Removal Of The Canadian Senate In 21st Century Democracy

2697 words - 11 pages

In 2012, the Canadian Senate became embroiled in a scandal that is still ongoing, and still having an effect on Canadian political life today. At times in the 20th century, there have been calls for the reform, or even the abolition of the Senate completely. The current scandal has resulted a renewal of the frequent calls for reform that have frequently accompanied the many questionable actions of Senators. The structure of the Senate, and its outdated rules of appointment and procedure are also frequently the target of reformers in Canada. It is the contention of this paper that the Canadian Senate be reformed to represent the democracy that is Canada in the 21st Century, as this body is outdated and representative of entrenched party interests, as well as of a system that dates back to the days of aristocratic and upper-class privilege.
The 2012 expenses scandal was followed closely by the Canadian public. The entire scandal has also given the impression that certain Senators had adopted a sort of “above the law” attitude, and only showed repentance when they were caught abusing their office and breaking the law. This type of crime and malfeasance is especially egregious when the people who are committing the crime are the ones charged with (at least to some extent – as will be shown later in this paper) making and upholding the law.
Let us examine the scandal as the latest example of Senate corruption and elitism. In late 2012, an investigation was opened to look into irregularities in the reporting of travel expenses by three Senators: Mike Duffy (Prince Edward Island), Mac Harb (Ontario) and Patrick Brazeau (Quebec). By February 2013, Senators, acting on the basis of preliminary information resulting form their own investigation, hired an outside auditing firm to audit the three Senators mentioned above. In addition, ongoing investigation into the actions or possible misdeeds of other Senators was ongoing, and exposed possible financial irregularities in the travel expenses of Senator Pamela Wallin (Saskatchewan). A result of these investigations prompted the Auditor General of Canada to being an investigation into the expenses of the whole Senate.
The results and consequences to the scandal were many. One of them was increased calls by many segments of Canadian society for the reform or abolition of the Senate. Wallin, Duffy, and Brazeau were suspended. Brazeau is also the focus of a criminal investigation involving sexual and domestic abuse and is currently the day manager of a strip club in Ottawa. His entire Senate career was embroiled in scandal and alleged misdeeds. Harb retired from the Senate after paying back over $180,000 – but he is now collecting his Senate pension of $123,000. Duffy is still embroiled in a legal fight, with allegations of coverups and payoffs coming to light. Wallin was suspended without pay, but protested vigorously her innocence. All of the Senators have kept their medical, dental and life insurance...

Find Another Essay On Removal of the Canadian Senate in 21st Century Democracy

Podcasting in the 21st Century Essay

1783 words - 7 pages Podcasting in the 21st CenturyNamed the "Word of the Year" by the New Oxford American Dictionary in 2005, podcasting has grown in popularity enormously in the last several years. Beginning back in 2000, podcasting has now become as accepted as radio or television. What started as a simple concept is now being used by the Prime Minister of Canada. There are literally thousands of topics one can discover with podcasts. From computers to movies

Women in the 21st century Essay

1079 words - 4 pages In October 2013, the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Education, UNESCO, stated that millions of girls are still being denied an education. Why is it that women in the 21st century are still not given their basic human rights? The effects of oppression are seen in two very controversial short stories. In Charlotte Perkins Gilman's "The Yellow Wallpaper," and William Faulkner's "A Rose for Emily", alienation caused from the

Sexism in the 21st century

918 words - 4 pages generations of women have experinced. With that being said, can we say that sexism is a thing of the past? One of the main causes of perpetuating these sexist ideals in the 21st century is media. Women have moved from being the stay at home housewife that obeys everything her husband says to complete dehumanized sex objects. While we have gone a long way in terms of womens rights, media is doing the most damage to women. More specifically within

Heroes in the 21st Century

1280 words - 5 pages editorial, as well as all armed forces, Scott Silverman, Captain Richard Phillips, Marc Buoiniconti, and Jasper Schuringa show that heroes do walk amongst us each and every day in the 21st century. As mentioned in Text 1, Lance Armstrong Syndrome: Do Heroes Exist?, “If we look deeply at ourselves we can find a little hope that heroes can exist, probably in every one of us, but not as a blanket rule or even as a perfectly high glossed figure devoid of

