This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Revenge: Is It Justified? Essay

1199 words - 5 pages

How is a person supposed to act when they are betrayed? The thought of revenge is something that every human thinks about in times of betrayal. It is necessary for someone to know if taking revenge is appropriate or not. In the book “The Count of Monte Cristo”, by Alexander Dumas, revenge is a prominent theme throughout the book. It is mostly shown with the main character of the book, Edmond Dantes. His revenge was justified even though some of his acts of revenge had unintended outcomes for others.
You may wonder where should a person draw the line when it comes to revenge? In the book, Edmond Dantes is a hard working first mate on the Pharaon, and doesn’t do anything outside of the ...view middle of the document...

Luigi would then only let him eat for ridiculous amounts of money. They took all but 50,000 of Danglars's remaining fortune and left him to live a life of mediocrity. This was obviously done because Danglars helped put Dantes away for personal, monetary gain within the firm of Morrel & Son. The other reason Dantes did this is because it’s the same thing that Danglars did to his father; He let him starve to death. The reason this revenge is appropriate is because he is doing the same damage that Danglars did to him. Even though Danglars may not have starved Dantes, it was still his father and that’s why it was justified revenge.
Some say Revenge is a dish best served cold. Edmond Dantes would agree with this, because he realized that if he took revenge without thinking or planning any of his actions, it would not be satisfactory.
“He decided it was human hatred and not divine vengeance that had plunged him into this abyss. He doomed these unknown men to every torment that his inflamed imagination could devise, while still considering that the most frightful were too mild and, above all, too brief for them: torture was followed by death, and death brought, if not repose, at least an insensibility that resembled it.” (15.8)
What this means is that Edmond Dantes did not just want to kill these men; he wanted them to suffer. This is exactly what he did to Fernand Mondego. Fernand took Dantes wife, Mercedes, and then locked him up forever. Dantes did not just suffer for one day, but he sat, rotted, and almost died in prison. Why would Dantes want to just kill Fernand without making him suffer like he did to him? The revenge Dantes took on Fernand was justified because he made him feel the same suffering that he had to go through, and that led Fernand to end his own life.
Although it seems throughout the book that Dantes is okay with his revenge, there is one point in the book that he starts to question himself and he wonders if he has gone too far. Dante had no intentions of ever hurting anyone that was innocent, but it still happened. Dantes involuntarily was the cause of Madame Ville fort’s death. He also was shocked when he found out Fernand had killed himself. Even though this is one point in the book where it could be...

Find Another Essay On revenge: Is it justified?

'The death penalty is justified because it - and it alone - pays proper respect to the importance of human life.' What is your view on this?

1305 words - 5 pages death penalty is truly justified in its execution and also if it is the only, and ultimately, the most suitable means of paying homage to the value of human life.Today, approximately ninety countries around the world still retain the death penalty. This includes China, Islamic countries, Singapore, as well as thirty seven states of the United States. The controversy surrounding this form of criminal punishment has never faltered over the years

"The Revenge Wrapped in Tragedy" Hamlet is more a tragedy than a revenge play. Discuss this idea by examining three essential elements of the play that make it a tragedy

1210 words - 5 pages Shakespeare's Hamlet is more of a tragedy than a revenge plot in that it follows the unfortunate downfall of a prince due to his vengeful goal rather than the honour or justice brought about by his revenge. The tragedy underlies the plot in three fateful elements: death, corruption and betrayal, themes that echo throughout the play and resonate in each character's actions ultimately leading to their own demise, whether by their own hand or

Problems of a Red Passport: How Diplomatic Agents abuse immunity- Criminal Jurisdiction and why it is justified

4098 words - 16 pages ability to freely exercise their diplomatic functions completely unhampered, international customary law grants a host of privileges and immunities. It is in the 1961 Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations that the functions and scope of diplomatic immunity are laid out, legally positing the understanding that personal inviolability and immunity are a vital protection given to diplomatic agents and their missions on a reciprocal basis between

Revenge and Murder, Justified with the Characters in the Short Story, Killings

1089 words - 4 pages , protective family man, to a man planning and carrying out revenge. Matt has raised his children to be respectful and insightful toward others. He has watched them grow into nurturing adults to lead their own lives and families. Matt is concerned about his youngest son Frank and the relationship he has with Mary Ann: It seems like a lot for a young guy to take on, Matt finally said. Sometimes it is. But she is worth it. Are you thinking about

