Religious And Medical Dilemma Essay

1152 words - 5 pages

"You shall not eat the blood of any creature, for the life of every creature is its blood" (Lev. 17:14). This is just one of the several scriptures found in the bible from which the Jehovah Witnesses base their beliefs. To summarize the above excerpt, Jehovah Witnesses strongly believe that contributing to the health of their bodies by way of any type of blood material is not intended by God’s will. However in dire cases, ethical questions need to be raised regarding the patient’s mental capacity and legal competence. In particular cases concerning minor patients, where mental capacity is accounted for, parents should not have the dominant opinion about how their child wants to receive surgery based on their own personal beliefs.
The hospital was presented with a difficult decision to make concerning a particular case involving a minor Jehovah Witness. A fifteen year old girl was brought in to the emergency room after being the subject of an automobile accident. There are four options the doctor can consider: refusal of the surgery, perform the surgery without blood considering the parent’s wishes, perform the surgery with blood respecting the decision of the patient, or complete the surgery with blood and do not inform the parents.
When asking whether or not parents should make the decision for the child in this case, concerns could be raised as to if the patient is endangered by their own parents. When a parent is basing a lifesaving decision on religious beliefs that the patient might not even reciprocate, is the parent looking out for the child or their religious reputation? In this particular case, the patient’s surgery would be a low-risk and high-benefit procedure and the patient expresses her wishes in favor of the blood transfusion despite her religious beliefs. On a farther note, who is to say that this child has religious beliefs?
As a doctor, to prepare myself to take on this case I would have to process a substantial amount of information and use my best judgment to conceive what the best plan of action regarding this case should be. Reviewing the four key principles in medical ethics: nonmaleficience, beneficence, respect for autonomy, and justice, would prove to be very helpful. After reviewing and consulting with my peers I would most likely conclude that the patient is the one receiving the service and is to be put first above all other factors contributing to the situation.
According to the first principle, nonmaleficience, it would not be appropriate as a professional to practice medicine based on his or her own beliefs and not consider the patients feelings about the operation. In this particular case, regarding religious constrictions the doctor must decide if the patients’ needs outweigh the ethical belief of nonmaleficience. Asserting empathy in this case could prove to be a problem. How does a person wholly understand the beliefs of another when they have not been exposed to those beliefs and...

Find Another Essay On Religious and Medical Dilemma

Euthanasia, an Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma

1083 words - 4 pages voluntary euthanasia should occur would be persistent vegetative state, and terminally ill with impending death. He agrees this is a very important ethical dilemma that is going to continue to need studying due to increases in medical and technological advances that could prolong life. The final interview was with a spiritual leader in Detroit Medical Center, Michigan who is a chaplain. Regarding our topic assisted /voluntary euthanasia, she stated that

The Contraception Mandate: A Complex Debate Between Religious Freedoms and a Woman’s Right to Health

2240 words - 9 pages Obama on March 23rd 2010. The mandate states that employers who offer health care insurance are required by law to provide “minimum essential” health care coverage to their employees’, part of which includes the coverage of contraceptives. Exempt from the mandate, are companies with fewer than 50 employees and religious institutions. The problem has been that certain religiously affiliated for-profit, and non-profit organizations are not covered

Assisted Suicide

1087 words - 4 pages Is the role of a medical professional to ensure the health and comfort of their patients, or to help them end their lives? Since Dr. Kevorkian assisted in the suicide of Janet Adkins in 1990, physician-assisted suicide (PAS) has been one of the most controversial issues in the medical field today. While some view it as an individual right, others view it as an unethical issue that goes against medical ethics and religious values. Mr. H. M. is

Moral Dilemmas Faced by Jewish Leaders

2408 words - 10 pages All around the world, every minute of everyday someone encounters a moral dilemma whether it is minuscule or monumental. Going against ones religious or moral beliefs can be problematic; it may in fact be so moving that it causes one to reexamine their entire thought process. Before the Holocaust, Hitler campaigned in Germany with promises that Germany will be great again, people took these promises like candy and followed his every word

Ethical Issues of Stem Cell Research

665 words - 3 pages sides. The ethical issue is in the process of isolating a human embryo stem cell from the blastocysts, which causes the embryo to die (Sandhyarani, 2009). The number of people who could benefit from stem cell development is endless. Yet many people, in particular those with moral and religious concern, question the use of embryo's for research.Perceived dilemmasThe stem cell research dilemma is not one that will quickly resolve, especially since

Should we use Stem Cells in Order to Cure Other Diseases?

