This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Resource Curse Essay

587 words - 3 pages

Introduction
This field paper will discuss the controversy on the existence of ‘resource curse’. Resource curse is an economic paradox which states that countries and regions having an abundant base of natural resources, especially non-renewable and point-sources are likely to have worse performance in economic development and economic growth. This term was first raised in the book ‘Sustaining Development in Mineral Economies: The Resource Curse Thesis’ (Auty, 1993). He describe in this book that country with rich natural resources, like Bolivia, Peru and others, failed to take advantage of this preponderance. Contrarily, they have lower economic growth and poorer disciplined development policies. In one word, they perform worse than less endowed countries. (Auty, 1993) It is still controversial in the academic world that if resource curse exits or not. This paper will summarize the literatures into three ...view middle of the document...

The autarkic development prematurely boost the rapid expansion of heavy and chemical industry, requiring primary sector to meet ‘the foreign exchange and revenue transfer needs of the economy’; while actually primary sector shrinks as per capital incomes rise and foreign exchange become constrained by tariff protection and policy transfers, proving that autarkic development is unsustainable. As a result, Economic growth becomes ‘erratic and slow’.
Sachs and Warner (1995) write about the evidence that support resource curse’s existence. Their research shows that economies in 71 countries with endowed natural resources exports to GDP in 1971 tended to have lower growth rates during the subsequent period 1971-1989, proving that economies with rich resources grow less rapidly than those with fewer natural resources. In their later working paper, Sachs and Warner (1997) improve their research and gain a similar result, changing the base year to 1970 and extending the subsequent period to 1990. Their research shows that there is actual negative correlation between natural resources and economic growth. Davis (2013) replicates Sachs and Warner’s research. He does a statistical replication of Sachs and Warner’s 1997 paper, with some improvement to the research method, gaining the same result.
Xu and Han (2005) explore the regional disparity between provinces in China and consider it as a result of resource curse. They use the percentage that basic reserves of coal, petroleum and natural gas in each province take up in national proportion to measure natural resource in each province and use it as the abundance index. 1978 is the base year and the subsequent period is 1978 to 2003. They generate a scatter diagram (figure 1) that has the abundance index as horizontal axis and the annual growth rate of GDP in each province as the vertical axis. The diagram show a clear pattern that the dots—representing every province—approximately converges to a left-to-right high-to-low fit line, showing that in this 25-year period, the economic growth in provinces with abundant natural resources are much slower than provinces with deficient natural resources.

Find Another Essay On Resource Curse

Democratic Republic of Congo: Development Policy Issues

1593 words - 6 pages outright, but the problems in its former colony remained.” (Snow). The major development policy issue reflected in this media article is the notion of a resource curse. The resource curse is a concept constructed by Paul Collier on the political economy of natural resources and its effects on a countries’ development. In short, Collier asserts that countries with an abundance of natural resources, especially those that are rare, do not develop at

Comparing failed states Essay

1945 words - 8 pages Examining the degree of state failure between contemporary Georgia in to the moderate degree of state failure in present-day Serbia, this essay argues that the resource curse most significantly accounts for the disjuncture in regime capabilities and potency found across these cases. The availability of large oil and natural gas resources in the context of the Georgian case, the country’s state never faced pressures to engage in significant

Having a natural resource means to be poor: paradox or consistent pattern?

885 words - 4 pages society. As Dorcas Onigbinde note “the notion of natural resource curse is closely linked to poor resource management as it creates stagnation and conflict, rather than economic growth and development” (2008, p.3). Moreover sometimes governments have no the effective system for sharing and distributing income among country's population. Country's populations do not get any benefits from producing of state's resource, only people in governmental

Failure of State Intervention

1315 words - 6 pages , particularly, African countries still struggling so much? Much like the natural resource curse, underdeveloped regions in Africa perpetually struggle to survive and develop meanwhile receiving millions, billions, sometimes trillions in aid. I would call this phenomenon the financial lending curse. The natural resource curse identifies the economic struggle faced in Africa in regions rich in natural resources, but see little to no financial returns

Odysseus the Epic by Homer

1253 words - 5 pages and there are no storms. In addition to that delay, Poseidon puts a curse on Odysseus when Odysseus taunts and teases Polyphemus the Cyclops. This curse makes the journey home much more extended due to the gods involving themselves. Odysseus has to travel to Hades during his journey home to receive his prophecy, which is an extremely dangerous place to have to travel to. While in Hades, Odysseus suffers pity and sadness while seeing the spirit of

