This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Counterarguing Coleman's Allegations That Global Warming Is A Scam

1277 words - 6 pages

The argument put forward by John Coleman, in his article “Global Warming Greatest Scam in History!”, is flawed mainly due to numerous logical fallacies. “Ad Hominem”, “Guilt by Association”, “Red Herring”, “Appeal to Irrelevant Authority”, “Hasty Generalization”, and “Genetic Fallacy” are some of the logical fallacies that can be observed to prevail in Coleman’s argument. As a consequence, the soundness, validity, clarity, reasoning and consistency of the whole article are insubstantial. Coleman’s premises fail to support his proposition that global warming is a scam, making the whole argument distorted and faulty.
The first defective premise that Coleman uses to support his claim, is that the scientists are “dastard”, “manipulative” and “wacko”, who are only “eager to produce findings that would be important and be widely noticed and trigger more research funding”. Coleman states that those scientists, who claim that global warming is happening, are only after their own agenda. They are lunatics, only after fame and glory. As such, he reasons that their findings must therefore not be trustworthy. That flawed logic is an example of “Abusive Ad Hominem”. By describing the scientists as being “dastard”, “manipulative” and “wacko”, Coleman attacks the scientists on a personal level in an attempt to discredit their findings. The logical fallacy is to assume that a person’s argument has a direct correlation with their character, when it does not. In this case, the strength of a scientist’s argument should not be assumed to be determined by his character. These types of abusive comments do not strengthen Coleman’s argument at all, but instead shows how groundless his premise is.
Furthermore, another type of “Ad Hominem” can be observed in that same premise, which is “Circumstantial Ad Hominem”. Circumstantial ad hominem is when someone attacks another person based on their intention, in order to discredit their argument. This logic is flawed as well for the validity of a person’s findings is not based on their intentions. An example of such an attack is when Coleman marks the scientists’ findings to have the sole purpose of “becoming well known and respected and [receiving] scholarly awards, and… more research dollars”. He is trying to argue that because the scientists want to become rich and popular, their findings must automatically be untrustworthy. This is fallacious logic in that the scientists’ intentions have no influence on their findings’ weight. This is another case of Coleman’s baseless premise.

The second flawed premise in the argument is that PHD students are “more likely than not, part of that single minded culture.” In this case, Coleman is saying that all PHDs are of the same type, their only aim is money and glory. Coleman uses hasty generalization and genetic fallacy to support it, which are both faulty logics. First of all, hasty generalization can be observed as Coleman reasons that because he got his PHD, all other PHDs must...

Find Another Essay On Counterarguing Coleman's Allegations that Global Warming is a Scam

IS Global Warming a Threat? Essay

1204 words - 5 pages What is global warming? What causes it? Who or what does it affect? Is it a threat to Americans and our universe? There are many different answers to these questions that people don’t know or think about. Global warming is affecting us in many ways, good and bad that we don’t notice. Based on the effects of global warming reported it affects us more bad than good in my perspective. Weather is what we experience each day. Climate is the sum of

Global Warming is a Disgrace Essay

1404 words - 6 pages of plant plankton plummets, marine mammals will go hungry and eventually die (Borenstein). I honestly think this is terrible that because the plants actually provide for other living organisms and yet they will become vanished. There are too many living things becoming extinct due to global warming and people should start to make a difference. It was under debate for quite some time whether or not global warming was natural or caused by people

Is Global Warming a Hoax?

1260 words - 6 pages Is global warming a hoax? Anyone who listens to the news for sure very often comes across a news anchor stating how the Earth’s climate is changing. Global warming is a term that creates fear among many. But with all the open and uncensored media out there how do we know that this is not a lie or cover-up? So what does global warming actually mean and is it really true? If global warming is such a big deal why are we taking our time to act

Global Warming is False

1831 words - 8 pages “The warnings about global warming have been extremely clear for a long time. We are facing a global climate crisis. It is deepening. We are entering a period of consequences.” Global warming is the idea that human activities are leading to the unnatural warming of Earth’s climate. Global warming became a reason to save life on Earth before it had the opportunity to turn into good science. Al Gore insists that uncontrolled releases of carbon

Global Warming is Real

2207 words - 9 pages There are many different views on whether global warming is actually real or not and possible catastrophic damage it causes. It is a big issue in politics now, everyone is arguing whether or not it is actually real or that it is just a weather pattern. People need to wake up and realize that it is real, just look at the shorter winters and the warmer weather. The Glaciers are melting, crazy weather patterns are happening, so what else could it

What is Global Warming?