Reflective Writing Exposition

999 words - 4 pages People can be motivated to take revenge on others for various reasons. While these reasons may be considered as very serious or rather trivial, they are all motives for revenge. Revenge occurs when a person has been offended or angered by an individual and in result they have the desire to pay them back. People’s opinions on revenge differ from each other, some may believe it is justified and some don’t. Mahatma Ghandi believed that revenge is


531 words - 2 pages Steven ShinMrs. LeimkuhlerEnglish 1026 Feburary 2014Justified or Not Justified?A sword is often known to have two edges. It can help a person but also destroy that same person as well. Often portrayed as a "double-edged sword" revenge is seen in many different media especially television, music, and movies. Not only those, but the theme is a prevailing topic in acclaimed literature as well. One of these well known novels is Dumas' book, The

Stance on Revenge

1014 words - 5 pages “If you live in a society where the rule of law is weak, revenge provides a way to keep order. But revenge comes at a price. Instead of helping you move on with your life, it can leave you dwelling on the situation and remaining unhappy, psychologists' research finds. Considering revenge is a very human response to feeling slighted…,” (Price). Revenge is a natural human response that we think will help us; however, many times it ends up hurting

Descriptive essay on the emotion, Revenge

658 words - 3 pages often blur the lines between revenge and justice. Often spoken conjoined, these forms of retribution are unrelated to each other. Revenge differs in that it is an emotional act, simmered and stewed upon. It is thought out, often carefully planned, and executed to inflict the most suffering on the victim, with immediate gratification sought by the perpetrator. Destruction of one's personal property or libeling of one's reputation are favorite forms

Of Revenge: Francis Bacon’s Optimistic Tale?

1044 words - 4 pages would have believed that Medea’s actions were justified due to the wrongs Jason committed against her. It is for this reason that the character of Medea is carefully crafted to fit Bacon’s mold of a person seeking revenge, as well as illustrates the importance of the theme of revenge in the play. Though Bacon’s views are illustrated through Medea, they are grossly disproportional to the character of Iago in Shakespeare’s Othello. Bacon quotes

Vengeful Defence

790 words - 4 pages Maloney and Charles Braling were both not being threatened. They both just tried to solve a problem in the cruelest of ways. It is impossible to know if Montresor was threatened, for he never revealed the insult that drove him to his actions. Two of the three characters were not being threatened by the person they took revenge upon. For an act to be justified under self defense, the actions taken must not be too extreme. Mary Maloney was terrified

Revenge and Justice in the Iliad and Second Treatise of Government

1269 words - 6 pages this rule. Locke argues that revenge is justified if it is by the people against a king who has made himself a tyrant, something we defined earlier, for his actions against them, for the sake of defending themselves from further mistreatment. He makes it clear that the mistreatment should be severe and against the people, and that revenge is not justified for one individual against the king for any misdeeds the king does against him. This is

Similar Essays

Revenge, Is It Morally Justified? Refers To The Count Of Monte Cristo By Alexandre Dumas

1023 words - 4 pages on smaller issues. But is it morally justified? The answer to this question is largely depends on whom you ask, and it may vary according to the concepts and values that he/her was raised on - it differs among different peoples, cultures and traditions. In this essay I will try to answer this question from the point of the story The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas. In order to discuss the revenge issue of this book let us begin by a

Abortion: Is It Justified? Essay

945 words - 4 pages American culture and politics today. Being often shown as a two-sided debate, the abortion controversy is actually quite multifaceted, involving varied speculations on biology, ethics, and legal rights.However, can abortion be justified? Are there circumstances in which it is right to practice an abortion, leaving aside the procedure it means having one? The purpose of this essay is the former.One of the most controversial issues of the abortion

Is It Justified To Have Faith

841 words - 4 pages Is it ever justified for us to believe in anything on insufficient evidence? William Clifford and Joseph Long have different answers to this question. Clifford thinks that it is always morally wrong because we have a moral obligation to exam our beliefs epistemically. On the contrary, Long argues that there are prudent values to believe something without absolute justification, therefore, it is permissible to do so. To illustrate Clifford’s and

Revenge... Is It Really A Good Thing?

739 words - 3 pages It has been said revenge is a dish best served cold, or that revenge is sweet. But a man named Sir Francois Bacon says that revenge just hurts a person in the long run. He says that taking revenge is not such a good thing after all, and that it is not worth doing in the first place. Bacon’s idea of revenge is also present in Romeo and Juliet, The Autobiography of Takashi Tanemori, and The Blade of Grass in a Dreamless Field. Romeo and Juliet by