Teachers Have Standards Too

1315 words - 6 pages well as what the crude words the students are communicating mean in the proper form of statement. In addition, teachers could near to abolish curse words by sending students who violate the school’s contract stating that the students agree with the school’s standards, including language parameters, to the vice principle to be dealt with. The art of the cleanliness of words is mainly important for students because obscene language is unacceptable

Untitled

604 words - 2 pages a bald headed teacher with a head so hollow. a day for a final a speech to be exact id liek to use his head as my mat!!! stupid twat!rhymeing is fun its something to do maybe you should try it you might liek it to.! im the new dr. seus ryhme if you can writing out of my butis my plan. a curse for a curse is it usualbe here? or will there be big fluffy reindeer driving rihgt near? ahh 250 words needed to be seen...for me to copy other papers so

WHY IS THE NEXUS BETWEEN NATURAL RESOURCES AND ARMED CONFLICT ONE OF THE BIGGEST GLOBAL CHALLENGES? WHAT ARE ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR THE PROMOTION OF PEACE AND JUSTICE?

1245 words - 5 pages ), 3][5: Michael L. Ross, "What Do We Know about Natural Resources and Civil War?", Journal of Peace Research, Vol. 41, No. 3 (May, 2004), pp. 337-356 (Sage Publications, Ltd.), 343]Another economic consequence of the resource dependence curse is a sudden oversupply of revenues. Although this may seem, and actually is, an opportunity for investment and further economic development, most countries fail to manage these incomes properly, frequently

Authorization of Resource Rights

1745 words - 7 pages . Nine proposes to consider at resource rights through the prism of legitimate political authority, which is based on two principles, desert and efficiency. Nevertheless, both authors agree that current dictatorial rulers are not legitimately authorized to use resources of a country for their individual interests. Works Cited 1. Wenar, L. 2008. Property Rights and the Resource Curse. Philosophy and Public Affairs 36 (1). 2. Nine, C. 2013. Resource Rights. Political Studies 61: 232 – 249.

The Last Man and the Plague of Empire

1258 words - 5 pages England's prime resource is its people (its "children" [323]) whereas the greatest assets of the equatorial regions are their commodities--their spices, plants, and fruits. Verney further sentimentally recalls Britain's history of unshrinking exploration (read colonization and economic exploitation) of foreign nations under the crown's sponsorship, as he grieves for lost "times when man walked the earth fearless

Is Availability of Petroleum Products a Curse or Blessing to Nigeria?

2225 words - 9 pages relationship between economic growth and natural resource abundance and the sustained poor performance on such social indicators such as education and health. These oil -related negative outcomes have come to be referred to as oil resource curse which operates through a number of channels. Therefore, from documented work and present crisis in the Niger Delta, availability of petroleum products in Nigeria is a curse rather than blessing following the

Similar Essays

The Resource Curse And Development Essay

2175 words - 9 pages In another study by Arezki and van der Ploeg provide a new cross-country empirical proof for resource curse effect. They cast a research based on World Bank’s World Development Indicators and conclude that there is a strong negative relationship between natural resources and income per capita. However de jure openness—which means ‘the number of years that a country is rated open to international trade’—and de facto trade openness—which means

Resource Based Economy: Blessing Or Curse Essay

3252 words - 13 pages Resource-Based Economy: Blessing or Curse Russia is not only the largest country on our planet, but also the richest in terms of natural resources. Russia has more than 20% of world reserves of natural resources. There are more than 10% of the global oil reserves, one third of gas, about 25% of mineral ores. Moreover, it has 9% of the world’s arable land, over 20% of the world forest area and it posses the largest reserves of fresh water

The Resource Curse: Democracy And The Developing World

1666 words - 7 pages When a country strikes oil, or some other valuable natural resource, they may take it as a blessing; however, this discovery is often very destructive. Recent studies in social sciences suggest that developing countries with resource wealth tend to have political crises. This paradox is called the resource curse- the political counterpart of the infamous Dutch disease (Lam et al., 2002)*. In this paper I will argue how this phenomenon not

Book Review

1816 words - 8 pages Book Evaluation: Pauline Jones Luong and Erika Weinthal. Oil is not a curse: ownership structure and institutions in Soviet successor states (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2010) In the book Oil Is Not a Curse, the authors test their hypothesis about the underlying causal mechanisms for resource curse through congruence procedures, and conclude by proposing an edge-cutting argument: whoever owns and controls the mineral sector affects