Republicanism And Direct Democracy Essay

1245 words - 5 pages

Republicanism and direct democracy, these are two ways that a people can be governed. There is a major difference between these two systems. In a republican system the government represents the people. The representatives are chosen by popular vote and are given the power to make decisions on behalf of the people. The people do not get to voice their own opinions, the best they can do is vote for their representative and hope he wins. This can also be referred to as indirect democracy. Direct democracy which was exemplified in the ancient Athenian city-state, or the New England town meeting in modern times, is a government based solely on the people. The governmental decisions are passed only if the majority of the people vote for it. "People", that is the key word, the people themselves are included in making political decisions.

Race: the descendants of a common ancestor; distinct variety of human beings; lineage. These are the definitions the dictionary gives for race. However, what really is race? And what causes human beings to dislike a specific race? There are many who disagree as to what the answers to these questions are. I would like to discuss two specific writers that argue about this issue, W.E.B. Du Bois and Manning Marable.

According to Du Bois there are two aspects that differentiates one race from another. Firstly, all humans differ in regard to their physical attributes (hair color, skin color), plus language also differs widely among humans. These differences, says Du Bois, plays a great part in diminishing one's ability to better himself in society; " Any striving, no matter how intense and earnest, which is against the constitution of the world is in vain." The constitution of the world is that if you are different, physically, then your chances in making it are slim to none. The second factor that differentiates races and binds certain groups together are different histories, laws and religions, habits of thought, and striving for certain ideals of life. This factor really stems from the first difference, its just going a little deeper into discovering the answers to the two questions. To sum it all up, in the words of Du Bois, "The whole process which has brought about these race differences has been a growth... the differentiation of spiritual and mental differences between great races of mankind and the integration of physical differences."

Manning Marable raises an interesting point, in the world today, blacks have become more actively involved in politics, education, and are financially better off. However, in direct proportion to this, harassment and violence towards the blacks have increased tremendously. "Despite their gains, many blacks felt that the goal of racial harmony, and integration into the American mainstream was more distant than ever before", as Marable puts it. The reason behind the problems that are affecting the blacks is "race." This means according to Marable that,...

Find Another Essay On Republicanism and Direct Democracy

More than a Radical Revolution Essay

906 words - 4 pages private interests to better their community. To truly appreciate the struggles of the Founders, we must note that these individuals were leaders in their class, not large groups of people, whose sole duty was to provide authority and governance to society. These struggles were well worthwhile as we ourselves witness how the rooted principles of republicanism and democracy effect the character of America today. The almost unreal visions of The

Being American: Liberty, Equality and Republicanism

1004 words - 4 pages continues to be a republican nation, not a democracy. I say this because since 1892, The Pledge of Allegiance, states “to a republic for which it stands.” Therefore, being American today means accepting the abstract ideas of liberty, equality, and republicanism. Works Cited Badarik, Michael. "What is the difference between a Democracy and a Republic?." N.p., n.d. Web. 6 Apr 2011. . Bellamy

Absolulely Absolutism - Analysis of Political Structure in Shakespeare's Coriolanus.

1648 words - 7 pages , north, south, and their consent of one direct way should be at once to all the points o' th' compass." (II, iii, l. 18-25)Shakespeare allows one of the citizens to make a legitimate argument that there will be different point of views even if everyone was made as a whole (as republicanism suggests). Coriolanus, an absolutist, is given an important speech the audience first encounters his character."What would you have, you curs, that like not peace

Our Founding Fathers Affect on the Past, Present, and Future

1550 words - 6 pages In the beginning, the nation’s Founders were profoundly skeptical of direct democracy. They believed that the “follies” of direct democracy far outweighed any virtues it might possess (Politics in American pg. 76). According to an essay by Rose Wilder Lane (Lane, 1943), “George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, John Adams, James Madison, and James Monroe feared democracy.” The founders believed that the Constitution left all

The American Revolution, an unified movement of colonial forces fighting against the imperial British

