“Revolutionary Government Resorted To Extreme Measures To Consolidate Power.” How Valid Is This Statement?

1569 words - 6 pages

"Revolutionary Government resorted to extreme measures to consolidate power." How valid is this statement?The Bolshevik take over of October 1917 was achieved with speed and little bloodshed; however, the new government was far from secure. The Bolsheviks controlled little except Petrograd and many thought that they would struggle to hang on to power. Many people were against the Bolsheviks "The insane attempt of the Bolsheviks is on the eve of collapse…the Bolsheviks are alone" (soldier section of SR party, October 1917)1 . One Socialist Revolutionary leader gave it 'no more than a few days', while the Menshevik leader, Tsereteli, gave it three weeks2. This dire situation forced the Bolsheviks to resort to extreme measures like shut down the Constituent Assembly, signing the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk, the use of terror and then 1917 land decree.Lenin had promised to the people that a new parliament, the Constituent Assembly, was to be elected. One of the dearest dreams of the Russian people was to have a government in which they would elect and would represent their interests. This was not one of Lenin's dreams. In Lenin's eyes, the Constituent Assembly posed a real threat to his socialist vision. He believed it to be a real threat because what if the elections were held and the Bolsheviks did not receive the majority of votes? On the other hand, if he didn't let the elections take place, how could he claim he represented the interests of the people of Russia like they always wanted? The results of the elections are below,% of the votesSocialist Revolutionaries 40.4Bolsheviks 23.2Other Socialists 15.0National Parties 7.7Kadets 4.6Mensheviks 2.9Cossacks 2.2Figure 1: Election results for the Constituent Assembly3, taken from Oxley, Russia: From Tsars to Commissars, page 115Lenin did his best to make sure that the Bolsheviks won the elections. His efforts did not succeed as the Bolsheviks only received around a quarter of the votes (refer to Figure 1), with the Socialist Revolutionaries (SR's) receiving a majority of the votes. Lenin was furious and dealt with the matter forcibly. When the Assembly met on the 5th January 1918, he ordered the Red Guards to close down the Assembly. Lenin declared that his form of government represented a higher stage of democracy than the elected assembly. The Bolsheviks and Left SR's met and declared themselves the Government. Lenin, however, only brought the Left SR's in as junior partners in the SOVNARKOM (the new government party, exclusively made up of Bolsheviks). He believed this was useful because, with the Left SR's in the party, he could claim to represent the interests of the peasants. The remainder were labelled 'counter-revolutionary'. Later the Left SR's were eventually removed from government because they opposed Lenin's signing of a peace treaty with Germany - The Treaty of Brest-Litovsk. These political machinations, which trampled the democratic will of the majority of Russians supports the...

Find Another Essay On “Revolutionary Government resorted to extreme measures to consolidate power.” How valid is this statement?

'Hitler's charismatic personality and policies only partly explain the Nazis' rise to power in 1933.' To what extent do you agree with this statement?

889 words - 4 pages and were not only humiliated, but also found it had placed strain on their economy. To solve this problem, the government printed more money, making it decrease in value and causing hyperinflation. Also, because the constitution decreed that no one party could gain majority, leadership in the Reichstag was constantly changing. By this time, most Germans had already lost much faith in the Weimar Government and thought it unstable.At the time of the

"A successful economic policy was the key behind Hitler´s maintenance of power in Germany." - To what extent do you agree with this statement?

990 words - 4 pages Dunia Malezai "A successful economic policy was the key behind Hitler´s maintenance of power in Germany." - To what extent do you agree with this statement? Hitler maintained power in Germany through a number of different measures. The successful economic policy, however, was the most important of all. The economic chaos in Germany after the Wall Street Crash of 1929 and the overall economic instability of Weimar Germany was a perfect

How did Hitler consolidate his power and continue to gain support, using propaganda, after taking power?

1723 words - 7 pages , and reports. The Nazis kept a very close watch on the different groups within their population, in order to best learn how to reach the different groups most effectively. Through their targeting of a variety of different groups, and their familiarization with those groups, the Nazis used propaganda to further consolidate their power after Hitler's appointment to chancellor.One of the most forceful manifestations of Hitler's propaganda campaign in

Issues of power and control are evident from the start of the play. To what extent do you find the truth of this statement reflected in Acts I & II of 'The Tempest'?

1076 words - 4 pages telling of his past to Miranda, Prospero coveys his feelings of spiteful loathing towards his brother, Alonso. “The government I cast upon my brother,” tells of how he simply handed over his command to Alonso and his admittance that “to my state grew stranger, being transported and rapt in secret studies,” shows the he himself is to blame for his abdication and eviction. Alonso now has the power and control that Prospero once owned. Referring to

Chilean and Nicaraguan Revolution: The Failure To Consolidate Power

2269 words - 9 pages Central Unica de Trabajadores and this alliance was formed in August 1988. A recent challenge that the Chilean Left party was facing was the 1990s governmental officials. These officials were attempting to connect new labor movements with revolutionary socialism. This connection with new labor movements and ideas of the socialism is the best outlook for working class people so they will not have to struggle anymore or anything time in the near

How did the purges enable Stalin to consolidate his rule?

