This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Review Of Army Of Shadows

1267 words - 5 pages

In Army of Shadows (2008), Hillel Cohen reexamines the typical historical narratives about Palestinian perspectives prior to the Nakba. Much of the discussion pertains to the changes that took place within the mindsets of numerous groups of Palestinians during the British Mandate. It could be beneficial to compare the approach and methodologies of Hillel Cohen's book to Ilan Pappe's The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine (2006) and his reassessment of Israel's historical memory. Pappe focuses on the planning and actions that were taken to ensure an ethnically cleansed Israel and places this in direct contrast with current perspectives of historical rhetoric. Both authors draw from a variety of sources in order to adequately examine the realities of Palestinian societies that often retract previously accepted historical memories.
Cohen analyzes what he terms “Palestinian collaboration” and how collaborators were seen from the nationalist leadership to be “traitors.” This has been less considered by historians from both Palestinian and Israeli narratives. Much of Cohen's discussion begins with the rise of nationalism in the early 1920s among Palestinian elites and how this movement was interpreted differently by different groups and ignored altogether by others. In the early days of Palestinian nationalism, Hajj Amin al-Husseini made “efficient use of his power to brand people as traitors in his struggle for leadership” (51). His attempts to Islamicize nationalist movements led to stigmatization of opposing groups. This can be seen in his vying for mufti of Jerusalem and for the head of the Supreme Muslim Council. Early on he was charging his opponents with collaborating with Jews and Zionists. During his campaigns against the Nashashibis, he was already accusing them of being “traitors.”
Throughout the 1920s, the nationalist rhetoric against collaborators and traitors took hold among all aspects of society, especially in Jerusalem. One of the more important aspects of nationalism in the 1920s was how Arabic newspapers were used to “define” notions of treason. Cohen assesses how one is determined to be a traitor, whether through absentee land sales or contributions to Zionist intelligence organizations, and how this leads to violent repression of all varieties of treason. It is interesting to note that although nationalism was becoming “rooted” within Palestinian society, the notion of treason was not wholly accepted. Widespread concepts of nationalism did not become “the principal component in the basket of identities of each individual and the one for which he is willing to kill and be killed” but instead, in the 1920s, setup the mechanisms that helped to achieve this goal: establishment of nationalist “norms,” coercion, and reward. “The press, the religious system..., and the educational system served as central tools” to setup the negative and positive influences into the norms of nationalism. This in turn led to the concepts of who is a...

Find Another Essay On Review of Army of Shadows

Stepping out of the Shadows Essay

1689 words - 7 pages Angeles Review of Books magazine Grande talked about her motivation behind the book, explaining that one of her goals was to reveal more about the life of immigrants and how complicated a situation it is for these families to be in, how many struggles they endure and sacrifices they make in their journey toward what they hope will be a better life. Mary Pipher believes that writers can move and affect their readers most effectively by writing about

Criminal Shadows: Inside the Mind of a Serial Killer. A book by David Canter. Book Review

1022 words - 4 pages David Canter, professor of Psychology at Liverpool University, has written more that a dozen books on psychology, and his biography states he " the pioneer and leading expert in psychological profiling......" Criminal Shadows: Inside the Mind of the Serial Killer (1994) is a factual book, based on his own experiences, on the evolution and development of profiling and is set out chronologically. He explains that he believes a criminal

Rhetorical Analysis of Game of Shadows

759 words - 4 pages Referred to by many as an American past time, the game of baseball has evolved from just a game that was once played by soldiers in between tours overseas to a nationally televised sport that attracts billions of viewers a year. Created in 1860 by a New York man named Alexander Cartwright, “town ball”, or as we call it baseball, was first played in a local park on the outskirts of Hoboken, New Jersey. In his book, Game of shadows, Mark Fainaru

The Army of Potomac

1247 words - 5 pages “Wake up men!” My eyes slowly opened and then reality dawned on me as a cold lump in my stomach. We knew this morning was the moment that we had been preparing for, when the Union engineers finished our pontoon pathway so we could cross the bridge to Fredericksburg- and then travel to the capital of the South, Richmond. In my heart, I knew that something was going to fail- but as a private of the Union Army of Potomac, I was to hold steadfast

Reality of the Shadows: The Allegory of the Cave

1157 words - 5 pages be an attribute of grade-three thinkers. Similarly, in the ‘Allegory of the Cave’, Plato narrates that once a prisoner had been freed, he understands the reality behind the shadows. In this context, it is crucial to understand Goulding`s attribution of grades to the people. His obsession with ‘thinking’ led him to the conclusion that he himself cannot think at all. It was back in school when he observed the statuettes of his headmaster who had

