Renaissance Tragedy And Investigator Heroes Essay

2457 words - 10 pages

Renaissance Tragedy and Investigator Heroes

The role of the investigator in Renaissance tragedy, with special reference to Shakespeare's Hamlet and Thomas Kyd's The Spanish Tragedy

I therefore will by circumstances try, What I can gather to confirm this writ
Hieronimo The play's the thing
Wherein I'll catch the conscience of the King

The roots of the blossoming tree of crime fiction can be traced back to the ancient soil of The Bible, and beyond, in literature which contains mysteries to be solved, and figures who act as detectives. Mystery was present in Classical Greek tragedy. In Oedipus Rex (c. 429 bc) the identity of Oedipus is a mystery, the unravelling of which influences the movement of the plot. In fact the very term 'anagnorisis' indicates a discovery - a revealing of a mystery.

In the biblical era perhaps one of the earliest acts of 'detection' took place when Herod killed all new-born babies on one particular night in an attempt to eliminate the child prophesied to ruin him. We have other examples of detection prior to Christ too; the prophets, such as Daniel, could interpret dreams. This was detection in the sense that they had to interpret symbolic images to understand their significance. In that sense the prophets could be called 'investigators'. But these dreams were very often interpreted in a visionary state of mind, therefore detection in the strictest sense of the term cannot be used here.

We have detection in the 12th century German epic Nibelungenlied as well where Hagen, the minister of Brunhild's revenge coaxes the secret of the vulnerable spot in Siegfried's body from Kriemhild.

In Romantic fiction we see for the first time in European literature, a systematic use of mystery in plotting. As A. H. Clewer stated in his essay Modern Crime Fiction [1], 'the early whodunit approach is perhaps related to mysteries of identity in Romantic fiction. For example, in Scott's Ivanhoe the identity of the Black Knight is mysterious, and its eventual revelation forms an important element in the plot. Keats uses a similar gambit in his tragedy Otho The Great (1819) presumably influenced by Scott.

But the role of the investigator that we find in the writings of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Agatha Christie, Edgar Allan Poe and others probably entered into the realm of fiction through Voltaire's Zadig (1748). As John Drinkwater observed in The Outline of Literature [2] 'Zadig was a Sherlock Holmes born before his time.' [See excerpt in Appendix]. If Voltaire had been born after Conan Doyle 'Zadig' might have been taken as a parody of the great detective who resided in Baker Street.

In Elizabethan drama the plot tends to move forward in complex ways, but without any element of the mysterious. There are no actual mysteries in Shakespeare's plots, however complex they are. But although there is no real mystery in the tragedies of Shakespeare and Thomas Kyd, the figure of the investigator features prominently....

Find Another Essay On Renaissance Tragedy and Investigator Heroes

Unraveling the Mystery of William Shakespeare

627 words - 3 pages Consequences. They come in shapes of dark evil and unimaginable good. However with each consequence, in turn a “rebirth”. A new perspective. A new insight. The creation of a profound poet and playwright, William Shakespeare, was one of the many marvelous consequences of the Renaissance. In fact his outstanding work was the direct result of the Renaissance. In order to understand how Shakespeare came to be, there is first a need to understand

Classical and Renaissance Paradigms of Heroism in Hamlet

1612 words - 6 pages Classical and Renaissance paradigms of heroism in Hamlet In the early part of the seventeenth century, when William Shakespeare wrote The tragedy of Hamlet, prince of Denmark, Europe was the center of a waning Renaissance that had, over the past three centuries, changed the intellectual bedrock of the West beyond recognition. The moral code of conduct for the common people had been transformed into one that embodied the tenets of

The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet

1233 words - 5 pages secret to all but few, and fate brings them both to an untimely death. Love and death are both prominent themes in this drama, leading it to be one of Shakespeare's most renowned romantic tragedies.According to, a tragedy is given the definition as follows: "(esp. in classical and Renaissance drama) a play in which the protagonist, usually a man of importance and outstanding personal qualities, falls to disaster through the

Heroes, the topic was are there real-life heroes today and if so who are they? Be sepecific.

