Resistance: The Organisation's Big Problem Essay

2390 words - 10 pages

"People resist change." This belief is deeply ingrained in organizational life. It is inscribed in corporate documents, management textbooks, policy assumptions, executive training materials, consulting reports, and in societal media outside of organizations.(Hacking, 1999) This belief, demonstrate that it is a poor metaphor for change management, show that "resistance to change" is not commonly defined in the literature, and offer the results of an exploratory empirical study which suggests that people may actually be more willing to embrace, rather than resist, change.A person in one organization said resistance to change is like a mantra we feed ourselves: "In every team meeting we get together and spend the first twenty minutes saying change is hard. People resist change." This is an unexamined belief about human nature. Our assumptions about stability and the promises of equilibrium were all also promises and that is not how life is (Wheatley, in Maurer, 1996: 51).Anyone who has worked in, or studied, organizations can testify to the poor track record of organizational change efforts. A meta-analysis of large-scale change efforts suggests that positive outcomes occur less than 40 percent of the time (Porras et al, 1983). Kotter (1995) observed a decade of change efforts and characterized a few as very successful, a few as utter failures, and the rest mostly toward the lower end of the scale. Pascale, Millemann, and Gioia (1997) report a Harvard Business School study which tracked the impact of change efforts among the Fortune 100. Of the change programs initiated between 1980 and 1995 (average expenditures exceeded one billion dollars per corporation), only 30% produced an improvement in bottom-line results that exceeded the company's cost of capital, and only 50% led to an improvement in market share price. In another study, senior executives in Fortune 500 companies reported that less than one-half of the changes in their organizations were successful (Maurer, 1996). Moreover, they suggest that resistance to change was the main reason for failure. We believe that the executives are looking in the wrong place for the culprit. It may be that belief in resistance to change itself is a contributing factor to the dismal history of change efforts in organizations.8.1Unmasking "Resistance to Change"Meta-triangulation is an effective method for approaching this subject (Lewis and Grimes, 1999). This process unmasks "resistance to change" from three perspectives:(1) The term "resistance to change" is deconstructed.(2) The literature of the field is used to show that the term and its definitions are problematic.(3) An empirical study is reported to show whether and how "resistance to change" is actually operational.These three varying perspectives provide a rich, multi-faceted lens into "resistance to change."A second critique is that the use of the word "change" is too monolithic (Dent and Goldberg, 1999b). It is obvious that a variety of changes...

Find Another Essay On Resistance: The Organisation's Big Problem

Summary - Quirke: Communicating for Change (Managing Corporate Communicastion)

1529 words - 6 pages value areas differently from their managers. People resist change when it might cost them more than they would gain.A belief that the change is not in the best interest of the company:E.g. the board underestimates the difficulties of competing on an international stage.A lack of trust in those introducing change:Greater resistance if the relationship of those introducing change and those affected by it is bad. The organisation's culture plays a

Can planned change be implemented in a rapidly changing business environment? - Using the Planned Change Model

3978 words - 16 pages to resist the change. With such knowledge provided to the OD practitioner from an insider, the practitioners, at least, would not be caught off-guard by the resistance to throw the change plans off-track. Instead they may be able to deal with the resistance gradually, making adjustments to the change plan to counter them as it goes on.However, many action research studies haven been observed to abort at the diagnosis stage of a problem (Dickens

Management Social Responsibility

2551 words - 10 pages responsible company has been such a big issue for many businesses. It might sway the financial performance of the company either positively or negatively. The manager of a company has to be able to make an ethical decision in order to be socially responsible.As proposed by Robbins et al (2003),there are two opposing views of social responsibility that can be related regarding the organisation's approach to social responsibility which have impacts on

Do you think that the concept of organisational culture is a useful one in the real world? If so, why? If not, why not?

3912 words - 16 pages the organisation's culture may be little more than peer-group pressure to conform, behave, perform and even think within the corporate confines., while other aspects may be dominated by the personality os a senior corporate leader, such as John F. Welch.Organisation - a cultural paradigmFurther obfuscating culture as a concept, are arguments introduced by Smircich (1983, in Fulop & Linstead 1999:92) that culture is "not something an

GCSE Physics Coursework - Resistance of a Wire Coursework Resistance of a Wire

1551 words - 6 pages not mean that the diameter is half that of the wire 1. That is because if you halve the diameter then you decrease the area by a factor of about 3 (A = ¥ðr2)EvaluationAs mentioned previously, the biggest downfall of the investigation was the apparent mistakes when choosing the wire, in that they would appear to be of differing diameters. This did not, in this case, cause a big problem as the same wire was used for each set of results so

Global Financial Regulation and the International Tax and Investment Organization.

