Research Critique 1 Essay

784 words - 4 pages

Article 1
Sheen, Y. (2007). The effect of focused written corrective feedback and language aptitude on ESL learner’s acquisition of articles. TESOL Quarterly, 4 (2), 255-283.

This study investigated the efficacy of two types of written corrective feedback (direct feedback with metalinguistic explanation and direct feedback only) as well as their correlation with language analytic ability.

Method and results
There were three questions the researcher aimed to answer in this study:
1. Does focused written corrective feedback (CF) have an effect on intermediate ESL learners' acquisition of English articles?
2. Is there any difference in the effect of direct correction with and without metalinguistic feedback on ESL learners' acquisition of English articles?
3. To what extent does the learners’ language analytic ability mediate the effectiveness of CF?
To answer these questions, the researcher designed a quasi-experimental studies with its procedures described in the following diagram:

Five English native speaker instructors and 91 intermediate level ESL students took part as participants in this study. The students came from various L1 background and were international student as well as immigrant students, ranging from 21 to 56 years old. The students were then divided into two control groups (direct correction only and direct correction with metalinguistic explanation) and one control group.
The language analytic ability test was a 14 items of multiple choices test, asking students to pick the best translation of short English phrases in an imaginary language. The pretest, posttest, and immediate post comprised of three similar tests: (1) speed dictation test, containing 14 items that should be completed in 8 minutes, (2) writing test, asking students to rewrite a short narrative text in 12 minutes, and (3) error correction test, in which students were asked to correct 17 items of grammatically incorrect sentence.
The data were computed using a set of statistical calculations, including one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc multiple comparison test, repeated measures ANOVA, ANCOVA, and Pearson product moment correlation test.
The result revealed that both groups that received written CF received higher scores in the speed dictation test, writing test, and error correction test than the control group. This indicated that focused written CF was effective in promoting intermediate ESL leaners’ acquisition of English articles.
The group that received direct correction...

Find Another Essay On Research critique 1

The manifestation of violence in Antigone

2073 words - 9 pages ). The society needs someone to follow and thus chooses to follow Creon. Antigone in application to Benjamin’s Critique on Violence There is violence present in Creon’s decree itself as “Power established by law-making violence threatens the law- breaker with law- preserving violence” (Auerbach 1:2007). Anyone who breaks the law, will be punished, the punishment is thus, the ‘law- preserving violence’ as it gives the rest of the state an example of

Reflexivity Essay

1183 words - 5 pages Reflexivity When an ethnographer examines a group of people, she is influenced by her position and understanding of her own culture. Before an ethnographer even begins her research, her opinion is effecting the process of selecting a topic. For instance, Anthropology’s most commonly known researcher Bronslow Malinowsky wrote the Argonauts of the Western Pacific. He did not choose to study a culture similar to his own because of the

Towards Conversation Entailment : An Empirical Investigation" by Chen Zhang and Joyce Y

614 words - 3 pages structure is incorporated in the representation. Critique 1 To simplify the model, the paper makes an assumption that a noun term from the conversation and a verb term from the hypothesis (or vice versa) wouldn't be aligned to one another during the alignment model. While modeling argument consistency using implicit and explicit modeling, the lack of noun-verb alignments can have a negative impact on the overall semantic information available. Since

A Critique: Web-based Orientation Materials and Information Processing

2574 words - 11 pages Critique of Web-based Orientation Materials Based on the information that is known about orientation material as well as web-based training materials, I will now critique this platform and how it enhances or takes away from the processing of messages. This next section will look at five key areas: (1) the cost savings compared to traditional training, (2) the technology gap for those individuals that potentially lack in computer skills, (3

reaction paper

1176 words - 5 pages understand the process of their research and how many resources can be distributed to each research phase. Therefore, these two quotes are staying in the list because they remind scientists the most important elements of research. The goals Four personal goals were stated in the first assignment but not all of them sustain after this semester. The first three goals are to think outside of the discipline, to critique a research design, and to understand

