This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Research Article Critique: A Critique On Bitchener

1217 words - 5 pages

The objectives of this study were: “(1) to investigate whether targeted corrective feedback on ESL student writing results in improved accuracy in new pieces of writing over a 2-month period and (2) to investigate whether there is a differential effect on accuracy for different corrective feedback options.” (p.103)

Methods and results
This study aimed to answer the following questions:
1. Does accuracy in the use of two functions of the English article system vary over time?
2. Does accuracy in the use of these features vary according to the type of corrective feedback provided?
3. Does accuracy in the use of these features vary as a result of the interaction of feedback type and time?
Seventy five low intermediate level ESL students studying at two language schools in Auckland, New Zealand participated in this study as the subjects. The students had different L1 backgrounds, had studied English for 8 years, and had the average age of 22.7 years. They were randomly assigned into four different groups: group 1 received direct corrective feedback plus written and oral metalinguistic explanation (Direct CF + W&O), group 2 received direct corrective feedback and written metalinguistic explanation (Direct CF + W), group 3 received direct corrective feedback without additional metalinguistic explanation (Direct CF only), and group 4 did not receive at all (No CF).
Written metalinguistic given in this study was in the form of short explanation of the use of articles supplemented with some examples. Oral metalinguistic explanation was a 30-minutes lesson in which the researcher explained the rules and example about the use of articles that the students had on their returned writings, including also a short exercise in which students were asked to fill in the gap with a or the.
The data in this study was collected using writing prompts with picture. In this test, the students were given a picture and then asked to describe what was happening in it. All three pictures for the pretest, posttest, and delayed posttest were similar in nature, depicting a beach scene, a camping site, and a park picnic respectively. Some key words were provided next to the picture to help minimize students’ anxiety level. They were then asked to complete the writing task in 30 minutes.

The findings showed that, compared to the control group, the accuracy of the three experimental groups improved significantly right after the first treatment until the delayed posttest. This indicated that direct, focused CF was effective in improving the students’ accuracy in using articles. However, pairwise comparison further showed that the significant differences were only between group 1, group 3, and group 4, meaning that the result obtained by group 2 (Direct CF + W) was not significantly different from the control group.

Critique of the method
There are several points worth discussing in this article. The first and the most important one is the integration of the ‘mini lesson’ in...

Find Another Essay On Research Article Critique: A Critique on Bitchener

Nursing Research Article Critique Essay

1678 words - 7 pages Control is and has been a pervasive factor in the lives of many across the world, influencing the way research can be conducted or the way people try to maintain a balance in the weight or appearance. The simple principle has to ability to create complexities for a person both on an external and internal level. An example of this is eating disorders, in which a person manipulates the amount of nutrition they may receive, either by denying

Article Critique on GMO Essay

694 words - 3 pages Article Critique on GMOPOL 1113Prof. Marija NaumoskiFall 2014By Sachet KhanalEverybody enjoys eating ice cream on a hot summer day, and having pan cakes for breakfast, but most of us don't bother thinking about what is in our food or how it was made. A lot of food available for sale are genetically modified, but as these foods do not have to be labeled, we will not know whether the food we buy is genetically modified or not. In an article titled

Critique of Quantitative Research Article

790 words - 4 pages Dr. Karrie Hendrickson published an article in 2009 analyzing patterns of hospital resource utilization of children with leukemia and CNS tumors. Dr. Hendrickson used quantitative research as her means of analysis. In her article, Dr. Hendrickson specifies the population as children ages 0 to 19 years diagnosed with cancer at a large north-eastern hospital between fiscal years 2000 and 2004. Specifically, she focused on children diagnosed with

Article Critique

747 words - 3 pages Fastest Growing Occupations This review will critique the article ‘Fastest Growing Occupations’ by Daniel E. Hecker in the journal Monthly Labor Review in the book Everyday Arguments by Katherine Mayberry (Mayberry, 2009). The brief analysis of the articles author, the point of view, and the evidence provided to prove a claim, is the evidence factual, and sources utilized. Finally the conclusion will be my viewpoint on the article and my