1218 words - 5 pages interests in this important area. Specifically, section 3 describes how the ITIO should firstly work to expand its membership beyond the existing members to states with similar economic interests, secondly persuade one or more member states to challenge the legality of the new regulations in the World Trade Organisation's Dispute Settlement Body and the European Court of Justice, and thirdly look to make common cause with like-minded NGOs and

Transforming 'Old City Sports'

3071 words - 12 pages both more customer orientated and more successful at managing the human resource potential of the organisation's employees. In essence, we have been asked to investigate how we can manage our employees to match our customer needs.In order to find existing successful HRM strategies, the report firstly identifies 'best practice' HRM procedures from two sport and leisure organisations.The report will then consider the potential problems and obstacles

The Resistance Of A Wire

760 words - 3 pages mentioned previously, the biggest downfall of the investigation was the apparent mistakes when choosing the wire, in that they would appear to be of differing diameters. This did not, in this case, cause a big problem as the same wire was used for each set of results so it is known that the results for each wire are correct.I can honestly say, that this investigation is very reliable as we have repeated the experiment, we also used accurate

Investigation of Gravity

719 words - 3 pages acceleration.Because of air resistance we can compile sports like skydiving, since when participating in skydiving you are having a free fall and the air resistance stops you from crashing onto the ground. As you are using a paraglide and as it has a big surface area, it also has a stronger air resistance. Skydiving is only one of many sports in which air resistance is required.Air resistance is relevant in our society because otherwise we would


2307 words - 9 pages changes in the environment.According to contingency theory organisations need adjustment in order to meet environmental conditions. In this process organisations often face resistance to change. One cannot expect everyone in an organisation to respond in an identical manner to specific change proposals. Different individuals and groups are likely to be affected in different ways and are also likely to perceive the implications differently from those

"Business Ethics" by Shagun Jain.

3926 words - 16 pages corporate culture and employee commitment to the organisation. Besides having a mutual influence on one another, employee commitment & corporate culture both affect the organisation's ability to successfully implement its strategy. In turn, the successful or unsuccessful implementation of strategy affects organisational performance.FIGURE A page 121In terms of a general definition, organisational performance is the outcome that occurs as a

Similar Essays

Water Pollution, Is It As Big Of A Problem As We Think? Speaks Of The Factors That Cause Pollution, The Effect That Pollution Has On Our World Today, And What It Has In Store For The Future If Things

2466 words - 10 pages million people die each year from drinking contaminated water!Another big problem are Oil spills. These large scale accidental discharges of liquid petroleum products are an important factor of the pollution along shore lines. The most spectacular spills involve the supertankers that are used to transport the product, but offshore drilling contribute to a large share of the pollution. One estimate is that for every million ton of oil that is shipped

Discrimination Still A Big Problem In The American Economy

1850 words - 7 pages slightly biased. To quote the President of the United States in a speech just recently, April 8, 2014, “Today, the average full-time working woman earns just 77 cents for every dollar a man earns…in 2014, that’s an embarrassment.” It is an obvious problem that is facing America, directly impacting our economy. Regardless of the source the numbers may vary just slightly, demonstrating the situation needs to be addressed in order to allow our economy

Discuss How Organization Structure Interacts With The External Environment To Affect Organizational Performance.

1256 words - 5 pages IntroductionToday's society is diverse and rapidly changing and it is the organisation's ability to adapt or be in fit with the external environment that will determine its overall performance. Ethical issues arise throughout all organisations daily activities but it is the continual debate about what is right or wrong that will shape ethical decision making now and for generations to come.This essay aims to investigate culture within the

Q. Discuss Whether Strategic Planning Is Worthwhile For Small Firms Or Not

1238 words - 5 pages Before I discuss whether Strategic Planning is worthwhile for small firms or not, I would like to briefly explain what strategic planning is.Various definitions of strategic planning have been offered in the literature. However, defining strategic planning remains a problem because it can be defined in many ways depending on the size and nature of the business. Planning does not seem to have clear definition of its own place in organisation