pervert the orthodox Calvinistic view of guilt laid out in the teachings of the doctrine’s namesake and the standard confessions of the church at the time.

While they may not make very good theology, these dogmas at least provided material for two nineteenth-century character studies, James Hogg’s The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner and J.G. Lockhart’s Adam Blair. Written when much (but not all) of post-Enlightenment Scotland had taken an anti-clerical, anti-religious stance, these novels explore the faith of the previous generation and how fundamentalist Presbyterianism may have gone horribly wrong. The protagonists of each book react in completely opposite ways to their sinful acts; Lockhart’s eponymous character has a nearly legalistic view of his own sin, while Hogg’s Robert Wringhim follows a more antinomian path. Oddly enough, it is the former who ends up redeemed and the other damned, but their respective journeys toward those ends follow much of the same path.

Robert Wringhim, Hogg’s central character, grows up in a rather dysfunctional family, to say the least; he lives with his mother and her minister, and the novel implies that he is actually the illegitimate son of the latter. Taught from childhood that the elect, the people God had chosen for salvation, were incapable of doing any wrong and could never lose their special status because of any actions they took. The senior Robert Wringhim, his father figure, is fully convinced of this himself, and uses it to excuse both his son’s sin and his own. As a result, even after his supposed salvation, Wringhim believes that his justification before God gives him license to do what he pleases without any spiritual consequences. He accepts this unquestioningly, but the role of the minister in the Church of Scotland had at the time of the book’s events almost requires him to do so: "In the eighteenth century Scottish Presbyterian community the minister was not just a man--he was the defender of public morals, the archetypal good man, the figure for emulation" (Richardson 54). Add to this that his particular minister also acts as his father figure, and it is little surprise that Robert believes in such a radical teaching.

It is that same near-idolization of...

Find Another Essay On Religion in James Hogg’s The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner and J.G. Lockhart’s Adam Blair

Change and Innocence in Memoirs of a Geisha by Arthur Golden

956 words - 4 pages Thesis: Through many hardships and tribulations, Chiyo Sakamoto undergoes a metamorphosis in which she ultimately is forced to lose her innocence after coming to terms with the inevitability of change. Outline: 1. Core Component 1: Explain how Chiyo suffered and what she sacrificed growing up that led to a loss of innocence. a. Subcomponent 1: Chiyo was sold by her parents, separated from her sister, and forced into a new life she had to now

Identity speech: Yolngu Boy and Clive James' unreliable memoirs

1057 words - 4 pages Identity is the way we see ourselves in the way of others. Alternately, it is possible to be an identity, with Clive James simultaneously showing his personality and identity through Unreliable Memoirs. Either way, identity is shaped from a variety of things including culture, personality and society. Without having an established identity, people often come into conflict with themselves, and others as they struggle to piece their identity

The Self-hatred of Kochan in Confessions of a Mask

709 words - 3 pages The Self-hatred of Kochan in Confessions of a Mask In his semi-autobiographical novel, Confessions of a Mask, Yukio Mishima examines the struggle for acceptance by a man living outside of the socially accepted norms. A motif that strongly pervades this novel is death and the images of blood associated with it. Kochan, a Japanese adolescent living in post-war Japan, struggles with his homosexuality and his desire to be "normal." In order to

The Beauty of Adam and Eve

1090 words - 5 pages In a world bombarded with technology and constant distractions, society often forgets the importance and beauty of art. A branch of art, literature, lends a tremendous impact upon society. Marjorie Pickthall constructs an elegant poem, Adam and Eve, while reinterpreting the well-known Biblical story, Adam and Eve. Similar to Pickthall, a renaissance artist, Masaccio, however, interprets the Biblical story of Adam and Eve with a different

The History of Adam and Eve

807 words - 4 pages There is a famous story that is in the bible. This story is about Adam and Eve. It is probably one of the most important stories in the bible. This story tells about the very first sin that was ever created. It goes on to tell about how everything changed once Adam took a bite of the apple. It is one that I have heard since I was just a little girl and it still holds meaning today. This is how the story goes. The story starts out with God

A Comparison of Generational Conflicts in The Kiss and Marriage Is a Private Affair

2417 words - 10 pages Generational Conflicts in The Kiss and Marriage Is a Private Affair         As a family's lineage develops, there may be apparent differences in the way of thinking, attitude, and devotion to tradition between the generations. These differences or developments can either build up friction between generations, or in some cases ultimately heal the discord between other generations. Both Julia Alvarez's contemporary short story, "The

