Rhetoric In The American Immigration Debate

1649 words - 7 pages

According to Aristotle, a speaker could frame any debate using three approaches: an appeal to logic, an appeal from credibility, or an appeal to emotions. All speakers and writers use the tripartite approach to rhetoric in varying degrees and ultimately the audience judges their effectiveness in the context presented. In America, few topics are as hotly debated as that of undocumented migration, and it can be difficult to pick through the partisan and often vitriolic rhetoric in order to come to a rational conclusion. Politicians frame the debate using elements of the American mythos. While the evidence they present to back their conclusions may be factual, it necessarily omits the full truth in order to present a partisan political front. As such, politicians predominantly rely on the reader or listener’s emotional satisfaction. And even the most scrupulous journalists—meant to impart objective fact to the public—are not free from personal bias, making the discourse even more convoluted. In analyzing three prominent voices in the immigration debate, US president Obama, journalist Sonia Nazario, and Arizona congressman J.D. Hayworth, we can evaluate the effectiveness of the different rhetorical approaches by whether or not they reach their intended audiences. Nazario fulfills her journalistic raison d’être by succeeding at objectivity, while Obama and Hayworth as politicians succeed by lying by omission in speeches and in writing in order to pursue policy goals and appease supporters.
Sonia Nazario, herself an immigrant, was aware of the acrimonious debate on undocumented migration through her work as a prominent Los Angeles journalist. The issue was brought to a head when her housekeeper’s son arrived unannounced from Guatemala having made the perilous—and illegal—journey on the top of freight trains. As Nazario writes in Enrique’s Journey, the true story of another young man, Enrique, making the same perilous trip, “I thought I understood… the immigration experience… Still, my parents arrived in the United Stated on a jet plane [and] I had no true understanding of what people are willing to do to get here" (xxiii). Nazario undertook the writing of Enrique’s Journey—an account of an undocumented migrant boy trying to reunite with his mother who had left him for a job in the States—to herself better understand the human aspect of the debate.
The story of Enrique is fundamentally a story that stirs the emotions. While we may find reasonable the logical arguments laid out by the Nazario’s sources, and while Nazario’s ethos is backed by extensive notes, the tale is fundamentally an anecdotal account in the larger debate over immigration. Its appeal is pathetic in that it viscerally shows the life and travails of an immigrant from Central America, following the protagonist through drug addiction and beatings, danger and deportations, poverty and exploitation, and finally the thorny reunion with his mother. Nazario intentionally writes an...

Find Another Essay On Rhetoric in the American Immigration Debate

The Real Issue Behind the Immigration Debate

504 words - 2 pages might seem laughable to raise the question of who is an American. But in fact the challenge to the American Founding principle that all men are created equal makes us confront the question not only of human identity but of American identity. Some maintain that an openness to immigration outside Europe is a natural result of American ideals. They point to economic benefits of immigration, lowering the costs of labor. Imitating earlier patterns

The Immigration and Job Loss Debate

1155 words - 5 pages The Immigration and Job Loss Debate A debate that always seems to raise its ugly head when the issue of "foreign labor" is discussed concerns the types of jobs that immigrants take and whether they are actually taking these jobs away from American workers. I look at it as jobs they are "left with", not ones they are taking. The debate always shows an American family that has been displaced or lost their livelihood because they can no longer

By: Gibby95          The Debate Dissagreement In the American society

1330 words - 5 pages By: Gibby95 The Debate Dissagreement In the American society we tend to resolve our differences by directly addressing our opposition by forms of debate. Throughout history, debate has been a tool of reform or what some may call reason, but; in recent years the argument has been made that our adversarial culture is in need of certain alterations. Early education generates the idea that creating an argument is essential to developing our

The Pros of American Immigration

726 words - 3 pages immigrants themselves. America is made of many different cultures, all of which have contributed to the American way of life. Jews contributed doctors and lawyers. Japanese are computer and business contributors. Koreans are well educated and have been involved in many professional, technical, and managerial careers. African Americans have contributed music, science, literature, entertainment, and many other things to our culture. Our culture is

The American Dream and Immigration

782 words - 4 pages earnings in a positive way. Studies have shown that “Immigration has caused small but positive gains in wages of American born workers of between 0.1 percent and 0.6 percent between 1990 and 2006”( Greenstone,Looney). However, Immigration may reduce wages for the least skilled workers. But those are the last jobs that the government should look into to protect. The economy was never at its best and with having immigration it makes a more productive economy. The benefits rise time over time with an expanding growth of wealth.