Parenting in the 21st Century

1981 words - 8 pages these decision making processes makes them to be very participative and thoughtful on the well being of the child’s education and thus prompts them to come up with more new compelling measures on how to improve education in this century. School resources to implement the plan Actually the school needs a lot to implement the involvement plan. Nevertheless, a close analysis of all what is needed in executing the plan is within the reach of

Museums In the 21st Century

1333 words - 6 pages normally would not just because of the sheer power of the exhibits around them. They are a necessity in society because it betters and cultures the population, making the world greater as a whole. I am thankful that museums are taking the initiative to becoming more modernized, adding twenty first century touches to the exhibits as well as creating virtual tours. Even though they do not compare to being there in person, it is a step in the right

education in the 21st century

670 words - 3 pages The twenty first century has brought profound challenges to nature, values and the control of higher education in the United States. Society expectations and public resources for higher education are undergoing fundamental shifts. Changes both within an outside the academy are altering its character- it students, faculty, and governance, curriculum, functions, and very place in society. The import of major external influences on U.S. higher

Leadership in the 21st Century

1697 words - 7 pages INTRODUCTIONNew societal conditions are eliciting new forms of leadership necessary to launch and sustain the transitions toward more knowledge-intensive societies. Leadership in the digital age needs new attitudes, new skills, and new knowledge gained through unique professional experiences responsive to the societal features identified earlier.We must distinguish between two related but different leadership categories. The most inclusive

Nationalimsm In The 21st Century

1906 words - 8 pages nations are timeless yes that's right timeless phenomena. When man did happen to climbed out of the primordial slime, wot wot wot, he immediately set about creating nations. ·         The next major school of thought is that of the perennialists who argue that nations have been around for a very long time, though they take different shapes at different points in history. ·         While postmodernists and Marxists also play in the larger

Hacking in the 21st Century

2740 words - 11 pages A countless number of today’s companies understand “hacking” is not just a crime, but a necessity to today’s internet security. “Microsoft and Facebook announced last November that they would pay bounties to ethical hackers for discovering vulnerabilities, not just in their own products, but in software systems that make up the internet infrastructure, as well” (Acohido par 3). Companies are soliciting outside computer specialists to illegally

Challenges of the 21st Century

926 words - 4 pages Challenges of the 21st Century   Citizens of the world look on with anticipation as our society moves into the twenty-first century. Although the world has not accomplished the wild ideas presented in science fiction, we have made a huge amount of progress in technology. However, many hurdles still need to be faced. Numerous critical problems will face both America and the world as a whole in this new millennium. Three problems

Similar Essays

Canadian Sports In The 21st Century

989 words - 4 pages Change is inevitable given a certain amount of time. However, one thing that has never changed during the 21st century in Canada is sports. Although the sports itself have evolved and the athletes have also became stronger, faster, and more fit with each passing decade; the one thing that has never changed are the Canadians' passion and pride in sports and the will to perform to the best of their abilities. Barbara Ann Scott, Terry Fox and Wayne

Challenges Of Management In The 21st Century

876 words - 4 pages Challenges of management in the 21st century In the 21st century they consist of various barriers that prevent managers and leaders from achieving their goals and improving their organizations work. Managers constantly try tackle this issues that drive towards lowering productivity. Challenges of management include : • Technology • Ethics • Globalization • Competition • Diversity • PESTEL Technology. Keeping up with technology is

Uses Of Space In The 21st Century

1024 words - 4 pages realize that they wouldn't be able to watch TV or use a phone to ring up their mates if it wasn't for geo-stationary communication satellites, which travel around the Earth at the same speed as the planet, so they're always above a certain part of a country, to send phone messages and TV pictures. Satellites also help us preserve the environment in a lot ways, especially land survey satellites that take detailed photos which can be used to detect

Terrorism In The 21st Century Essay

3458 words - 14 pages On September 11, 2001, the destruction of the World Trade Center and the Pentagon changed the mindset and the opinion of nearly every American on the one of the most vital issues in the 21st century: terrorism (Hoffman 2). Before one can begin to analyze how the United States should combat such a perverse method of political change, one must first begin to understand what terrorism is, where it is derived from, and why there is