This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Reservations By Religion Essay

1040 words - 4 pages

The idea has disturbing possibilitiesWHEN we entered the age of reservations in the early 1950s, we closed both the front and back doors to reservations by religion. Are we opening them now, some half a century later ?When the debate on reservations began, in the Constituent Assembly, we decided we would have job reservations only for the Scheduled Castes and tribes. A little later we opened the door to "other backward castes " as well, because they were making practically the same case as had been made earlier by the Scheduled Castes, that Hindu society had inflicted social and economic discrimination upon them and thus had gravely reduced their capacity to compete with others on a footing of equality; therefore for a time they needed reservations as a class to regain their competitive ability.On each occasion some Muslim leaders urged similar reservations for such Muslims as belonged to the same disadvantaged categories. Their implied rationale was that since most Muslims were converts from Hinduism or had descended from the converts they were also disadvantaged by the Hindu society and needed the same compensatory advantage for a time.But the demand was rejected on the ground that anyone who could be shown to belong to a scheduled or a backward caste could qualify as such where he was, but since his religion, Islam, claimed that it treated all Muslims as equal -- and many Scheduled Caste Hindus had been persuaded to become Muslims on the promise of such equality -- he could not at the same time claim compensation for an inequality which, according to his religion, did not exist.They might have won reservations under a system meant to remedy economic deprivation. But the system we had then was aimed against inequalities inflicted by the caste system, which did not exist among them as claimed by them.A few things have happened since then which impinge upon any reconsideration of that issue. First, court judgments have narrowed the scope for reservations even on the basis of caste because they have ended reservations for the so called "creamy layer" among the entitled castes, that is those persons among the entitled castes whose socio-economic status has risen somewhat already.Second, and somewhat contrary to the first, reservations have been extended to categories who are under-represented in the services and also suffering from "social and economic backwardness". This has been the combined effect of the First Constitutional Amendment Act, adopted in 1951, and the 1985 judgment by the Supreme Court in the "Vasant v. the state of Karnataka" case.Third and latest, the Sachar Commission has shown that the Muslims are under-represented in many walks of life and can be presumed to be socio-economically backward as well.But a contrary view is also being voiced, that reservations by religion would be like separate electorates by another name, would divide and destroy national unity along communal lines, and should be eschewed as strictly now as it was...

Find Another Essay On Reservations by religion


1006 words - 4 pages Religion and Politics in America advances five theories for placing in a meaningful context the sometimes bewildering complexity of relations among religion, politics, and culture in American society. The culture wars thesis illuminates the contours of religion and politics today by emphasizing Americans' deep social divisions over values and lifestyles. Conservatives stress the importance of traditional values: religion, marriage and family

What are the differences between the Indian religi

1352 words - 5 pages When the settlers first came to America they were meet by the Indians. Once the settlers were able to make it on there own, they no longer needed Indian help. Then they began to try to change the ways of the Indian. One of the aspects that the settlers spent much time on trying to change of the Indians was there religion. One of the main religions that the Indians were forced to try to convert to was that of Cathoilism. Many attempts were made

The Disappearance of Native Americans in California

1642 words - 7 pages , and sustainability which then weakened native resistance to other intrusions. "Suddenly these natives, who were accustomed to their own independent society, found themselves herded together, fed strange food, deprived of their religion, restrained from their own specific sexual customs, and then treated roughly by padre or soldier when they deviated from the Church's prescribed norm. (Eargle 1986)” (Wahl, They

Native North American Culture and Its Demise

654 words - 3 pages , in North America many Native ethnic groups’ cultures were destroyed by British, French and Dutch colonizers. The cruel results of European attempts to tear through Aboriginal society and extract all aspects of non-Christian culture and religion can still be felt today. Through establishments like reservations and internment schools and military action, the Euro-American/Canadian governments were able to destroy most of Native Canadians and

Plains Indians And The Reservation And Assimilatio

1299 words - 5 pages by the United States Army to the Native Americans. The main goal of the reservations were to change Native American thoughts from a migratory lifestyle to European ideas of land ownership. Through the reservation policy, Native Americans lost huge amounts of land. This policy was more effective than the concentration policy, but still failed in gaining any peace between the Anglo and Native Americans. The Native Americans often rebelled over the

