Religious And Public School’s Student’s Moral Beliefs In Hypothetical Situation Surveys For Establishment Clause Child Benefit Testing

1593 words - 7 pages

The goal of my study is to analyze the results of surveys to see whether the moral side of the child benefit arguments should be acknowledged. I would like to propose a longitudinal study where surveys are used to observe what type of relationship if any exists between the type of school the student attends, and that student’s moral view. Gathering data on this relationship is important to know when state Supreme Courts have based policy using ‘Child Benefit Theory’ arguments.
Whether or not there is in fact a sort of positive moral outcome from attending a particular type of school would be mean there is a difference in moral understanding different between the two types of institutions forcing relevance to the policy making. Alternatively, it may be the case that there is not an observable difference between an individual’s idea of morality and their school’s type. If the data drawn from surveyed students differ in terms of what is right to do inside of hypothetical situation, then moral aspects of child benefit theories would then be relevant to child benefit based establishment tests.
The Establishment Clause states that policy cannot support an established religion. To some interpreters like Derek Davis and Douglas Laycock the purpose for a Wall of Separation is not to hinder child benefits or be a nation free from religion, but was only to forbid a national or state religion. Other interpreters such as George Kurland and Robert Peterson support more neutrality when allocating funds, without child benefits taking precedence. Due to the implicit nature of the constitution and vague language these competing interpretation cause reasonable disagreements amongst courts.
In order to solve these issues of justifying allocating public funds for the sake of student educational needs the Supreme Court has incorporated a variety of ‘Establishment tests’ (Veen 2000). Establishment tests are the assessment methods to determine whether funds are unconstitutional under the first amendment’s establishment clause. However, if tests cannot be reliable confusion arises as to why certain decisions favor different criteria thus causing confusion for the courts and institutions as well.
Part of the confusion is due to the uncertainty of how strictly we are to interpret the Establishment Clause. The Establishment Clause’s purpose according to Thomas Jefferson is to create a wall of separation between church and state. But the language is somewhat vague. Lisa Thurau-Gray also points out how most recent decisions have provided support for less rigid interpretations of the Establishment Clause. However, these same decisions can in effect pose an unfair advantage in certain contexts. (Gray 1998).
Some thinkers like Veit-Michael Bader a professor of sociology, and of social and political philosophy at the University of Amsterdam support an establishment test which is more open to educational advantages despite indirect religious support. The indirect support is...

Find Another Essay On Religious and Public School’s Student’s Moral Beliefs in Hypothetical Situation Surveys for Establishment Clause Child Benefit Testing

Drug testing in schools. The issue of drug testing in public schools. The postion is for drug testing and gives reasons and quotas from laws

1354 words - 5 pages DRUG TESTING IN SCHOOLSThe issue of drug testing in public schools has become the most debated issue in the United States. This issue raises questions regarding the protection of the students' civil liberties and the moral obligations the schools have to parents, students and society. Schools are under pressure to do something about the drug use in the schools by the students. The school administrators are being forced to deal with both alcohol

Religious beliefs of Shintoism in Japan

1688 words - 7 pages differences that run between these two religions; nonetheless, Shinto was and remains a religion that tends to defy characterization largely because of its varied background and its socio-political construction and distinct traditions. It is common for practionners to have other religious affiliates. There are no sets of gods or doctrines to follow by, but rather in a belief in many gods and spirits living in animate and inanimate objects. In

Religious beliefs of Shintoism in Japan

1688 words - 7 pages differences that run between these two religions; nonetheless, Shinto was and remains a religion that tends to defy characterization largely because of its varied background and its socio-political construction and distinct traditions. It is common for practionners to have other religious affiliates. There are no sets of gods or doctrines to follow by, but rather in a belief in many gods and spirits living in animate and inanimate objects. In

Thomas Hardy and His Religious Beliefs

716 words - 3 pages Thomas Hardy and His Religious Beliefs Thomas Hardy was born into a very active Christian family. He was the son of Orthodox Christians who made sure that he regularly attended services. Many of Hardy's relatives were involved in the church. Some were members of the clergy and some were musicians at the local church. Hardy, a member of the Stinsford parish, taught a Sunday school class when he was a young man. He even had aspirations of

Ancient Maya Religious Practices and Beliefs

1405 words - 6 pages matters. Many elite class sons became priests because they could not all hold a political office. “Priests who were full-time specialists in religious matters emerged as Maya society became larger and more complex.” (Sharer, 2009) They played an important role in Maya government and politics and directed the calendar that the Maya used to set dates for religious ceremonies and performed large, public ceremonies. Priest wrote many books

