Review Of Documentary "Muddy Waters" On Sedimentation On The Great Barrier Reef In Australia.

1001 words - 4 pages

MUDDY WATERS by Sally Ingleton(Shown 20th May on SBS)The documentary Muddy Waters provides an insight into the sedimentation on the Great Barrier Reef between Cairns and Townsville and how it is destroying the reef. However, though the movie does try to portray opposing sides of the debate as to what is causing this sedimentation, many fundamental issues to the problem have been avoided or underplayed.The video stated heavy metals as one of the causes of the sedimentation and "marine snow" on the Great Barrier Reef but failed to mention what heavy metals are or which heavy metals are thought to be contaminating the reef. This heavy metals argument was used a lot in attacking cane farmers but very little information was actually given on the subject. Contaminant heavy metals may enter the environment by a variety of human activities, not only cane farming. Such things as land fills or even galvanized roofing can contribute to a rise in levels of heavy metals in sediments.Heavy metals such as mercury, cadmium, copper, and zinc occur naturally in sediment. The problem is distinguishing what are the expected natural levels of the substances, what is from human sources and what, if any, are risks to the environment. CRC research has shown that some naturally occurring metals, such as cadmium, build up higher levels of concentration over time by natural processes. This means that the natural levels of metals in some sediments may even be higher than levels measured in contaminated sediments, a situation that makes it more complicated for environmental managers to recognise and evaluate risks to the environment.Despite the documentary it has been shown that the Great Barrier Reef itself is not under the most threat of heavy metal contamination derived from Townsville. The areas most prone to contamination are estuarine and intertidal zones, which act as a trap for muddy sediments and pollutants. Refuse tips, storm water runoff from built up areas, and industrial sites close to these vulnerable areas are typical sources for heavy metals, points which were entirely omitted from the film.The documentary also focussed on cane farms as the sole perpetrators of adding fertilisers and pesticides to the reef through runoff and soil erosion through their irrigation drains. However thousands of tonnes of nitrogen and phosphorous from fertilisers, used on banana and cotton farms, were also being washed into the sea and poisoning marine life. Banana farms were only briefly and ineffectually brought up and cotton farms were not even mentioned in the film. Beef and dairy cattle grazing farms were also not discussed as possible causes of flood plumes and pollution. Cattle grazing accounts for 83 percent of land use in catchment regions draining into or near the Great Barrier Reef area and farms with some 4.9 million cattle depositing 18 million tonnes of sediment a year. Despite the impression given in the video, crops accounted for only 1.13 percent of land use in...

Find Another Essay On Review of documentary "Muddy Waters" on sedimentation on the Great Barrier Reef in Australia.

The Great Barrier Reef Essay

1089 words - 4 pages . (Brace, 2003: 98). By the marine tourism industry is a major contributor to the local and Australian economy. However, according to Australian research department, is generally of a reactive nature to site-specific problems such as the impacts of visitors on the Great Barrier Reef. (Hall, 1991:298). In addition, Scientists said today that the Great Barrier Reef damaged about 10 percent due to the tourism activities. (CBC, 2005). An example is

The Great Barrier Reef Essay

1172 words - 5 pages The Great Barrier Reef is 350,000 kilometers long, the world’s largest living organism, and is home to 6,000+ species, but these species could be in danger. According to recent research, the Great Barrier Reef is on the verge of dying because of reckless human behavior. The reef is beneficial to not only ocean life, but also people and the mainland. There are also ways to people can preserve the reef. Some scenarios that have affected the

The Great Barrier Reef

1301 words - 5 pages negative impacts on the coral reef. The tourists are carried around the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park (GBRMP) by over 500 commercial vessels which drop fuel, anchors and other forms of pollution that damage the reef. The tourists also break the fragile corals by touching and reef walking as well as contaminating the water with sweat and suntan lotions. (Source 5) Most damage to the reef has occurred in the last fifty years. It coincided almost

The Great Barrier Reef -Outline 2 physical characteristics of the Great Barrier Reef

2500 words - 10 pages that are important to the indigenous cultural heritage of Australia in the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park area. Some include:•Seek food for nourishment on a daily basis and for special occasions or ceremonies•Seek natural products including plant material for the production of baskets, necklaces and other goods12•Implement, control and monitor traditional management measures to maintain biodiversity in the sea and the on the land12

Shipping and the Great Barrier Reef

4812 words - 19 pages from outer space (Guynup p.22). The GBR includes 2,900 separate reefs and hundreds various islands and cays. The GBR stretches over 2,000 kilometers up the coast of Queensland. The Great Barrier Reef Marine Park (GBRMP), established in 1975, includes nearly 350,000 square kilometers, which is over half the area covered by all of the protected areas in mainland Australia (Chadwick and Storrie p.1, CRC p.1). This vast environment serves as

