This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Reparations: Should They Be Given? Essay

1745 words - 7 pages

Slavery Reparations Are Wrong- Ladies and gentlemen; I don't believe that anyone in this chamber would move to disagree with the idea that slavery was an atrocity, committed from the depths of the darkest parts of the human sole. Africans were seized from their native land, and sold into lives of servitude into a foreign land. Indeed, it was a tragedy on such a scale that cannot be measured nor quantified. And it is this very notion of unquantifiable tragedy which speaks to the matter of reparations for slavery. To be quite blunt, reparations, even if they may be deserved, are not feasible under any system or economic tangent - indeed such an undertaking would only not remedy the situation, but it would sink Africa and her people deeper into the cycle of poverty and oppression that they have so struggled to free themselves. While the arguments against reparations may seem shallow or self-serving to advocates of such a system, upon examination, the logistics of what to give, and whom to distribute it to, preclude any potential benefits of such a system of indemnity and requite. The point of the follow critique is not to say that Africans were not mistreated, nor that they are not worthy of reparations, but that perhaps reparations are not an adequate solution to this situation, and indeed will only serve to worsen. Africa is a continent in dire straits. European colonization and colonialism damaged the native structure and society - some might say that this simply proves that European man caused, and ought to pay for, the damages done to Africa and her people. However, I would argue that simply placing a 'band-aid' blanket over Africa, would serve only to mask their problems, and relieve us of our guilt. It was this same attitude that the early European missionaries took with Africa - that they are not capable of dealing with their own problems and situations. Authors suggest that reparations should take the form of capital transfers and African status in the International Monetary Fund (Mazuri, 22). Does this sound like mending the deep running wounds and damage done to Africa, or like a transfer of monetary funds in order to "fix" Africa? Indeed, this idea of presenting money to Africa in order to "apologize" for what we have done is nothing more than a quick fix solution - it is not a long-term remedy for the underlying structural damage. The very center of Africa has been changed, for better or for worse. Surface solutions, while some may claim they are "a good beginning" or perhaps just a token of our apologetic state, will only further social damage and entrench abusive African regimes. A cognate situation with African Americans is with that of Afrocentric history (Asante, 174); many suggest that perhaps we ought to provide black student with their own curriculum, such as to instill in them a sense of pride that will improve their education. The U.S. News and World Report comments: "The Afrocentric curriculum is usually presented as an...

Find Another Essay On Reparations: Should they be given?

Should Alexander be given the title "The Great"?

989 words - 4 pages After Alexander the great died, he was given the title "the great" due to his success in conquering Europe. People thought he made many great to change Europe. Was that really the reason he was given the title the great? What goals do you have to achieve in order you can receive the tile of "the great"? Someone great should be a leader that contributed to the society greatly and made a significant achievement to change the world and make the way

Should condoms be given out in highschool? I do believe condoms should be given out in highschool

1404 words - 6 pages ages. This is one example, among many, of why condoms should be available at schools.I know by being a parent and speaking to other parents we don't want condoms in our children's schools as a way of condoning sex. But, if a teenager, or anyone, decides that they want to have sex, they are going to have sex. If there is a condom available to them, they will be much more likely to use one. For young teenagers, 14 and 15, going to the drug store and

College Athletes: Should They be Paid?

2037 words - 9 pages A lot of people believe college athletes are like employees and should be paid to play. College athletes spend most of their time playing their sport for the college, most athletes see themselves more as athletes than students, and they feel like they should be paid for risking their body’s every day. American colleges and universities should recognize college athletes are paid through scholarships and other opportunities and does not need to

Food Stamps: Should They Be Limited?

2458 words - 10 pages for work, or at least look for work as a condition of receiving aid. I think that there should be an incentive to receiving food stamps like working a part-time job. I have heard people say that they quit their job and lost a source of income just so their amount of stamps would increase and they would not have to work. If this was the mindset of every recipient of these benefits, then the program would have fell through already. It is those who

College Athletes: Should They Be Paid?