"Fugitive Pieces" by Anne Michaels, "The Power of One" by Bryce Courtenay and "Empire of the Sun" by J.G. Ballard

1644 words - 7 pages The power to overcome life threatening experiences helps a person to grow within. In the books Fugitive Pieces by Anne Michaels, Empire of the Sun by J. G. Ballard, and The Power of One by Bryce Courtenay, the main characters--Jakob, Peekay and Jim respectively--were all able to overcome adversity at a young age. This was developed through their relationships with a father-like mentor, their ability to build courage from fear and their informal

The memoirs of a Musician with Wanderlust

2791 words - 12 pages I was woken up by the pastor because of it was time for mass. Sat in the pew and listened to him as he told of Christ being born. When he was done with his sermon he said he had an announcement he said that last night a young lady came to the church and told us her story and played her guitar and sang for us. He continued by saying that they were so moved by her story they pooled they're money together and bought the lady a gift. Then one of the

Comparing Homosexual tendencies in St. Augustines Confessions, and The Epic of Gilgamesh - Grant Macewan - comparative essay

1167 words - 5 pages AlixAnn Scheetz Loving Without Borders 3043754 Words:1089 Comparative Literature 102 Dr. David Reddall The two pieces of literature that I will be comparing are “The Epic of Gilgamesh” which is set in ancient Mesopotamia in 2700- 600 B.C.E and “Augustine's Confessions” which takes place in the Roman empire between 354-386 A.D. Between these two texts the idea can be developed that Eros, the idea of love and lust, can be formed by a strong bond

Private James Francis Ryan and PTSD

1789 words - 7 pages recuse and bring James Francis Ryan home. James Francis Ryan is a World War II veteran and everyday he thinks about what happened during the war. The biggest problem he faces is stress from World War II. World War II was a very tragic event at that time and many veterans developed various mental illness. From the movie, it shows that James Francis Ryan was no exception in facing problems because of the war. He wants to make sure that he lived a

Memoirs of a Geisha

1736 words - 7 pages A geisha is truly a unique and fascinating individual in the within the Japanese culture. Often times, many individuals do not take the time which is necessary to learn about another person’s culture to understand what incidents occur to shape them into who they are. Americans are primarily guilty of putting the geisha in the same box as prostitutes and placing an identical label on them, when in fact, a geisha isn’t a prostitute at all

Similar Essays

Robert Wrhinghim In James Hogg's Novel, The Private Memoirs And Confessions Of A Justified Sinner

1222 words - 5 pages Robert Wrhinghim in James Hogg's Novel, The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner Works Cited Not Included      James Hogg's classic novel, The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner, portrays the fictional story of Robert Wringhim, a strong Calvinist who justifies murder by quickening the inevitable. Robert commits infamous acts of evil, believing that these murderous actions glorify God by annihilating

Doctor Jekyll And Mr. Hyde, Frankenstein And Confessions Of A Justified Sinner

3239 words - 13 pages of Robert's attitude towards women, at a secret desire for sexual violence and domination and at the 'attraction of evil and sin', admitting even to himself that, "ÉI felt a sort of indefinite pleasure, an ungracious delight in having a beautiful woman solely at my disposal.". In Confessions of a Justified Sinner, Robert's definite dislike for women could be because he views them all with the same impression as he views Eve &endash; Adam

Confessions Of A Sinner Essay

1523 words - 6 pages floor and if I looked hard enough it would magically come to me. The line of children in front of me progressed forward a step, all in unison, such good kids, holy, on their way to a divine heaven, no doubt. I on the other hand held back, reluctant to take that deafening step toward my own inner hell, which in this moment, was the catholic confessional. How close was I getting? Leaning to the right ever so slightly, enabled me myself to see

Religion And Its Effects On Stephen Dedalus In James Joyce's "A Portrait Of The Artist As A Young Man"

1177 words - 5 pages Religion is an important and recurring theme in James Joyce's A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man. Through his experiences with religion, Stephen Dedalus both matures and progressively becomes more individualistic as he grows. Though reared in a Catholic school, several key events lead Stephen to throw off the yoke of conformity and choose his own life, the life of an artist.Religion is central to the life of Stephen Dedalus the child. He