Response To Michael Pollan’s Essay “Escape From The Western Diet”

884 words - 4 pages

In the essay “Escape from the Western Diet”, an excerpt from the book “In Defense of Food: An Eater’s Manifesto”, Michael Pollan pitches in on the debate regarding the dietary regime of Western culture. Pollan brings into equation various theories on how the Western diet has led to our society becoming one of the unhealthiest countries in the world. He also asserts his own position on the topic while briefly responding to each individual theory. So what is the principal blame for the diseases and illnesses associated with consuming a Westernized diet?
Theories are wide and lasting: overabundances or deficiencies of certain nutrients; industrial processing; environmental issues; the Western world’s implementation on the raising of crops and cattle; just to name a few. In the end however, as Pollan put it, “they are only theories…of an empirical phenomenon” and thus, should be viewed as such. Whatever the reason for our diet being as insalubrious as it may be, one thing is clear, at least in Pollan’s mind: we need to “stop eating a Western diet.”
When it comes to the topic of nutrition and eating habits, most of us will readily agree with Pollan in the instance that we as Americans are perhaps the worst offenders. To be honest, it’s quite hard to disagree with him here. Whether stereotypical or not, staples of the Western diet emit a worldwide assumption that we are a burger-eating, soda-drinking, donut-devouring nation; all unhealthy foods might I add. Is this the case for everyone? Of course not, but that’s one of the ways citizens of the United States are negatively perceived.
It’s also difficult to argue with Pollan’s desire for wanting to escape the Western diet. We are after all, a nation succumbed by a great many diseases, and our diet is a major contributor to such. While I agree with Pollan up to a certain extent, this agreement ends on the solution he believes we should take in order to secure a more salubrious lifestyle.
Pollan makes reference to Dr. Denis Burkitt and the theory of how we should return “back to the bush” in order to cure disease. In other words, this essentially means that we should return to “the diet and lifestyle of our ancestors.” While Pollan states that this is an unattractive strategy for combating the Western diet—and I support that claim—I would say that his own intentions aren’t far off from Burkitt’s theory. Pollan sums up his plan in just seven short words: “Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants.” This sounds relatively simple, but how hands-on is...

Find Another Essay On Response to Michael Pollan’s essay “Escape from the Western Diet”

Escape...essay about what I do to escape from the problems and anxiety of life. Can be used as an essay for scholarships or college applications

467 words - 2 pages Life is tough. No one is going to deny it. Instead, everyone finds a place they can go to escape from the problems and anxiety of life. It doesn't matter what you may be suffering from, or how happy and nice a person you are, everyone needs to flee from life. When life is getting tough, I love to retreat to the football field. The football field is my sanctuary, during a game. All the turmoil and troubles that may be swirling around us

The Escape from Sobibor Essay

934 words - 4 pages remembered forever, they had to courage to fight back, the courage to take a stand to those who had mercilessly murdered their brothers and sisters. (enter revised thesis statement) The Escape from Sobibor cannot be measured by the number of survivors who escaped the barbed wire horror, but by the number of lives that were changed by the courageous Jews who refused to die without fighting. The Escape from Sobibor can be considered one of the most

Concerns in the Western Diet

1811 words - 7 pages ingredients and just really are not food. Michael Pollan discusses these issues in his book titled In Defense of Food: An Eater’s Manifesto. Pollans’ goal from this book is to inform people, mainly the eaters of the western diet, what this diet is and what it contains. He furthers his argument on defying the food we eat in Part three, Chapter two “Eat Food: Food Defined”. Pollan, in this chapter, breaks down the foods we buy then eat, and how we

The Death of Humanity: A Response to Michael Levin’s Article,

1565 words - 7 pages sexual abuse to the prisoners was taking place the American people were outraged to know that our soldiers had committed such hideous acts of inhumanity. The following article comes from The New Yorker author Seymour M. Hersh and was published in May 2010, the article is in response to the thousands of prisoners that were detained at Abu Ghraib. “Abu Ghraib [was a] U.S. military prison. Most of the prisoners, however—by the fall there were

What Should We Eat essay about the Western Diet - Mesa Eng 101 - Essay

589 words - 3 pages What Should We Eat? According to Michael Pollan’s article entitled “Escape from the Western Diet”(2008) and Steven Shapin’s article entitled “What Are You buying When You Buy Organic?”(2006), each author constructs a criticism for what’s healthy and what’s not. Pollan claims the food industry is to blame because they use different nutritional theories to release new products, and that the health industry is to blame because they use theories to