Adaptive Management

865 words - 3 pages management includes four dimensions of policy design: 1) Conceptual soundness-is the idea sensible? 2) Technical-is the idea translated into practice well? 3) Equity-who are the winners and losers? 4) Pragmatic-does it work?There are a few critiques of adaptive management. One critique is that since it is experimental, it is impossible to know which "experiment" is best for obtaining a desired management outcome. People may not desire to experiment or

Guidelines for Action Research

1191 words - 5 pages factors will affect what I do. Therefore, the act of action research meets two of my main objectives: 1. To identify, understand and solve problems discovered in the original practice, and to facilitate this using myself as a researcher/practitioner. 2. To use any research created to find a solution to any problem or concerns that are raised in the cycles of research. As a by-product of this research I will use the outcome and the process to

Educating Information Technology Staff

1318 words - 6 pages -2923.2010.03723.x Crews, J. M., Cao, J., Lin, M., Nunamaker Jr., J. F., & Burgoon, J. K. (2007). A comparison of instructor-led vs. web-based training for detecting deception. Journal of STEM Education: Innovations & Research, 8(1/2), 31-40. Retrieved from http://ojs.jstem.org/index.php?journal=JSTEM Davis, J., Crabb, S., Rogers, E., Zamora, J., & Khan, K. (2008). Computer-based teaching is as good as face to face lecture-based teaching of evidence

Reaseach Critique of the Article Shaping Juror Attitudes by Malouff and Schutte

935 words - 4 pages Amanda Maybaum Research Critique After reading the article, Shaping Juror Attitudes: Effects of Requesting Different Damage Amounts in Personal Injury Trials, one might notice the elements of research conducted throughout this study, focusing on the many strengths and weaknesses. The following research critique will discuss the fundamentals of the study, the quality of validity and reliability, strengths and limitations as well as future

Issues that Affect Educational Outcomes for Indigenous Australians

1093 words - 4 pages to commence education in the first place. Annotation/ critique The purpose of the paper was to examine the associations between health and education for Indigenous Australians. Biddle had cited from the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare as well as supporting his own scientific research by drawing on perspectives of others' analyses. Biddle has cited research from the National Aboriginal and Torress Strait Islander Survey (NATSIS). The

Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instruction by Ralph Tyler

2119 words - 8 pages resources. Most teachers do not have the time to gather this sort of data, and even if they did, how likely is it that this information would be a source for creating objectives. My critique, based on time and resources, of Tyler’s objectives, leads directly into my next critique of this particular section. Let’s assume that it is possible to conduct all of the research and studies that Tyler suggests. I then wonder, is this information more

Similar Essays

Article Critique 1 Essay

910 words - 4 pages Article Critique 1 Catherine Cangany’s article Fashioning Moccasins: Detroit, the Manufacturing Frontier, and the Empire of Consumption, 1701-1835, cover the main theme 18th century Detroit. Cangany explores how the moccasin, a fashionable and practical shoe, transformed from a shoe exclusively worn by native groups to a highly fashionable shoe that French and British colonies started to integrate into their own culture to taking the moccasin

Article Critique 1 Essay

873 words - 4 pages Article Review 2 Dennis Carter-Edwards’ article The War of 1812 Along the Detroit Frontier: A Canadian Perspective covers the theme of local history during the 19th century in Detroit. In particular, Carter-Edwards explores the Canadian perspective of the war of 1812 in the Windsor-Detroit region. The author examines three big categories; the measures that the British took to defended the area, the factors that influenced British decisions, and

Second Suite In F “1. March” Critique

970 words - 4 pages “You gotta play this piece like an English military band would,” said Jules during band one day while rehearsing the first movement of Gustav Holst’s Second Suite in F. “1. March” begins with four notes played by the low brass which is then echoed by the upper woodwinds. The trumpets have a noble melody which broadens when the entire ensemble joins in. Next, the piece lightens up with an upper woodwind melody. Later on there is a euphonium solo

What Is Critique? Essay

2339 words - 10 pages something from a different sense. This essay will discuss what is critique or critical theory by looking at the various approaches illustrated in the work and research of Craig Calhoun, Dorothy Smith and Fuyuki Kurasawa. Craig Calhoun describes the ‘philistine’ as someone who is unreflective, passive, someone who does not look deeper then what they see on the surface in the academics sense. He sees it as someone who is content in a world that is not in