Restorative Justice In South Africa Can It Work?

1608 words - 6 pages

Introduction
In a society filled with crime, violence, and corruption prisons are overflowing and imprisonment often creates more hardened criminals, rather than creating rehabilitated persons. South Africa needs to adopt a less putative approach to the punishment of crimes, and restorative justice can either help achieve this or only worsen matters. In this essay I will evaluate this punishment theory with regard to case law, legislation and various implementations relating to the matter. In evaluating these, I will develop my own opinion on restorative justice and its efficacy in a South African context.
Restorative justice: background and history
The main aim of restorative justice is to involve the perpetrator, the victim and the community in the process of punishing the perpetrator in a less putative manner, and restoring the perpetrator, the victim and the community to its previous state. In the traditional South African context it is believed that evildoers must be restored to the community, rather than be punished. Hence, restorative justice stems from Ubuntu – “…the humanity of others is inextricably linked with their own humanity. Key social values of Ubuntu include group solidarity, conformity, compassion, [and] respect for human dignity, humanistic orientation and collective unity.” Restorative justice is rooted in victim-offender mediation (VOM) which began in developed countries during the 1970s, but only gained popularity in South Africa from 1992. The first initiative of VOM was facilitated by the National Institute for Crime Prevention and Reintegration of Offenders (NICRO), a non-profit organisation involved in programmes focussed on crime prevention and reintegration of offenders after their release from prison. This project was first conducted in Cape Town (based on Howard Zehr’s model) – focussing on crime as a harm that needed to be resolved by looking at the victim and his or her needs for repairing this harm. The project started by NICRO was targeted at pre-trial and pre-sentence stages of the criminal procedure. It was reported that the prosecutors were hesitant to refer serious crimes. Therefore the referrals were mainly juvenile offenders. Despite this, NICRO now also focuses on adults and is still successful today. Following this there were several other programmes instituted, some which still exist today such as the Restorative Justice Centre in Pretoria.
The application of restorative justice in South African law
Most restorative justice projects are run by non-profit organisations, particularly with cases dealing with crimes of a less serious nature. These cases are often dealt with through diversion or non-custodial sentencing. Hence, these cases often go unreported and not much precedent exists with regard to this punishment theory. Further, there is no legislation available regarding this punishment theory, except in the context of child offenders. In the Child Justice Act 75 of 2008, one of aims of the Act...

Find Another Essay On Restorative Justice in South Africa - Can It work?

Apartheid In South Africa Essay

2284 words - 9 pages Segregation is a concept as old as time, and it is not unique to the United States. South Africa still suffers from the effects of an organized and government mandated system of segregation called apartheid that lasted for over a quarter of a century. Apartheid, literally translated from Afrikaans, means apartness (Mandela 40). It is defined as a policy of racial segregation and “political and economic discrimination against...

Investment in South Africa Essay

1223 words - 5 pages Caltex plant was established in South Africa in 1977 after the owners decided to expand its operations in South Africa. The construction of the plant brought controversy over the interested parties, there were two dimensions of the utilitarian benefits of the Caltex plant, and there were violations of the justice and of moral rights whereas on the other side there were possible benefits to the South Africans. The plant setup was helpful in that...

Morality in South Africa

643 words - 3 pages Politicians, religious leaders and social commentators have all spoken about a breakdown in morality in South Africa, with crime as the most commonly cited evidence. The lack of respect for the sanctity of human life, for the next person, private property, disregard for the law of the land, lack of parental control over children, and the general blurring of the lines between right and wrong are continuing to plague our communities. To communicate...

Apartheid in South Africa

1600 words - 6 pages The word apartheid comes in two forms, one being the system of racial segregation in South Africa, and the other form is the form that only those who were affected by apartheid can relate to, the deeper, truer, more horrifying, saddening and realistic form. The apartheid era truly began when white South Africans went to the polls to vote. Although the United Party and National Party were extremely close, the National party won. Since they...

Apartheid in South Africa

1347 words - 5 pages Nelson Mandela helped bring an end to Apartheid in South Africa because he was a believer in basic human rights, leading both peaceful and violent protests against the white South African Government. His beliefs landed him in prison for twenty-seven years, almost three decades. In doing so, he became the face of the apartheid movement both in his country and around the world. When released from prison in 1990, he continued to honor his...

