This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Reviewing The Necessity Of Punishment

1713 words - 7 pages

Reviewing the Necessity of Punishment

"From 'On Crimes and Punishment'" by Cesare Beccaria is an excerpt from On Crimes and Punishment. In his address to the public, particularly those in political positions, Beccaria discusses the way we as a society choose to carry out the law. What he calls "useless severity" of punishment encompasses his thoughts on extremes such as capital punishment and the cruelties that we allow our government to inflict upon its own people in a failing attempt to bring order to our society. The death penalty has plagued our society for centuries, perhaps beginning with the idea of human sacrifice that has been turned around as a cycle of never-ending death and cruelty. The writing techniques employed by Beccaria effectively convince his audience that our forms of criminal punishment are nothing more than an unnecessary bad habit.

In a debate, one can easily bring their opposition to silence by asking them a question that they cannot answer. Beccaria uses this method to his advantage in his work. He asks a series of questions that can't be easily answered. The lazy reader would much rather have faith in Beccaria's beliefs than sort through the questions and find answers themselves. He asks, "What is the best way of preventing crimes? Are the same penalties always equally useful? What influence have they on social custom?" (64). These questions only lead to more questions. The reader may be able to ponder situations that both promote and discredit any solutions they may have for these questions, leaving them more confused about their own stance. The reader is so wrapped up in trying to answer these questions, that they don't realize that Beccaria himself never answers them. This sly technique encourages the reader to believe that since these questions can't be easily answered, it is simply better and easier to accept Beccaria's opinion of criminal justice as truth.

Cesare Beccaria is quick to point out the opposing view to his statement, then use it as reinforcement for his own argument. Discussing capital punishment, he clearly states that many countries, if not most, practice this and have done so for centuries. He doesn't give his audience much time to think about that as he quickly calls the history of mankind "a vast sea of errors, among which there float a few confused truths, each one far from the next" (68). Instead of just referring to the mistakes made in our history, Beccaria calls them "a vast sea of errors" implying that these mistakes are so tremendous in number and carry such weight with them that they have not been given enough credit for the tragedies they have caused. It is also unclear if Beccaria is insulting his opponent, adding their opinion to this "vast sea of errors." In turn, the reader doesn't want their thoughts bunched with these erroneous opinions. The author claims these mistakes are the effect of "confused truths." To the reader, "confused truths" equates fallacy. The diction is...

Find Another Essay On Reviewing the Necessity of Punishment

The Necessity of Personal Responsibility Essay

1260 words - 5 pages Personal responsibility may be perceived in many ways, but it is imperative to understand the relevance of why it must begin with our self. First, one will never develop an attitude of responsibility if they always look for others to complete their task. It is a necessity that one has personal discipline or their efforts to be responsible will prove to be fruitless. Second, being responsible yields great rewards and acting responsible is a

The Necessity of Computer Security Essay

1743 words - 7 pages application of cryptography for civilian purposes is not just a right, but is also a necessity. Increasingly in today's era of computer technology, not only banks but also businesses and government agencies are turning to encryption. Computer security experts consider it best and most practical way to protect computer data from unauthorized disclosure when transmitted and even when stored on a disk, tape, of the magnetic strip of a credit card. Two

The Necessity of Urban Farming

1238 words - 5 pages control be used in lieu of more hazardous chemicals. However, despite the sometimes staggering effort required the benefits of urban farming are becoming more of a necessity than a luxury. Urban farming is not a new idea. During World War II a message was sent out to our communities as well as the allies to start Victory Gardens. (Putnam, Cosper) The premise was to avoid a shortage of fresh food and relieve some the pressure on the nation to

The Continued Necessity of Feminism

1830 words - 8 pages response to a reporter’s question, “Why do you write these strong female characters,” Whedon said: “Because equality is not a concept. It’s not something we should be striving for. It’s a necessity. Equality is like gravity. We need it to stand on this Earth as men and women. And the misogyny that is in every culture is not a true part of the human condition. It is life out of balance, and that imbalance is sucking something out of the soul of

The Necessity of Reforming the Citizenship Process

1779 words - 7 pages majority of Americans cannot do so. While these results clearly show the ignorance among many Americans and the flawed education system in America, they also illustrate the necessity of modifying the citizenship test. Although some believe that the citizenship test is unfair, there are others who believe that the citizenship test is “dumbed down and deleterious” (Miller 1). John Miller, in “What Should an American Know? The New Naturalization

