Representation Of Native Americans By Columbus And Williams American Literature Essay

2118 words - 9 pages

In this essay, I will discuss how the indigenous population of the “New World” is represented in the early writings of the European encounter, exploration and colonisation of the Americas. However, I will not only elaborate on people in general, but also how the landscape shapes these representations and the differences between the colonisers and writers of the two texts that I have chosen. Regarding this, the first text to support and explain my arguments is the Letter of Discovery from Christopher Columbus, and the second one is A Key into the Language of America by Roger Williams.
Concerning Christopher Columbus writings, the first impression that we have of Native Americans is that they are like another different and underdeveloped human race, that from the very beginning is automatically considered as inferior. Upon his arrival in Isla Juana, Columbus firstly observes how these indigenous people run away quickly in order to avoid him. “There were only small hamlets, with the people of which I could not have speech because they all fled immediately” (59). It is said that Native Americans were not sure whether Columbus and the rest of his men came from heaven or hell, so it is understandable that they were scared. In the Letter of Discovery, Columbus reports that these people go naked, except for some women who wore a leaf or a net of cotton to cover their intimate body parts. Reiteratively, he continues stressing how timorous they are stating “As soon as they have seen my men approaching they have fled, even a father not waiting for his son. And this, not because ill has done to anyone; on the contrary, at every point where I have been able to have speech, I have given to them of all that I had, such as cloth and many other things, without receiving anything for it; but so, they are incurably timid” (60) which I consider ironic taking into consideration the way he treated them. We can previously see his behaviour when Columbus writes “I understood sufficiently from other Indians, whom I had already taken, …” (59) taken meaning as making them slaves, which I personally see as a very logic reason to fear Spaniards. We find another example when he says, “I took by force some of them, in order that they might learn and give me information” (61). In addition, without receiving anything for it is also very ironic since he has literally taken over their land and natural resources. Besides that, continuing with the description of Native Americans, they do not have iron or steel, therefore their weapons are made of canes with a small sharpened stick at the end of it, but they would not use it because they are extremely timorous, so they flee instead.
When Columbus has more contact with them the description changes. Now they are portrayed as guileless and generous: they share everything they possess and display so much love. They are also intelligent but then they are described as savages when they are taking the things Columbus...

Find Another Essay On Representation of Native Americans by Columbus and Williams - American Literature - Essay

Mystery of Native American Origin This essay deals with sifferent migration theory's of Native Americans

770 words - 3 pages . One Migration theory is A Pacific Crossing Theory, which maintains that Aboriginal Australians and South Pacific Islander peoples traveled across the Pacific Ocean in boats to the west coast of South America. This theory was supported by a campsite found in Monte Verde, Chile that dated back 14,700 years. The campsite suggests humans were present in South America thousands of years before Native Americans were believed to have crossed the Bering

A Large Flaw in Human Nature (Essay comparing/contrasting treatment of Native Americans and African Americans by the white people)

804 words - 3 pages one person disagreed, would that person stand up against their government, friends, or family? Most likely not. Two of the most gruesome, horrifying examples of this human flaw of being easily persuaded seem to fit hand in hand: United States enslavement of Africans and future African Americans, and the Holocaust. Though these two events are not the same, they have many distinct shared characteristics. Both began the same way. Someone came up with

Cruel and Inhuman Treatment of Native Americans by the Colonists

1745 words - 7 pages The process of assimilation, as it regards to the Native Americans, into European American society took a dreaded and long nearly 300 years. Initially, when the European’s came to the hopeful and promising land of the “New World”, they had no desire or reason anything but minimal contact with the Indians. However, starting in the 1700s the European colonists population skyrocketed. The need for more resources became evident and the colonists

Treatment of Native Americans by Europeans

3588 words - 14 pages Native Americans have faced increasing encroachment by European and Euro-American settlers since the discovery of the Americas by Europeans in 1492. Beginning with the Caribs, mistakenly labeled as Indians by Christopher Columbus, continuing with the ‘Indian Wars’ waged by the U.S. government against such tribes as the Lakota and Apache, and lasting until today, native peoples have had to adjust and adapt constantly to survive. Native peoples

Native American Literature

1101 words - 5 pages had some descript on the historical context of the issue with Cherokee nation and the Navajo nation. The main argument was showed in the introduction and it was supported by evidences in the essay. Throughout the essay, we explained the history of the two nation’s tribes by giving some examples to help out the readers to fully understand the issue what going on the Native American Literature.

