Rethinking Silence In Elementary Classrooms Essay

1807 words - 7 pages

There has always been a great deal of value placed on class discussions and open communication between peers in elementary classrooms. The benefits of effective communication in the classroom have been researched and proven many times over. As a result of this association between talk and success, silence has come to acquire a negative connotation. These negative feelings that educators have toward silence in their classrooms is causing an oversight of the potential benefits it has to offer. The research provided in this paper aims to change the way educators perceive silence and encourage teachers to rethink the amount of importance they place on talking. This research will define two different types of silence and discuss the benefits that it can have on students. It will then cover several ways that teachers can use silence productively in their classrooms.
Weak and Strong Silence
In her article “Schools Weak on Strong Silence”, Adi Bloom describes that there are two types of silences present in schools, weak and strong. The terms “weak” and “strong” are used to describe the classroom environment created by the way teachers utilize silence. Weak silence, also referred to as negative silence, is used by teachers for the purpose of maintaining control over students. Teachers use this type of silence to keep order in their classrooms, and to show authority. Weak silence is used as a tool to benefit teachers. Generally, a teacher’s attitude toward silence stems from their own personal experiences. The influence of these experiences is apparent in the way they use silence in their classrooms (Waite, 2013). As a result of the encounters students have with weak silence in their classrooms, students learn to associate silence with fear, unease, and rejection (2009). This association with silence can have a negative impact on the lives of students outside of school.
Strong silence, or positive silence, is characterized by the mutual agreement made between students and teachers choosing to be silent. This type of silence is a choice made by students; it is not forced onto them. Adi Bloom (2009) explains, “Choosing something gives it the strength to emerge. Because silence is a powerful aspect of human experience, choosing it allows its power to enter a person’s world-and, of course, the world of others” (p.15). Forcing silence creates a sense of oppression, while giving the opportunity to choose silence is freedom. Students enter into an agreement with the understanding that in order to achieve silence, they must be respectful of others around them. Eventually, students will discover that silence is not only about respecting their peers, but that it is also about taking care of themselves. Another aspect of using strong silence in classrooms is taking the time to teach students how it can help them. For many students it is a new experience and it must be introduced and explained by teachers. In time, students will understand the value of...

Find Another Essay On Rethinking Silence in Elementary Classrooms

A Career in Elementary Education Essay

1467 words - 6 pages , this does not mean you cannot teach a social studies class, because as an elementary school teacher you will most likely be teaching multiple different subjects, as previously stated. During your Junior and Senior year of college be prepared to work under the guidance of an experienced teacher, visit elementary classrooms and write reports on your observations, create lesson plans and practice them in front of your peers, and approach your

Training/Faculty Development Plan Essay

1297 words - 5 pages conversations need to happen in regard to what our essential knowledge should be and we must no longer hide behind our cinder-blocks and neatly stacked textbooks circa Education 1.0. Rather, we must bring the real world into our classrooms and rethink how we can motivate students in a new Education 2.0 reform. For a hundred years, students across the nation have shuffled into their cinder-blocked, uniformly-rowed, lack-luster classrooms and have been

Special Education Placement in Public Schools

1795 words - 7 pages Special Education Placement in Public Schools History of Public Schools Before the 1840’s the education system was only available to wealthy people. Individuals such as Horace Mann from Massachusetts and Henry Barnard in Connecticut believed that schooling for everybody would help individuals become productive citizens in society. Through their efforts, free public education at the elementary level become assessable for all children in

America Needs Bilingual Programs

1449 words - 6 pages believes that the most successful programs incorporate elements of all three approaches ("Bilingual Education: Arguments..."). At most, students were expected to spend three years in bilingual programs before being fully integrated into English speaking classrooms (Porter).   In "The Case Against Bilingual Education", Rosalie Porter illustrates the main argument against the use of bilingual education: bilingual education programs have

The Moment of Silence in Hillsboro Schools: A Positive and Constructive Time

625 words - 3 pages effects on the students and staff members of Hillsboro City Schools, but improves our community.INTERNETAmerican Civil Liberties Union. "Constitutional Amendment on School Prayer or Moment of Silence." 24 September 2008 .Masters, Brooke A. "Va. Minute of Silence in Schools is Upheld; Federal Judges Rule Law is Not Unconstitutional." 24 September 2008 ThePetitionSite.com. "Moment of Silence for New York's Schools." 26 September 2008U. S. Department of Education. "Guidance on Constitutionally Protected Prayer in Public Elementary and Secondary Schools." 30 September 2008

