This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Respect And Status In Violence Essay

1585 words - 7 pages

Kevin Powers and Geoffrey Canada both describe violence and its effects on people in their novels. They assert that violence profoundly changes a person; however, they differ on the merits of these changes. Canada concludes that violence teaches people and helps them grow, while Powers concludes that it dehumanizes and scars them. The two authors also disagree on the necessity of violence. Specifically, Canada argues that violence is necessary and is used to gain distinction and status, while Powers argues that violence is unnecessary and causes people to lose their singularity and identity. Even further, Canada believes violence protects the boys and their lives, while Powers believes violence kills the young soldiers. From their personal experiences, Canada claims boys in the South Bronx need to be violent to gain respect and to survive, while Powers claims the violence of war is a waste of young men’s lives as they lose respect and even their lives.

Geoffrey Canada’s characters in Fist Stick Knife Gun use violence to increase their status and honor, and to make themselves stand out from the rest of their group as being more powerful. Canada’s violence is necessary to his characters as it is their only way to distinguish different people’s power. Canada’s characters also use violence to save their lives, as the adults in their life cannot protect the children. Canada writes: “status was a major issue for boys on the block” (Canada 18), a very blunt yet compelling statement that describes the importance of “status” for the boys on the block. “On the block,” respect and power means everything, as social order is decided by these qualities. Canada argues that in the South Bronx this “status” and social order could only be decided through fights, as described in the third chapter of FSKG. “Everyone, and I mean everyone, had to prove he could beat boys his age” (Canada 21). For the purpose of gaining status, every boy “had to prove he could beat boys his age.” If a boy could not fight, he had no power or status as all status stemmed from the boys’ skill at fighting. The boys had to “fight different people on the block until it could be ascertained exactly where they fit in” (Canada 22). Everybody needed to “fit in” on the block, and fighting was the way to decide where they fit. All life on the block was dictated by the “clear pecking order within the groups as well as between them” (Canada 21). This “pecking order” was also extremely important as “it was used to resolve disputes that arose over games, or girls, or money, and also to maintain order and discipline on the block” (Canada 22). Violence needed to be the basis for the “pecking order” so that there was an easy hierarchical way to “resolve disputes.” Violence also served as a method of instruction that even mothers in the South Bronx used. After Canada’s brothers recover their jacket from the thief in chapter one, Canada writes, “[Mothers] feel their job is to turn their child into a lion...

Find Another Essay On Respect and Status in Violence

The Roles of Respect in “Spanglish” and “The Stolen Party

714 words - 3 pages To dwell in a society, respect is genuinely relevant. It construes the dignity of an individual. Ideally, it is interpreted as a gratitude value of someone or something and several people believe that respect is an act of conduct others with just and kindness. However from some individual’s point of view, it means much more than just an act of appreciation. It is the cornerstone of the social order in which we exist. As seen in the scripts of

Media Violence and Violence in Society

1442 words - 6 pages “If television causes aggression and violent behavior, assuming that the television programming contains some violence, there should be more and more violent crime after television is available” (Freedman). Many suggest the violence in media is causing violence in society but then how is it that violent crimes are actually decreasing in the United States. The violence that is occurring is actually due from the mentally ill, poor parenting, and

The Role and Status of Women in Buddhism and Confucianism

1292 words - 5 pages The role and status of women in any religion in the word is known to be controversial. In Buddhism and Confucianism, women are seen as unequal and some of their belief promotes gender inequality. As outsiders of both main Chinese religions, we wonder how women put up with the gender inequalities. Women go through with the inequalities because they respect their faith and believe deeply in the teachings of Buddha for Buddhism, and

Social Status in Mrs. Dalloway and Pride and Prejudice

1646 words - 7 pages , because with her high status she is able to control everyone around her. Similarly, with the marriage of Wickham to Lydia Bennet, it makes it clear how important social class really is. Wickham will do anything to gain a higher social standing, and the Bennet’s are doing everything in their power to protect their daughter’s social standing. When Lydia and Wickham run off together and decide to get married it brings shame to the rest of the

The Changing Role and Status of Women in Britain

2466 words - 10 pages The Changing Role and Status of Women in Britain 1. Explain why women failed to gain the right to vote between 1900 and 1914. In the twentieth century women’s role in society was hugely different to what it is today. Women were regarded as being inferior to men and were treated as such. Although girls were given a compulsory state education 1870, few went to university and those who did were not awarded a