Native American Literature

1220 words - 5 pages The normal life of Native Americans in early America was pretty low key. They were the only people in Northern America until the end of the 15th century. Soon after, in the 16th and 17th centuries, many people from Europe traveled to America. This caused many problems for the American Indians. The European diseases and weapons caused many deaths among the Native Americans. They were abused by the newcomers who stole their land and treated them

Native American Literature

1801 words - 7 pages "(32). The relationships that Native Americans had were special, sacred, and very meaningful"”it is a shame that it is sometimes not like that today.         The value Native Americans put on nature, their high grasp on spirituality, and their appreciation of affairs is highly significant and relevant in Native American literature. So after a few weeks, you go hunting out into the forest again. You see that prized elk, and you strike it

Southeastern Native American Literature

1246 words - 5 pages contemporary Native Americans. Much of the literature written by Native Americans from the Southeastern U.S. draws from traditional tribal myths. Many of these myths have been transcribed and translated into English by various ethnographers and folklorists, and, in the case of the Cherokee, myths have been collected and published in acclaimed books. Anthropologist James Mooney, an employee of the federal government at the end of the

Native American Literature

726 words - 3 pages Spending this semester reading Native American Literature, really brought me to make comparisons to my past experience. I think in each story, there was always something significant that seemed similar to my life. There were stories that had similar connections, and as I read them, I put my mind to connect what the author was saying and to what I remember from my life and make a connection. Actually, I thought every story was good and well to

Historical trauma found in 'Tracks' and 'Bad Indians.' - Native American Literature - Essay

2062 words - 9 pages Erdrich and Bad Indians by Deborah A. Miranda. This novel and this memoir are great works of literature upon which an individual can garner a better understanding of how historical trauma affects Native Americans- both fictional and nonfictional. Tracks deals with the devastation of the Anishinabe (also known as Chippewa or Objiway) people between the winter of 1912 and the spring of 1924 in Matchimanito, North Dakota. The novel focuses on the life of

This Essay Reviews The Diffren Types Of Tricksters In Early Native American Literature

857 words - 4 pages tales are passed from generation to generation through the oral tradition. Now many of these ancient tales have been adapted and retold in print so they can be enjoyed by both children and adults. In Native American oral traditions the Trickster assumes many forms. He can be a Raven, Mink, or Blue jay, or, more generically just, The Tricky One. Though the trickster's form may very from legend to legend his role in Native Americans cultural

Similar Essays

The Negative Portrayal Of Native Americans In Children’s Literature

2096 words - 8 pages The Negative Portrayal of Native Americans in Children’s Literature The American institution has raised countless generations with misconceptions and lies regarding various foreign cultures. During the 1950’s the educational system in America was given the responsibility of teaching children the horrors and injustices they would suffer if the "evil" communist took over the world. Schools taught students that communist wanted to take away

Possible Parallels Between Africans And Native Americans As Explained In Ivan Van Sertima's They Came Before Columbus

894 words - 4 pages influenced by African travelers. He thoroughly examined possible cultural parallels between Africans and Native Americans; the first-hand accounts of the European explorers; and the intercontinental transportation of goods. Van Sertima argued that contact between the Nubians and Olmecs in 700 B.C.E. and followed by other contacts from Mali in 1300 C.E., altered indigenous art and architecture while proposing that explorers like Columbus and

The Pursuit Of The American Dream By African Americans, Native Americans, And The Working Class

1672 words - 7 pages buffalo from a moving train also helped to speed up the near wipe out of the species. What appears to have helped Native Americans reach the “American Dream” discussed earlier was their assimilation into American society. The best words used to describe the purpose of assimilation were those uttered by the founder of one of the first assimilation schools in the country: “Kill the Indian in him, and save the man,” (Pratt). Around 20,000 Native

American Treatment Of Native Americans Essay

2049 words - 8 pages American attitude was conform or be killed. The hunger for land and sheer dominance nearly wiped out an entire nation of Indian tribes. Indians are still around today, however, there are only a few tribes left who still live in inhabitable places, such as deserts in New Mexico and Oklahoma. Over time, many historians have documented how poorly the Indians were treated by Americans and the U.S. government. The Indian Nations have been given more