The Expiration of the Feminist Necessity

2082 words - 8 pages The Expiration of the Feminist NecessityFeminism started as a movement for women's equality to men in all aspects of existence with the exception of inherent physiological and physical differences. The movement over time has created quite a stir and made some overwhelming changes in the ways that women are viewed when compared to men, with regard to purpose and ability. However, feminism is no longer necessary to fulfill the purpose for which it

Evaluating the Necessity of Space Travel

1695 words - 7 pages pushing the limit of necessity through the ample budget appointed to space travel and its societal outcomes. Firstly, space exploration has defined a positive connection between a multitude of nations, each seeking to uncover new finds. Fourteen space agencies worldwide compose the International Space Exploration Coordination Group (ISECG). Otherwise known as “a group that dedicates to sharing information in order to help individual efforts as

Actions of Necessity during the Holocaust

609 words - 2 pages greed” (Wiesel 55). By using blackmail to beat up his father and taunting him for his lackluster marching, Eliezer, who could not stand his father facing this punishment, had his gold crown stolen away. Overcome by greed, Franek did all he could to soothe his hunger. How could humans be so terrible? When situations are threatening, humans become inhumane. Almost everyone would be swallowed by the will to survive and be urged to perform tasks that they would have never dreamed of doing.

The Necessity of School Dress Code

821 words - 4 pages The school dress code is a serious issue in all schools and has been for a very long time. Everyone knows that everyone has their own point of view when it comes to the dress code. The school dress code has to be taken more seriously if we want the schools that children attend to be better places. The school dress code is a necessity because it does not violate any constitutional rights, keeps students safe, and teaches self respect. The school

The Necessity of Bicycle Helmet Laws

1486 words - 6 pages The Necessity of Bicycle Helmet Laws     Bicycle accidents have increased dramatically in the United States. About 500 American children and teenagers die each year in bicycle accidents, and three-quarters of those deaths come from head injuries (Jacques 1). Recent federal safety reports suggest that helmets can reduce the risk of head injury, but that only 4% of children under the age of ten wear helmets when bicycling. The percentage

The Necessity of Health Care Reform

1306 words - 5 pages , something they had no part in controlling. The health care providers who do this should face punishment for not giving those people a fighting chance against their disease. Medicare should also receive more money to continue running. It greatly helps out those that truly need it and might not have another way of acquiring health care. These are attainable goals if everyone in America became insured. If everyone was insured, costs would go down

Similar Essays

The Necessity Of Sleep Essay

791 words - 4 pages Recently, scientists have proven how important sleep is to the brain, and the harmful effects of sleep deprivation. In “Goodnight. Sleep Clean,” by Maria Konnikova, she shows that sleep is a necessity for a long, healthy life. Why do humans sleep? Maiken Nedergaard, a Danish biologist, has researched sleep functions at the University of Rochester’s medical school. From her research, she has found the reasons behind our sleeping needs

The Necessity Of Deceit Essay

1740 words - 7 pages enacted in various forms which inevitably result in negative consequences that are viable and understandable. Essentially, deception is a necessary aspect of humanity which cannot be overlooked; it is required for conformity purposes as well as for personal gains. It is clear that in spite of the necessity of deception, the actions which support such motives influence the manifestation of adverse ramifications.

Necessity Of The Incarnation Essay

1118 words - 5 pages Jesus, the Son of God, became Incarnate. We are the reason for the necessity of the Incarnation. Jesus had to be human for our salvation. We know that He is truly our savior. His Incarnation, suffering, death, and Resurrection was for all of us. Jesus came to save us from our sins and evilness, and to guide us back to the Godhead. In the beginning the Word created everything. After creation, humans were holy, and in harmony with God. One

The Necessity Of Car Insurance Essay

947 words - 4 pages The Necessity of Car Insurance A few days ago, while I was spending the day with my friend Sean, he received a notice in the mail that his car insurance payment had gone up by twenty dollars a month. He, of course, wasn’t happy with this increase and started complaining about how car insurance was ridiculous and how much he hated it. He started going on about how people should not be required to have car insurance and listed a number of