How the Australian Great Barrier Reef Succeeds at Preservation and Sustainable Use and How it Applies to a Worldwide Problem

3377 words - 14 pages shallow reef and near-shore environments (Hatcher 1998). In the Great Barrier Reef, recreation accounts for about four times the income that fishing does. Because the economic benefits are on such are large scale, the policy process really depends on the cooperation of everyone who is monetarily affected by the reef. Addressing equity throughout the policy process is important. What this means is allowing all interested parties - poor or

My theme opinion on By the Waters of Babylon

634 words - 3 pages Alexander Lopez Lopez 1Mr. HernandezEnglish 1021 September 2014By the Waters of Babylon: Avoiding ApocalypseThe story "By the Waters of Babylon" takes place in both a tribe in a forests and later the remains of what we know was New York. As John, a son of a priest, makes his journey to his limit, he decides to go farther and reach the city of the god to understand more about them. Upon reaching his destination, he finds out that the "gods" were

The Effect of the External Environment on Work in Australia

2034 words - 8 pages The Effect of the External Environment on Work in Australia This essay considers how changes in the external environment of organisations have altered the world of work. Australia is currently experiencing a period of economic growth. But some new challenges have appeared. Australian organisations are facing skill shortages and an aging workforce. This shortage has been addressed by introduction of new technology in workplaces and influx of

Review of the findings of the joint parliamentary Standing Committee on Family and Community Affairs in their inquiry into child custody issues of Australia.

1188 words - 5 pages In June 2003, a joint parliamentary Standing Committee on Family and Community Affairs was commissioned by the Prime Minister to conduct an inquiry into child custody issues and the child support formula. The committee presented its report on the 29th of December 2003 along with its recommendations for reform of the Family Law Act 1975. The focus of this report will be on an evaluation of the existing law and the recommendations provided by the

In the documentary film "The Color of Fear, "a group of men engaged in a candid discussion on racism.

768 words - 3 pages In the documentary film "The Color of Fear, "a group of men engaged in a candid discussion on racism. The group consisted of eight men, and they were African, Asian, Latino, and White Americans. It was to show that all Africans, Asians, Latinos, or Whites do not think alike and are diverse. I believe that is why there were two men representing each ethnicity. At some point in the movie it made me feel quite uncomfortable to watch because of the

"Crumb" Documentary on Robert Crumb the cartoonist

714 words - 3 pages CRUMB is a documentary about the famous underground cartoonist named Robert Crumb. He is the one who did the Keep On Truck'n illustration, the X-rated Fritz the Cat cartoon character, and the Mr. Natural cartoon series among others.CRUMB tells Robert's story as well as that of his highly dysfunctional family. He and his two brothers, Charles and Max, cling to the edge of the sane world. Robert has his success as a cartoonist to vent his pent up

Similar Essays

Acanthaster Planci On The Great Barrier Reef

4074 words - 16 pages Acanthaster planci on the Great Barrier Reef The organism Acanthaster planci, commonly known as the crown of thorns starfish, has a drastic effect on the health of coral reefs all over the world, including the Great Barrier Reef of Australia. This poisonous echinoderm feeds upon the coral, and although this should be a healthy and natural part of the ecosystem, the population explosions of the starfish have caused devastation in many

The Effects Of Global Warming On The Great Barrier Reef

922 words - 4 pages too high, coral polyps lose the symbiotic algae inside them, causing them to turn white, or "bleach," and eventually die. In particular, Australia has been slow to cut back on greenhouse gas emissions. This may explain why in 1998, almost 90% of the Great Barrier Reef was affected by coral bleaching. Global warming trends may also lead to more extreme and unpredictable weather. An increase in tropical storms could do extensive physical

The Great Barrier Reef Essay

1223 words - 5 pages that he had just discovered the Great Barrier Reef. Cook and his team had been exploring the waters offshore of what is now Queensland, Australia when the H.M.S. Endeavour became trapped in the labyrinth of coral. Not too far below the surface, rough, spiky towers of coral tore into the ship’s frame and held the vessel fast( As timbers splintered and the sea poured in, the crew arrived on deck “with countenances which

The Great Barrier Reef Essay 521 Words

521 words - 2 pages The Great Barrier ReefThe Great Barrier Reef is the biggest group of coral reefs in the world.It stretches along the coast on the north-east part of Australia. It is called the Great Barrier Reef because it creates a barrier between the Pacific Ocean and the coast.The Great Barrier Reef is a scattering of thousands of individual reefs. The reefs is on the World Heritage List made by UNESCO, because of its size and its many different plants and