From Out of the Shadows: Americanization of Mexican American Women

1486 words - 6 pages , deportation or Americanizing immigrants from Mexico. Women and their children were especially involved in some of the American groups trying to assimilate large numbers of the Mexican community. The history of Mexican American Women in the Southwest and Midwest is mentioned in detail in Vicki L. Ruiz's book From Out of the Shadows and also covers historical background of the author's relatives. Much of the Americanization of American Mexican women

Overview: The Way of Shadows by Brent Weeks

2590 words - 10 pages French Review Apr. 1959: 428-34. Rpt. in Drama Criticism. Ed. Jelena O. Krstovic. Vol. 27. Detroit: Gale, 2006. Literature Resource Center. Web. 26 Nov. 2013. . Weeks, Brent. The Way of Shadows. New York: Orbit, 2008. Print. Wynchank, Anny. "Perception of the Relationship France--Africa by Andre Gide and Camara Laye." Tydskrif Vir Letterkunde 46.1 (2009): 179. Literature Resource Center. Web. 26 Nov. 2013. .

Army: A Profession of Arms

931 words - 4 pages statement by taking an oath, where he swears loyalty to the Slovak Republic, honesty, bravery and disciplined behavior, that he will follow Constitution, Constitution Laws, Laws and Army Regulations and he is ready to defend freedom, independence, sovereignty and territorial integrity of the Slovak Republic. He is ready to sacrifice his own life. Professional soldiers differ from the ordinary citizen particularly in psychological and personal

An Army of One: Me.

1911 words - 8 pages Feeling good about oneself is an inherently good thing; however when this is intensified so severely that it becomes the focus of everyday life, complications and consequences may occur. Jean Twenge tries to warn today’s “Generation Me” about the dangers of their obsession with the self in her piece, “An Army of One: Me.” This desire to look out for only the individual has dramatic effects on the direction of today’s society. What has also

Plato's Use of Metaphor of Shadows in His Allegory of the Cave

759 words - 3 pages Plato's Use of Metaphor of Shadows in His Allegory of the Cave Plato uses his Allegory of the Cave to explain to people the awareness of his realm of forms. Plato uses the prisoners in the cave to symbolise the people without the knowledge of the Theory of Forms. Such prisoners would mistake appearance for reality. They would think the things they see on the wall (the shadows) were real; they would know nothing of

Dorian Gray And The Lady Of Shallot: Stepping Out Of The Shadows

1132 words - 5 pages consumed by the theatre. She confesses: …Before I knew you, acting was the one reality of my life. It was only in the theatre that I lived…. I believed in everything. The common people who acted with me seemed to me to be godlike. The painted scenes were my world. I knew nothing but shadows, and I thought them real…. Prince Charming! I have grown sick of shadows (66).” Sibyl repeatedly hides away from having to be a part of life because she has been

Similar Essays

The Shadows Of Reality Essay

1388 words - 6 pages The Shadows of Reality We are like the people in Plato’s “Allegory of the Cave.” The people chained to the cave were forced to look at projections and shadows that were cast upon the wall. Because the shadows were the only thing they had seen, they perceived them to be the “truth”. Today our “shadows” have become the media, death, and pain which influence what we believe to be “truth.” The media, death, and pain are fairly common in today’s

Prince Of Shadows Essay

1830 words - 8 pages Prince of Shadows by Rachel Caine is a retelling of Romeo and Juliet from Benvolio Montague’s point of view. I chose this book, because I was intrigued by how the author would recount the well-known love tragedy. Also, I enjoy reading about romance and retelling of famous tales. Therefore, I chose the Prince of Shadows to read. Instead of telling the story of Romeo and Juliet from a third-person or Romeo’s point of view

Reality Of The Shadows Essay

1113 words - 5 pages thinkers. Similarly, in the ‘Allegory of the Cave’, Plato narrates that once a prisoner had been freed, he understands the reality behind the shadows. In this context, it is crucial to understand Goulding`s attribution of grades to the people. His obsession with ‘thinking’ led him to the conclusion that he himself cannot think at all. It was back in school when he observed the statuettes of his headmaster who had asked him, “Don`t you ever

Shadows Of A Family Essay

830 words - 3 pages Shadows of a Family Japanese culture is one that is steeped in tradition. The Japanese only need to go back to their cultural roots to understand the importance of the family. However, with the country becoming more Westernized, its younger generation seems more independent-minded regarding traditional practices. As the children begin to follow the Western way of life, it brings tension to the older generation. The Kazuo Ishiguro's story, "A