This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

H.J. Mc Closkey's On Being An Atheist

1703 words - 7 pages

In the article “On Being an Atheist”, H. J. McCloskey tries to show that believing in God is unreasonable. McCloskey first tries to point out flaws in theism by trying to disprove the cosmological and the teleological arguments. After trying to show the flaws in the two argument he brings up the problem of evil to try to discredit theism as a self-contradictory belief. At the end of his article he tries to show his readers that atheism is comforting and that theism is not. When you go through McCloskey’s argument it shows many flaws in his reasoning as he wanted to show that it is impossible that there is a God. Throughout McCloskey’s article he refers to that theist do not a proofs that there is a God, thus they should not be used. The problem with this is that atheist and theist would have to purge of most of their arguments for the reason that most everything does not prove the argument.
McCloskey is correct that the “proofs” do not completely establish that there is a God, but they do give us a better understanding about the world and if there is a God. The cosmological and the teleological arguments are only argument, thus they do not completely prove that there is a God as Dr. Foreman says, “that these argument give us a best explanation” (Foreman). McCloskey is wrong in saying that the arguments should be abandoned for the reason that, even though that they do not completely prove that there is a God, they are “starting blocks” that need to be better refined to make a more complete argument for a necessary being, such as the God of Christianity. If you were to abandon these arguments that do not completely prove what they were trying to, you would have abandoned many other augments such as evolution.
There must be a necessarily being for the reason that at some time, even if it was in the infinite past, there must have been some kind of being or action that created the original activation energy of the universe. Everything around us had to have or has some type of energy that caused us to exist. McCloskey is wrong in saying that were is no proof that in the world existing. Steven Evans says that all things are being that exist and do not have to exist which are call contingent, thus there must be some type of necessarily being that caused all contingent beings to happen. McCloskey does not take into account that there must have been something that gave everything a cause in life.
The cosmological argument does not completely prove there is a God for the reason that the cause of the universe could be assumed to be the big bang theory not a necessarily being such as God. Although the cosmological does not completely prove there is a God, it does get the theologist closer to being able to prove there is indeed a God. When you pair the cosmological argument with other arguments, such as the teleological argument, it makes the argument for God even stronger. Again, these are incomplete arguments that need to be refined into better stronger...

Find Another Essay On H.J. McCloskey's On Being an Atheist

The Necessary Proofs for the Belief in God Explained in “On Being an Athiest,” by H.J. McClosky

1607 words - 7 pages The article “On Being an Athiest,” by H.J. McClosky, was very interesting. McClosky basically lets us know that as atheists they do not believe in God and why they do not believe in the God that theists do. According to McCloskey, there are three proofs for a theist to believe in God; the cosmological, teleological, and the argument from design. McCloskey refers to the arguments for God as proofs, and he suggests that we cannot establish a

Critical Analysis of McCloskey’s Arguement in "On Being an Athiest"

1523 words - 7 pages In this response, the author would like to state he is a Christian and finds the chapter to be very difficult to read. The chapter, “On Being an Atheist”, can be very convincing if the reader is not strong in their beliefs. Being a new Christian for over a year, the author of this response wants to make a statement that the spiritual warfare Christians believe in, has taken place this week. Atheist believes in no God. Therefore, they would

The Effect of Being an Only Child on the Child's Personality

1141 words - 5 pages The Effect of Being an Only Child on the Child's Personality Literature Review: Before a child has friends they have their family. Everything that they know and love about the world mostly comes from what they see around in their house. Children usually find role models in their family most of the time it is the child’s sibling. Yet only children don’t have that experience of living with another child and begin to develop their

Research Paper on Mcdonald's Being an Evil Corporation. Mainly Mcdonald's Being The Worst Compared to any Other Fast Food Restaurant Out There

1597 words - 6 pages well.Eating at McDonald is an option but being a supporter and encouraging people to eat right isn't a crime. McDonald can do this by reducing the fattening in their food or letting their customers know what they are dealing with.McDonald is not only a threat to human health but animals and our precious environment as well. McDonald is destroying the rainforest. How can the process of selling burgers be linked to the rainforest? Hard to believe there's a

Being a Hero, an essay on the Aeneid and how the gods make a hero who he is Sometimes a little wordy,

1439 words - 6 pages out and shine.Aeneas accomplishes much and earns immense glory throughout the Aeneid. Nevertheless, this achievement of hero status relies on the assistance of the gods, and this assistance does not necessarily come in a positive form. Juno causes storms, hate, and war, either to stop Aeneas or at least make things more difficult for him. Venus, the divine mother, does everything she can to counteract the obstacles that Juno makes. Other gods and supernatural beings all play a part in affecting Aeneas' life. Without all this divine intervention, Aeneas would have been an uninteresting, average Joe.