Public Education and Standarized Testing in the US

1607 words - 7 pages 3rd – 8th grade use New York State Testing Program and high school students take regent examinations. Students from Pennsylvania take Pennsylvania System of State Assessments which is now being replaced by a more challenging test called the Keystone Exams in grades 3rd – 8th and 11th in high school . Each state are criterion-referenced test, thus, your child will only compete against him or herself, rather than be

Public Education and Standard Testing

971 words - 4 pages influence the results on standardized tests and the education the students receive. Standardized test have no use without the students who take them and the students rely on them. Unfortunately, the uncertainty of standardized testing is that it doesn’t provide a clear picture of a student’s knowledge and skill of subject matter, or the interrelatedness to other content areas. (Moore). Since standardized test can’t provide a clear picture for

Moral Beliefs Discussed in Sophocles' Antigone and Western Philosophy by David Papineau

2544 words - 10 pages , but your family forbids it and threatens to cut all ties with you if you choose to do so. Given this difficult situation, what do you feel is the right thing to do? Sophocles attempts to approach these issues of right and wrong and human morality through the characters in his play Antigone. Since there are many different takes on moral obligations and they alter between different principles of religion, civic duty, family commitment and

Drug Testing and Public Assistance

2141 words - 9 pages these laws and argue against it because they feel it violates ones Fourth Amendment right. If it is considered Constitutional to drug test athletes, is pre-hire condition for employment and random drug testing a paid employee in a private and public sector, then why is it considered unconstitutional to apply the same standards for welfare recipients? (Schaberg, 2012) The Fourth Amendment protects people from unreasonable searches and seizures

Situation Analysis for Marks and Spencer in Holland

2408 words - 10 pages Country, Industry and Competitor Analysis This situation analysis focuses on the suitability of Marks and Spencer in Holland and the necessary factors the company has to take into account before venturing into this market. The market has several advantages which Marks and Spencer can tap into going by the level of success it has experienced in the UK. The company can focus on developing a clothing product line that appeals to young, urbane and

What was the situation in terms of religious faith in England 1558-1603 and how did central government attempt to change this situation?

2129 words - 9 pages the strongest claimant to the throne on the event of Elizabeth's death and her arrival in England in 1568 created major political and religious problems for Elizabeth. Although these issues caused problems for Elizabeth, it was unlikely that she would keep England a Catholic country and it seemed evident that the current religious situation would undergo a significant change, impacting many areas of faith and people in England.At the end of

Similar Essays

How Far Does Situation Ethics Give A Practical And Modern Way For Making Moral Decisions Religious Studies Ethics Essay

559 words - 3 pages How far does situation ethics give a practical and modern way for making moral decisions. Situation ethics is a flexible theory that can be applied and adapted to every situation. For example, homosexual relationships are seen as wrong by most religious believers and by some atheists. However, situation ethics gives a different approach to homosexual relationships; as long as the relationship is based on love and not lust it is acceptable

Beliefs And Morals Of The Native American Indians Research The Native Americans Focusing On Their Religious Rites And Practices. Include A Section On Moral Values

765 words - 3 pages Developed a Moral System (Ethics)In the Indian society there are well structured boundaries as to what people should and shouldn't do. It is similar in many respects to our modern Australian code of ethics; one man should not take the wife of another to be his own or steal from anyone else within their own tribe. Everyone is expected to share what they had for the benefit of the whole region too. So while not everyone likes some of the social

Describe The Religious Beliefs And Practices In Pre Islamic Arabia

859 words - 3 pages In Arabia, the period before the emergence of Muhammad was a time of many different and varying religious practices.To understand the religious beliefs and practices of the time, it is necessary first to have some basic appreciation of Arabia as a whole. The Arabian Peninsula can be divided into two distinct climactic and geographical zones: North and South. In the South was an area along the coast of the Arabian Sea that received regular rain

Religious Beliefs In Aeschylus' Oresteia, Homer’s Iliad, And Sophocles’ Electra

1666 words - 7 pages Religious Beliefs in Aeschylus' Oresteia, Homer’s Iliad, and Sophocles’ Electra The final and definitive defeat of the Persian army at the battle of Plataea represented the end of an age-long threat to Athens. But the victory was also a miracle, as all the odds were against the Athenians at the onset of the war. While Pericles took charge of Athens after the war and started the advance of democracy, religion also thrived. The rebuilding of