Rethinking Teacher Education in the 21 st Century

7553 words - 30 pages Rethinking Teacher Education in the 21 st Century: Putting Teaching Front and Center Rethinking Teacher Education in the 21 st Century:�Putting Teaching Front and Center In most higher�education�institutions today, teacher�education�remains uncomfortably situated. It is too often an embarrassing subject of academic discourse, reflecting unresolved dilemmas about its intellectual stature. Although colleges of�education�have obtained a

Keeping Recess in Schools

1604 words - 6 pages learning, social development, and health in elementary school children" (Albert Einstein School of Medicine). These short breaks are great socializing time for the students. Children have the opportunity to talk and socialize with others, and in the process learn different things such as the culture of their classmates and friends. In the classroom students do not have that time because teachers usually require silence while they are instructing the

Observation of Preschool and Elementary Classrooms

1735 words - 7 pages private speech in both classrooms, however I expected there to be more examples of whispers or silent lip movement in my elementary observations as some students might be transitioning from private speech to internalized private speech. In regards to classroom instruction, in both classrooms I expected the teacher to instruct the classroom on how to do something and to lend assistance and provide scaffolding, but then gradually lessen their

The Importance of Using Creative Methods of Teaching in Elementary School

604 words - 2 pages not encourage students of any age to use their creativity then, we are taking away something beautiful from the world. In the book “Integrating the Arts Across the Elementary School Curriculum” (Gelineau) it was very important to use creative and new ideas. Without the use of creativity in classrooms we will lack creative abilities when we get older and work. Many jobs such as marketing, advertising, and teaching just to name a few use creativity

Transition from Elementary to Middle School

1251 words - 5 pages the primary concerns of students (Akos, 2002). In order to make this transition easier, programs such as “blocking, shadowing, or buddies” need to be implemented the year preceding middle school and continue through the first year of transition. The transition from elementary to middle school is a major event in the lives of students and parents. Most students will experience some emotional turmoil and social adjustment due to unfamiliar students

Leadership Through Curricular Reform in Music Education

2549 words - 10 pages Introduction Curriculum reform requires that all teachers become teacher leaders. "This involves a commitment on the part of all to lead as experts in their subject area, their classrooms, and in the vision and mission of the school/district" (Hill, 2006, p. 178). Each teacher, especially the music educator, has to be an advocate for their subject within the curriculum. As the music curriculum is currently changing, the music educator should

Similar Essays

I Pads And Tablets In Elementary Classrooms

2234 words - 9 pages Tablets and iPads are being used in elementary schools to advance the technology in classrooms. Some say that these devices are being used in classrooms because elementary students in this generation are already using these devices at home for learning. Schools all over the United States have begun to carry out million dollar plans to supply their students with Microsoft, Apple, and Samsung electronic “notebooks”. Many schools have hopped on

The Potential Impacts Of Upcoming High Stakes Testing On The Teaching Of Science In Elementary Classrooms Research Article Critique

1165 words - 5 pages . Some of the data collection methods seemed sloppy and time was definitely a contributing factor. While the content was thought provoking, intriguing, and worthwhile, the methods would need to be cleaned up to be able to cite this source as valid. Works Cited Pringle, R.M., Martin, S. (2005). The Potential Impacts of Upcoming High Stakes Testing on the Teaching of Science in Elementary Classrooms. Research in Science Education 35:347-361. doi: 10.1007/s11165-004-5599-z

Why We Should Have Computers In Elementary Classrooms

731 words - 3 pages Every day in our life we use technology to do our basic communication, such as a telephone for talking, a computer for seeing and so on. In school, teachers communicate to different students by giving them class lessons about math, reading, writing, science and etc. According to Robinson, schools are teaching students as “factory base.”—Where elementary students are accordingly kept by their age instead of their skills and talents. How does the

Single Gender Classrooms: Beneficial Or Harmful? Essay

1310 words - 5 pages measuring quality of education. With this in mind, I have found that students in single-gender classrooms have had great improvements in various aspects of education and attitude, as measured by their teachers, parents, and even themselves. At Edisto Elementary School in South Carolina, Principal Belinda Johnson reported that 90 percent of boys in single-gender classes improved in Language Arts while 78 percent improved in writing skills. Students