The old image of elderly person on being one, who is in firm, stays at home, and leads a thoroughly depressing life is rapidly changing as an image of the 21st century

842 words - 3 pages Gray MarketThe old image of elderly person on being one, who is in firm, stays at home, and leads a thoroughly depressing life is rapidly changing as an image of the 21st century. As our population ages and people are living longer and healthier lives, the game is rapidly changing. The newer and more accurate image of an older person who is active, interested in what life has to offer, and is enthusiastic consumer with the means and willingness

When is drug testing not nearly enough? This essay is about the pre-employment tests that are being used in order for an applicant to get a job. It focuses on drug testing and psychological testing

1822 words - 7 pages tests, tests are legal as long as they are being used for the right purposes. "For example, it is legal to test accounting applicants with a math test, however, it could be considered discriminatory practice to screen custodial employees with the same math test as the math competency for an account is very different than a custodian" (Employment Legal).There are different types of tests on the market today. They can measure hundreds of different

An intersting perspective on character analysis, as seen by consideration being given to decisions that characters make. ("The Scarlet Letter", "Hunger of Memory" and "Catch-22")

1607 words - 6 pages positive manner and ultimately could change the course of events radically or insignificantly. An analysis of the choices made and how the characters came about to making those choices reveals a great wealth of information and provides an avenue into the psyche of the character and the situation they are in. Catch-22 by Joseph Heller, The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne, and Hunger of Memory by Richard Rodriguez are three very different books

King versus McCloskey: Does God Exist?

2070 words - 9 pages H.J. McCloskey wrote a journal article in 1968 called “On Being an Atheist” which denounced the existence of the Intelligent Designer. He uses different tactics to try and prove that there could not be a God. McCloskey shows that his argument for atheism is not sound as the evidence he proves in his article can be combatted with well-thought responses provided by philosophers and Christians in order to show there is the possibility God exists

Response to the Atheist

1847 words - 8 pages The article “On Being an Atheist” by H.J. McCloskey provides much insight into the atheistic viewpoint. It provides comparison to the opposing theistic perspective pertaining to the existence of God. It argues for the reasons and virtues behind the belief of atheism to prove its superiority over theism as a source of strength. In the essay, McCloskey refers to arguments like the cosmological argument, teleological argument, and arguments from

A response to an atheist

1612 words - 7 pages . Philosophy of Religion: Thinking About Faith (2nd ed.). Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2009. Craig, William Lane, Reasonable Faith: Christian Truth and Apologetics, 3rd Ed.,Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 2008. McCloskey, H.J. “On Being an Atheist”. Question 1. February 1968.

Similar Essays

H.J. Mc Closkey's On Being An Atheist

1761 words - 7 pages Response to McCloskey Introduction In his article “On Being an Atheist”, H.J. McCloskey, an Australian philosopher took a serious stance on arguments against the existence of God. He offered numerous reasons for the stance he took including, the problem with evil to suggest that one should not believe in God. McCloskey believes that atheism is a much more comfortable and understandable belief as opposed to believing in God who allows the

On Being An Atheist, By H.J. Mc Closkey

1495 words - 6 pages In the article “ On Being an Atheist,” H.J. McCloskey attempts to inform his readers that the belief in atheism is a “much more comfortable belief” by effectively using a disdainful rhetoric towards theists and their faith. McCloskey delves into both the Cosmological and Teleological arguments, which within he criticizes the arguments and to further his argument against theism, he also presents the Problem of Evil and why evil cannot possibly

On Being An Atheist An Article By H.J. Mc Closkey

1933 words - 8 pages reasons can't be endless, important there was a cause that was autonomous and not created by an alternate reason. References Craig William Lane. The Absurdity of Life without God., n.d. Web February 28, 2013. Evans, C. Stephen and Manis R. Zachary. Philosophy of Religion, 2nd Ed. Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2009. Print. Keller, Timothy. The Reason for God. New York, NY: Riverhead, 2008. Print. McCloskey, H.J. “On Being an Atheist,” Question 1: 51-54. Print.

Mc Closkey's On Being An Athiest Essay

1900 words - 8 pages McCloskey in "On Being an Atheist" argues in favor of atheism and attempts to discredit theism. He uses many tactful approaches in disputing theism such as the arguments for God as a whole failing to establish a case for God. Focusing on the Cosmological argument, McCloskey claims that the existence of all that we see fulfills no grounds for there to exist a God or necessary being. He furthers the argument by stating that the cosmological