Rhetorical Analysis Of “Tarmageddon: Dirty Oil Is Turning Canada Into A Corrupt Petro State” And “Ethical Oil: The Puppet Rap”

1005 words - 4 pages

The discussion on Alberta’s oil is gaining traction among certain groups in Canada. According to Andrew Nikiforuk’s “Tarmageddon: Dirty oil is turning Canada into a corrupt petro-state,” the continuous development of the Alberta tar sands is only serving to adversely impact Canada’s political, economical, and environmental capacities. The article argues that unless the subject of the Alberta tar sands is addressed as poisonous to the nation, Canada will become overwhelmed and unstable. In a similar regard “Ethical Oil: the Puppet Rap” by Caitlin Dodd, David Henderson-Hean, Kai Nagata, Spencer Powell and Emile Scott, is a satirical rap portraying the Ethical Oil group and spokespeople in a negative light. The video targets environmentally inclined individuals and groups, and brings to their attention some logical fallacies surrounding claims made by the Ethical Oil campaign. Although both pieces address the debate over oil happening in Canada and, they use different methods to satisfy their purpose.“Tarmageddon…” uses a persuasive and argumentative approach while “Ethical Oil…” relies on satire and amusement. Both pieces employ the use of pathos to persuade their audiences, the use of which is stronger in “Tarmageddon…” leading to its more effective use of rhetorical strategies.
Nikiforuk’s article is written to argue a point and persuade the audience, non-specialist individuals, to his claim. There are many methods used to achieve this. Starting in the introduction Canada is glorified for what it used to be known for, then that image is quickly juxtaposed with the now dark and destabilized country because of the developing tar sands (Nikiforuk 211). This introduction, which uses pathos by using strong words to evoke negative emotions, quickly gives the reader a sense of uneasiness with the tar sands even without yet having heard any of the facts. Imagery is used to appeal to the imagination of the reader so they can connect more easily with the facts being presented. The use of pathos is seen throughout the article in the form of language choice and imagery to sway the reader to the author’s desired side. To follow up with the emotions the reader is being ‘given’, Nikiforuk uses the appeal to logos as a way of solidifying the readers agreement with his argument. Facts are given in the form of empirical data, such as bitumen having a carbon footprint 244 percent greater than US domestic crude based fuel (Nikiforuk 212). The methods of repetition and comparison are also used to back up the author’s claim. It is repeatedly stated that there is a lack of transparency between the tar sand reports and the public (Nikiforuk 212), evoking worry in the reader that they are not being told everything. Saudi Arabia, which Canada is constantly being compared to, is referred to as an undesirable country. This comparison aims to create fear in the reader that “Canada now shares the same sort of unaccountability and lack of transparency that marks fellow...

Find Another Essay On Rhetorical Analysis of “Tarmageddon: Dirty oil is turning Canada into a corrupt petro-state” and “Ethical Oil: the Puppet rap”

The Impact of Oil and Natural Gas on The State of Oklahoma

1627 words - 7 pages I have been employed in the oil and natural gas industry for the past 106 years, and they have been the best years of my life. Oklahoma has been facilitated in various ways because of the positive effect on the state. There are also many negative impacts on our environment that have occurred from the oil and natural gas fields. Oklahoma is known for its impressive oil industries. Without oil and natural gas, Oklahoma would be a completely

The Process Of Decomposition Of Mixtures Into Compounds And Elements: Grey Water And Crude Oil

1151 words - 5 pages is very important, it is made up of many components which can all be separated into create many commercial products. Some of the products formed from crude oil are Petroleum, Naphtha, Gasoline, Kerosene, Diesel distillate, Lubricating oil, Fuel oil and Residuals like asphalt.A mixture of at least two liquids can be separated by the distillation method, but this only completely separates the components of a mixture if the components have an

"The War in Iraq: What do you Believe!?" This paper was written about a year into the war, and at the time many people were arguing about the oil and Saddam issue

1064 words - 4 pages what many deaths would cause? A second Vietnam is going to happen. The US is going to send more and more troops, and more casualties are going to be the outcome." They have some good points such as the deaths of soldiers, but in every war there has been deaths. Death is inevitable in a war, and that is what the War on Iraq is. I do not believe this will turn into anything comparable to Vietnam though. We are not in that bad of a situation, and

Analysis and Description of Olive Oil

648 words - 3 pages qualities, and grading of this oil. I will look into the culinary uses and limitations. I will also research what legislation and governing bodies there are to monitor the qualities of olive oil. I simply adore olive oil. I have for as long as I can remember. I love the whole shebang involving this fruit: the touch, the consistency, the flavor, the bouquet, the hue, the assortment, the allure – oh the potential. Growing up in a Jewish

