This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Review Of “Electoral Reform Proposal Failures In Canada”

960 words - 4 pages

Review of “Electoral Reform Proposal Failures in Canada”

The author Lawrence Leduc is a political science researcher at the University of Toronto. Aside

from this article, he has written many other scholarly critiques about the political system in

Canada. From the very beginning, it is evident that Leduc’s academic credentials confirm his

strong background in politics. In other words, readers would appreciate his expertise on the topic

and might potentially use the article as an academic source. This review will seek to analyze

the strengths and weaknesses of the author’s arguments and evaluate its significance to potential


The main argument that Lawrence Leduc tries ...view middle of the document...

In his argument, he provided a clear and concise

history of why electoral reforms occurred. According to the evidence, it was clearly shown

that proposals like the Law Commission of Canada were ignored by the Canadian government.

Moreover, the graph that he provides, indicated that there was a decline in voter turnout

beginning in the late 80’s and early 90’s. At this point, the reader can understand why Canada’s

political system needed an electoral reform. Another issue he addresses is explaining what

the Law Commission of Canada was. The reader will enjoy how applicable electoral reform

proposals are to the multiple streams model. The streams model theory explains that when a

new administration takes over, it can either advance or destroy your policy window. This is

how Leduc emphasizes why the Law Commission of Canada’s proposal had failed because the

Liberal administration was no longer in power. Finally, the reader will admire the brief analysis

of a few provinces that reiterates his original argument of lessons learned in Canada. Although

Leduc provided information from the 90’s and early 2000’s, he does not mention much from

the other decades. Another issue was that he focused heavily on the provinces and could have

elaborated more on the federal government.

The second part that provided compelling arguments was when he talked about the Citizens’

Assembly in Ontario. He gave a detailed description of how the Liberal government was not

interested in the actual assembly and it was just a PR stunt to appease the public. This supports

his second main argument of how politicians fear electoral reforms as they pose a threat to

their power. Similar to the Law Commission of Canada, the reader can relate the topic of the

Citizens’ Assembly to the issue of senate reform. Both are difficult to accomplish because of

the partisanship in politics. Furthermore, Leduc clearly explains why the...

Find Another Essay On Review of “Electoral Reform Proposal Failures in Canada”

"Society's Restraint to Social Reform" in Canada

1454 words - 6 pages Of the many chatted words in the social reform vocabulary of Canadians today,the term workfare seems to stimulate much debate and emotion. Along with thenotions of self-sufficiency, employability enhancement, and workdisincentives, it is the concept of workfare that causes the most tensionbetween it's government and business supporters and it's anti-poverty andsocial justice critics. In actuality, workfare is a contraction of theconcept of

Policy Proposal for Economic Reform in Russia

2761 words - 11 pages Policy Proposal for Economic Reform in Russia Despite making a recovery after the 1998 market crash, Russia remains weighted with numerous holdovers from the Communist era that keep its economy from taking advantage of free-market reforms. In short, Russia has not prospered under capitalism because it has not yet discovered it. In order to do so, the Russian government must engage in extensive reform in several key areas: improving the rule

Successes and Failures of Patriarchy in Colonialism

3256 words - 13 pages usurpation and ends with his return to power. Patriarchy starts in “Things Fall Apart” with Okonkwo working hard and coming to power and ends with his subsequent death. Moreover, in “Translations”, patriarchy is set around characters dominating each other and the introduction of the English forces introduces another level of patriarchy. Despite all the similarities and differences between characters, the success and failures comes down solely to

Canada and the United States of America Necessary Allies in Matters of Defence: A Canadian Policy Proposal

2060 words - 8 pages Canada and the United States of America Necessary Allies in Matters of Defence: A Canadian Policy Proposal Defence cooperation is a significant component to the Canadian-American relationship. Not only does each country have to provide individual defence and provide defence for their neighbour, but both Canada and the United States seek to defend North America as well. Being the two neighbouring North American countries, it is essential

The Potential of a Majoritarian Electoral System Instead of a Proportional Electoral System in South Africa

1345 words - 5 pages The journey to democracy has been strongly driven by electoral systems. These systems provide routes for governments to represent the wills of their people. It provides the platform of legitimacy to the government and in most cases ensures freedom and order within a country. This essay will discuss the major differences between a majoritarian electoral system and proportional electoral system. In addition, it will demonstrate that the use of a

Draft: Are Current Political Conditions Ripe in Canada to Mobilize for a Change from Single Member Plurality (SMP) Electoral System?