2763 words - 11 pages forms of republicanism emerged in the early 18th century when after the collapse of Catholicism, English philosophers began to reflect upon the first of the great republics in Rome and Greece. This evaluation of the history of these two empires created and propelled republicanism into a revolutionary context. For the first time in modern history, the ideas of the old republics were being studied, evaluated and even practiced. The foundations of

The New Science of Politics

1039 words - 4 pages all who entered the political arena would have a shot at presenting ideas that would become a representation of the national self interest. The framers sought this extended commercial republicanism within the union and the Federalists continued to strongly support a Constitution of this design that created factions of ideas that would protect the nation from the spector of excessive democracy, as well as abuse of power. Madison felt that

Direct democracy -vs- representitive democracy. Contains the ideas of Rousseau

942 words - 4 pages The term Democracy is derived from two Greek words, demos, meaning people, and kratos, meaning rule. These two words form the word democracy which means rule by the people. Aristotle, and other ancient Greek political philosophers, used the phrase, `the governors are to be the governed', or as we have come to know it, `rule and be ruled in turn'.The two major types of democracy are Representative Democracy and Direct Democracy. Clearly the

Montesquieu's Greatest Mark on Philosophy

1543 words - 6 pages Letters sowed the seeds of many of the ideas featured in his chef d’œuvre. In particular, Montesquieu spends some time in both works examining the universe of possible governments. But he advocates not, in fact, for republicanism or, perhaps less surprisingly, despotism. Rather, Montesquieu supports the “moderate” position: a government less despotic than despotism, and yet less democratic than democracy or republicanism. He makes the case

Radicalism of American Revolut

1510 words - 6 pages transformation to the social and economic factors that faced the colonists. While Gordon Wood creates a persuasive argument in his book, he does however neglect to consider other contributing factors of the revolution. It is these neglected factors that provide opportunity for criticism of his book. The overall feeling one gets from reading Wood?s book is that republicanism was not a radical concept to the American colonists. Wood believed the

A.P. U.S. Test

683 words - 3 pages political debates broke out over the role that democracy should play in government. The American shift to republicanism and gradually expanding democracy was the beginning of the end of monarchy, aristocracy, oligarchy and dictatorship world wide.Jefferson's uprising doctrine of equality, "All men are created equal" also was relating to the reform of voting laws. The owning of property was required in order to vote, every state except Mass


714 words - 3 pages The White House stands proudly on capitol hill, the longstanding symbol of democracy for Americans. Democracy, a government created by the people for the people, gives its citizens a voice in the government of their country. In countries with democracy all citizens have an equal part in creating laws and help make decisions pertaining to governing. Governments based on democracy include direct and indirect democracy. The Greeks created

Similar Essays

Federalist No.10’s Faction And Direct Vs. In Direct Democracy

857 words - 3 pages . Madison explains that the only way to deal with causes of faction is by controlling its effects. This is where the constitution comes into play, providing security of the public good and the rights of other citizens. To assure constitution, democracy is enacted to form a more civilized community governed by the people. The way democracy is organized is determined by the ideas of being direct or indirect. Direct Democracy is defined by people as

Critical Analysis Of Mendelson's And Parkins' "Introducing Direct Democracy In Canada"

1263 words - 5 pages In the article titled Introducing Direct Democracy in Canada, Mendelsohn and Parkin attempted proving to the readers that the holding of more referendums would improve Canadian democracy, as it would involve the general public in the making of policies and decisions that directly affected their lives. They state that the Canadian executive is given an enormous amount of power when he comes into office, which does not give others-outside of his

Causes Of The American Revolution Essay

1040 words - 4 pages The period before the American Revolution was characterized by a series of social as well as political shifts that occurred in American society as new republican principles took hold in the gentry of the colonies. That time era distinguished the sharp political debates between radicals and moderates over the role that democracy should play in a government. This broad new American shift to republicanism and a newfound support of democracy was a

History Essay

2303 words - 10 pages discussed a revised version of democratic structures. He rejected direct democracy and presented a government modeled by checks and balances that is very much still in use today. Also, he believed that the ‘rule by the people’ was the ‘rule by the mob’. Furthermore, his political theory is one that influences current constitutional principles. This political theory related governance to management. Aristotle believed that the nature of leadership