982 words - 4 pages There have been many types of medical advances, but one in particular that has been said that it can help on the treatment of different type of diseases. Stem cells are multicellular organisms that can develop many more of their kind and then give birth to new kind of cells. This types of cells come from the umbilical cord of a new born. This became a huge dilemma where there’s a competing with moral and ethical values. The rumor is a never

Ethical Consideration of Misrepresented Information in a Patient Chart

2002 words - 9 pages Communication in the workplace is a vital part of having an effective team. And when that chain of communication is broken, problems will arise. If this is the case, what happens when there is a person’s life on the line? In medicine, these situations happen all the time, and having the ability to communicate effectively is very important. In the ethical dilemma presented, a complication happens during a surgical repair of a ruptured bowel. With

Stem Cell Success or Moral Dilemma

1955 words - 8 pages enfeeblement to medical technology. It is very important that we find a happy medium for both sides of this controversial matter so that we may continue to explore cure options. Most wonder how can regenerative stem therapies help heal patients? Has Japanese scientist Haruko Obokata found the answer to ethical stem cell replication (Connor)? And how can we satisfy the religious communities on this topic? Some may ask “What are stem cells?” Little

Moral Dilemmas Faced by Jewish Leaders

2143 words - 9 pages All around the world, every moment of everyday someone encounters a moral dilemma whether it is minuscule or monumental. Going against ones religious or moral beliefs can be problematic; it may in fact be so moving that it causes one to reexamine their entire thought process. Regardless of ones age during the Holocaust, so many were faced with unbelievable ethical dilemmas. Many Jewish leaders faced moral dilemmas and made heroic decisions

Beliefs Taken to the Extremes

1811 words - 7 pages Beliefs Taken to the Extremes          Belief is a fundamental human trait. Belief in many things is what helps humans continue living their lives. Religious beliefs are one of the strongest forces of human emotion and often times those emotions can create dangerous situations. When people's religious beliefs are taken to extreme levels innocent people can be hurt. All throughout history there have been examples of just such incidents

Major Reforms from 1790-1860

811 words - 3 pages Massachusetts' Horace Mann. Mann, secretary of the Massachusetts Board of Education, campaigned effectively for this expanded curriculum, and soon after influenced the entire national educational system. Not only did preliminary education undergo diversity, so did higher education. The previously founded colleges of William and Mary, Harvard, and Princeton offered little more than religious boredom. The nation began to recognize this dilemma and

Similar Essays

Religious Pluralism And Islam Essay

1813 words - 8 pages there is little religious regulation, the religious economy will be very pluralistic. Religious firms are then faced with a competition dilemma, either the firm innovates and specializes, to meet the needs and tastes of various niches to win over a larger share of the religious market than their competitors, or it disappears. Pluralistic religious marketplaces will be able to meet the tastes and needs of a greater majority of believers. Increasing

Saving A Hospital Essay

1004 words - 4 pages to the policies and procedures will alleviate any misunderstanding and confusion. By having the patients acknowledge that their religious beliefs and practices may cause medical mishaps will also assist the hospital with their liability issues and bad press that they are receiving. Addressing each issue calmly and rationally will hopefully show the light at the end of the tunnel for this executive assistant that obviously has a challenge ahead of him, but with the right level of thinking, the task should not be that difficult.

Ethical Dilemmas : Examples During The Holocaust

1040 words - 5 pages All around the world, every minute of everyday someone encounters a moral dilemma whether it is minuscule or monumental. Going against ones religious or moral beliefs can be problematic; it may in fact be so moving that it causes one to reexamine their entire thought process. Before the Holocaust, Hitler campaigned in Germany with promises that Germany will be great again, people took these promises like candy and followed his every word. Soon

Reiligious Diversity In The Workplace Essay

1022 words - 5 pages discussion, and the events of September 11, 2001 (9/11) have led to workplace conflicts between Muslims and non-Muslims. Additionally, Esteicher and Gray (2010) expounded on how religious discrimination creates a dilemma between balancing the rights of employees to protect and express their beliefs with the rights of coworkers to work in an environment absent of pressure by the religious views and practices of other employees. In Jenny’s case her