916 words - 4 pages POLI 2304 Paper Intro The research question I chose for my term paper was number 13, which asks “Are the current political conditions ripe in Canada to mobilize for a change from our single member plurality (SMP) electoral system? If so, what should be the nature of the change? If not, why not?” To address these questions, I created the thesis statement “Canada’s current electoral system unduly favours the pluralist approach to the detriment of

Overview of Divorce in Canada

1706 words - 7 pages /desc01 -eng.htm>. Page 12 The Economist. " A senseless census reform." The Economist. The Economist Newspaper, 20 Oct. 2010. Web. 6 Jan. 2014. . The Globe and Mail. "History of Regional Unemployment Rates in Canada Add to ...." The Globe and Mail. Philip Crawley, 9 Oct. 2010. Web. 6 Jan. 2014.

Contempt of Court in Canada

2368 words - 9 pages offence of contempt of court and narrow the scope of this paper. The second part will set out and explain the arguments in favour of, and against, codifying the law. Finally, the last part of the paper will set forth some proposals for reform. The Openness Principle Even before freedom of expression was enshrined in our constitution, the judiciary noted that the basic principle governing judicial proceedings in Canada was their openness

Decriminalization of Marijuana in Canada

1338 words - 5 pages Marijuana is currently a hot topic of debate throughout Canada, and has been for the past few years. Marijuana was first banned in 1923 under the Opium and Drug Act, but since 1997 the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act have controlled it. In 2000, over 30,000 Canadians were charged with possession of marijuana. Currently, the marijuana laws are not enforced equally across the country, which has prompted the interest in changing the laws or

History of Bullying in Canada

1662 words - 7 pages , A, 2003). Bullying not only takes place in person but can presented in many different forms and manners. Some including online or more formally known as cyberbullying, where a person is threatened by the means of online communication or social networking. According to Statistics Canada (2009), “1 in 10 adults living in a household with children reported a child victim of cyberbullying” (StatsCan, 2009). Other types of bullying include physical

The Electoral Reforms in Patterns of Democracy by Arend Lijphart

991 words - 4 pages In his book ‘Patterns of Democracy’, Arend Lijphart mentions how electoral systems of majoritarian and consensus model of democracies differ. The electoral systems in majoritarian democracies quintessentially tend to be single-member district plurality system, while consensus democracies usually tend to use the method of proportional representation. Most electoral systems fit into the two categories of PR and plurality-majority. However, there

Similar Essays

Electoral Reform In Canada Essay

1870 words - 7 pages Electoral Reform in Canada The issue of electoral reform has become more important than ever in Canada in recent years as the general public has come to realize that our current first-past-the-post, winner-take-all system, formally known as single-member plurality (SMP) has produced majority governments of questionable legitimacy. Of the major democracies in the world, Canada, the United States, and the United Kingdom are the only countries

Electoral Reform In Canada: An Examination Of Proportional Representation

2765 words - 11 pages , electoral systems have frequently been the focus of intense scholarly debate. Electoral reform in Canada has been a main focus of these debates and "proportional representation (PR) is currently proposed as a solution to a large number of the country's ills" (Fitzgerald, 2001, 49). There clearly are many advantages for a country to adopt a PR system, however, in Canada, the adoption of such a system could have potential negative consequences thus

Time For Reform? Considering The Failures Of The Electoral College In The Us

1882 words - 8 pages TIME FOR REFORM? CONSIDERING THE FAILURES OF THE ELECTORAL COLLEGEDescription: This paper discusses the many shortcomings of the ElectoralCollege, and posits possible alternative electoral processes which likely bemore democratic.Time for Reform?Considering the failures of the Electoral CollegeA common misconception among American is that when they vote they elect the President. The truth is notnearly this simple. What in fact happens when a

Changing The Electoral System In Canada

2040 words - 9 pages Systems." Trinity College Press 10.1 (1991): 33-51. Web. Milner, Henry. "Obstacles to Electoral Reform in Canada." American Review of Canadian Studies 24.1 (1994): 39-55. Print. Sachs, Jeffrey. The Price of Civilization: Reawakening American Virtue and Prosperity. New York: Random House, 2011. 107. Print. Schwartz, Bryan. "Proportional Representation for Canada." Manitoba Law Journal 28.2 (2001): 133. Web. 14 Mar. 2014. Spafford, Duff. "Does