702 words - 3 pages HeroesWhat is a hero? A hero is often viewed as being someone that is rich, famous or beautiful. Some even say heroes don't exist, but instead are only existent in a fantasy world. A hero can come in all shapes, sizes, genders, and racial backgrounds. Heroes usually are oblivious to our knowing because, for the most part they are humble and may not know themselves that they are heroes. The truth is that there are many real-life heroes among us

Italian Art History

1203 words - 5 pages renaissance classicism. This meant sharp colors (Chiaroscuro), friezes and frescos. The subject matter came from classical history and mythology. The second wave of Neoclassic really hit when the Napoleonic Empire took power.The art work from the 1400's to the 1600's showed a drastic change after 1520 when Mannerism was brought about. After a while the Mannerist style was known to not be such a good thing. People saw the paintings as not classical and

Tragic Flaws and the Role They Play

518 words - 2 pages Tragic Flaws and the Role They Play Many Greeks considered tragedies to be the greatest form of literature. The characters in these tragedies, mainly the heroes, were not doomed from the start because of their fate, but rather had certain flaws that made them cause their tragic ends. These tragic heroes have been talked about for generations and have had their stories passed down year after year. These heroes, all having different tragic flaws

Zora Neale Hurston and her impact on the Harlem Renaissance

1364 words - 5 pages Zora Neale Hurston and her impact on the Harlem Renaissance The Influence of Zora Neale Hurst on and by The Harlem Renaissance " Nothing ever made is the same thing to more than one person. That is natural . There is no single face in nature because every eye that looks upon, it sees it from it's own angle. So every man's spice box seasons his own food." The Harlem Renaissance, a

Renaissance Man

652 words - 3 pages Renaissance Man Disabilities cannot limit creativity, which was how Leonardo da Vinci viewed life. Leonardo da Vinci is an example of a hero, because his studies and contributions were the building blocks for modern technology. Like many heroes, he had overcome many obstacles throughout his lifetime. I will discuss Leonardo’s life, struggles, and accomplishments. Leonardo’s Life

Discuss the aspects of good and evil in shakespear's work

513 words - 2 pages Hamlet or King Lear than to Oedipus or the Oresteia. When Shakespeare's King Richard invites his faithful remnant to sit upon the ground and 'tell sad stories of the death of kings,' he is invoking the concept of tragedy inherited by the Renaissance from the Middle Ages. A tragedy was the sad story of the death of a king or someone comparably eminent. Death was die nexus--as it was not in Greek tragedy. Tile first adjustment the modern reader


1607 words - 7 pages . Introduction Death of a Salesman, by Arthur Miller, and Othello, by William Shakespeare are two plays that each represent the genre of tragedy. The fundamental difference in these two representations of tragedy are the time at which they were written. Shakespeare wrote his play during the renaissance era while Millers play is considered a modern day tragedy. Although these plays were written in different times they both display humanism which

Hamlet’s Tragic Flaws

3066 words - 12 pages referring to the way Hamlet was before tragedy befell him. Hamlet's transition from Renaissance man to madman is another part of this tragedy that inspires pity. "Next, the character must be true to life". The hero should be neither better nor worse morally, than the average person, and must have a balance of good and bad characteristics. If the hero is imperfect and the audience can identify with him, they are more likely to feel fear for the hero

Similar Essays

Tragedy And Thomas Hardy Literature Essay

718 words - 3 pages dramatic representations of the sufferings of his heroes and heroines. The suffering of the characters, often allied to the difficulty of moving into a more modern world whose hostility is reflected in the painful coincidences in the plot, usually ends in the death of the hero or heroine. Some regard Hardy’s novels as a representation of Classical/ Aristotelian tragedy (King, 1978; Brooks, 1971; Johnson, 1923), while others regard them as realistic

Robert Frost And Poetry Essay

3601 words - 14 pages of the operation of a general law, and the keyword is fortune. Williams quotes many examples to explain this point that the ground of tragic action was the operation of this arbitrary and incomprehensible power. The medieval idea of tragedy was worldly as fortune was taken to be worldly success. The falls of heroes were examined in the light of the doctrine of fortune. Behind the particular sins was a more general sin: that of trusting to fortune

Elements Of A Shakespearian Tragedy Essay

582 words - 2 pages Shakespeare wrote many tragedies, which included The Tragedy of Julius Caesar. Hechose to take an important event in Roman history, the death of Julius Caesar to write a play forthe Globe Theater in 1599. The people who lived during the Renaissance were very interested inthe play and the story of Julius Caesar's death. People's views of the play dating from 1599 tothe present may be very different and continually changing. Though the elements

Tragedy In Drama Essay

1706 words - 7 pages spirited, associated with Dionysus. Moving through the Renaissance, there was a change in social attitudes and behaviors. These changes are underscored by the changes to the classic tragedy made by William Shakespeare. In both Julius Caesar and Hamlet, Shakespeare combines the ideas of Aristotle and Nietzsche into complex tragedies with many facets. In some senses, the plays exhibit elements of classic Greek tragedies. Both Hamlet and Caesar are