Ecotourism in South Africa

1515 words - 6 pages South African ecologists currently face many challenges relating to the conservation of biodiversity and the growing economy. Excessive hunting and land development, as well as unemployment, all remain growing concerns for this struggling country. Jan-Hendrik, a South African who made contact with us, stated, “South Africa has lots of social and economic problems because most people are poor. To get them to middle class requires the economy to...

Apartheid in South Africa

1807 words - 7 pages "During my lifetime I have dedicated myself to this struggle of the African people. I have fought against white domination, and I have fought against black domination. I have cherished the ideal of a democratic and free society in which all persons live together in harmony and with equal opportunities. It is an ideal which I hope to live for and to achieve. But if needs be, it is an ideal for which I am prepared to die." -- Nelson Mandela -- 20...

Adolescence in South Africa

1729 words - 7 pages In this essay the concepts of sensitive periods and critical periods are going to be discussed, and critically evaluated in regards to identity development amongst South Africans. In doing so one should also take into consideration South Africa’s historical context. The period of Adolescence is when individual undergoes a set of physical and psychological changes, known as the teenage years, and begins the progression to adulthood. In other words...

Crime in South Africa

1327 words - 5 pages The above statistics are alarming given the focus of resources to these stations. It seems, from the face of it, that the implementation of Presidential Stations is not working even though these stations were prioritised over others. The former MEC for Safety and Security from Limpopo also realised the failure in 2000 and was quoted saying that In our assessment for the past six months, we have found that the Thohoyandou police station failed...

Apartheid in South Africa

856 words - 3 pages Apartheid, the Afrikaans word for “apartness” was the system used in South Africa from the years 1948 to 1994. During these years the nearly 31.5 million blacks in South Africa were treated cruelly and without respect. They were given no representation in parliament even though they made up most of the country. It was not until 1994 when a black man named Nelson Mandela came to power in the South Africa congress. Once elected Mandela removed all...

Aids in South africa

1352 words - 5 pages IN A Time of Need"Everyday lost is a day in when 10,000 more people become infected with AID." - Kofi AnnanSeventeen million people are dead. Twenty-five million more have the same death sentence hanging over their heads. An entire continent is held captive by the fear of this killing machine. By the year 2010 life expectancy on this continent will have plummeted to the levels found at the beginning of the last century. This...

Similar Essays

The Veracity Of Restorative Justice Gaining Support In South Africa

1611 words - 6 pages The Veracity of Restorative Justice Gaining Support in South Africa Introduction Restorative justice has materialised greatly in South Africa’s jurisprudence, legislation, writings and practices. Is this a sign that restorative justice is gaining support in South Africa? To evaluate the veracity of this statement one will have to know the difference between traditional justice and restorative justice, in which the latter case is a less punitive...

Is Restorative Justice Gaing Support In South Africa?

1752 words - 7 pages Introduction Punishment, central to any legal proceeding where the accused is found guilty, directly falls under criminal law and is determined by punishment theories. Whether South Africa is moving towards restorative justice approaches influences many aspects: it allows the protection of society, results in more of a crime-free life for the offender and it gives offenders the chance to learn from their experience, and gain insight into their...

How Does Restorative Justice Work Within Nacro?

3978 words - 16 pages G20320704 Tutor: Joanne WestwoodSP3005 COMMUNITY PROJECTCASE STUDYWhat role does restorative justice have within Nacro?Word Count: 4178 Date: 21/03/10What role does restorative justice, have within Nacro?The community project I am involved with focuses on children and young people who are at risk of, or have already been involved with the Criminal Justice System. By way of referral, they...

Apartheid In South Africa Essay

2552 words - 10 pages Origins of Apartheid In the seventeenth century, South Africa was colonized by Dutch and British imperialists. In response to British domination, Dutch settlers made two colonies: The Republic of the Orange Free State and Transvaal. Dutch descendants became known as “Afrikaners” or “Boers.” In the early 1900s, Boers discovered diamonds on their land. This led to a Britain invasion and sparked the Second Boer War, which lasted three years. ...