The Report of Oil

2262 words - 9 pages suyker, 2004: 18). The other negative effects of an increased in oil price is the price of other energy will go up with oil.Environment and ethical aspects of the use of oilOil release energy when they burn. It is extremely useful for our daily activities. We mostly use mineral oil to heat our homes and to run our industries and vehicles. Also oil may provide for thousands of products we use every day. However, refining and using oils has a damaging

Shell Oil and the Exploitation of Nigeria

2206 words - 9 pages spillage of massive amounts of oil the ecosystem of the Ogoni people has been devastated. It resembles a wasteland with little to no vegetation and wildlife being very scarce. Furthermore the Ogoni people have received almost nothing for the all the oil exported from their land. An estimated 10 billion dollars a year is earned for the Nigerian government most of which is embezzled by high ranking officials or put into the military to keep the

The Production and Distribution of Oil Products

2273 words - 9 pages organisational infrastructure is still regarded as moderate. Because of the age of de Langen’s article, the conclusions might be outdated, meaning that there is need for an update. Safety and security in port is another factor that has been taken into consideration by the port of Rotterdam. The port acknowledges the possibility of water pollution through oil or chemical spills. This is why it has a clean-up organisation working around the

What is the structure of the world oil market?

1916 words - 8 pages consumption is growing which is making the demand more elastic leading into price for oil increasing. Also the structure of the oil market is not a free market, as no country can join the oil market.Explain how the price of oil is determined in the world market?Oil prices are very significant to the world market, as oil use to be very cheap, however oil prices have risen dramatically mainly because it's a very use full fuel and provides many benefit

The Braer Oil Disaster - Essay outling the consiquences and effects of the Braer Oil Disaster

692 words - 3 pages disinfectant which burns the oil away. The other method is the "Boom and Skimmer" method. This involves a long inflatable rubber tube being directed around the oil spillage. Attached to the tube is a long curtain, which drapes to the sea bed and encloses the oil into one area where it can be treated, and the oil can't get out. The oil is usually cleaned by different boats which go around and scrape the oil from the surface and take it onboard and out of

Demand and Supply of Oil

844 words - 3 pages Oil in the world, and as a member of OPEC price and supply of Oil is controlled by the 10 members of the OPEC and Non-OPEC countries. Yr Oil Price Tq Oil Demand Tq Oil Supplied OPEC Supplied OPEC Share 00 24 76,000,000 76,900,000 25,400,000 33% 1Q 27 76,300,000 76,300,000 26,200,000 34% 2Q 29 75,300,000 75,400,000 26,700,000 35% 3Q 24.5 76,500,000 76,500,000 25,201,000 33% 4Q 25

The Importance of Crude Oil

1194 words - 5 pages some serious concerns among the policy makers all over the world. The unfavorable economic impact of high oil prices on oil-importing developing countries is generally considered as more adverse than for the developed countries because of their more dependence on imported oil and less efficient in this case. Malik. A (2007) also mentioned in her research that, the recent surge in the oil prices especially after 2000 has worried many economists

Similar Essays

Oil Pollution In The Niger Delta: The Responsibility Of The Nigerian State And Oil Companies

2276 words - 9 pages State and MNOCs like Shell are responsible for oil pollution in the Niger Delta. The following paper will proceed by first examining the historical and current context of Nigeria; then it will examine each major position in turn, followed by a careful estimation of the most supportable position through an examination of primary and secondary research sources. Historical Context: Before Colonization to After Independence It is necessary to first

Oil Resources In Canada Essay

3335 words - 13 pages out of the peat until the layer of diatoms turned into coal, oil or natural gas (CEC, 2013). Canada has oil industry throughout the country and currently 12 out of 13 provinces are active in the oil industry. Natural gas production is occurring in British Columbia, Alberta, Quebec, and New Brunswick. Natural gas could also become large industry in Prince Edward Island, Nova Scotia, Newfoundland & Labrador, Yukon and the Northwest Territories. Oil

Is Australia Turning Into An American State?

792 words - 3 pages In a time of change and social upheaval, we, as Australians, must become conscious of the fact that we are not immune. We will change with the world as well, but we must endeavor to remain autonomous to aggressive Western states.Already we have started to turn from a proud, independent nation into a subjugated state of external powers. The one time firm and resolute stance that Australia took to prevent becoming dominated by foreign states is

Legal And Ethical Analysis Of Ashland Oil Inc. : Trouble At Floreffe

2698 words - 11 pages unsubstantiated claims.V. JUDGMENT AND RATIONALEAOI being in the oil business since 1965 should be very familiar with the various aspects of AST and its construction. Further, AOI is a member of API and should also be fully aware of the very purpose of its standards, specifically primary testing method of AST. AOI is obligated to review past industry problems, learn from them, and incorporate these lessons learned into any new construction and