1033 words - 4 pages transportation, entertainment, and school supplies, leaving an average difference of about $3,200 annually for each athlete.” One analyst has stated that athletes should not be directly paid, but should be provided with other benefits, such as medical coverage and a form of free agency. If athletes were offered benefits, they might decide to stay in college longer to finish their degrees. Instead, many of the talented athletes decide to go

Gun Control Laws - Should They Be Altered?

624 words - 2 pages While many people believe there should be more gun control and the possibility of banning guns all together, I believe the gun control laws should not be changed. Although there are many reasons that may persuade people to choose to ban guns, I believe that there are several other reasons that lead to all the tragedies with guns in America. Banning guns is not an answer the gun problem in America, there are a few other things that could be done

College Athletes: Should They Be Paid?

1087 words - 5 pages , entertainment, and school supplies, leaving an average difference of about $3,200 annually for each athlete.” Michael LeRoy, a labor law professor at the University of Illinois suggests that athletes should not be directly paid, but should be provided with other benefits, such as medical coverage and a form of free agency. If athletes were offered benefits, they might decide to stay in college longer to finish their degrees. Instead, many of the talented

Online Bullies, Should They be Charged?

958 words - 4 pages are the people who feel the most insecure about themselves. I believe that someone who bullies should also know the consequences of their action and should be charged for bullying. Not only will people continue to bully if they are not stopped but they will also become more harsh with words and cruel with physical actions. “States are enacting tougher penalties for acts considered to be bullying. that’s because the stakes have never been so high

College Athletes: Why They Should be Paid

1615 words - 6 pages satisfaction of winning. So, should Division One college athletes be paid? Division One athletes should be paid because they generate a significant amount of revenue for the school. For basketball players at the University of Kentucky, their day starts earlier than most other students and ends later than most as well. They wake up early in the morning and have a morning practice and lifting session. After that they go to their classes and study

Women's suffrage in Australia. A speech: why should suffragettes be given the power to vote?

793 words - 3 pages Welcome everyone to this meeting of The Women's Suffrage League to discuss the reasons on why it is essential that women be given the power to vote.Firstly, ask yourselves: Are women citizens?Does the law concern them?Do women benefit from being represented by men?And do you believe that women are inferior to men?Yes, women are citizens. But only when they are required to pay taxes. Not if they ask to vote.And yes, the law does concern women

Should digital property be given the same protections as physical property?

1232 words - 5 pages world in the intrinsic fashion. Software like art is muddled in the realm of music and movies where performance has been somewhat overshadowed by the technological advancements of its craft. Music and Movies are not tangible however law makers thing they should be but they aren't exactly art either so they should be treated as a mix. Being such we must treat their entity in the same mixed fashion by supporting only those that not just peak our

Similar Essays

Why African Americans Should Not Be Given Any Reparations For Slavery

2253 words - 9 pages benefited blacks (if that were true then one could also come to the twisted logic that the Jews benefited form the Nazi concentration camps), he also said that welfare is repayment for slavery (suggesting that it exclusively benefits blacks), and that blacks themselves were slave owners (which they may have been, but that doesn't exonerate the sin or harm of slavery. I am telling you this because I don't want you to be against slave reparations

Should Condoms Be Given In Schools

783 words - 3 pages condoms is important also. Condoms are used to prevent serious medical conditions. It only makes sense that medical staff should be involved in giving the product to student. This can also ensure that if there are any questions regarding the product, they are addressed properly. Students who deal with medical personal may also feel that their privacy is also maintained. To further ensure privacy condoms should given in a non see through bag

Should Children's Testimony Be Given More Trust?

2308 words - 10 pages answer as well as they should and can. Quoting Warner (2008), “Children, even very young ones, can give reliable evidence if questions are tailored to their cognitive development”. Despite the fact that young children may lack the complete cognitive development to be able to understand the nature of truth and lie, they do have the ability to tell the truth and understand instructions in simple words by their language standard (Peterson, 2007

Should Public School Students Be Given Birth Control Pills?

717 words - 3 pages The question regarding whether or not public schools must offer birth control methods to teenagers remains controversial. There are those who are for birth control being provided in public school and those who are against it. This paper will describe two issues that prove that contraception should indeed be provided within public schools. The first reason is that most Americans support the idea that public schools must provide birth control