Resortive Justice To Discipline Students Essay

1971 words - 8 pages

For a long time it was thought that there is only one way to discipline students. But recently a new method has arisen and is becoming ever more popular. It is restorative justice. This method involves restorative practises that are meant to teach long term lessons while it’s opposite, zero-tolerance, is more of a short term solution. Zero-tolerance is punitive punishment for unruly behaviour that often consists of detention, suspension and expulsion. There are mixed views on which of these methods are better to use on students. This paper will analyse both methods and provide the public opinion as well as which method is better, based on the research.
Zero-Tolerance Section
Zero-tolerance is defined as the refusal to accept antisocial behaviour, typically by strict application of the law. The punishment for said behaviours is detention, suspension and expulsion. Zero-tolerance is meant to be used as a last resort by teachers and administrators but often ends up being used for minor offenses. Major offenses are: bringing a gun to school and assaulting a teacher or another student. Minor offenses include: being out of uniform, bringing a cell phone to class or using profanity or any kind of offensive language. It is often the case that those who are being persecuted fall under a certain demographic. These students are generally Latino or African American. According to an article by Graham in the “2008-09 school year, black students had 35 suspensions per 100 students; Latino students, 23 per 100; white students, 14 per 100; and Asian students, 5 per 100” (Graham). In “Proactive Discipline” the authors document that black male students are overrepresented in suspension and are punished for more subjective offenses, such as disrespect, than their white peers (Sharkey and Fenning).
There is a philosophy behind the zero-tolerance policy, “it is the presumption that strong enforcement can act as deterrent to other potentially disruptive students” (Skiba). This has to do with the “broken window” theory. In the theory it is said that the community should react to every little act of misconduct with brute force in order to get the message across. In the United States there have been thousands of reports that show that punishments are off the scale (Skiba). News reports document reports of students bringing knives to cut chicken in a lunch box, pointing a drawn gun at another student and the always present issue of weapon-like props as parts of Halloween costumes. These students have suffered expulsion and suspension for these seemingly harmless actions. The use of zero-tolerance has become increasingly popular in schools all over the country. In Chicago, IL since its implementation in 1995, the number of expulsions has risen from 81 to 1,000 three years later (Skiba).
The effects of zero-tolerance are as follows: schools with higher suspension and expulsion rates have lower test scores, the earlier the student gets a suspension the...

Find Another Essay On Resortive Justice to Discipline Students

My Philosophy of Education Essay

523 words - 2 pages people as desirable-- these include respect for others, courage, honesty, justice, a willingness to work, and self-discipline. I will do all I can to enable my students to function and even flourish as active participants in our classroom community by encouraging appropriate behavior. I will also encourage them to play positive roles in their families. Ultimately, I believe that part of elementary education is the preparation for productive civic

Classroom Behavior and Management Theories Essay

2771 words - 11 pages of the rest of the students in the community, be that the school or the classroom. Teachers begin by teaching students about their personal freedoms. The Bill of Rights was written to protect the three basic human values. These values are: Ø Freedom Ø Equality and Ø Justice More specifically stated they include The First Amendment- freedom of speech, press, peaceful assembly, and religion; The Fourth Amendment- the right to privacy and

The Knowledge is Power Program

1820 words - 7 pages place at a KIPP school. KIPP’s goal of getting their students to college, while an achievement worth noting, may be shortsighted in terms of the larger picture of social justice and equality. Educational progressives, social theorists and educational historians offer a different take on these schools, one that is difficult to quantify, but instructive nonetheless. First, KIPP schools utilize a strict method of discipline and control in order

Effective Discipline in the 21st Century

1322 words - 5 pages behavior is certainly one aspect to discipline, for learning it in an atmosphere of confusion is difficult. Children have to learn to conform to the rules of behavior needed in a classroom. However, discipline should be described as ongoing, proactive set of behaviors used to create a cooperative environment, which minimizes the likelihood of negative, disruptive behavior. Teachers have the right to ask for a quiet class, keep the students in