The Significance of Rhetoric in Music

621 words - 2 pages form of persuasive communication is music. You may doubt my sanity or think to yourself "Yeah, right." After all, when was the last time any of us heard a "persuasive" piece of music? Non-the-less, I ask you to bear with me and hear me out. Although rhetoric and music are separate disciplines, there are however, striking similarities between them: communication, delivery, and effect to the audience. In effect music and rhetoric shed light on each

Rhetoric in the Decleration of Independence

690 words - 3 pages Rhetoric in the Decleration of Independence Independence, to many that word means freedom, a fresh start, a place of salvation, free from the tyranny of kings. The Declaration of Independence gives power to the idea that such a nation could form and be successful. This powerful piece of political prose and rhetoric has held strong to these beliefs for years. The introduction consists of a single long sentence that subtlety directs

Major Problems in American Immigration History

1762 words - 7 pages In Chapter 8 of Major Problems in American Immigration History, the topic of focus shifts from the United States proper to the expansion and creation of the so called American Empire of the late Nineteenth Century. Unlike other contemporary colonial powers, such as Britain and France, expansion beyond the coast to foreign lands was met with mixed responses. While some argued it to be a mere continuation of Manifest Destiny, others saw it as

Immigration in the US

1591 words - 6 pages and other types of abuse. A popular technique abusive husbands use is the threat to deport the poor bride back to her home where she will suffer in poverty. The process of immigration within circumstances of a mail order bride moving to the U.S. tends to be gradual and complicated. In order to immigrate to the United States, the bride has two options. Under the Immigration Naturalization Services (INS), the American groom

Diversity of the american West. Immigration

1757 words - 7 pages The American West is an extremely ethnically diverse region. Large populations of immigrants and natives to it have established an Anglo, western population that continues to feel confined culturally and, more importantly, racially. Racial diversity may exist in the West, but inclusion is not intrinsic of diversity. Anglo westerners have worked to forge an identity void of other races existing in the West for centuries. Exclusion of Indians

Immigration in the United States

1104 words - 4 pages of the entire population. With this rapid increase in diversity, many citizens have opposing views on its impact on the United States. In my opinion, an increase in immigration does contain both positive and negatives effects, but in general it provides an overriding positive influence on America’s society (“Population”). In 2007, the White House issued this statement in hopes to influence a Congressional debate: “Immigration has a positive

Similar Essays

Immigration In The American Government Essay

1999 words - 8 pages Will Substantially Raise Welfare Costs and Poverty." The Heritage Foundation. 12 May 2006.Schlosser, Eric. Reefer Madness: Sex, Drugs, and Cheap Labor in the American Black Market.The Immigration Debate: Studies on the Economic, Demographic, and Fiscal Effects of Immigration. 1998. ed. Smith, James P. and Barry Edmonston.

The Debate In The United States Over Immigration

1300 words - 5 pages The Debate in the United States over Immigration      Immigration plays a huge role in the population of the United States. The U.S. is looked at as a place for a new start and a place to begin a new life. This country gives people the opportunity to make their own choices and have their own freedom, who are we to decide who can have these rights or not. Should Americans really have to right to deny another human being the right to live in

German American Immigration In The 1930s

1870 words - 7 pages in communities and strive. The immigration of Germans during this period was believed to be a benefit to the American culture which, at the time, was going through a Great Depression. The beginning of the 30s in Germany was run under a president by the name of Paul Von Hindenburg and the country, still recovering from World War I, was under good control. Since Hindenburg became president in 1925, he would make laws and decisions without the

Rhetoric In The Media Essay

1048 words - 4 pages      Many times we hear things through media and don’t actually listen to what they may say. When people hear something through mass media, they don’t realize that there is a person’s point of view stated in the story. And many times what people don’t see is that there is no such thing as an objective point of view. This is called Rhetoric; when someone states their point of view using words that either sway an