980 words - 4 pages mention of these people, and furthermore no subsequent disagreements to Stalin and his rule in the party. This is significant as it shows how far Stalin was willing to go to make sure that his rule was safe from anybody else. Thus by the end of the third Moscow trial Stalin had affirmed his position in the party by ruling with terror. No one would speak out against him again.The purge of the Red Army would be the next great purge of Stalin's


4456 words - 18 pages of Zambia confers generous powers on the President, making him the effective hub of the whole machinery of Government. Like his American counterpart, he is at liberty both in law and in conscience, to be as big a man as he can or as small as he chooses.The power outlined by Mubako and Hirschfield is evident in the relationship that the executive has with the other organs of government and how it fits into the general provisions of the law and the

This essay is about how the New Democracy rose up to power during 1820-1840

635 words - 3 pages Adams, because he actually listened to the people and voiced their opinions to Congress. This helped Jackson get his nickname as the "people's president." Jackson agreed with the spoils system, which gave political supporters their chance to shine by taking a position in the public office. "Every man is as good as his neighbor, perhaps equally better" was Jackson's motto when it came to the spoils system. "Rotation in office" soon became accepted

Is prostitution a crime?if so, what measures would you take to eradicate this social evil?

982 words - 4 pages SociologyIs prostitution a crime? If so, what measures would you take to eradicate this social evil?According to the Webster's dictionary, prostitution is defined as "the act or practice of indulging in promiscuous sexual relations especially for money". Prostitution is the sale of sexual services for money or other kind of return, generally indiscriminately with many persons. A person selling sexual favors is a prostitute, a type of sex worker

"From 1781 to1789 the Articles of Confederation provided the United States with an effective government." Using the documents and your knowledge of the period, evaluate this statement."

954 words - 4 pages , Joseph Jones of Virginia states that Congress is unable "to pay their (members of the army) demands, unless furnished with the means of several States." This makes the Articles of Confederation very ineffective due to the power taken away from Congress and given to the individual states, and therefore, unification not present, also seen in Document D as well as C. The Articles of Confederation took power from the army and therefore weakening the

How valid is the claim that in 1914 states went to war due to fear rather then motives of gain?

1201 words - 5 pages How valid is the claim that in 1914 states went to war due to fear rather then motives of gain?Austria's quarrel, Germany's warOne of the theories about the outbreak of the First World War is that nations went to war not to necessarily gain something but mainly because of fear which caused by many different factors.Europe before the war can be compared to a round-about with the countries involved, Germany being the central pole, speeding up and

Similar Essays

Why Were The Habsburgs Unable To Consolidate Their Power In Hungary During This Period?

2092 words - 8 pages Habsburg rule would not be good for them, and thus made certain that the Habsburg could not secure power in Hungary during this period. Another factor that must be argued is the fact in the entire period that the Habsburgs should have been attempting to consolidate their power in Hungary, they were instead preoccupied with events on the Italian peninsular. After the Ottomans retreated from Vienna in 1529, the Habsburgs had taken a defensive stance

"To A Great Extent The Constitution Is A Document With As Many Checks Upon The Power Of The People And Majority Rule As Upon The Power Of The Government." Assess The Validity Of This Statement

745 words - 3 pages legislative. The government felt that this distribution of power would allow the authorities of each branch be able to be more able to suit the particular needs and demands of each office as well as hinder both corruption and unseemly behavior of the officials in government. The legislative branch or the law-making body of government is broken up in power between the Senate, and the House of Representatives. The power of each house is shared among

'all Men, In The Novel, Abuse Their Power And Higher Place In Society Over Women'. Discuss How True This Statement Is In Margret Atwood's 'the Handmaid's Tale'.

514 words - 2 pages 'All men, in the novel, abuse their power and higher place in society over women'.Discuss how true this statement is in Margret Atwood's 'The Handmaid's Tale'.The handmaids tale is set in a patriarchal society highly dominated by men, some of which abuse their power and use their higher status in society to get what they want. A prime example ofAnother example of a character that abuses his power, is one who takes advantage of the protagonist of

Analyse To What Extent This Comment Reflects The Move To Bolshevism/Communism In Russia From 1917. Evaluate To What Extent Stalin’s Rule Of The Soviet Union Reflected Revolutionary Committee Power?

3225 words - 13 pages forced the decline of the committee power and it will show how the rule of Lenin and Stalin were different.The Bolsheviks became increasing popular throughout Russia during WW1 due to the unpopularity of the provisional government. The Russians wanted to get out of WW1 but the provisional government did nothing to satisfy this. Desertions became more popular in the army, with over 2 million Russian soldiers returning back home in 1917. During the