This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Critique Of Is There A God? By Bertrand Russell

2174 words - 9 pages

The article “Is there a God?” was written by Russell in 1952 at the request of a London magazine; however, it was not published (547-548). Russell, an advocate of science, was known for his unconventional views and social criticism (“Irvine”). This article came at a time when science was finally establishing significant ground. Discoveries in the 20th century such as the theory of relativity, evolution and quantum mechanics meant that people were finally looking towards scientists for answers (Polanyi). People in Western society deferred easily to the authority of science since empirical evidence, unlike religious claims, cannot be refuted (Polanyi). Russell was an analytic philosopher and hence, placed more emphasis on logic and empirical evidence (Irvine). Russell, being a mathematician as well, incorporates more logic than conventional philosophers (Irvine). This article is a profound example of how Russell deals with conventional subject matter. The apparent purpose of this article might be to debate the existence of God; however, Russell’s purpose is polemical. Russell analyses various perspectives on the existence of a deity in the context of 20th century.
In this article, the historical origins of monotheism are explored since it is the most prevalent of all forms of deity worship. Then the various arguments by theologians in favor of existence of a God are considered. Russell narrates the history of philosophy pertaining to the existence of a God. The question of existence and its various implications are tested against scientific claims and evidence. Finally, the moral arguments in favor of deistic worship are considered.
The analytical tone is evident from the start, particularly where the history of monotheism is discussed. Historical analysis of religions shows that the various claims of universal truth are in fact localized. There were various political reasons for believing in one religion or the other. Russell trivializes the claims of the Jewish religion and instead focuses on the growth of their political power. Russell satirizes the whole affair of political struggle between various religions by using the example of Antiochus who decreed the Jews to “eat pork, abandon circumcision, and take baths”. The success of religions is dependent upon military power as Russell shows by the analysis of monotheism’s rise. Russell points to Buddhism and Confucianism as religions having no deities. Hence, Russell reduces religion to an ideology. In the context of 20th century, Russell claims that ideological influence is becoming more and more difficult. The rise of atheism in Soviet Russia, for example, cannot be countered with violence. Russell makes it apparent that the existence of religions is not enough to believe in a deity. To the audience of the 20th century, uninfluenced by the ideological fog of early ages, the first paragraph is convincing.
A hint of dismissive tone against religion is visible throughout the article. Russell makes...

Find Another Essay On Critique of Is there a God? by Bertrand Russell

Is There A God Essay

1479 words - 6 pages Bertrand Russell has arisen one of the most important issue, which attracts the psyche of every human being. The existence of god has been a question that has plagued mankind started to think logically since forever. People believe in God but when they are asked, have you seen god? The answer usually is negative. Like many other authors, Bertrand Russell had written an article on this controversial topic of “is there a God” in 1952. Before

Is there a God? Essay

1868 words - 7 pages faith and ignore logical arguments that question their beliefs. Furthermore, he showed how theists ineffectively linked happiness with religion and then refuted their irrational ideology by providing logical reasoning. However, at some instances, Russell’s article showed signs of bias towards theism and ignorance of certain theistic beliefs which made some parts of his arguments somewhat ineffective. To conclude, Russell provided the reader with strong rational arguments that possibly made the reader doubtful about God’s existence or, at least, think about the degree of God’s credibility.   Works Cited "Is there a God", Bertrand Russell

The world view of bertrand russell

2474 words - 10 pages existence of God. Russell states that his view is agnostic (123), meaning he is neutral. He doesn't say that he is for religion nor does he say that he is against religion. He just believes science must prove there is a God (129). Copleston adds that one should look for the existence of God and saying not to is dogmatic (129). Copleston then questions Russell's view of the universe. Bertrand Russell answers that "The word "universe" is a handy

Is there a God?

1458 words - 6 pages Is there such thing as a God, or is He or She just a figment of ones imagination? Is God a crutch that people can depend on or is He or She really there? Is there such thing as miracles? Who created God? Why are there so many different religions and denominations with so many different beliefs? What about the Big Bang theory? Did Noah really have Ark? Last but not least, why would God let such evil and horrific things happen to people in our

Is there a god?