Article Critique

782 words - 4 pages Introduction In 2006, an article was published by three doctoral students, (Tricia Seifert, Jerri Drummond, and Ernest Pascarella) at the University of Iowa, highlighting a research study undergone by the three concerning the role of institutional types, with emphasis on historically black colleges (HBC’s) in African-American students’ experiences. The findings, as published in the Journal of College Student Development showed that students

article critique

1352 words - 6 pages ethnic differences in violence across areas and on why this research was important and past research done on this topic (Groveland). Next I discuss the theoretical framework of the article and the hypothesis that guided the research. In this section I address the general criminological theory that the researchers used to inform their analysis. (Social disorganization theory) Lastly I end the article critique with a summary of the study design

Article Critique

1152 words - 5 pages In an article written by Antonanzas, Rive, Badenas, Gomez- Lus and Guilhaume (2006), the different style of treatment of Alzheimer’s Disease (AD) was found to have implications on research. In the United States and many other developed countries, AD patients are often institutionalized at a certain point of the disease when they are said to cause a burden on their caregivers. In Spain, AD is rarely a disease that institutionalizes a

Article Critique

838 words - 4 pages article Confucian Person in the Making. On page 88, I found a couple of errors. First, Chang refers to the Western philosophical project as if he is quoting them; however, there are no quotations marks. Furthermore, when you look up Western philosophical project there are no relative search results. Therefore, it leaves me perplexed to as what he is directly referring to. Secondly, the title of the section “What Is the Proper Relationship

Article Critique

739 words - 3 pages petrels but after reading their argument it seems that they are first testing whether chemical signaling occurs that there are chemical signals assisting in the process. However, this means that the findings they report on are not ecologically realistic. In my eyes, ecological realism occurs when an experiment or study is a copy of an event that happens in nature or is close to what happens in nature. This article does not seem ecologically realistic

Article Critique - 1426 words

1426 words - 6 pages a whole group. The research in the study was quantitative and provided the authors with both group level analyses data and individual responsiveness to instruction. In regards to the first research question posed by the authors: Does participating in K-PALS result in improved critical beginning reading skills for students with IEPs?; the study found a statistically significant difference on three of the eight areas of interest. These three

Article Critique on CSI Plagiarism

686 words - 3 pages cause them. His thesis is: a better way for professors to be more “assertive” on addressing plagiarism is to play the same game. And by that, he means to shame, mock or embarrass the students into fearful obedience. Bauman ends the article by presenting an example of a conversation between the students and himself where he applies his new way of fighting back. The strength of the article is found on the narrative of the stories that the author

Similar Essays

Quantitative Research Article Critique Essay

1627 words - 7 pages Quantitative Research Article Critique This paper is an academic critique of an article written by Lautrette, et al. (2007) titled: “A Communication Strategy and Brochure for Relatives of Patients Dying in the ICU” and accurately reflected the content of the article and the research study itself. The abstract explained the article in more detail, while remaining concise. The type of research study, sample size, variables, intervention

Nursing Research Article Critique Essay

993 words - 4 pages value on it subjects (Polit & Beck). In the end the resulting data is neutral and statistical. However, like all things its approach is not perfect, yet, it has the ability to yield valuable data. Summary of Critiqued Article For nursing, research has played a major role in the way clinical practice is done. Research has allowed nurses to provide appropriate care to patients. It allows them to perform their job by providing them the tools and

Research Article Critique Essay

870 words - 4 pages determine the drivers of higher costs for children who die…targets for cost-saving interventions can be identified (2009).” The research article did not clearly state a hypothesis, but it was deduced that the total cost of both the inpatient and outpatient treatment of children with the two cancers identified was going to be very costly. Sample size was clearly identified to the readers as “the final sample consists of 223 children, ages 0-19, who had

Qualitative Research Article Critique Essay

1435 words - 6 pages Qualitative research is "the investigation of phenomena, typically in an in-depth and holistic fashion, through the collection of rich narrative materials using a flexible research design" (Polit, Beck, and Hungler, 2001, p 469). Qualitative researchers focus on the descriptions and deeper meaning associated with the data collected. Another way to define qualitative research is to describe it as a type of research that involves interpreting non