5297 words - 21 pages What Is Global Warming?Global warming refers to temperature increases in the troposphere, which then causes climate change. Natural changes, human activities, or both can cause this type of warming. Global climate change is a broader word that refers to the changes in the Earth's climate, which include temperature, precipitation, and storm intensity and patterns (Colling, 2007).The majority of the world's climate experts believe that global

Global warming is real

1006 words - 4 pages ". He also believes that if after 10 years there have not been made any effort to reduce the greenhouse gases the global warming will reach its peak and become unstoppable (2).Global warming is a danger and does include bad effects on our health, weather, economy and fragile ecosystems. The unbearable heat caused by the warming can lead to some serious health problems like asthma and air pollution. The number of very hot days elevates smog to

Global Warming is Real

818 words - 3 pages When thinking of global warming, one could picture a line of dominos. Imagine if someone had knocked over just one domino, what would happen to the rest of the dominos in the line? The others would follow. Global warming can be compared to dominos in that both cause a chain reaction. Carbon dioxide could very well represent the first domino since it is carbon dioxide that creates the blanket-like effect of CO2 in the atmosphere. This blanket

Global Warming is a Theory, Not a Fact

2452 words - 10 pages monsoons (Gwynne). Global cooling was a scare that resulted because of a theory, but now the concern is global warming. With many theories resulting in a a dead end when they were only hypotheses in the first place, intellectual citizens have begun to distrust the scientific community because of their tendency to teach theories as facts instead of educational hypotheses. Currently, ordinary citizens hesitate to trust any ideas published in

Global Warming is a Fact, Not a Theory

3392 words - 14 pages When many people think about their future, usually they are only considering things that will effect or benefit their personal lives. Things such as the city that they will live or if they will have the same job five years down the road. Few people think about what may be going on in the environment around them. Global warming, also known as the greenhouse effect, is a rise in the entire temperature of the earth’s atmosphere. It has been

A Global Disaster: Global Warming

2381 words - 10 pages surpassed normal, predicted ranges. Global warming is occurring - there should not be any doubt. Evidence clearly shows that the Earth is warming abnormally. Since 1880, the globe has heated, “the warmest years occurring in the past 12 years” even regardless of a solar output decline, or less potency of the sun’s energy (“Climate Change: How do we know?”). It is important to note that the warming began at approximately the middle of the

Similar Essays

Global Warming Is A Reality That Must Be Taken Seriously

506 words - 2 pages Global Warming is a rising epidemic that is one of high controversy. The growing concern that Global Warming is going to thermally destroy the earth is causing concentrated precautions to take place. With worry mounting in the lives of the human race, it is intensifying the idea that things must be done to stop the depletion of the ozone layer. There are several problems around the earth that prove the occurrence of Global Warming. It is very

Evidence That Global Warming Is Occuring

827 words - 4 pages Throughout the last 650,000 years, the Earth has faced a change in its climate. There is evidence from the change in the Earth’s orbit and the extent of solar energy that it collects. It is because of Global Warming! Specifically, according to the chart below, carbon dioxide has never reached above 300 ppm for the last 650,000 years and currently as of the year 2013, we have exceeded that limit to almost 400 ppm (Evidence for Global Warming

Discuss What Is Global Warming. And The Effects That Global Warming Gives And How To Prevent It. And A Little History On Global Warming

1109 words - 4 pages climate to some extent, it is uncertain what long-term effects a diminished biosphere will have on the world as a whole. It is becoming more apparent, however, that as man continues to squander the Earth's resources, the climate could change in such a way that it is no longer benevolent to mankind. The greenhouse effect and global warming both correspond with each other. The green house effect is recalled as incoming solar radiation that passes

Global Warming: An Issue That Is Man Made?

1506 words - 7 pages Global warming is both a political and scientific problem, which tends to be manipulated by media to prove one side of the argument. Although the media sways the public to see global warming as a settled matter, it is far from that. Scientifically speaking, the evidence to support man-made global warming comes from assumptions rather than solid evidence that can be fully proven. Scientists cannot say for certain whether or not the warming of the