Responsibility To Protect Essay

1984 words - 8 pages

Since its adoption by world leaders at the World Summit in 2005, the Responsibility to Protect (herein R2P) has been hailed as a major achievement in protecting populations from genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity, or ethnic cleansing that would be committed by rulers. However, some see the R2P not as an effective human right instrument for civilians’ protection as it appears to be another tool for imperialism. My position in this essay is that I believe the R2P doctrine is a considerable achievement in world politics as it signals to potential perpetrators of mass atrocities that the world would no longer stand by, but will use force when necessary to protect innocent civilians. My position is articulated as follows. First, I will present the content/principles of the R2P doctrine . Second, I will point out the legal and moral argument underpinning the R2P, particularly its military aspect. Finally I will evoke some cases where the R2P has been critical in protecting populations from mass killing and show the shortcoming of those who argue against the R2P.
First of all, the R2P clearly states that: i) the State has the primary responsibility to protect its population from heinous human rights abuses such as genocide, war crimes, crime against humanity and ethnic cleansing; ii) the international community has the responsibility to assist States in fulfilling their primary responsibility as indicated in point i) and as such, it should use appropriate diplomatic, humanitarian and other peaceful means to protect populations from those crimes; iii) however, when a State fails to protect its own populations or is the actual perpetrator of such crimes against its populations, the international community must be prepared to take stronger measures, including the collective use of forces (military intervention) with the authorization of the UN Security Council.
Second, the key principles of the R2P, known as the “precautionary Principles” are as follows:
1) The right intention, which stresses that the primary purpose of the military intervention, must be to halt or avert human suffering.
2) Last resort: this means that the use of force (military intervention) can only be undertaken when all the non-military options for the prevention or peaceful resolution of the crisis have been explored.
3) Proportional means: this principle indicates that the scale, the duration, as well as the intensity of the military intervention to be conducted should be the minimum necessary to secure the objective of human protection.
4) Reasonable prospects: to achieve the objective of human protection, there must be a reasonable chance of success in halting or averting the suffering of civilians justifying the intervention, with the consequences of the intervention not to be worse than the consequences of non-intervention (inaction).
Third and most importantly, the R2P defines the “Just Cause Threshold” justifying the military intervention. The threshold for...

Find Another Essay On Responsibility To Protect

The Sound and the Fury: Noblesse Oblige

1725 words - 7 pages The Sound and the Fury: Noblesse Oblige William Faulkner wrote The Sound and the Fury with many underlying themes. The most prominent theme in my opinion is noblesse oblige. Faulkner expresses The Compson’s noblesse oblige as they respond to a tragedy that affects each character in a unique way. Catherine, Jason, Quentin, and even Benjy executes a “responsibility to protect” their daughter and sister Caddy throughout the entire novel

Corporate Governance and Social Responsibility Essay

1337 words - 5 pages AbstractThe formal definition of social responsibility is "management's obligation to make choices and take actions that will contribute to the welfare and interests of society as well as the organisation." However, it is not as straightforward as it may seem. Having social citizenship means putting managerial ethics to practice and work. So how can we measure social responsibility of one company's ethical decision? With the competing demands

Corporate Responsibility

1662 words - 7 pages products and services and avoid misrepresentation (Atkins, 2006). It also protects consumers against consumption of goods which will endanger their health (Atkins, 2006). In this regard, business ethics and corporate social responsibility seek to protect the interests of customers who form the basis of companies’ survival. These principles reinforce the terms in Trade Description Act 1972, Sale and Supply of Goods Act 1994, Consumer Protection Act

Does social responsibility in a business contribute to its profits?