855 words - 3 pages God?Is there a god?If there is a god why doesn't he make himself more evident and his existence not only proved by faith? Vailable questions that have plagued mankind since the place we have come to know as our world, came to be. I consider myself a Christian but many times I struggle with the same questions the atheist and agnostics use to disprove the existence of an all powerful, and omniscient God. Can we prove God or did this God make it so

Is there a God?

1408 words - 6 pages named Blaise Pascal. Pascal studied calculus and was very good at using math to figure out anything. He was asked if he believed in God, and if so could he prove it with math. His reply developed into a theory in which he states it is better to believe in a God than to deny it. He came to this conclusion by looking at the problem rationally. Pascal figured out that the way to look at the existence of God is to look at it as odds. He said that there

Is There A God?

810 words - 4 pages there is a God. They must take the word of others and books like the Bible to show them that there is a God. Rev. Billy Graham, a firm believer in God, presents a very fallacious argument in his speech. Cline (2014) defines a fallacy as “Fallacies are defects in an argument – other than false premises – which cause an argument to be invalid, unsounds or weak” (para. 1). This is mostly done by Graham’s failure to ever give any evidence or

Is There Really A God?

1889 words - 8 pages something out of nothing. Therefore there needs to have been a First Cause that created this ‘something’ being the universe . There had to have been a first cause which allowed for everything else to happen, since everything has a cause . According to Aquinas the only possible First Cause is God. However, this argument contradicts itself. By saying that one thing, for example God, can exist without a cause, you are contradicting that everything must

Why There Is A God

1938 words - 8 pages with anger then a feeling of abandonment, finally followed by stress and frustration. I tried and thought repeatedly, how could God let evil exist? I continued my thinking process and thought is there not more scientific evidence to dismiss God's power than to worship it? How could evolution be explained? The age of the Earth itself is older than what any holy book from any organized religion claims. Is that not enough to reject God? And to me

Assessment of the View that it is Rational to Believe that there is a God

1058 words - 4 pages Assessment of the View that it is Rational to Believe that there is a God Rational: To be rational is to think logically and within reason. To base your thoughts on evidence, and then use that evidence to come to a "rational" conclusion. Motivation: To be motivated to do or think something, normally the motivation will be because it will benefit you in the long run. Many philosophers use theses types of words when

There is No God

783 words - 3 pages gosh darn it, those sheep-like bi-peds really love me!" Certainly the only reason to create man and have him worship you would be to satisfy some need. And since God by definition is without needs, the only rational conclusion is that God does not exist.If God did exist, shouldn't we expect to see more evidence of Him? The Bible fails to offer such evidence. When looked at through objective eyes, the Bible appears more like a fantastic fable than

Similar Essays

A Critique Of “Is There A God? By Bertrand Russell”

1763 words - 8 pages The article “Is There a God” was written by Bertrand Russell and was commissioned but never published in illustrated Magazine in 1952.Bertrand Arthur William Russell was a British Philosopher, logician and social critic. Bertrand Russell was the recipient of countless awards for excellence during his long lifetime (1872-1970), including the Nobel Prize for literature, which he won in 1950. The range of his critical inquiry is without parallel in

Is There A God?, By Bertrand Russell

1349 words - 6 pages disprove the Olympic Gods either. For most of his adult life Russell maintained that religion is little more than superstition and, despite any positive effects that religion might have, it is largely harmful to people. . In the article the author explains to the reader and stresses upon the opinion as to why the existence of god is a false concept and thus concludes that there is no point in believing in a supreme ruler. The author expressively

The Relevance Of Philosophy, Essay About A Bertrand Russell Extract

1136 words - 5 pages '. These include the prejudices people are familiar with, such as racism or sexism, and an equally important, but less obvious group of prejudices: those caused by peer pressure - e.g. if you move to Saudi Arabia as a child, there will be strong pressure on you to become a follower of Islam.It is clear to me that Russell was something of a cynic, at least where popular sentiment was concerned. He is advocating that you be very careful of the

Bertrand Russell : A Free Man’s Worship

831 words - 3 pages This essay will explain the beliefs and philosophies of Bertrand Russell. He was the author of, "A Free Man's Worship". In Betrand's essay, he presents an atheistic perspective on morality. He clearly believes that there is no God and that eventually the human race will rid itself. In this essay, why Bertrand concludes there can be no God will be explained. Bertrand writes that a God that was good could not possibly have created a world