Revenge: A Bittersweet Victory Essay

1127 words - 5 pages

This story of the most heinous revenge is, like all stories by Edgar Allen Poe, very open to interpretation. One thing that cannot be disputed, though, is the theme. The fundamental theme of The Cask of Amontillado is revenge. While the reasons the main character, Montresor, desires revenge are rather unclear, the reasons for his motivation are not. The way he executes his plans also exemplifies a clever use of deception to amplify his vengeance. Unfortunately, though, the aftermath of his actions proved far less gratifying than what he foresaw. These elements of revenge consume this story in the usual vague and mysterious manner which we so often see with Poe.
Because this story is told in first person perspective from Montresor’s point of view, we cannot be completely sure what it is that Fortunato did to him, if anything at all. Montresor simply states that Fortunato insulted him. At one point, when speaking to Fortunato, Montresor claims, “you are rich, respected, admired, beloved; you are happy, as once I was.” By saying this, he implied that whatever it was Fortunato did to him, it made him lose those qualities of his life, causing him to be unhappy. Montresor implicates further blame when he informs Fortunato that, “the Montresors . . . were a great and numerous family.” This is the real concern for Montresor because he has a great pride in his family. This leads the reader to believe that Fortunato not only insulted Montresor, but his family as well.
This suggests that Montresor may be trying to avenge his family by killing Fortunato. This is further exemplified by the Montresor family motto, “nemo me impune lacessit,” which translates to, “no one dare attack me with impunity.” Here lies the main reason for Montresor’s drive for revenge. The motto of the family he loves more than anything flat out states that no one insults a Montresor and gets away with it. This message is also conveyed through the Montresor family crest, which shows a snake biting the very foot that is crushing it. The snake in this case, is Montresor, who does not let his attacker get away with the attack. Overall, Montresor’s craving for vengeance is derived from the pride he feels for his family.
Montresor satisfied these cravings by plotting and executing the perfect revenge. The reason Montresor killed Fortunato in the catacombs was because of his intense family pride. Because in Montresor’s mind Fortunato had insulted his family, he saw the catacombs as the perfect place to kill him so they could, in a sense, witness the event. That way his actions avenge them as well as himself. As to the reason for the method of live entrapment he used to kill Fortunato, it comes not from Montresor, but instead from the author himself. During the time Poe published this story, the fear of being buried alive was very real among the masses. In fact, some cemeteries would place bells on the limbs of the recently deceased, so if they were accidentally buried alive, they...

Find Another Essay On Revenge: A Bittersweet Victory

Frankenstein and The Monster Description Essay

630 words - 3 pages   In “Frankenstein,” Mary Shelley captures various similar characteristic between Victor Frankenstein and his monster. He and his creation are very alike in personality. They shared an eagerness to learn, and a thirst for revenge. They also showed a sense of gratefulness for nature. Even in their most depressing moods, the ways of nature always seemed to calm them. In the deaths of William and Justine, Victor found peace staring upon the

Revenge in Hamlet Essay

1183 words - 5 pages action that could have brought quick revenge. A key moment in the play comes in the first act, when the ghost of Hamlet's father informs the prince of his duty: "If thou didst ever thy father love...Revenge his foul and most unnatural murder." [1.5: 29, 31] With these words, the Ghost puts the play in motion, for the rest of the story will be governed by Hamlet's quest for this revenge. Furthermore, the spirit emphasizes the need for Hamlet to act

The Cask of Amontillado

884 words - 4 pages the satisfaction of his success by leaving him in a lurch as to whether he did the right thing. What ever the case may be, Montresor unfortunately never realized the true revenge that he had hoped he would exact on his enemy Fortunato. Revenge, although executed exactly as Montresor planned, still eluded him by falling short of his own expectations. Physically, Montresor had won this match, but Fortunato had ultimately taken away the sweetness of this victory that Montresor so eagerly yearned.


1658 words - 7 pages underlying psychological issues that led to them committing these unnatural, morally wrong acts. Susan was rejected by her lover, Kathleen's father had brutally murdered her mother, Caro was a victim of a failed marital relationship, whilst in Euripides play, Medea was not only rejected and a victim of a failed marital relationship but she also had her pride torn from beneath her. Revenge is one of the most primitive, brutal human impulses. When an

Revenge in Shakespeare's Hamlet

1426 words - 6 pages Revenge in Shakespeare's Hamlet In Hamlet, Shakespeare uses revenge as a major theme present throughout the work. Revenge plays a crucial role in the development of Fortinbras, Prince of Norway, Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, and Laertes, son of Polonius. All three men seek revenge for the murder of their fathers. Revenge can be interpreted as a separate character in Hamlet. Revenge is set to overcome anyone who seeks it. Initially, after each

