Representation Of Cloning In The Media

1523 words - 6 pages

Representation of Cloning in the Media

 
   Since the birth of Dolly, the cloned sheep, the debate over human cloning has been characterized in the media as an ethical debate. When scientists announced that they had cloned an adult sheep, the public also heard that cloning humans was possible. The media stories about this unprecedented feat was not about the procedures utilized in but rather about the morality of the process itself. Media coverage focused on ethical concerns of cloning, its social, religious and physiological significance, and the motivation behind it. Although the there are many views expressed in the media on cloning, the main characterization of cloning as an ethical issue centers around two connected worries: the loss of individuality, and the seemingly evil motivations behind cloning. In a sense media coverage framed the public moral debate on cloning around the above issues.

 

In the coverage of cloning, the media has chosen to represent cloning as a danger to individuality and uniqueness. This concern about losing individuality stems from the status of clones as copies. The March 10, 1997 cover of Time Magazine shows two large identical pictures of sheep and in the background numerous copies of the same picture and the cover title asks, "Will There be Another of You ?". The picture accompanying the main article shows a coin operated machine dispensing white males, while another picture shows identical bodies dropping out of a test tube. Similar images expressing this concern over the loss of individuality brought on by cloning dominate the popular media.

 

This representation of cloning as a means of bringing about the loss of individuality reflects two widespread ideas. The first is the idea that copies cannot measure upto originals. Time reports, " Dolly does not merely take after her biological mother. She is a carbon copy, a laboratory counterfeit so exact that she is in essence her mother's identical twin" (67). The use of the word counterfeit conveys a message that clones are illegal and at the same time are inferior to the originals. U.S News & World Report informs us that many ethicists believe that the interest in cloning will die away, because "making copies pales next to the wonder of creating unique human beings the old fashioned way" (61). The implication of both articles is that clones are not as good as the originals.

Moreover, the existence of clones is interpreted as an affront to human dignity. Time magazine, for example, uses militaristic language to show that cloning is in some way a declared war on our very humanness; "for many, the basic sanctity of life seemed to be under attack" ( Nov 3, 67). In the same issue, Time quotes a scientist who claims, "we have a right to our own individual genetic identity...cloning could well violate that right." By making such claims, the media assumes that a fixed quantity of human dignity is allocated to each genetically distinct...

Find Another Essay On Representation of Cloning in the Media

representation of women in the media

862 words - 3 pages Media essay – Representation of females The representation of females in the media today is very complex. In some media texts such as the “asda Christmas advert” the dominant ideology of women being happily married and domesticated is reinforced. , whereas in other media texts such as “Miranda” the dominant ideology of women is challenged as they are trying to break the stereotypes people have of women “Miranda” is a TV programme created by the

The Representation of The Media Essay

1891 words - 8 pages representation of truth though these texts, we have seen to expose the need behind the truth. To an audience and the truth in general has been seen to have many consequences. These results in representations both near, far and not the truth at all and always rely on the specific type of need concerning the media. So we can conclude that there are only representations of truth determined by media needs and hence no true truth.

Trans* Representation in Media

2391 words - 10 pages either addressed poorly and distastefully or that doesn’t fully capture the experience of those people who feel like they don’t fall on either end of the gender binary spectrum. Discussion Negative Representation One of the worst problems with contemporary visual media when in regards to trans* representation is that unless one actively seeks out the knowledge about the complexities of their struggles, then most of the representation is fairly

media representation of crime

936 words - 4 pages One of the most researched issues in the social sciences is whether media representations of violence have damaging effects upon audiences. Three main sociological approaches to media and crime have emerged but no one approach has been conclusive (Carribaine et al, 2009, pg. 408). The first approach is called the ‘ill – effect’ or sometimes referred to as the hypodermic syringe model. This approach main focuses on young and working class

Politics of Representation- the media representation of the Sydney Olympic Games

1486 words - 6 pages international media organisations emphasised the banner in their broadcasts of the event. The humorous inclusion of a lawnmower ballet, was a representation of Australian suburbia - its green backyards and traditional barbecues. The representation would not be the same if it were not a 'ballet' in contrast with lawnmowers. Such nonsense was what really captured audiences and presented a positive view of Australia internationally.The 'awakening' theme