1062 words - 4 pages obligations. Social responsibility is somewhere in-between these two issues, and its role within an organisation is; to protect the environment and community, treat stakeholders fairly, help create a more stable global economic system and improve the synergism between the natural and human communities within their scope of influence (Petrick and Quinn, 2001: 1), in order to create the right perception in the marketplace. It is this perception that

Corporate Social Responsibility

2454 words - 10 pages importance to an understanding of social responsibility. The third dimension of social responsibility considers the outcomes of decisions in terms of who benefits from them. An acceptable decision outcome should either protect or promote the rights of those affected. There could be exceptional circumstances, which would justify minimising one of these dimensions. However, indiscriminate ignoring of these dimensions could undermine the legitimacy or, in


587 words - 3 pages even educate some Cherokees in English. The Cherokee nation also managed to incorporate a sense of responsibility when being put through the Indian Removal Act of 1830. This act enabled President Jackson to negotiate with the Cherokees for removal from their lands south, and they, in return, would receive lands west. Responsibility is shown through perseverence and accountability. Also responsibility consists of reliability. At this point, this

Some Differences between International Law and International Ethics

602 words - 3 pages Rights) can be written into a document that most states agree upon but not be considered a law. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights is not a treaty. It is a General Assembly resolution and the General Assembly cannot create binding treaties. Another example of ethical issues with no legal backing is the Responsibility to Protect innocent and defenseless peoples from violence and aggression. The Responsibility to Protect stems from the

What Do Grown Children Owe Their Parents?

995 words - 4 pages ; it is a moral responsibility to call an ambulance. The author fails to distinguish between the two types of "owe" that have been mentioned above. "Owe" simply represents responsibility. For example, if a person loves another person, a responsibility to look after the loved person comes into existence by itself. There is no legal system that will force a person to protect his/her loved ones. In a case, emotions take the policing role of the

Humanitarian Intervention

2049 words - 8 pages The debate of humanitarian intervention and the responsibility to protect have been discussed in international relations discourse more seriously within the last 60 years. The major historical developments which have led to an increase in the intensity of these debates have had beneficial and detrimental effects on Earth within the last 20 years. Several factors have contributed to this including; globalization, the rise in international

Who's at risk and who's to blame for a variety of occurance?

2057 words - 8 pages becomes the responsibility of the cigarette addict. The cigarette company seemingly performs more than the minimum obligation by also providing a product which fills the crave of addiction. Continued use of this addictive product may lead to detrimental health and lung disease. Cigarette companies attempt to protect themselves from such issues by warning users of the inherent dangers and therefore eliminating their responsibility for the result. After

Turn of the Screw Ambiguity

660 words - 3 pages suspense eventually gave way to hallucinations of people trying to harm the children. The governess admits that when she began to "take hold" of the children, the ghosts began to become more prevalent and threatening. On the contrary, the total responsibility awarded to the governess could have been to protect the children from ghosts, and she viewed it as a "magnificent chance" to keep them safe.The unclear causation in "Turn of the Screw" causes the

Similar Essays

The Responsibility To Protect: The Changing Definition Of Human Rights And The Ability To Protect Global Citizens

1214 words - 5 pages Liz PecanANTH 01211/3/2013Essay 2Section 404Colonization and Industrialization:The overall effect on GlobalizationThroughout history, various powers have expanded and exerted control onto what they deem to be lesser civilizations. As the world continues to change and grow, the impact of past formative processes continues to be seen in the current globalized world. There is a growing literature for the last few decades on globalization and on its

The Plight Of The Rohingya Essay

2516 words - 10 pages accentuated by ethnic communalism and simmering tensions which has existed for decades resulted in calls for the international community to intervene with the Responsibility to Protect (R2P) response to humanitarian crises for the Rohingya population. (Smith, 1995, p. 1) Wherever they seem to go, they still remain ‘stateless’, and can be described to not belong anywhere due to their ill treatment from the places they seek to settle within. (The Economist

Views On Corporate Social Responsibility Essay

1187 words - 5 pages good. Any outside interference is not needed and only harms business (Shaw & Barry, 2011). Also the “narrow” view is believed to protect interests of shareholders of corporations, as corporations first of all are created to satisfy their interests, which usually are clearly material. Social orientation of corporations decreases profits of shareholders. According to this view corporate responsibility concept can eliminate responsibility for

Social Responsibility Essay

860 words - 4 pages others such as libraries who need quiet. Around every business there is a social responsibility that needs to be maintained. Protecting a society is a great part of social responsibility. To protect can mean several things, for instance, the environment and the people. Police have the social responsibility to protect people from dangerous situations. This type of responsibility is a job but also something one chose to do, to benefit others. To