Classroom Discipline and Management for the Beginning Teacher

930 words - 4 pages it is unethical to use class management techniques just to keep students docile and quiet” (Education, 2001, p.436). Successful classroom management can set the stage for optimal learning, as well as reduce stress on the teacher. “Both professional and personal reasons underlie the need far a specific classroom management system. Virtually little or no learning can occur in a classroom bereft of effective management and discipline. In

Random Drug Testing in High schools

780 words - 3 pages place within a month of the time that child experimented with the drug, then they will suffer great consequences depending on the rules of that school. If a school goes as far as expelling students which fail the test then what justice is that to the children which are victims of circumstance and of experimentation, which is in place in all our lives.      Another problem with allowing schools to do random drug tests is the fact that we are

Literature Review on Behaviour modification strategies used in classrooms

2546 words - 10 pages youths of the society to acquire skills and knowledge that will help them become responsible contributors to society as adults and teachers are the facilitators of this learning process (Carey, 2003). However, better part of the teachers' role is to come up with solutions to the pervasive problem of maintaining discipline. Discipline is essential if students are going to learn unhampered by hostile disruptions (Osborn & Osborn, 1989; B. Rogers

Crime and Punishment in Medieval Europe

1212 words - 5 pages understanding into the different forms of torture in medieval Europe, and how it compares to punishment in modern day Australia. In the following lesson, students will be continuing discussions about the comparison of medieval crimes and punishment to the evolution of the nature of justice. This will transition into developing students’ knowledge on the Australian legal system and origin of common and statutory law. Students will then learn about

Education and Teaching - It's Time for Uniforms in Public Schools

965 words - 4 pages violent. Today it is a different story. I read the paper and listen to the news of school violence. Kids shooting kids. Children as young as 8 years old bring guns to school. These situations scare me to death. I try to remember when I was going through middle and elementary school and how I would have felt if school uniforms were mandated. I can not really tell you how I would have felt 15 years ago but some students may argue that wearing school

Corporal Punishment

1770 words - 7 pages officials could face criminal charges in such cases. Justice Powell of the Supreme Court says, civil and criminal charges are enough to protect students who receive beatings that are unfair or too harsh. He continues to say, this can develop to be too expensive and time consuming and that the country is split on this issue… yet we can discern no trend towards the elimination of corporal punishment by making it so costly (Hyman and Wise, 1979


1210 words - 5 pages While at school, we have learned about many different philosophies when it comes to dealing with student's behavior. There are some philosophies that are very stringent and harsh, and some that are really wishy-washy and too lenient. Personally I believe that Lee Canter's positive reinforcement and assertive discipline work best for the entire spectrum of students. In order to teach successfully, a teacher must have circumstances that make it

Similar Essays

School Internet Policies Essay

1127 words - 5 pages Students today receive discipline from school officials for expressing their opinions online. On social media sites, some school administrators monitor students’ activity using fake accounts to pry into their lives. However, schools do not have the authority to punish students for what they post on the internet when off campus. Since high school students use social networking sites to connect with others and express their ideas, school officials

Schools Should Eliminate The Use Of Zero Tolerance Policies

957 words - 4 pages plastic knives for peeling an orange. In each case, the goal of utilizing a policy of zero-tolerance has been that a strong enough message will have been sent to students that a more serious defiance of the rule will be averted in the future. I believe this intention fails on two counts: it does not deter worse events from taking place and is actually a mockery of true justice. First of all, the separate actions encompassed in zero-tolerance

Engaging Students Essay

1371 words - 5 pages Introduction Managing a classroom is very important element of teaching. It can also be very difficult, especially when teachers must discipline students for unruly behavior. Many researchers have identified and employed many strategies that help teachers to manage their classrooms and discipline students with dignity and fairness to their students. While there are many strategies, it is vital that teachers choose one and employ it with

Zero Tolerance Policies In American Schools

1172 words - 5 pages In all grades of education, from kindergarten to college, there is a form of discipline known as a zero tolerance policy. While the exact wording is different from school to school, basically a zero tolerance policy means that a student is immediately suspended, asked to attend an alternative school, or expelled if they are suspected or caught doing certain things. These policies are in place to hopefully deter students from doing drugs or being