A Peek at the Looking Glass

1021 words - 5 pages Anglo Saxon Europeans came across the Atlantic Ocean in search of sanctuary from total authoritarianism. They sought freedom to live life, as they wanted, free from slavery, freedom of religion, and freedom from taxation on all of their hard-earned property. Somewhere in their being, knowledge burned with a certain sense of their equality to all other men and they yearned for this equality. They had knowledge of the "New World" across the ocean

Wounding More than just the Knee: The Development of the Ghost Dance in America

2465 words - 10 pages deep within Native American culture. The white man, since his arrival in America, has always had extreme amounts of tension with Native Americans, often enacting laws in order to do what would make white society happy. As the United States government took away more and more of what Native Americans stood for, vast amounts of them turned to religion for reprieve from the pain and suffering instigated, in part, by the white man. The United States

This essay shows the resistance and accomadation of Native Americans on Europeans. Shows the devastating affects of each style of conquest. Reference to James Wilson- "The earth shall Weep"

2060 words - 8 pages Yokuts, Miwok and the Wappo people who had become semi-nomadic guerrillas. They tried to resist the Europeans by fighting for their land, they would not give it up easily but when they saw that it was time to go they did. If they didn't want to go into the missions or stay on reservations they had to find land that Europeans did not want. This was not easy. In 1877, after the Poncas moved and reached their new land, all their horses died. The water

Native American Boarding Schools During the Westward Expansion

575 words - 2 pages themselves. They began to push the Native Americans off of their own land. Many of them fought back to keep their homes, some succeeded, some didn't. By the 1800's most of the Native Americans signed a treaty with the European American government. The results left the Native Americans on small pieces of land called reservations in exchange for their land and peace. The European Americans promised that they would give the Indians living on the

The American Indian Movement

2676 words - 11 pages American Indians once lived a prosperous and full life, relying on the bounty of land and nature. Colonization by white settlers disrupted this peaceful existence, uprooting tribes from their land and forcing them to assimilate to new cultural and religion views. Years of mistreatment and abuse led to the organization of the American Indian Movement to fight for their rights and liberty. Through the AIM, Indians attempted to gain recognition

Cruel and Inhuman Treatment of Native Americans by the Colonists

1745 words - 7 pages example set by his brother Christ”(Hoxie p. 76). Eastman is not directly criticizing Christianity itself, but the practice of it by the white man. He believes and is stating the Christianity is not truly practiced and lived by the Europeans who are eager and forceful to pass on their religion to the Natives but live by it very little themselves. This is a very testing yet accurate assumption that was made by Eastman. A true Christian would not

Similar Essays

Reservation System A Necessary Evil? It Is About The Reservation System Prevalant In India

1192 words - 5 pages well as the individual's personal mental growth. Hence, the reservations have to be allocated by keeping in mind the nation's interest.Every social group, be it defined by caste, religion, language, race or tribe, has its own rich and poor. There are rich, well-educated and well-placed Yadavs, Kurmis, etc. who despite being born into so- called lower castes living amongst us. Equally, there are Brahmins, Rajputs, Vaishyas, etc. born into so-called

Indian Reservation Essay

626 words - 3 pages , while the Indians were fighting for their land. The Indians were established in the late 19th and early 20th century. The Indians were placed in the West of the United States. Some of the problems and issues associated with the Indian reservations were the relations between settlers and natives grew increasingly worse because the settlers encroached on the territory and natural resources in the West. By the late 1860’s, President Ulysses S

How Native Americans Were Forced To Reservations

975 words - 4 pages not have to deal with them. The reservations were the only land that was kept by the Indians away from the U.S. Government. The government found different ways to get the land three specifically were treaties, an act by Congress, or an executive order from the President. The reservations did have a positive effect on the Indians a lot of the modern day Native Americans considered their ancestral reservation to be “home.” The reservations were

Problems Afflicting The Native Americans Essay

2564 words - 10 pages million as grave and 24 million as gently affected as to that. Many Native Americans have no possibility to earn a living by farming. In some reservations the commercial hunting and fishing are also prohibited. Poor infrastructure The lack of infrastructure such as no electricity, telephones or Internet connectivity etc. makes their life difficult in the reservations. These drawbacks and the insufficient links to the traffic system often keep most