Relationship between socioeconomic status and health in Australia

2569 words - 10 pages SynopsisIn reporting to the NSW Minister of Health on "the relationship between socioeconomic status & health", a number of issues and variables need to be examined. These include:the health inequalities of all Australiansmigrant healthclass and healthgender and healthaboriginality and healtholder age and healtheffect of politics and policyways of reducing the difference in healthFor the purposes of this study, I will examine how the

Society and Status in Charlotte Bronte´s Jane Eyre

670 words - 3 pages considered upper class, because of her higher education, or lower class, because of her servant-status within the family. Bronte also puts in question the relationship development between two people of different classes, such as Rochester’s and Jane’s. Charlotte Bronte demonstrates that class boundaries are not finite and that individuals can transcend them. Since the beginning of the novel, Jane's ambiguous class status is evident. Jane is a poor

The Role of Socioeconomic Status and Race in Cancer Prognosis

1318 words - 6 pages Approximately 15 million cancer cases exist today around the world, with an estimated 24 million increase in the next twenty years (Ferlay et al., 2013). It is evident that the number of individuals facing a cancer diagnosis is rising and will continue to do so. Recent studies explored the correlation between socioeconomic status, race and cancer prevalence. Inadequate access to health care programs, higher exposure to drugs and alcohol, and

Status Changes Everything in Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen

772 words - 4 pages Bracknell won’t let Jack get married to Gwendolen, but he goes after her anyway. When status affects the relationship, it can change your viewpoint completely about someone. In Pride and Prejudice, Miss Bingley continues chasing Mr. Darcy although he shows no interest in her. Even though Miss Bingley can't take a hint and stop trying to flirt with him, she tries to criticize Elizabeth to Darcy to get his attention. Miss Bingley started talking to Mr

The role and status of women in Viking Age

1839 words - 7 pages Scandinavian R5BThe role and status of women in Viking AgeWith the general growth of feminist work in many academic fields, it is hardly surprising that the research on the role and status of women in Viking age has attracted considerable attention in recent years. There is a substantial amount of research on this and the expanding corpus of research addresses itself to all of the major dimensions of Viking women's lives. While some research has

The Status of Women and the Bhaki Movement in India

2673 words - 11 pages Rana 1 Ankita Rana Professor Rajkumar M.A. English IV Semester 21 April 2014 The Status of Women and The Bhakti Movement in India Originating in ancient Tamil Nadu, the Bhakti movement in India spread to the north during the late medieval ages when north India was under Islamic rule. The movement was spontaneous and counter to the predominant caste ideology which was dividing Hinduism. The adherents of the movement had their own rendering of

Similar Essays

Crime And Violence: Influence Of Socioeconomic Status

644 words - 3 pages There are many theories about why crime and violence exist in society. Sociologist have many perspectives on crime. While some believe that crime is caused by biological factors like race and ethnicity. Most people believe that crime is caused by a person’s socioeconomic status or their income. Socioeconomic status influence visibility which determines who is labeled as a criminal. Of the many theories about crime, one that sticks out is the

Violence In Sports With Respect To Marty Mc Sorley

1198 words - 5 pages abolishment of extreme violence in hockey. With respect to extreme violence, NHL vice President Colin Campbell says "It sends a message that you can't strike another player with your stick, particularly in the head. And when you do, the repercussions will be severe.8" Physical contact is an exciting part of hockey and should be kept in the game. Unnecessary violence, such as in McSorley's incident, should be severely disciplined. The biggest problem

Sorcery, Status, And Scandal In "Arabian Nights"

1431 words - 6 pages “implicit belief in magic is entertained by almost all Muslims”. This leads to the examination of the forbidden nature of magic, and why sorcerers are viewed in such a negative light. Furthermore, the wider question of the implications status may have on the portrayal and punishment of magicians will be explored. Magic in the time of the Arabian Nights was divided into two categories: spiritual and natural. Natural magic involved prestidigitation and

Health And Wellness, Mental And Emotional Health, Respect And Non Violence, Nutrition And Fitness, Addiction, Human Sexuality

1397 words - 6 pages time comes. Someone who is determined to become healthy should be well versed in subjects such as: Mental and Emotional health, respect and non-violence, nutrition and fitness, controlling addiction, and human sexuality. One must remember that wellness is not only the optimal condition of the body, but also of the mind. Many physical problems can be solved through the mind, your mind's thoughts and decisions are often expressed through the