Review: Asianising Singapore – The Pap's Management Of Ethnicity By Raj Vasil, Singapore: Heineman Asia, 1995

3591 words - 14 pages

In this book, Vasil presents a comprehensive albeit descriptive study of the management of the ethnicity in Singapore since independence through to the 1990s under the rule of two Premiers, Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew and his protégé, Goh Chok Tong. In this review, I aim to highlight the key policy ramifications of the management of ethnicity in Singapore as presented by Vasil, and compare it with Malaysia who shares a similar ethnic base although with significantly different proportions of Chinese and Malay populations.Apart from being ethnically diverse, Singaporeans, like Malaysians, were traditionally a fragmented society on the basis of language, dialect, religion, clan or caste, and region of origin in China and India. Unlike Malaysia with its dominant and growing majority Malay population, Singapore possessed and continues to possess a Chinese dominant majority. Thus the city state derives a unique character from Chinese preponderance both of people and of enterprise and industry. The policy challenge in managing ethnicity, therefore, remains to ensure that dominant majority adheres to Singapore's founding principle of cultural democracy, thus treating its Malay and Indian compatriots as of equal worth. At independence in 1965, this had to be accomplished as part of setting up a new, sovereign Republic of Singapore at the aftermath of turbulence from its expulsion from Malaysia. Singapore's expulsion from Malaysia, among other reasons, followed the breakout of riots in Singapore due to serious ethnic differences. This included taking into account the special sensitivities of their Malay neighbours in Malaysia, who were keeping a close watch on their behaviour and policies especially on ethnic issues, and not merely asserting their sovereign right to pursue policies dictated by their own national interests.It is noted that Vasil's account is largely based on interviews with many past and present PAP leaders and senior officials. His account in the narrative and has minimal argumentative elements. Vasil has systematically divided the efforts in managing ethnicity into three phases: managing ethnic diversity from 1965 to 1979; Asianising Singapore from 1979 to 1990; and management of ethnicity from 1990. I will attempt to supplement his thesis with a comparison with the Malaysian scenario also along significant timelines.1965 - 1979In the first phase of 1965 to 1979, there were 3 policy compulsions in defending Singapore's paramount founding principle of cultural democracy:1.De-emphasisng the Chineseness of Singapore2.Giving special recognition to the Malays3.Adhering to the founding principle of multi-racial cultural democracyThe Chinese constituted more than three quarters of the population. Therefore, with regard to the first objective, the PAP were faced with the task of curbing the urge of the Chinese to assert their dominance as the majority. In this regard, they had to de-stress the Chineseness of their population...

Find Another Essay On Review: Asianising Singapore – The PAP's Management of Ethnicity By Raj Vasil, Singapore: Heineman Asia, 1995

Migration from the Nation-State of Singapore

573 words - 2 pages citizenship and national identity. This has also raised an old issue of why Singaporeans are leaving Singapore for ‘greener pastures’ overseas (Straits Times, 21 August 2002). Most often, the ones who left are deemed as talents who could have contributed to Singapore if they had not ‘quitted’ Singapore (National Day Rally, 2002). This is widely known as a ‘brain drain’, a problem that most migrant-sending countries in Asia currently face. In Singapore

Economy of Singapore Essay

1310 words - 5 pages Introduction In this essay we look in-depth on how government strategies and economic policy play a crucial role in the success of High Performance Asian Economies (HPAEs) during 1960 to 1990 (World Bank 1993).There are eight countries within HPAEs: South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore, Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia and Japan. Its economic development has significantly rise that it was name ‘East Asia Miracle’ (World Bank, 1993). Out of

The economy of Singapore. Family, Marriage and the Threat of declining birth rate in Singapore

2046 words - 8 pages immediate environment. As Kou & Wong stated, with a rising standard of living and education, the social relations are more modern (or "Western" in the context of Asian societies) traits characteristic of industrial societies:1.1. The change in the roles of women:The ChannelNewAsia provide that the female labor participation rate in Singapore is very high. This fact was explained by Straughan, Kou & Wong and Salaff. They cited that with the advent

Contested Landscapes - Singapore Integrated Resort Question: Contested landscapes provide a lens to study society. By analyzing a case study of a “contested landscape” in Singapore, discuss the...

2926 words - 12 pages purchase or acquisition or the holding of management shares by any person who is not a citizen of Singapore and for the appointment of any such person as a director of a newspaper company.The above Laws "empowers the government to determine the composition of a newspaper company's board of directors" (Cherian George, 2000), hence allowing for governmental intervention if necessary, creating a "media with a national vision" (Cherian George, 2000

A cultural study of Singapore.