Robert E. Lee

935 words - 4 pages to the battle of Chancellorsville to be Lee's greatest battle as a general. The South was outnumbered 57,000 to 97,000. However, in a risky move, Lee splits up his army and has Stonewall Jackson attacks General Joseph Hooker. The plan was a huge risk but it paid off very well, with the Confederates claiming victory. However, it was a bittersweet victory for the South; they lost Lee's favorite and most trusted General, Stonewall Jackson. Lee said

This essay is about how in Shakespeare's Hamlet, Hamlet's revenge wasn't an act on himself

1408 words - 6 pages In Hamlet, Shakespeare uses revenge as a major theme present throughout the work. Revenge plays a crucial role in the development of Fortinbras, Prince of Norway, Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, and Laertes, son of Polonius. All three men seek revenge for the murder of their fathers. Revenge can be interpreted as a separate character in Hamlet. Revenge is set to overcome anyone who seeks it. Initially, after each of the murders, every son had a

The Power of Mark Antony’s Speech in Julius Caesar and Winston Churchill’s Speech, Blood, Toil, Tears, and Sweat

1012 words - 4 pages elements of Pathos, Ethos, and Logos in order to have the House proclaim their confidence in the government with his speech, “Blood, Toil, Tears, and Sweat”. Pathos was used in a manner to explain to the House and the whole Country in general what his goal was for his country. Churchill was willing to sacrifice for the safety of the United Kingdom, “victory at all costs, victory in spite of all terror, victory, however long and hard the road may be

Comparing the Hero in Sophocles' Oedipus the King, Homer's Odyssey, and Tan's Joy Luck Club

2662 words - 11 pages makes him a mythic hero. The mood of the story is one of victory, in which the best is yet to come. Odysseus revels in the feeling of eventual success because the other characters in the story are all on his side. Athena and some other gods and goddesses intervene into Odysseus' journey, confirming the happy ending from the very first page. Athena introduces the story herself, by saying: "But my own heart is broken for Odysseus, / the master

Comparing Works of Edgar Allen Poe

1773 words - 7 pages Death-Despair-Revenge: A Recipe for a Good Drama "Scorching my seared heart with a pain, not hell shall make me fear again." Edgar Allan Poe, Tamerlane, Part II Death, despair, and revenge, these three words form a treacherous triangle to any reader who dare enter the mind of Edgar Allen Poe. In many of his works these expressions seem to form a reoccurring theme. Comparing the works "The Mask of the Red Death" and "The Cask of

Paradise Lost

536 words - 2 pages revenge on God. As his speech goes on he get more worked up and irate. He whips up emotion by talking of the pain they are suffering and although he knows there will be no victory - they cannot beat God - they will at least have had some revenge. Moloch is seen as a towering pillar of strength but only by despair. Moloch is seen as an extremist. "which if not victory is yet revenge." The next person to speak is Belial, a fair person but all that he

Similar Essays

Hamlet By William Shakespeare Essay

1683 words - 7 pages led to death; while Fortinbras, without fulfilling or attempting his vengeance, gained land and power. Revenge can lead to a grand amount of success and wealth, or establish a fatal flaw that guarantees death. Although there is a chance for survival and victory with retaliation, the consequence of acting through revenge can come back to haunt a person, especially if vengeance was acted upon by an unsighted urge instead of a refined reason. Once a person retaliates a large unbreakable chain of revenge is created.

Revenge In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein Essay

795 words - 3 pages , Victor's father. People usually want revenge and enjoy it when they achieve it. However, the monster's revenge is very bittersweet. The book eventually ends with Victor's death. Both Victor and the monster want revenge but ultimately only the monster gets it. Only, the revenge doesn't satisfy the monster, it destroys him.The entire book is just pretty much how the monster controls Victor's life. The first time the monster strikes is when he kills

Hamelt's Fatal Flaw. Essay

807 words - 3 pages contrast to the previous scene, when he spoke and acted impulsively and with confidence, Hamlet has had time to fully think over his situation, and the result is a speech marked by indecision and confusion, both of which combine to impede his attempt at revenge.In the end, Hamlet extirpates Claudius, but this revenge is bittersweet, for it comes too late. "The native hue of [Hamlet's] resolution [was] sicklied o'er with the pale cast of [his] thought

Hamlet Essay

844 words - 3 pages had killed each other off, except forthe dying Hamlet. Hamlet being the last remaining royal figure of Denmark, wishes Fortinbras to bemade the king of Denmark. Hamlet dies of the poisonous wound, and Fortinbras is crowned King ofDenmark. His revenge has been completed. As a sign of victory, he orders Hamlet to be carried away asan honoured soldier, and proclaims, "Bear Hamlet, like a soldier, to the stage; For he was likely, had hebeen put on