The Media Watchers & Women's Representation of the Body

1991 words - 8 pages referred to women, rather then men. The media has helped to mold how we visualize words. Messages from the media help to define what is normal, acceptable and ideal, but do not help teach and distinguish between imagination and reality. Image and representation of women in the media has long been a subject of concern. In today's society woman are perceived as stereotypical models, which consequently have a negative affect on young girls who emulate

The Representation of Masculinity in Print Advertising

2038 words - 8 pages . p57). Gauntlett sees the new balanced gender representation that is in the media and puts this down to one of two things- 'that advertisers nowadays take their social role relatively seriously, or, to be more precise, have learned that it is not good business to offend any of their customers with sexist stereotypes' (ibid. p75).Gauntlett also refers to the gender balancing that has occurred in the media by citing the work of Cortese (1999) which

Representation of the Future in Various Films

1027 words - 4 pages Representation of the Future in Various Films One of the most important factors or conventions of science fiction films is that it is always set in a dystopian future, which means the worst possible future. In the films there is lots of technology and gadgets, the film look technological because of the grey/silver filters which

The Representation of Family in Slave Narratives

673 words - 3 pages In this essay I intend to delve into the representation of family in the slave narrative, focusing on Frederick Douglas’ ‘Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave’ and Harriet Jacobs ‘Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl.’ Slave narratives are biographical and autobiographical stories of freedom either written or told by former slaves. The majority of them were ‘told to’ accounts written with the aid of abolitionist

Iago; The Representation of Villainy in "Othello"

1134 words - 5 pages A villain is defined as an evil character in a novel, movie, play, or other story, especially one who is the main enemy of the hero according to Encarta Dictionary. In "Othello," Iago fits this definition perfectly though Othello does not recognize that Iago is his enemy until the end of the story. Iago is the evil-minded, backstabbing character in this dramatic story. He demonstrates this villainy act all through out the story beginning

The Role of DNA in Cloning

833 words - 3 pages genetically identical to the unit or individual from which it was derived.” I always thought that cloning was impossible, and is just science fiction. The process of cloning is the creation of genetically identical copies of a biological unit. This means that every single part of the DNA is identical. The natural way of a clone is identical twins. In nature, twins occur just after fertilization of an egg cell by a sperm cell. Then when the

Similar Essays

The Representation Of Females In The Media

3972 words - 16 pages The Representation of Females in the Media It is generally accepted that the media, primarily television, 'lags' behind reality and current social trends (Butler and Paisley, 1980) (Gunter, Television and Sex Role Stereotyping). However, This does not make the way women are portrayed in the media any better. Women are not only under-represented in the media but more importantly are portrayed to be "half clad, half

The Representation Of Teenagers In The Media

1661 words - 7 pages The Representation of Teenagers in the Media Throughout the media we see representation of teenagers. This can show teenagers in positive and negative lights. Teenagers are found in magazines, advertising, television and films, and they are targeted by newspapers and magazines etc. There are two different newspapers reports from the ‘Daily Mail’ and the ‘Dorset Echo’ that are part of this representation

The Representation Of Bogans In The Media

1806 words - 8 pages , and alcohol consumption and/or drug use.iThis report will attempt to examine the portrayal of the bogan subgroup in the media, using three texts. These texts are; 'Perhaps there's a little bogan in everyone'ii, a newspaper article in the Sydney Morning Herald, Trent From Punchyiii, an excerpt from an unfinished documentary, and the Last Train To Freoiv, a film. The three texts will be hitherto referred to as 'Perhaps', 'Trent', and 'Freo

The Representation Of Homosexuals In The Media

2117 words - 8 pages Representation of homosexuals in the mediaFor this essay I have chose the theme of the representation of homosexuality in the media. I have chosen this subject because I find it very interesting and there are many different examples of how this happens in the media.Will and Grace is an American television sitcom about a heterosexual woman who lives with a homosexual guy. They also have a friend called Jack ho is also gay. Jack is very extravert