1708 words - 7 pages years ago, Singapore was an undeveloped nation, with only 200 or so native Maylays. In 1819, it was established as a British trading post, and within three years had over 10,000 immigrants. It has endured colonization by the English, occupation by the Japanese, communism and a short merger with Malaysia. Today, Singapore has a booming economy and over four million inhabitants, mostly of Malay, Chinese and Indian descent. ("Brief History"). These

What is the Nature of the Liberty Desire in Singapore?

1288 words - 5 pages then largely free to do as he wishes, as long as it affects none but himself. Get many individuals together, and they form a society. The next major branch of liberty in Singapore would be social liberty, which could be defined as the freedom of groups of people to act freely amongst a community of people who share similar traits, be it nationality, ethnicity, or thought. The impacts of this branch of liberty is not only limited to oneself, but

The relationship of trade between Australia and Singapore

1255 words - 5 pages The development of trade between the two countriesAustralia and Singapore have maintained a trade relationship for a long time now. Both countries belonged to the British Empire. Singapore and Australia are both members of APEC (Asia pacific economic cooperation) and the world trade organization (WTO). Their trade relationship resulted in the Singapore and Australia free trade agreement (SAFTA) in 2003.The republic of Singapore has long been a

The Influence of Chekhov and Ibsen on Singapore Theatre

1259 words - 5 pages Singapore theatre is greatly influenced by the theatre of Anton Chekhov and Henrik Ibsen, especially in regard to the purpose of the play. Ibsen and Chekhov use their plays as social commentaries to explore Europe’s social issues and criticise outdated norms; Singaporean plays function as social commentaries, too. However, Singapore theatre and the theatre of Chekhov and Ibsen are definitely not entirely the same, with writing styles being a

Singapore Ministry of Transport: From the then till now

1138 words - 5 pages Singapore (MPA)* Public Transport Council (PTC)* Air Accident Investigation Bureau of Singapore (AAIB)Timeline of the acts/ policies of the Ministry:1929The Carriage by Air Act was established. It regulates documents of carriage and limits of liability of carriers for passenger death or injury, cargo and baggage damage and delay and gives effect to the Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules relating to International Carriage By Air 1929

A Study of Designer brands in the Singapore market

843 words - 3 pages crucial it is for the brand to succeed. This aids us in knowing what the public thinks about the different factors that contribute to the success of the brands.From the above results showing how the different factors were ranked, we could see that quality control is again thought to be determining factor of the success followed by marketing and so on till the last one which is shares. The graph shows in "1st" the number of times it was thought

Impact of Internet advertisement on body image among young adults in Singapore: Weight Management

2986 words - 12 pages image.Conclusion & RecommendationsIn conclusion, this study shows that adolescents in Singapore are heavily affected by the portrayal of Internet advertisement on body image. This is a critical issue and it is important for parents, teachers and healthcare professionals to step up and work hand in hand to address it. As body image is composed of several aspects, a multi-dimensional approach which includes physical, mental and environmental

Similar Essays

Singapore An Island In Southeast Asia

1476 words - 6 pages , government structure, strategic importance, and the future direction of Singapore. Background Information Singapore is an island located in Southeast Asia, and founded by the British East India Company in 1819. Singapore started as a British colony, joined the Malaysian Federation, and became independent in 1963. The island has a population of approximately 4.7 million people, and is located at narrow point of the Straits of Malacca off

Review On S. Rajaratnam's Speech: Singapore: Global City

761 words - 3 pages confident of Singapore's future economic success, and made the speech to answer critics who questioned Singapore's survival.While Rajaratnam, then Singapore's Foreign Minister, may be inherently biased in presenting an overly optimistic view to boost people's morale, he balanced his perspective by acknowledging that, firstly, Singapore fundamentally depended on the global economy owing to her inherent territorial constraints and, secondly, that

The Battle Of Singapore Essay

923 words - 4 pages The fall of SingaporeA brief overviewThe fall of Singapore, also known as the battle of Singapore, was a 15 day long military campaign involving the invasion of Singapore by the Japanese imperial army. This occurred in February of 1942, right in the middle of World War II. The capture and fall of Singapore to the Japanese led surrender by the British and many deaths, damage and also prisoners of war being taken.When did this even take place?The

The Battle Of Singapore Essay

2932 words - 12 pages Japanese forces. In the end, the British army lost the war because the Japanese forces expertly combined speed, savagery, and surprise without permitting the British forces to re-group and strategize. The Japanese were able to invade Singapore because of their dominance on the unprepared British forces. They efficiently applied the principles of mass, surprise, objective and unity of command by focusing on their outnumbered forces and acquiring