Research Findings Of Both The Benefits And Limitations Of Dap Testing

1401 words - 6 pages

Research Findings of Both Benefits and Limitations of DAP Testing

This paper focuses on research information of Draw A Person (DAP) testing in both its original form of Children’s Human Figure Drawing created by Florence Goodenough, it’s limitations, and it’s current form of function as DAP testing of today. DAP is typically used to identify cognitive strengths and limitations among primary aged youth through the evaluation of the drawn human figure. However, there is some evidence that suggests DAP could be of therapeutic benefit in other areas of function. Florence Goodenough first published findings in 1926 that revealed children’s drawings of a man can be correlated to their level of intelligence. Goodenough spoke of the human figure drawing task as being “useful in the analysis of specific mental functions and in the study of the development of conceptual thinking during early childhood” (Goodenough, 1926). Even though the Goodenough Draw-a-Man test was established as being a good measure of non-verbal cognitive ability, there are elements of this test that suggest:
1. In order to raise test validity, it may need to be used in conjunction with other means of measurement.
2. Lower socioeconomic status and/or limited access to structured programs have a significant effect on scoring outcome.
3. Scoring criteria and interpretation may be devised and utilized depending on the purpose and field of study.
The research that is focused on in this paper covers these three issues.
Goodenough-Harris Draw-a-Person Test Valid?
The Goodenough-Harris Draw-a-Person Test has been criticized by some for being outdated and the scoring instructions have been found to be laborious and imprecise on some items. The DAP Test, developed by Naglieri in 1988, has offered some norms for the self- drawing test. The introduction of the DAP has increased precision in its scoring system with half-year and quarter-year intervals. In contrast, the Goodenough model scored only in one- year intervals. In addition to giving a more accurate score on self-drawing tests, DAP has simplified the scoring system by grouping fifty items of interest, such as length of arms, symmetry of shape and size, finite details of other features, into 14 criteria as opposed to Goodenough’s system of 73 items of interest (Naglieri, 1988). The simplification of the scoring method has increased both time efficiency and human error in scoring. Both DAP and the Goodenough Draw-a-Person test are well correlated and together can be used as a measure of children’s body image and knowledge of their bodies. Ayers and Reid (1966) wrote,
“Ever since Goodenough demonstrated the value of drawing the self as indices of children’s intellectual capacity, variations of her technique have been used as expressions of cognitive, affective, and organic function. It commonly has been inferred that, in contrast to the drawing of other objects, depicting the human...

Find Another Essay On Research Findings of Both the Benefits and Limitations of DAP Testing

Case Study: The Benefits of Animal Testing

1757 words - 7 pages animal experimentation. Animal testing allows doctors to save countless lives. Without it, Amy along with countless others would die. Animal testing is a largely debated and controversial issue. It was first introduced in the United States in the 1920s (Goldberg 85). Since then, there have been many advances in the field of medicine and science. These advances are due largely to the fact that animals are used in experiments and research.  Animal

The Benefits of Genetic Research Essay

1127 words - 5 pages much evidence to the contrary. The debate on the benefits of genetic research and what they can do to help mankind has been argued with the help of extensive scientific testing, anonymous surveys, and rulings from our own Federal Government. People are hesitant about genetic research for several reasons; most of them centered around the invasion of their privacy and the negative effects it could have on their lives were the information to be

The Cruelty of Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation

1391 words - 6 pages The Cruelty of Animal Testing and the Need for Alternative Methods In his book Inhumane Society: The American Way of Exploiting Animals, Dr. Michael W. Fox estimates that twenty-five to thirty-five million animals are used in the United States each year for laboratory testing and research (58). Research involving tests done on animals is unnecessary and cruel. More humane methods of research need to be employed. Fox states that animal

The Statute of Limitations

810 words - 3 pages liabilities, with injuries may take time to manifest, many courts adapted different rules such as postponing the running of the statute until the injury has been reasonably discovered. The length of time differs among states and branches of law (Danzon, 1985). The long and deferred statutes of limitations lead to long tail of claims and contributed majority of medical malpractice and product liability (Danzon, 1985). In this section, statutes of

