Republican Unfairness (Problems With The Electoral College).

756 words - 3 pages

George PuicaModel CongressRepublican Unfairness"The Electors shall meet in their respective States and vote by ballot for President and Vice-President" (Amendment XII: to Article II, Section 3 of U.S. Constitution). These words would differentiate the United States from all other countries in the world. The Electoral College consists of a group of people called Electors, which submit votes for one candidate in each state. All of this is because the United States is a republic. Maine and Nebraska are, however, different. They work under a democratic system, rather than the republican system most states use. (national - Electoral College ©2000). In order to better serve our democracy, the Electoral College should be amended so that their votes are rationally divided, in each state, among the candidates running for President.Critics argue that an amendment to the Electoral College would be impossible to enact: members of Congress have proposed it several times before (Facts on File: Issues and Controversies - The Electoral College - A History of Electoral Chaos ©2000). The Electoral College should not be removed - it should be made more fair by changing it from a winner-take-all system, in which the majority winner from each state wins all of that state's electoral votes, to a more democratic system in which the votes in a state are divided among the candidates. Otherwise, the system will stay, for the most part, republican (national - Electoral College ©2000). It is unfair, as the loser of the popular vote can win the election. If there are only two candidates and one gets forty-nine percent of the popular vote in a state, he or she loses the election in that state (Schnider, "Florida Saved the Electoral College," National Journal Issue #6, Vol. #33, 2001)The Electoral College has created major problems in close elections. In 1824, John Quincy Adams won over Thomas Jefferson; in 1876, Rutherford B. Hayes won over Samuel J. Tilden; in 1888, Benjamin Harrison won over Grover Cleveland; finally, one hundred-twelve years later, the current President won over former Vice-President Al Gore, also unfairly. The "losing" candidate in each of the above elections won the popular vote but lost because of the Electoral College. (Howstuffworks "How the Electoral College Works"...

Find Another Essay On Republican Unfairness (problems with the Electoral College).

The Electoral College Essay

2395 words - 10 pages rural areas were overwhelmingly for the Republican candidate George W. Bush. As a result Gore won a small number of states with more votes while Bush won more states but with fewer votes. The majority had spoken but because of the Electoral College the United States turned a deaf ear and anointed Bush the winner. The majority of Americans voted for Gore but the Electoral College just as it was designed to do over ruled the majority and gave the

The Electoral College Essay

1192 words - 5 pages Electoral College system was devised to help cope with these problems. The Constitution was written and ratified in 1787 more than two hundred years ago. At the time of drafting the drafters of the Constitution never imagined there would be a two political parties that dominate our system of government or a national media that can readily bring each candidate before every citizen of this vast country. These were the problems of the time that faced

The Electoral College.

946 words - 4 pages undemocratic. In such acase each state has a single vote, which gives states with small populations such as Alaska equal weight with more populousstates like Texas and Florida. Also, one vote per state in the House of Representatives may not necessarily result in a choice thatreplicates the electoral vote winner in that state in November.There are however many strengths of the Electoral College system which serve American democracy well. The main

The Electoral College

2080 words - 8 pages The Electoral College The framer's intent of setting up the American government will never be known for sure, but it is gathered that they preferred a republic to a democracy. In the constitutional convention the drafters had to decide how much power they would entrust with the people of the United States, and how much should be controlled by representatives. They chose to have Congress make the laws, and congress would be selected

The Electoral College - 733 words

733 words - 3 pages president because the problems presented by the opposition are greatly exaggerated, and the electoral college diminishes such problems of opposing systems. Today the electoral college has become an unpopular system due to reasons greatly exaggerated by its critics. One such problem is that the "winner can lose," meaning that the winner of the popular election can still gain enough electoral votes to win the presidency. However, this has only

The Electoral College - 834 words

834 words - 3 pages state. With the Electoral College, the party that receives the most votes within the state takes all the electoral votes. This is a winner takes all system. One party could receive one more popular vote than another party and they still receive all the electoral votes. There are a total of 538 electoral votes. A representative only needs 270 votes to win the presidency (Hancock. "Distribution of Electoral Votes"). Is this winner take all process

The Electoral College - 513 words

513 words - 2 pages president through a College of Electors. The role of the College of Electors can be traced to the way that the Roman Catholic Church elects their Pope with the College of Cardinals.The structure of the Electoral College can be tracked back to the Centurial Assembly system of the Roman Republic. Under this system, the adult males were divided, according to wealth, into a group of 100 people called Centuries. Each group of Centuries was allowed to

the origin of electoral college

825 words - 3 pages      In the United States of America, the presidential election takes place every four years, on the first Tuesday of November [1]. Most people believe they are directly voting for the presidential candidate, and the person with the most popular votes will win the election. However, instead of voting for the presidential candidate, people are voting for the electors, individuals who vote in the Electoral College

Abolishment of the Electoral College

795 words - 4 pages abolished because the people who disagree with majority are not represented and the system is too complex and takes a very long time. With the Electoral College system, the people who do not agree with majority has no say in the electoral system of their state. If you vote for a Republican candidate but majority of your state votes for the Democratic candidate, then your candidate does not get any of your state’s electoral votes, they go to the other

History of the Electoral College

987 words - 4 pages a procedure to elect the president by the people, at least indirectly. The framers came up with this procedure for many reasons. Such reasons included the lack of information to make a good choice by the people and it was also a way to control the power of the people. Although the Electoral College is still used today, it has undergone several changes and still contains certain weaknesses. When the Constitutional Convention chose a method

The Flawed Electoral College System

1041 words - 4 pages they can come up with a way that will allow the smaller states to not lose the power they currently hold, I do not believe we will have change in this area. Works Cited The Electoral College, August 9th, 2011, Options for Electoral College Reform, August 9th,2011 Magleby, B. D., Light, C. P., Government by the People, 2009 Brief Edition

Similar Essays

Unfairness In The Electoral College Essay

756 words - 3 pages side. Furthermore, margin between electoral votes was less than one percent, but still Harrison became president despite of 100,000 popular votes difference! Election of 2000 came up with same scenario. Gore won people’s support but lost electors’; therefore he had to accept G.W.Bush as President. After all this, what we can believe is indeed, the Electoral College is such an unreliable representative of the popular will that in a close election

The Electoral College Essay 1010 Words

1010 words - 4 pages state wins all the pledged votes of the state's electors (Wikipedia The Free Encyclopedia n.d.).Furthermore, a candidate is required to receive two hundred and seventy votes out of the five hundred and thirty eight to be elected. Since Electoral College representation is based on congressional representation, states with larger populations get more Electoral College votes (Department of State n.d.). There are 48 States that have a winner-takes-all

Elimintating The Electoral College Essay

1661 words - 7 pages popular votes to Nixon's 34,107,646. In the final sprint of the marathon 2000 presidential campaign, Democratic nominee Al Gore and Republican nominee George W. Bush are neck and neck. Particularly in a contest close as this one, the Electoral College warps national politics and could lead to a major constitutional crisis. So, with a race this tight, it is entirely conceivable that one candidate may win the popular vote and still lose the

The Electoral College Essay 2474 Words

2474 words - 10 pages ? It is obvious to see that the people's vote is not counted because if it was then all it would take to elect a president would be a popular vote. As I see it there are many problems in the current electoral college system. First a president can be elected even if it is not what the people want. For instance the current elections (2000) can precisely prove my point. Democrat Al Gore won the popular vote with a slim difference of Republican