"It's very difficult to escape from the prison of tradition

1649 words - 7 pages "It's very difficult to escape from the prison of tradition. Education is so strong, it holds you like a chain. I didn't get completely free then, but I tried. I unlearned to draw. I had to forget with my hand." -Marcel Duchamp The legacy of an artist can be judged by two merits, first the work they left behind, and second the influence of those works on later artists. The evolution of European and American art throughout the 20th century was

Escape from the Freshman 15

1183 words - 5 pages curb, but they left me a present in the form of thirty pounds of fat. The American diet turned me from a pebble on the seashore to a mountain in the Himalayas. I always thought that I had a fast metabolism, but instead I got a double dose of the Freshman Fifteen. Today I’ve turned my situation around, so I conducted a survey to see if students in De Anza are keeping a healthy lifestyle. I

Escape from the Red Sea

2384 words - 10 pages Escape Through The Red Sea Exodus 14: 10-20 10 As Pharaoh drew near, the Israelites looked back, and there were the Egyptians advancing on them. In great fear the Israelites cried out to the LORD. 11They said to Moses, ‘Was it because there were no graves in Egypt that you have taken us away to die in the wilderness? What have you done to us, bringing us out of Egypt? 12Is this not the very thing we told you in Egypt, “Let us alone and let

Escape from Oppression - An essay which uses two literarty works to explore the theme of women's oppression from a feminist perspective (using feminist criticism)

1290 words - 5 pages "Aunt Jennifer's Tigers" by Adrienne Rich tells of the repressed Aunt Jennifer who produces scenes representing freedom and fearlessness, but in reality is trapped and powerless. Only through her artistic expression is she able to find a temporary release from her entrapment. In "Trifles", Minnie Wright allows herself to be subjugated for thirty years before she frees her whole self, through drastic means that leads to a more permanent solution

Response to the Environmental Issue from Hell

663 words - 3 pages The essay opens up with McKibben talking about how the political campaign against global warming is flawed because at our current point there is nothing much that can be done to fix it.(Mckibben,1) He then goes to state that humans are the biggest culprit behind global warming and supports this by giving examples such as SUVs and American ignorance.(2,9) He concludes by saying that if ten percent of America were to go green, it still would not

Can a change of diet from traditional (indigenous) to western have any discernable effect on one’s health and welfare?

1667 words - 7 pages disease for Australian Aboriginals is discussed. Concluding with how changing from a traditional indigenous diet to a western diet can have a discernible effect on one‘s health and welfare. Geographical boundaries, climate, fauna, flora and how they influence the diet of the Noonuccal and Goenpul tribes Minjerribah is situated within Moreton Bay, 30kms south east of Brisbane, east of Cleveland (RCC, 2010a para. 1 & 7) (Map A1). A subtropical climate

Similar Essays

Michael Pollan’s Omnivore’s Dilemma Vs T. Campbell’s, The China Study

1717 words - 7 pages by Michael Pollan in the Omnivore’s Dilemma is most similar to what the best science recommends. Pollan embraces a diet that includes all healthy foods derived from wholesome sources, and therefore, best represents what modern nutritional sciences recommend. Pollan’s ideal view of a balanced diet is best supported by the science. Campbell on the other hand, repetitively and dogmatically calls for humans to become complete vegetarians, and to omit all animal protein from their diets. This rigid recommendation is not best supported by human nutritional sciences, nor do most people have the will or opportunity to engage as total vegetarians.

The Western Diet Essay

1030 words - 5 pages . Consequently, Americans likely choose the Western diet because of the convenience. Then the convenience of the Western diet makes Americans do not need sacrifice their own time for preparing meal. However, consuming the Western diet provides Americans a shorter life span. In the book In Defense of Food, author Michael Pollan says, “... We should simply avoid any food that has been processed to such an extent that it is more the product of

The Western Diet Essay

1203 words - 5 pages promotes obesity and then causes depression (1). More scientific evidence suggest that having a improper diet like the Western Diet negatively affects peripheral and central dopamine, which are neurotransmitters (chemical which transmit signals across the synapse from the nerve cell to the target cell) directly linked to the mental health of the brain and are negatively affected by high fat diets (4). Research has also suggested that having a poor

Personal Response To Literature Passage From "Wild Geese", Responding To Jude's Need To Escape

645 words - 3 pages Minor Assignment: Personal Response to LiteraturePassage from, Wild GeeseIn the passage from Wild Geese, two ideas convey to me about Jude's need to escape. The first idea is that Jude feels smothered by her daily surroundings, and second is that Jude is living two separate lives.Jude's farm life and family ultimately suffocate her. Jude's father, Caleb is controlling and overbearing. Caleb is constantly seeking control over Judith by pushing