The Definition and Limitations of Harm

1536 words - 6 pages are also necessary for his overall definition to be viable. Without such limitations, society could restrict any action the majority of the population finds disagreeable. The actions an individual is at liberty to do would become limited, and Mill’s liberty principle would transform into “a law on the minority” (Mill 88). For example, vegetarians or vegans could insist that an individual should not eat meat, citing that it insults their morals

Nazi Appeal And The Limitations Of Democracy

2144 words - 9 pages Nazis sought to unite the classes for a stronger community. It's brand of socialism replaced class struggle with national struggle aginst anti-German forces from both within and outside of the nation (Spielvogel 2). Theoretically, everyone, regardless of social roles, was equal simply because they were German, members of the supposedly master race. The Nazis also had difficulty swaying Catholics to their side (Spielvogel 110). The Catholic

Limitations of the Paparazzi

1424 words - 6 pages The paparazzi can receive up to thousands of dollars for candid pictures of celebrities. As celebrities become more popular, the public wants to know what their doing every second of every day, even when they aren’t on camera. The paparazzi make it their job to find those things out Paparazzi are photographers who repeatedly hunt celebrities, public figures and their families for a chance to photograph them in candid, unflattering and at times

The internationalisation of education has benefits for both local and international students. Discuss.

1589 words - 6 pages new experiences in a foreign country, whereas domestic students are likely to acquire appropriate social skills and to widen their horizon. After giving a short definition of internationalisation of education, this paper will discuss both, the difficulties of an international student, studying abroad, and it will explore advantages which both, international and domestic students might take out of a cross-cultural relationship.The

The Study and Findings of Climatology in Nepal

1156 words - 5 pages The Study and Findings of Climatology in Nepal In many areas in Nepal, the history of climatology only dates back to 1956. Around this time, the Indian Meteorological Department instituted stations in various areas around the country, which were eventually taken over by the Nepalese government in 1966. Having these stations in place has given scientists significant insight into the Nepalese climate. However, some of the

Importance and Benefits of Educational Research

1497 words - 6 pages Importance and Benefits of Educational Research “When a student is ready, the teacher appears” is an ancient Buddhist proverb that is packed with wisdom (Smith, 2002). No matter how hard a teacher tries, if the student is not ready to learn, chances are good he or she will not bet. Luckily, students are present in the classroom because they want to be. Introduction When school-age children first enter the classroom, there is apprehension

Reporting The Findings from Research

790 words - 3 pages . Reliability and validity are also to be justified with description of tests undertaken. In-depth review of each step of the study is critical for both quantitative and qualitative research (Ryan, Coughlan, Cronin, 2007). This part of research is the most difficult for revision, as measures and methods have already been applied and data collected. Weak empirical evidence will lead to distorted results and consequently to erroneous conclusions. At

Similar Essays

The Ethics And Limitations Of Animal Research

1871 words - 7 pages operations. Not every animal experiment carries the risk of physical or mental stress to the animal. The purpose is to eventually build on the existing instruments, and identify the concern of the moral status of animals as and additional tool to evaluate the appropriate limitations of animal research. Types of Animal Research The range of applied animal research varies from simple observational studies, up to drug testing or dissections

The Benefits And Limitations Of Strategic Planning For Organizations

2411 words - 10 pages The Benefits and Limitations of Strategic Planning for Organizations "It was August of 1914 and Germany had committed virtually its entire army to the invasion of Belgium and France. Few German troops remained to defend East Prussia against the invasion of two huge Russian armies. Despite the numerical inferiority, Colonel Hoffmann, chief of the German Eighth Army staff, created an audacious strategy to surround and

The Benefits Of Genetic Testing Essay

1593 words - 6 pages Genetic testing is a voluntary type of medical test used to identify changes in chromosomes, genes, or proteins. This type of medical test checks for alterations in an individual's genes or changes in levels of gene products, proteins. Genetic testing could also be used to look for structure of certain proteins, and for levels of RNA that play a role in certain conditions. The purpose of the test is to indentify genetic problems or possible

Composting And The Benefits And Limitations Of Its Use As Soil Amendment

1316 words - 5 pages about the interactions of certain soil processes with waste materials, what happens in reality is far more complex. All these processes interact with the influence of each other, and any attempt to predict the cumulative effect of all these interactions would be futile. What this research does is to offer a broad overview of the possible limitations and benefits that compost has on the soil. Thus, monitoring of the compost process is necessary to